collapse
Quality Hunts for over 30 Years A lightweight orange vest that complements your technical hunting apparel!

Author Topic: Which deer to take in an underpopulated GMU?  (Read 2252 times)

Offline yakimanoob

  • Virtual Campfire
  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Scout
  • *
  • Join Date: Jun 2016
  • Posts: 412
  • Location: Naches
Which deer to take in an underpopulated GMU?
« on: March 06, 2017, 09:58:19 AM »
FIRST: I'm not interested in talking about ethics here.  I'm interested in pragmatic cause-effect relationships, and I'm trying to learn more about deer. 

I live near Naches, and mule deer here are underpopulated according to the WDFW status and trend reports.  http://dfw.wa.gov/publications/01875/

Let's ASSUME that assessment is accurate, rather than arguing about the validity of the WDFW numbers/conclusions.  And let's assume I'm going to kill a buck.  My question is: if I have the choice between a young 3 point and a mature 4x4, which one has a higher chance of breeding more females? 

For instance, say I'm tracking a group of deer in the same area and I've identified both bucks.  Killing one during modern rifle means that animal doesn't get to make babies for next year.  So if my mind is made up to harvest one or the other, which one should I take to maximize the number of bred does in the coming rut? 

What do you think?


Side note: I was fortunate enough to harvest a cryptorchid 3x3 on Cleman Mtn last year, so there's one less sterile buck in the world and more food/ladies for the boys who can make babies  :tup:

Offline Rainier10

  • Global Moderator
  • Trade Count: (+1)
  • Old Salt
  • *****
  • Join Date: Dec 2010
  • Posts: 6109
  • Location: Over the edge
Re: Which deer to take in an underpopulated GMU?
« Reply #1 on: March 06, 2017, 10:16:25 AM »
My opinion is to shoot the older buck.  The younger bucks will breed just as many does and have more years ahead of them as far as breeding.  If you give the younger bucks a pass it gives them another year to get wiser.  Just my  :twocents:
Pain is temporary, achieving the goal is worth it.

I didn't say it would be easy, I said it would be worth it.

Every father should remember that one day his children will follow his example instead of his advice.


The views and opinions expressed in this post are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of HuntWa or the site owner.

Offline Curly

  • Trade Count: (+1)
  • Explorer
  • ******
  • Join Date: Mar 2007
  • Posts: 17193
  • Location: Thurston County
Re: Which deer to take in an underpopulated GMU?
« Reply #2 on: March 06, 2017, 10:20:35 AM »
Shoot the small 3.  The meat will be more tender and taste better.
May I always be the kind of person my dog thinks I am.

><((((>` ><((((>. ><((((>.><((((>

Offline buglebuster

  • ELKOHOLIC
  • Business Sponsor
  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Frontiersman
  • *****
  • Join Date: Mar 2011
  • Posts: 2911
  • Location: yakima
    • https://www.facebook.com/Xposedskullworks/
Re: Which deer to take in an underpopulated GMU?
« Reply #3 on: March 06, 2017, 10:23:43 AM »
You should shoot the more mature older buck every time.
Owner/Operator at Exposed Skull works
Specializing in quality, affordable European mounts of all species.

Contact us today for questions and pricing.
(509)307-8001 (509)895-4791
Check us out on Facebook and Instagram

Offline yakimanoob

  • Virtual Campfire
  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Scout
  • *
  • Join Date: Jun 2016
  • Posts: 412
  • Location: Naches
Re: Which deer to take in an underpopulated GMU?
« Reply #4 on: March 06, 2017, 10:28:54 AM »
You should shoot the more mature older buck every time.

Why?  Do younger bucks breed more does if the older one is not in the picture?

Offline KFhunter

  • Global Moderator
  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Explorer
  • *****
  • Join Date: Jan 2011
  • Posts: 12512
  • Location: NE/WA
  • My posts do not reflect an official opinion of HW
Re: Which deer to take in an underpopulated GMU?
« Reply #5 on: March 06, 2017, 10:35:21 AM »
My opinion is to shoot the older buck.  The younger bucks will breed just as many does and have more years ahead of them as far as breeding.  If you give the younger bucks a pass it gives them another year to get wiser.  Just my  :twocents:

The younger bucks wouldn't travel as much and more likely to inbreed locally, they wouldn't really have a rut pattern established they'd follow like an older buck would. 

The mature buck would travel their well established rut travel/search patterns, sometimes travelling quite a ways and would cover more does.  The older buck would be more efficient as well.
"Beware of false knowledge; it is more dangerous than ignorance." -George Bernard.

Offline yakimanoob

  • Virtual Campfire
  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Scout
  • *
  • Join Date: Jun 2016
  • Posts: 412
  • Location: Naches
Re: Which deer to take in an underpopulated GMU?
« Reply #6 on: March 06, 2017, 10:38:45 AM »

The younger bucks wouldn't travel as much and more likely to inbreed locally, they wouldn't really have a rut pattern established they'd follow like an older buck would. 

The mature buck would travel their well established rut patterns  sometimes travelling quite a ways and would cover more does.

Thanks KFhunter!  This is exactly the kind of learning I'm after.  Can you recommend some reading for me to learn more about these kinds of patterns/effects?

Offline KFhunter

  • Global Moderator
  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Explorer
  • *****
  • Join Date: Jan 2011
  • Posts: 12512
  • Location: NE/WA
  • My posts do not reflect an official opinion of HW
Re: Which deer to take in an underpopulated GMU?
« Reply #7 on: March 06, 2017, 10:43:58 AM »
I might see an article while sitting in the Dr. office and that's about it.  The rags always focus on giant antlers and what latest trinket you must have to get those giant antlers.   I have no books on hunting either.   Sorry I can't make recommendations on reading material. 





"Beware of false knowledge; it is more dangerous than ignorance." -George Bernard.

Offline yakimanoob

  • Virtual Campfire
  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Scout
  • *
  • Join Date: Jun 2016
  • Posts: 412
  • Location: Naches
Re: Which deer to take in an underpopulated GMU?
« Reply #8 on: March 06, 2017, 10:49:51 AM »
I might see an article while sitting in the Dr. office and that's about it.  The rags always focus on giant antlers and what latest trinket you must have to get those giant antlers.   I have no books on hunting either.   Sorry I can't make recommendations on reading material.

At the risk of taking my own thread off topic: this is a big problem in the hunting world, right?  I can find a dozen reviews on any given bolt gun, but decent information on animal behavior patterns, population dynamics, and other concepts that would make us all better hunters is nearly impossible to find.

Not that the problem is unique to hunting... 

Offline Rainier10

  • Global Moderator
  • Trade Count: (+1)
  • Old Salt
  • *****
  • Join Date: Dec 2010
  • Posts: 6109
  • Location: Over the edge
Re: Which deer to take in an underpopulated GMU?
« Reply #9 on: March 06, 2017, 10:51:35 AM »
My opinion is to shoot the older buck.  The younger bucks will breed just as many does and have more years ahead of them as far as breeding.  If you give the younger bucks a pass it gives them another year to get wiser.  Just my  :twocents:

The younger bucks wouldn't travel as much and more likely to inbreed locally, they wouldn't really have a rut pattern established they'd follow like an older buck would. 

The mature buck would travel their well established rut travel/search patterns, sometimes travelling quite a ways and would cover more does.  The older buck would be more efficient as well.
That is another way to look at it for sure.  I was going back and forth on this one.

I just reread the question and it raises even more questions for me because he says he has the choice to shoot a  young 3 point or a mature 4x4.

I was thinking your odds of finding and shooting a mature buck are way lower than shooting an immature buck.  If you have lower odds of shooting the mature that in itself leaves the potential for more bucks to be around breeding.

Immature bucks are easier to find and kill so your odds of success are higher thus taking out more potential breeders.

After rereading it, if there were two bucks standing side by side, one mature and one immature, I am not sure what I would do.  I think you could make a case for either option.

I am not sure there is a "right" answer to this one.  I am interested to hear what everyone's point of view is.
Pain is temporary, achieving the goal is worth it.

I didn't say it would be easy, I said it would be worth it.

Every father should remember that one day his children will follow his example instead of his advice.


The views and opinions expressed in this post are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of HuntWa or the site owner.

Offline KFhunter

  • Global Moderator
  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Explorer
  • *****
  • Join Date: Jan 2011
  • Posts: 12512
  • Location: NE/WA
  • My posts do not reflect an official opinion of HW
Re: Which deer to take in an underpopulated GMU?
« Reply #10 on: March 06, 2017, 10:57:37 AM »
Quote
After rereading it, if there were two bucks standing side by side, one mature and one immature, I am not sure what I would do.  I think you could make a case for either option.

Assuming they're both legal take your pick.  The younger would taste better but you'd get less meat.  Fortunately we don't have to worry about shooting the mature buck because there are other mature bucks who will fill the void and until that void is filled a younger buck would sneak in and breed in a pinch.

I just don't think we need to worry about which buck to shoot other than the quantity vs quality personal choice.  If it were so under populated that does weren't getting covered then it needs to be restricted more and predators removed.
"Beware of false knowledge; it is more dangerous than ignorance." -George Bernard.

Offline DaveMonti

  • Trade Count: (+1)
  • Sourdough
  • *****
  • Join Date: Dec 2008
  • Posts: 1072
  • Location: Snohomish County
Re: Which deer to take in an underpopulated GMU?
« Reply #11 on: March 06, 2017, 11:11:00 AM »
It really doesn't matter which buck you take.  Breeding success is rarely, if ever, negatively impacted by a limited number of bucks.  If you kill both, there will still be plenty of other bucks in the area that will breed the available does.  Even spikes will travel miles and miles to find a hot doe. 

Offline jackelope

  • Administrator
  • Trade Count: (+18)
  • Legend
  • *****
  • Join Date: Mar 2007
  • Posts: 34883
  • Location: Duvall, WA
  • Groups: WSB RMGA NRA RMEF BHA
Re: Which deer to take in an underpopulated GMU?
« Reply #12 on: March 06, 2017, 11:14:12 AM »
There is no genetic difference between old bucks and young bucks. They either have it or they don't. I've killed enough deer in my life(really not that many compared to most here I'm guessing) that I'm not interested in shooting young bucks anymore. I just don't need to. I'm going to throw out that the old, mature bucks may or may not have worse odds of dying over winter, etc. If we're talking migration routes, mule deer seem to use the same routes and follow the does, right?
That video out of Wyoming depicting their mule deer migration seems to show they all follow roughly the same path, and the younger bucks move first, right?
:fire.:

" In today's instant gratification society, more and more pressure revolves around success and the measurement of one's prowess as a hunter by inches on a score chart or field photos produced on social media. Don't fall into the trap. Hunting is-and always will be- about the hunt, the adventure, the views, and time spent with close friends and family. " Ryan Hatfield

My posts, opinions and statements do not represent those of this forum

Offline KFhunter

  • Global Moderator
  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Explorer
  • *****
  • Join Date: Jan 2011
  • Posts: 12512
  • Location: NE/WA
  • My posts do not reflect an official opinion of HW
Re: Which deer to take in an underpopulated GMU?
« Reply #13 on: March 06, 2017, 11:16:24 AM »
It really doesn't matter which buck you take.  Breeding success is rarely, if ever, negatively impacted by a limited number of bucks.  If you kill both, there will still be plenty of other bucks in the area that will breed the available does.  Even spikes will travel miles and miles to find a hot doe.

I agree, buck to doe ratio is way down on the list of things suppressing deer populations if at all.  I wouldn't worry about this.   


To the OP; if you want to make a positive impact then hunt predators.  If you seek personal justification for taking a large mature buck then make a pledge to yourself that if you take out a couple of coyotes, or any single large carnivore you've more than earned that large buck. 


"Beware of false knowledge; it is more dangerous than ignorance." -George Bernard.

Offline KFhunter

  • Global Moderator
  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Explorer
  • *****
  • Join Date: Jan 2011
  • Posts: 12512
  • Location: NE/WA
  • My posts do not reflect an official opinion of HW
Re: Which deer to take in an underpopulated GMU?
« Reply #14 on: March 06, 2017, 11:21:00 AM »
There is no genetic difference between old bucks and young bucks. They either have it or they don't. I've killed enough deer in my life(really not that many compared to most here I'm guessing) that I'm not interested in shooting young bucks anymore. I just don't need to. I'm going to throw out that the old, mature bucks may or may not have worse odds of dying over winter, etc. If we're talking migration routes, mule deer seem to use the same routes and follow the does, right?
That video out of Wyoming depicting their mule deer migration seems to show they all follow roughly the same path, and the younger bucks move first, right?

The only thing I'd clarify (not disagreeing with you)  is that "bad genetics" wouldn't tend to make it to full maturity as often as "good genetics" would.  If a buck is an old warrior he's probably got good genetics.


I tend to shoot young bucks, I have enough trouble getting my wife and kids to eat that.  A smelly old rutted bruiser?   ....forget it.   When I was a kid if I brought home a buck with more than 3pt's I'd get chewed out.  "what you bring that nasty old thing home for boy?" 
"Beware of false knowledge; it is more dangerous than ignorance." -George Bernard.

Offline BULLBLASTER

  • Chris McCarthy
  • Virtual Campfire
  • Trade Count: (+10)
  • Old Salt
  • *
  • Join Date: Oct 2008
  • Posts: 5769
  • Volleyfire brigade
Re: Which deer to take in an underpopulated GMU?
« Reply #15 on: March 06, 2017, 11:27:11 AM »
There is no genetic difference between old bucks and young bucks. They either have it or they don't. I've killed enough deer in my life(really not that many compared to most here I'm guessing) that I'm not interested in shooting young bucks anymore. I just don't need to. I'm going to throw out that the old, mature bucks may or may not have worse odds of dying over winter, etc. If we're talking migration routes, mule deer seem to use the same routes and follow the does, right?
That video out of Wyoming depicting their mule deer migration seems to show they all follow roughly the same path, and the younger bucks move first, right?

The only thing I'd clarify (not disagreeing with you)  is that "bad genetics" wouldn't tend to make it to full maturity as often as "good genetics" would.  If a buck is an old warrior he's probably got good genetics.


I tend to shoot young bucks, I have enough trouble getting my wife and kids to eat that.  A smelly old rutted bruiser?   ....forget it.   When I was a kid if I brought home a buck with more than 3pt's I'd get chewed out.  "what you bring that nasty old thing home for boy?" 
:yeah:
It's also important to rememeber that there are more to "good" genetics than big antlers, but that seems to be lost in the magazine and tv management world.

Offline eburgtrapper

  • WA State Trappers Association
  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Hunter
  • *
  • Join Date: Sep 2008
  • Posts: 142
  • Location: Ellensburg
Re: Which deer to take in an underpopulated GMU?
« Reply #16 on: March 06, 2017, 11:27:19 AM »
I think about this as if they are cattle. If you have two Bulls, one is three and has let's say 7 years of breeding left, and you have an 8 year old with two years of breeding left, (excluding taste/meat quality) If you remove the older bull you still have 7 years of breeding from the younger animal.

Offline KFhunter

  • Global Moderator
  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Explorer
  • *****
  • Join Date: Jan 2011
  • Posts: 12512
  • Location: NE/WA
  • My posts do not reflect an official opinion of HW
Re: Which deer to take in an underpopulated GMU?
« Reply #17 on: March 06, 2017, 11:31:24 AM »
I think about this as if they are cattle. If you have two Bulls, one is three and has let's say 7 years of breeding left, and you have an 8 year old with two years of breeding left, (excluding taste/meat quality) If you remove the older bull you still have 7 years of breeding from the younger animal.

For every 40 cows put out 10 bulls (both young and old) and see what happens then.  Who's doing the breeding and who's doing the fighting?  and who's hiding in the corner trying not to get his butt kicked


"Beware of false knowledge; it is more dangerous than ignorance." -George Bernard.

Offline Gringo31

  • Washington For Wildlife
  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Frontiersman
  • *
  • Join Date: May 2009
  • Posts: 4991
Re: Which deer to take in an underpopulated GMU?
« Reply #18 on: March 06, 2017, 12:07:19 PM »
It's an interesting question.....


I'll add my  :twocents: in this way.  I don't believe one hunter has the ability to make much of an impact (limited to the two decisions you listed).  If you spend time and really watch deer, you may see that mature buck keep the smaller ones away and should he die, the smaller bucks won't miss a beat.

That being said, you can see a mature buck in a particular area today, gone tomorrow with the same does hanging around.  All in all, it matters little (when it comes to your choice and the impact of the herd).

As others have said, predator removal can make a real impact.  I'll also throw out there that IMO WDFW doesn't believe deer and elk can live in the same places.  Your area is seen by them as an "elk area" and they have made management decisions to have an intentional low deer population.
We must reject the idea that every time a law's broken, society is guilty rather than the lawbreaker. It is time to restore the American precept that each individual is accountable for his actions.
-Ronald Reagan

Offline jackelope

  • Administrator
  • Trade Count: (+18)
  • Legend
  • *****
  • Join Date: Mar 2007
  • Posts: 34883
  • Location: Duvall, WA
  • Groups: WSB RMGA NRA RMEF BHA
Re: Which deer to take in an underpopulated GMU?
« Reply #19 on: March 06, 2017, 12:09:33 PM »
I think about this as if they are cattle. If you have two Bulls, one is three and has let's say 7 years of breeding left, and you have an 8 year old with two years of breeding left, (excluding taste/meat quality) If you remove the older bull you still have 7 years of breeding from the younger animal.

For every 40 cows put out 10 bulls (both young and old) and see what happens then.  Who's doing the breeding and who's doing the fighting?  and who's hiding in the corner trying not to get his butt kicked




They will be breeding and no longer hiding in the corner when the mature buck dies.
:fire.:

" In today's instant gratification society, more and more pressure revolves around success and the measurement of one's prowess as a hunter by inches on a score chart or field photos produced on social media. Don't fall into the trap. Hunting is-and always will be- about the hunt, the adventure, the views, and time spent with close friends and family. " Ryan Hatfield

My posts, opinions and statements do not represent those of this forum

Offline eburgtrapper

  • WA State Trappers Association
  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Hunter
  • *
  • Join Date: Sep 2008
  • Posts: 142
  • Location: Ellensburg
Re: Which deer to take in an underpopulated GMU?
« Reply #20 on: March 06, 2017, 12:11:10 PM »
I think about this as if they are cattle. If you have two Bulls, one is three and has let's say 7 years of breeding left, and you have an 8 year old with two years of breeding left, (excluding taste/meat quality) If you remove the older bull you still have 7 years of breeding from the younger animal.

For every 40 cows put out 10 bulls (both young and old) and see what happens then.  Who's doing the breeding and who's doing the fighting?  and who's hiding in the corner trying not to get his butt kicked


Or let's say 2 bulls and 8 cows. That way it's a controlled size. Who knows what's going to happen with ten Bulls. Maybe the old Bulls win the fights and breed but then they are wore out and can't rebound and get killed by predators. All I'm saying is side by side it's better to take the older bull with the hopes of more years of possible breeding out of the younger one. I know there is a lot of different things to add to the equation like others have said male to female ratios, predators, winter....

Offline KFhunter

  • Global Moderator
  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Explorer
  • *****
  • Join Date: Jan 2011
  • Posts: 12512
  • Location: NE/WA
  • My posts do not reflect an official opinion of HW
Re: Which deer to take in an underpopulated GMU?
« Reply #21 on: March 06, 2017, 12:16:48 PM »
I'm just not sure there's a lot to be gleaned from a controlled herd of cattle to deer in the wild.  I know my young bull is pretty proud of himself even though he had to jump to breed the older cows  :chuckle:
"Beware of false knowledge; it is more dangerous than ignorance." -George Bernard.

Offline boneaddict

  • Site Sponsor
  • Administrator
  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Legend
  • *****
  • Join Date: Mar 2007
  • Posts: 41210
  • Location: Selah, Washington
Re: Which deer to take in an underpopulated GMU?
« Reply #22 on: March 06, 2017, 12:39:05 PM »
Too anecdotal to get any real answer.   Deer densities, buck to doe ratios are all askew where you are mentioning.   Throw in unlimited tribal harvest, etc.  just be amazed to find two branch Antler bucks in the first place. This is an area wher spikes are breeding.

  One could say an older buck would have a better chance of surviving the gauntlet than a younger one, thus might actually make it to breeding season.
My website.....DDK Photography
http://ddkphotography.pixels.com

Offline yakimanoob

  • Virtual Campfire
  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Scout
  • *
  • Join Date: Jun 2016
  • Posts: 412
  • Location: Naches
Re: Which deer to take in an underpopulated GMU?
« Reply #23 on: March 06, 2017, 01:10:50 PM »
Thanks for all the replies, everybody.  Sounds like I just need to spend my time working on the coyotes and not worry so much about which buck I take. 

And I'll say for clarity that if I ever ACTUALLY saw both in the same place at the same time, I'd be too surprised to even think about it and would probably fire on the one that presented the first clean shot.  This is a fun thought experiment though :)

Offline buckcanyonlodge

  • Business Sponsor
  • Trade Count: (+5)
  • Sourdough
  • *****
  • Join Date: Jun 2011
  • Posts: 1158
  • Location: Gifford, Lake Roosevelt, Wa.
    • Buck Canyon Lodge
Re: Which deer to take in an underpopulated GMU?
« Reply #24 on: March 06, 2017, 01:35:17 PM »
Let both of them walk..Go hunt an area where deer aren't so underpopulated. Both bucks breeding will bring the population back sooner.
Providing a select few deer , bear , and turkey hunts  with meals and lodging provided.  Stevens County is right in the heart of the best hunting and fishing in the Northeast corner of the state . . Our Lodge is also a great place for your family reunion, summer vacation  509-722-3949  www.buckcanyon.net
Call me for your REAL ESTATE needs in the Tri-County area. Hunting/Recreational or retirement properties. Westergard Real Estate Kettle Falls

 

* Recent Topics

Kapowsin by trophyhunt
[Today at 06:15:04 AM]


pearrygin by trophyhunt
[Today at 06:13:18 AM]


My boys first deer. by meat hntr78
[Today at 06:13:08 AM]


Bucks moving to does by Billy74
[Today at 06:13:05 AM]


Lab Breeder Recommendations by WRL
[Today at 06:10:19 AM]


Elkfever's Peaches Ridge Hunt by Gearhead1940
[Today at 06:09:23 AM]


1st hunt bagged two birds by E35alex
[Today at 06:02:28 AM]


WA Fall Turkey by E35alex
[Today at 05:59:56 AM]


Big Blacktails on this thread? by 7mmfan
[Today at 05:47:31 AM]


WY Solo DIY Public Land Antelope Success by archer0135
[Today at 05:44:34 AM]


Opening day mulie by E35alex
[Today at 05:34:02 AM]


Daughter got it done-First buck is a good one! by E35alex
[Today at 05:31:04 AM]


Wife's opening day Mulie by E35alex
[Today at 05:29:27 AM]


Lake roosevelt kokanee by rasbo
[Today at 04:54:39 AM]


Getting Discouraged by dscubame
[Today at 04:35:21 AM]


Coyote hunting by JimmyLee
[Today at 01:54:27 AM]


Lyman trade rifle .54 cal recoil!! by Old Dog
[Today at 01:19:09 AM]


Capitol Forest? by fishnfur
[Today at 12:06:46 AM]


WDFW issues permit for Cooke Aquaculture to bring in 1.8m eggs from Iceland by j_h_nimrod
[Yesterday at 11:10:59 PM]


338-378 Weatherby Questions by Magnum_Willys
[Yesterday at 11:07:49 PM]