Post by: Birddogman on March 09, 2013, 09:13:36 PM
Post by: Birdguy on March 09, 2013, 10:05:17 PM
To your question of finished, at some of the release sites I have been to if your dog held to shot he/she will likely not get the bird as someone's dog already has :bash:. That does not mean you will not get the bird from that other hunter but your dog will not get the retrieve. If you hunt with other pointers a dog that honors is almost always welcome in the field, where one that does not has a tougher time being invited back. It really depends on your style/method of hunting in my opinion.
Post by: Stilly bay on March 10, 2013, 12:03:32 AM
however with this new setter I have I think I am going to take him all the way since he is a damn fine animal and I would like to trial him.
Post by: jetjockey on March 10, 2013, 06:49:19 AM
Post by: Happy Gilmore on March 10, 2013, 08:20:25 PM
Post by: jetjockey on March 11, 2013, 07:24:34 AM
hunt with a Chessie who will sit on a whistle. You'll get far more pheasants than hunting over any pointing breed. Especially in the Dakota's and Montana. Sharptail....get a pointer
Depends on how, and where you hunt. In milo, cut corn, and cattails, your right. But push birds into the coulees and natural prairie landscape where birds spread out and can be pinned, and a pointing dog will smoke a flusher/retriever. You throw some snow on that milo, and that changes everything as well.
Post by: whitey on March 11, 2013, 08:03:11 AM
He I wouldnt consider him a finished dog because he only gets better with time. He is a dog that will react to the situation at hand. Some birds hold better than others. Some flush and die others hold and then he is released to flush and they die. :yike:
Ducks he will head for the water when the shooting starts, but also will put on a sneak with me when jump shooting. Just need a dog that minds and the dog must behave and get along with other dogs while in the field.
(https://hunting-washington.com/smf/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fi279.photobucket.com%2Falbums%2Fkk157%2Fruger123%2Fflowers%2520mts%2520and%2520stuff%2FIMG_1993-1.jpg&hash=d770d24c28a73beab4d5507d873aafea503aaa98)
(https://hunting-washington.com/smf/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fi279.photobucket.com%2Falbums%2Fkk157%2Fruger123%2Fflowers%2520mts%2520and%2520stuff%2FIMG_0022.jpg&hash=f8ae64e43b3ab364b756848e1faafb56073e30fa)
Heres Harleys half brother Ruger.
(https://hunting-washington.com/smf/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fi279.photobucket.com%2Falbums%2Fkk157%2Fruger123%2Flexi%2520and%2520family%2FPicture015.jpg&hash=5c76653d1208279e126e5a9833d303a75f69470e)
Post by: AspenBud on March 11, 2013, 11:39:01 AM
The reality is I have dogs that find and point birds. Everything that happens after is not as pretty however. Pheasant and grouse still go in the bag though.
It takes time, money, and resources (birds, land, etc) to make a finished dog. If you have all of that I would say make it happen. If you can afford to send the dog off to a trainer I say do it. Or find a group to train with and pool resources.
But hold in mind that "finished" means different things to different people. For example, the gentleman who won the NSTRA quail invitational only teaches his dogs to be steady to wing and not the shot. Someone training a dog to American Field standards would train a dog to be steady to wing, shot, and not retrieve. Go to Europe and you'll see pointing dogs trained to flush on command and drop to their bellies at the flush. No right or wrong here. Just what works for the owner.
Post by: Happy Gilmore on March 11, 2013, 11:46:04 AM
hunt with a Chessie who will sit on a whistle. You'll get far more pheasants than hunting over any pointing breed. Especially in the Dakota's and Montana. Sharptail....get a pointer
Depends on how, and where you hunt. In milo, cut corn, and cattails, your right. But push birds into the coulees and natural prairie landscape where birds spread out and can be pinned, and a pointing dog will smoke a flusher/retriever. You throw some snow on that milo, and that changes everything as well.
The grassland where we hunted was mostly about 3-6' tall. Plowed fields and cut wheat were the only open range. Hard to see a dog on point looking out over a couple thousand acres of chest high grassland. That's where the chickens feel safe.
Post by: Stilly bay on March 11, 2013, 12:16:37 PM
hunt with a Chessie who will sit on a whistle. You'll get far more pheasants than hunting over any pointing breed. Especially in the Dakota's and Montana. Sharptail....get a pointer
Depends on how, and where you hunt. In milo, cut corn, and cattails, your right. But push birds into the coulees and natural prairie landscape where birds spread out and can be pinned, and a pointing dog will smoke a flusher/retriever. You throw some snow on that milo, and that changes everything as well.
The grassland where we hunted was mostly about 3-6' tall. Plowed fields and cut wheat were the only open range. Hard to see a dog on point looking out over a couple thousand acres of chest high grassland. That's where the chickens feel safe.
thats why we have garmin tracking collars. you don't need to see your pointy dog to know where he is and what he is doing.
Post by: AspenBud on March 11, 2013, 12:35:48 PM
hunt with a Chessie who will sit on a whistle. You'll get far more pheasants than hunting over any pointing breed. Especially in the Dakota's and Montana. Sharptail....get a pointer
Depends on how, and where you hunt. In milo, cut corn, and cattails, your right. But push birds into the coulees and natural prairie landscape where birds spread out and can be pinned, and a pointing dog will smoke a flusher/retriever. You throw some snow on that milo, and that changes everything as well.
The grassland where we hunted was mostly about 3-6' tall. Plowed fields and cut wheat were the only open range. Hard to see a dog on point looking out over a couple thousand acres of chest high grassland. That's where the chickens feel safe.
thats why we have garmin tracking collars. you don't need to see your pointy dog to know where he is and what he is doing.
And beepers with point mode.
Post by: Stilly bay on March 11, 2013, 12:39:33 PM
hunt with a Chessie who will sit on a whistle. You'll get far more pheasants than hunting over any pointing breed. Especially in the Dakota's and Montana. Sharptail....get a pointer
Depends on how, and where you hunt. In milo, cut corn, and cattails, your right. But push birds into the coulees and natural prairie landscape where birds spread out and can be pinned, and a pointing dog will smoke a flusher/retriever. You throw some snow on that milo, and that changes everything as well.
The grassland where we hunted was mostly about 3-6' tall. Plowed fields and cut wheat were the only open range. Hard to see a dog on point looking out over a couple thousand acres of chest high grassland. That's where the chickens feel safe.
thats why we have garmin tracking collars. you don't need to see your pointy dog to know where he is and what he is doing.
And beepers with point mode.
Ahhh nothing like the sound of a truck backing up for ambiance while your out hunting... or even worse, that fake hawk scream... or bobwhite chirp. I wish they would make those things illegal.
Post by: jetjockey on March 11, 2013, 12:41:33 PM
hunt with a Chessie who will sit on a whistle. You'll get far more pheasants than hunting over any pointing breed. Especially in the Dakota's and Montana. Sharptail....get a pointer
Depends on how, and where you hunt. In milo, cut corn, and cattails, your right. But push birds into the coulees and natural prairie landscape where birds spread out and can be pinned, and a pointing dog will smoke a flusher/retriever. You throw some snow on that milo, and that changes everything as well.
The grassland where we hunted was mostly about 3-6' tall. Plowed fields and cut wheat were the only open range. Hard to see a dog on point looking out over a couple thousand acres of chest high grassland. That's where the chickens feel safe.
thats why we have garmin tracking collars. you don't need to see your pointy dog to know where he is and what he is doing.
Exactly. I cant see my dog 90% of the time when were hunting. However, she knows where I am because I sing to her and I know where she is because of the GPS.
Post by: AspenBud on March 11, 2013, 02:34:16 PM
hunt with a Chessie who will sit on a whistle. You'll get far more pheasants than hunting over any pointing breed. Especially in the Dakota's and Montana. Sharptail....get a pointer
Depends on how, and where you hunt. In milo, cut corn, and cattails, your right. But push birds into the coulees and natural prairie landscape where birds spread out and can be pinned, and a pointing dog will smoke a flusher/retriever. You throw some snow on that milo, and that changes everything as well.
The grassland where we hunted was mostly about 3-6' tall. Plowed fields and cut wheat were the only open range. Hard to see a dog on point looking out over a couple thousand acres of chest high grassland. That's where the chickens feel safe.
thats why we have garmin tracking collars. you don't need to see your pointy dog to know where he is and what he is doing.
And beepers with point mode.
Ahhh nothing like the sound of a truck backing up for ambiance while your out hunting... or even worse, that fake hawk scream... or bobwhite chirp. I wish they would make those things illegal.
I'll be honest, I won't run a Pointer in the woods without one. I know some think they scare off birds but my experience with grouse is the opposite. It's a change in routine noise that scares them into flying, not silence.
Pheasants are another story but I'd argue it depends on time of year and whether you're hunting pen raised fowl on the release sites or the real deal east of the mountains.
The Garmin stuff is great, but it has failed me in the past. The beeper always works.
Post by: Shannon on March 11, 2013, 10:32:27 PM
Post by: JJD on March 12, 2013, 08:01:27 AM
hunt with a Chessie who will sit on a whistle. You'll get far more pheasants than hunting over any pointing breed. Especially in the Dakota's and Montana. Sharptail....get a pointer
Depends on how, and where you hunt. In milo, cut corn, and cattails, your right. But push birds into the coulees and natural prairie landscape where birds spread out and can be pinned, and a pointing dog will smoke a flusher/retriever. You throw some snow on that milo, and that changes everything as well.
The grassland where we hunted was mostly about 3-6' tall. Plowed fields and cut wheat were the only open range. Hard to see a dog on point looking out over a couple thousand acres of chest high grassland. That's where the chickens feel safe.
thats why we have garmin tracking collars. you don't need to see your pointy dog to know where he is and what he is doing.
And beepers with point mode.
Ahhh nothing like the sound of a truck backing up for ambiance while your out hunting... or even worse, that fake hawk scream... or bobwhite chirp. I wish they would make those things illegal.
Doesn't bother me a bit, turn off my hearing aids and it's back to peace and quiet. :chuckle:
Post by: Happy Gilmore on March 12, 2013, 08:43:43 AM
I've always had labs until about 6 years ago and have two Pudelpointers now. My pointers find and pin more wild roosters than my labs did. They are more fun to watch IMO and the shots are a lot easier when you flush the birds yourself IMO. I never have hunted over wild birds with a pointing lab but don't get as much enjoyment out of watching them work as I do a pointer. When I go to Montana every year to hunt pheasants with lab and Weim guys, my dogs always produce more birds in the bag. A lot of pointers don't like to get in the brush and thick cattails like a lab but Pudelpointers do. I've hunted with Wirehairs that crash thick cover as well or better than labs also. I think the pointers especially shine when the bird numbers are down and the dogs need to cover more ground to get a limit in the bag.
Was yours one of the ones who hooked up with Richard in MT last season?
Post by: Stilly bay on March 12, 2013, 12:57:37 PM
hunt with a Chessie who will sit on a whistle. You'll get far more pheasants than hunting over any pointing breed. Especially in the Dakota's and Montana. Sharptail....get a pointer
Depends on how, and where you hunt. In milo, cut corn, and cattails, your right. But push birds into the coulees and natural prairie landscape where birds spread out and can be pinned, and a pointing dog will smoke a flusher/retriever. You throw some snow on that milo, and that changes everything as well.
The grassland where we hunted was mostly about 3-6' tall. Plowed fields and cut wheat were the only open range. Hard to see a dog on point looking out over a couple thousand acres of chest high grassland. That's where the chickens feel safe.
thats why we have garmin tracking collars. you don't need to see your pointy dog to know where he is and what he is doing.
And beepers with point mode.
Ahhh nothing like the sound of a truck backing up for ambiance while your out hunting... or even worse, that fake hawk scream... or bobwhite chirp. I wish they would make those things illegal.
Doesn't bother me a bit, turn off my hearing aids and it's back to peace and quiet. :chuckle:
that kinda defeats the purpose of having a beeper doesn't it? :dunno:
different strokes for different folks.
I value stealth for my hunting trips. any human/unnatural noise tips the birds off and puts them on alert. I can stand beepers and people that constantly hack and call for their dogs out side of a field trial.
to me a good day in the field is when I only have to say "good dog" and "load up" it doesn't happen as much as I would like, but I really enjoy running silent when I can, and I feel I bag more grouse because of. too often have I heard birds that were pinned down flush at the sound of a beeper.
I do really like the tritronics beeper that can be activated with your transmitter, that is very handy and a safety feature to boot. kinda like when you loose your car in a huge parking area and push the lock button on your key fob.
Post by: Shannon on March 12, 2013, 02:34:37 PM
No I didn't meet up with him last year. The pudelpointers that were in that group he did meet up with- I'm not sure they are an average representation. Maybe my dogs aren't an average representation because I hunt them 50+ days a year. I'm not saying my dogs are the greatest bird dogs out there but they are extremely lethal on pheasants.