Hunting Washington Forum
Big Game Hunting => Deer Hunting => Topic started by: 300UltraMagShooter on December 06, 2013, 11:25:33 AM
-
Ha you all seen the 204 inch typical from WA?
I'd post pics but don't have permission. :drool:
-
:bdid:
:ban:
-
It's all over Facebook. At what point does permission to post a picture become a moot point? I've seen it shared/commented on/etc 4 times on my FB feed just this morning.
We're talking about the whitetail, right?
-
Really now why would you say somethong without a pic not funny.
-
Fine, ya'll talked me in to it.
-
That is a great buck. The score would have fooled me, but none the less, a whitey of a lifetime. Is there any story to go along with this? Archery? Late tag?
-
That's a stud buck!
-
Wow that is a awesome whitetail
-
So... wow... 204 net or gross?? What a monster...
-
I would literally pinch myself if I saw something like that in the woods. Holy mother of all things horny........That thing is huge
-
Great buck.
-
There are a couple 204" muley's from Washington this year too, that's a stud whitetail. :tup:
-
Amazing!
-
Wow! That is an amazing buck! What a rack! :drool:
-
To be honest I've never killed a buck if I saw that I would probably lock up. What a giant thanks for the pic
-
:drool:
-
WOW!!!!!!!! WHATTA BUCK :drool:
-
HOLY SMOKER MOTHER POKER !!! THAT IS ONE HECK OF A DEER ... :yeah: :bow: :bow: :brew:
-
Amazing buck. Who knows the story?
-
:yeah: wondering the same thing
-
WOW!! :yike:
-
Love to find one of his offspring......
-
Wow! What a buck! Congrats to the hunter!
-
WA sure is a sleeper state when it comes to big deer. Not as many bucks as some of the other well known deer meccas but every year there sure seems to be some bruisers produced. Congrats to the hunter.
:yeah: I seem to think the same thing each fall. Some real big, neat deer appear each year, some on cams others just like this with some lucky or really good dedicated hunter next to them :tup:. Just another great benefit of this site.
-
Wow, I was expecting a mule deer, that is a pig of a whitetail. Hopefully the muley pics will surface for all to see soon. This will keep everyone drooling for now. :drool: Stud deer for sure.
-
Beautiful buck but can't see over 200" there. Trophy either way though for sure
-
Beautiful buck but can't see over 200" there. Trophy either way though for sure
:o what in the world is it missing? :dunno:
-
outstanding buck... :tup: :tup: :tup:
-
Whitetail Elk? :o :dunno:
-
Holy smokes!! Now that's a deer! I'd love to hear more info about it. Anyone know the details?
-
That picture does not do it justice. It's a stud
-
Smoker buck for sure! I see 190 though. Still a masher buck for WA.
-
Another pic of his buck!
-
Good Lord that buck is huge.
Is that the US boundary clearcut?
Edit: Not insinuating any foul play, just curious.
-
Another pic of his buck!
Power line road with a designer sweat shirt.................some guys got all the luck :bash:
edit, No power lines but he is a dual citizen.
-
This buck was taken by a friend of mine. He sent me a e-mail with picture. Part of what he had to say was" I am proud that no bait was involved getting this buck. He was setting in a place between two bedding areas and near some scrapes. The buck was chasing a doe for 45 minutes around him before he got a shot. The buck and doe were being chased by another nice buck". He sent the following about the antlers. Width 21 inches, beam length 24 inches, 13 scoreable points, brow tines 8 inches. He is not sure how to score it and has come with gross scores between 188 and 198. Earlier in the season he rattled in a very tall buck but a spike charged in and spooked it. Glad that happened know.
He is a very competent archery hunter with elk and nice bucks in the past. A few years ago while on his knees rattling he called a cougar into closer than 10 yards. He shot the cougar through the bridge of nose, out throat into chest. He though the cat was going to jump him.
He lives in the Colville area. I don't know where he got the buck, and wouldn't say if I did, he hunts many areas.
-
That deer is amazing! I can't wait for all the " official internet picture scorer's" to be proven wrong. How many times do we have to learn you can't score a buck from a picture?
Awesome for the guy who shot that stud!
-
Definitely the buck of a lifetime.
-
I can't wait for all the " official internet picture scorer's" to be proven wrong. How many times do we have to learn you can't score a buck from a picture?
Awesome for the guy who shot that stud!
Its already been posted up.
Width 21 inches, beam length 24 inches, 13 scoreable points, brow tines 8 inches. He is not sure how to score it and has come with gross scores between 188 and 198.
-
Congratulations, the buck of a lifetime.
-
That deer is amazing! I can't wait for all the " official internet picture scorer's" to be proven wrong. How many times do we have to learn you can't score a buck from a picture?
Awesome for the guy who shot that stud!
With most bucks you can get close by using the pictures...seen it time and time again once they were on the ground....but I have also misjudged a few...but not ground shrinkage...more like they were bigger than I thought.
-
Word on FB is the hunter who scored on this awesome buck is Jim Ebel from Colville, WA. His daughter told us she took the cool picture up by the border. Very happy for the hunter.
-
This buck was taken by a friend of mine. He sent me a e-mail with picture. Part of what he had to say was" I am proud that no bait was involved getting this buck. He was setting in a place between two bedding areas and near some scrapes. The buck was chasing a doe for 45 minutes around him before he got a shot. The buck and doe were being chased by another nice buck". He sent the following about the antlers. Width 21 inches, beam length 24 inches, 13 scoreable points, brow tines 8 inches. He is not sure how to score it and has come with gross scores between 188 and 198. Earlier in the season he rattled in a very tall buck but a spike charged in and spooked it. Glad that happened know.
He is a very competent archery hunter with elk and nice bucks in the past. A few years ago while on his knees rattling he called a cougar into closer than 10 yards. He shot the cougar through the bridge of nose, out throat into chest. He though the cat was going to jump him.
He lives in the Colville area. I don't know where he got the buck, and wouldn't say if I did, he hunts many areas.
Thanks for more details on the story. I would say he is in the right range with 188-198.. I had him around 195 gross from the photos...though it's hard to say without every angle....every score I heard prior to this was 204-208.
-
What's most impressive is he was able to outdo everybody bait hunting.Big congrats to him. :tup:
-
Superman buck. Great to see the genes are around.
:tup:
-
Wow..... just, wow.
I've never seen anything like that walking.....
-
I'd be more impressed if this buck was taken over bait. :chuckle:
-
Its not missing anything besides a few inches.. Like I said a beautiful buck that would be hanging above my fireplace if I ever shot a buck like that.
-
Now that's a big boy :drool:
-
I had him about 180-185. He lacks long tines for a 200 inch deer. Those are my own personal thoughts and answering the ? what does he lack. IMO That being said, BUCK OF A LIFETIME. Drooling over such a trophy, congrats to the hunter. What an animal!
-
Beautiful animal. I have never seen such "flat paddles" (if that is the right word) for the tines/eye guard/whatever.
-
http://www.spokesman.com/stories/2013/dec/11/landers-internet-abuzz-over-huge-whitetail/ (http://www.spokesman.com/stories/2013/dec/11/landers-internet-abuzz-over-huge-whitetail/)
-
Definitely worth reading. Good story.
-
That deer is amazing! I can't wait for all the " official internet picture scorer's" to be proven wrong. How many times do we have to learn you can't score a buck from a picture?
Awesome for the guy who shot that stud!
Sometimes its really not rocket science.
A 150 whitetail is a great buck. A 160 is a giant, a 180 is a gagger, and 200 well....
Just keeping it real.
-
That deer is amazing! I can't wait for all the " official internet picture scorer's" to be proven wrong. How many times do we have to learn you can't score a buck from a picture?
Awesome for the guy who shot that stud!
Sometimes its really not rocket science.
A 150 whitetail is a great buck. A 160 is a giant, a 180 is a gagger, and 200 well....
Just keeping it real.
I agree, and will also add that a 140" whitetail is a fantastic whitetail as well.
-
That deer is amazing! I can't wait for all the " official internet picture scorer's" to be proven wrong. How many times do we have to learn you can't score a buck from a picture?
Awesome for the guy who shot that stud!
Sometimes its really not rocket science.
A 150 whitetail is a great buck. A 160 is a giant, a 180 is a gagger, and 200 well....
Just keeping it real.
The left side of that buck has 200 written all over it. I don't know what you mean by short tines. The right side, I assumed you probably couldn't see it all in the picture.
Looking at the right side, it is definitely not a 200 inch deer, but still huge.
-
http://www.spokesman.com/stories/2013/dec/11/landers-internet-abuzz-over-huge-whitetail/ (http://www.spokesman.com/stories/2013/dec/11/landers-internet-abuzz-over-huge-whitetail/)
Good story, like i said in an earlier post. Maybe 190. Great buck. If youve seen enough good bucks its not hard to give a good estimate on score if its a decent picture. I cant wait for people to finally realize what it takes to make a 200" buck.
-
That deer is amazing! I can't wait for all the " official internet picture scorer's" to be proven wrong. How many times do we have to learn you can't score a buck from a picture?
Awesome for the guy who shot that stud!
Sometimes its really not rocket science.
A 150 whitetail is a great buck. A 160 is a giant, a 180 is a gagger, and 200 well....
Just keeping it real.
+1
-
Here is a 200 inch net buck for your comparison pleasure
-
Here is another 217" buck. Both of these 200" deer are Washington deer.
-
Here is a 200 inch net buck for your comparison pleasure
What does that thing gross?
-
C'mon Buckman, what are you trying to do? It is almost a year until most of us can hunt again and you are teasing us with those studs. You trying to get a bunch of guys to give it one last go in 124 or something? Just giving you grief, those are some dandy racks, thanks for sharing for comparison.
-
Here is a 200 inch net buck for your comparison pleasure
What does that thing gross?
Just eyeballin' it, no expert here - but I'm going to guess that B&C gross numbers are 215 gross typical and 224 4/8 gross non-typical.
:chuckle:
-
Here is a 200 inch net buck for your comparison pleasure
What does that thing gross?
Just eyeballin' it, no expert here - but I'm going to guess that B&C gross numbers are 215 gross typical and 224 4/8 gross non-typical.
:chuckle:
I don't think it has that many deductions. Besides the extra brow tine it's pretty symmetrical.
-
I see about 3-4" of deduction minus the brows. One hell of a whitey in any state or providence. :tup:
-
Here is a 200 inch net buck for your comparison pleasure
What does that thing gross?
Just eyeballin' it, no expert here - but I'm going to guess that B&C gross numbers are 215 gross typical and 224 4/8 gross non-typical.
:chuckle:
I don't think it has that many deductions. Besides the extra brow tine it's pretty symmetrical.
Well, I think I'm pretty close. That's the Cartwright buck and those #'s are from DBHAWTHORNE's article on it.
-
Here is a 200 inch net buck for your comparison pleasure
:tup: First time I have seen that picture
-
Here is a 200 inch net buck for your comparison pleasure
Is that the cartwright buck?
-
Irionic the pic is taken with a truck tire... :chuckle:
-
Here is a 200 inch net buck for your comparison pleasure
:tup: First time I have seen that picture
Yeah DB. Those are the replicas one of only two. Daydreamer bought them. I picked them up for him and will be taking them go him soon.
-
Irionic the pic is taken with a truck tire... :chuckle:
:yeah: :chuckle: :tung:
-
Love seeing giant bucks! Who care what they score! Any of those are bucks of a lifetime, anywhere!
-
Isn't it just fun to imagine what could be out there... thats what keeps me going too... I probably will never find or kill him... but to know there is "the one" walking around out there....
-
Jim Ebel is a good guy, glad to see he is the hunter who got the buck. He ran the Colville Fish Hatchery for years, in fact he's on our advisory board for the fish hatchery. According to Rich Landers story, Ebel said the buck scored about 186. Funny how people change the story. Totally awesome buck! :tup:
-
The whitetail potential in this state is off the charts. Amazing bucks for sure.
-
From those pics it's hard to get an accurate score. Preferably you would want a direct side profile of both sides and a straight on...once it grows non-typical points you may need more angles.. Typically on those bigger bucks the best you can hope for is within 10 inches....from those pics (which are not optimum for scoring) on the conservative side I would have him at 185 but I can see 195..I kept hearing 204 - 208 which also probably skewed my bias.. Was still not able to come up with 200+ no matter how I looked at it (but could have been possible that I was misjudging something). There is one thing glaringly apparent from those pics: That buck is exceptional. No score needed to see that.
Glad a respectable man killed him. Congrats to the hunter!
-
Stud buck sir!!!!!!!!!! :tup:
-
My buddy missed that buck a couple times he has property right above where that buck was taken he was sick to his stomache when he.heard somebody else got him.
-
My buddy missed that buck a couple times he has property right above where that buck was taken he was sick to his stomache when he.heard somebody else got him.
It happens.. When its taken by a respectable hunter it makes it easier to swallow.
-
My buddy missed that buck a couple times he has property right above where that buck was taken he was sick to his stomache when he.heard somebody else got him.
I located a nice buck and hiked a buddy in to get him with his late tag this year, got him within 225 yards two days in a row and he missed both times, broadside, my tripod as a rest while he sat. :chuckle:
-
My buddy missed that buck a couple times he has property right above where that buck was taken he was sick to his stomache when he.heard somebody else got him.
I take it your buddy has property in Canada then??
-
i would probably forget to pull the trigger if a buck like that walked out in front of me, especially a blacktail :'( :'(
-
The whitetail potential in this state is off the charts. Amazing bucks for sure.
This.
I've been telling my wetside buddies for 20 years that the state record lives in Stevens County.
-
Wow