collapse

Author Topic: Statisticians counter Weilgus  (Read 663 times)

Offline Humptulips

  • Global Moderator
  • Trade Count: (+2)
  • Frontiersman
  • *****
  • Join Date: May 2010
  • Posts: 4403
  • Location: Humptulips
    • Washington State Trappers Association
  • Groups: WSTA, NTA, FTA, OTA, WWC, WFW, NRA
Statisticians counter Weilgus
« on: October 07, 2017, 03:08:05 PM »
http://www.spokesman.com/blogs/outdoors/2017/oct/03/statisticians-counter-wsu-profs-findings-killing-wolves-does-more-harm-good/#/0

ENDANGERED SPECIES -- A Washington State University professor erred in controversial research released in 2014 suggesting that killing wolves that attack cattle is counterproductive because it stimulates more attacks, according to a statistical analysis released today.

Working with a Ph.D. statistician, the Washington Policy Center analyzed the data provided by Dr. Robert Wielgus and found several problems with conclusions that are widely used by critics of Washington's wolf management, especially in cases where wolves are killed.

"Rather than support his hypothesis, his own data point in the opposite direction, supporting the state’s policy of removing wolves when there is a conflict and undermining Wielgus’ own hypothesis," says Todd Myers of Seattle-based WPC, a conservative think tank that promotes public policy based on free-market solutions.

Since 2011, Washington has periodically resorted to lethally removing wolves -- from one or two to an entire pack in one case -- to stop repeated attacks on livestock.

Wielgus surveyed the literature and reported that the practice is counterintuitive. “People think, let’s kill the wolves and get rid of the problem," he told The Spokesman-Review in 2014. "But it doesn’t work that way with carnivores. Sometimes, the punitive solution is causing the problem.”

Wielgus tied the increased livestock deaths to disruptions in the pack’s social structure.

“If you kill the alpha male and female, the pack fractures,” he told S-R reporter Becky Kramer. “Instead of one breeding pair, you may have two or three.”

The first challenge to the Wielgus study was published in 2016 by three University of Washington statisticians who crunched the numbers and found that killing wolves that prey on livestock can lead to a short-term increase in attacks, particularly for sheep. But the year after the wolves were killed, livestock attacks went down.

At that time, WDFW had decided to remove members of the Profanity Peak Pack to stop repeated attacks on cattle in Ferry County. Wielgus, leaning from academia toward activism, strongly attacked the decision. The controversy led to death threats and an unusual denunciation of a professor by WSU officials.  Wielgus later retracted his comments.

The new analysis released by the Washington Policy Center says the Wielgus 2014 study claim that killing wolves resulted in increasing attacks on cattle and sheep is not supported by his own data.

Statistical analysis identified several problems with the research and confirms weaknesses previously identified by UW statisticians in 2016, Myers said.  In his words:
•The WSU study’s conclusions are based on erroneous statistical arguments, and are not supported by rigorous analysis of the study’s own data.
•Contrary to Wielgus’ conclusions, our re-analysis of his study’s data finds that the strongest explanation of an increase in loss of cattle and sheep was simply an increase in the wolf population.
•Wielgus’ study also fails to replicate his hypothesis on an independent data set to ensure his finding is not merely an artifact of this data set.
•Wielgus’ claim that removing wolves increases the number of breeding pairs is also undermined by the data in his study.
•Data in Wielgus’ study actually support the current Washington state strategy of removing wolves where there is conflict with a rancher, consistent with the common-sense conclusion that removing wolves reduces livestock deaths.
Bruce Vandervort

Offline dreamunelk

  • Political Topics
  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Sourdough
  • *
  • Join Date: Jan 2009
  • Posts: 1936
Re: Statisticians counter Weilgus
« Reply #1 on: October 07, 2017, 04:42:13 PM »
 :bumpin:

Offline CementFinisher

  • Washington For Wildlife
  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Sourdough
  • *
  • Join Date: Oct 2010
  • Posts: 1018
  • Location: Spanaway, wa
Re: Statisticians counter Weilgus
« Reply #2 on: October 07, 2017, 11:33:03 PM »
 :chuckle: surprise suprise

Offline wolfbait

  • Site Sponsor
  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Old Salt
  • ******
  • Join Date: May 2009
  • Posts: 5370
Re: Statisticians counter Weilgus
« Reply #3 on: October 08, 2017, 02:17:45 AM »
Wonder how many idiots jumped on the Dr. Robert Wielgus band wagon? WDF&Wolves? Didn't this same "Doctor" come out with a bogus cougar study?

 

* Recent Topics

Kuiu Icon Pro 3200 by Jgill19
[Today at 10:20:34 PM]


WTS/WTT: Knight Bighorn with Accessories (Price Drop) by gee_unit360
[Today at 10:17:42 PM]


Forest Service turns down inventor of substance that puts out fires by returnofsid
[Today at 10:17:22 PM]


Maybe moving to Idaho by bornhunter
[Today at 10:09:55 PM]


Side by Side or Jeep by bornhunter
[Today at 10:00:33 PM]


Re: What does he score? 7mm version by fishnfur
[Today at 09:50:34 PM]


High Buck Hunt by 7mmfan
[Today at 09:48:07 PM]


Anybody ever build one of these? by fishnfur
[Today at 09:36:43 PM]


Wolves tree DNR worker in Okanogan county by PlateauNDN
[Today at 09:24:42 PM]


Looking for Giants! by fishnfur
[Today at 09:19:16 PM]


new to the forum:) by fishnfur
[Today at 09:12:40 PM]


FS: Hunting Pack by AlbinoRhino
[Today at 09:08:39 PM]


Ada County Hunter holds First Idaho Grizzly Tag by cbond3318
[Today at 09:08:04 PM]


How is the twisp Winthrop area fairing so far 2018? by TylerMulie
[Today at 09:04:00 PM]


For sale Mossberg 500 by Ricon650
[Today at 09:03:00 PM]


meat damage rabbits by GBoyd
[Today at 08:53:13 PM]


Reloading for accuracy/consistency help by hunter399
[Today at 08:42:37 PM]


White River Rifle bull by Harbor_hunter
[Today at 08:27:52 PM]


2018 Area 9 and 10 Summer Kings by WSU
[Today at 07:53:23 PM]


Big bows by Ricon650
[Today at 07:37:25 PM]