Hunting Washington Forum
Big Game Hunting => Backcountry Hunting => Topic started by: RallyDawg on July 19, 2016, 02:27:55 PM
-
I am looking to purchase a solo shelter set up for the back country can see the benefits of both. I really like the idea of a bivy/tarp set up but have never spent anytime using one so I am looking to get an idea how may guys run this set up compared to a 1 man tent. I would be using this set up up until the end of October (3 season) in EWA.
-
Hammock and rainfly.
-
I use a backpacking tent.
-
Lightweight 2 man tent. Plenty of room to sleep with gear stored inside tent.
-
Lightweight 2 man tent. Plenty of room to sleep with gear stored inside tent.
This! :yeah:
I love the comfort of a hammock but you will get cold! By the time you spend the money for the under insulation and the tarp for the hammock you could have just gotten a tent. IMHO.
-
I use a Kifaru Paratarp with a ti goat raven omni zip or a BA Flycreek ul2. Both work great and both have their pros and cons. I use the bivy by it's self if I know it's not gonna rain. Tarp and bivy is a real lightweight compact setup that weighs just over a pound if I remember correctly.
-
I used my new jimmys tarps skyline this past weekend and liked it
-
Lightweight 2 man tent. Plenty of room to sleep with gear stored inside tent.
:yeah: Yup a tent under 4 lbs and plenty of room. I like being sealed off from the bugs and the elements.
-
I personally use a Lightheart Gear Solo. It's a roomy 1p tent, weighs in around 30oz seam sealed. The only caveat is that it uses trekking poles to set up, but it's awesome.
-
I VOTED OTHER, I LIKE MY WINNEBAGO IN THE BACK COUNTRY. I CALLED AND THEY SAID I WAS GOOD TO GO WITH IT BEING HELO'ED IN. :cmp1:
-
After using both tarps and tents I like tarps better. Bugs have never been a problem with the tarp. 90% of the time using a tarp I use a bivy also.
-
I have a bunch of different options. From tipi/stove to tarp and bivy to just a bivy to a tent and more. Overall, I'd recommend the BA Fly Creek UL2 for price, weight, and it's multiple uses. Tent and everything included is under 3 lbs. You can just take the fly, footprint, and stakes to be around 1.7 lbs. At $280 no tax/free shipping (if you know where to look) for the full tent and footprint, it's my #1 overall recommedation. :twocents:
-
I have used a pice of black plastic 6mil for a long time but just recently bought a hammock and a nylon tarp I love it. No more sleeping on the ground and waking up with the back pain the comes with sleeping not the ground, I use an insulated pad under me with a bivy and a woobe (poncho liner) I would say if you get cold ease you would want a sleeping bag. My pack comes in at 30# with food for 3 days and two full water bottles.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Hammock and rainfly.
That is sweet. You know the weight of that set up?
-
Hammock and rainfly.
That is sweet. You know the weight of that set up?
Under 3 pounds with the heavy duty straps.
-
I have a Cimarron, it is bad$!@. It is HUGE for 1, large for 2 AND a stove AND gear, and plenty for 3 or 4 if you gotta.
My next ultralight set up will be a Bearpaw Wilderness Designs La Garita 2, weighing a whopping 17 ounces.
Floorless is flat out better. More room, less weight, less mess, more versatile...
(https://hunting-washington.com/smf/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fuploads.tapatalk-cdn.com%2F20160720%2Ffbb3e0c9e3c29fcb7e4fe414f9bae8a4.jpg&hash=b92fc382063c95a582881c803d05b1df2ec23484)
Sent from my SM-N910P using Tapatalk
-
Blue Tarp. Pick a size any size. :tup:
-
I use a BA cooper spur 2 and love it! I'd love to get one of the mega tarps, but dang man, Ive just had too many hunts where the bugs are crazy craZy insane. I'll take my tent thank you. It's barely 3 lbs.
-
Tbob I've been on some scouting trips where you could kill 20+ skeeters with one slap. And once you setup the tarp the bugs that fly under it bounce along the roof and don't land on you while laying under it. As soon as you get up you are swarmed again with hundreds all over you. Not sure why it's like that.
That's been my experience while using a tarp in Alaska and Washington.
-
....all the more reason I recommended the tent. Also, if I see see one benefit of the Copper Spur over the Fly Creek that would justify 1/2 pound, I'd be all over it. :twocents:
-
Silnylon tarp, cheap to sew one for yourself. Then buy one of those SeaToSummit bug nets that weigh like 7 ounces. Then you don't have to worry about finding perfect trees for a hammock and tarp.
-
My options are always open as the chance of rain, forecasted winds, bug problems, and temperatures will all dictate my decisions. Staying as lite as I can and being as comfortable throughout the night is always my goal.
-
I slept in a borrowed Fly Creek UL1 for the first time last month. I am 5'6", 165lbs, and there wasn't much extra room inside. I was able to squeeze my boots under the "awning" and my pack had to sit outside. Definitely go for the 2 man.
For our elk hunt this year we will be sleeping in a Kifaru Tut though.
-
If I'm going deep I just take my GI sleeping bag system
Good to about -10 or so
Waterproof and warm
That and a space blanket if it's raining
-
Hammock and rainfly.
I tried the hammock and tarp setup for a few seasons but I found that in the cold weather it was really difficult to stay warm in the hammock. I still like the idea of it because you aren't limited to flat terrain for sleeping but I couldnt figure out how to get the right amount of insulation without adding a ton of weight to my pack. Any tips?
-
Hammock and rainfly.
I tried the hammock and tarp setup for a few seasons but I found that in the cold weather it was really difficult to stay warm in the hammock. I still like the idea of it because you aren't limited to flat terrain for sleeping but I couldnt figure out how to get the right amount of insulation without adding a ton of weight to my pack. Any tips?
Cut a custom ccf pad that fits into your hammock, upgrade your bag, or go with the under quilt.
-
Different trips sometimes require different options. I do however prefer my BA 2-person whenever possible. Hammock and tarp, GL SL-5, and a BA 2 person are all relatively close in weight, so I focus more on the terrain and weather when making a decision. Options are never a bad thing...
-
Just remember Mother Nature has a way of changing your hunting plans. Find a set up that will handle all elements that she can throw at you. We ended up pinned down in are tents for 2 days of rain wind and snow.
(https://hunting-washington.com/smf/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fuploads.tapatalk-cdn.com%2F20160722%2F4691bbe5aa835212d9894b6f4b91bea1.jpg&hash=3c39d9bcc0b4f91cc09cc23f3dd29edcd2dbf9fd)
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Hammock and rainfly.
Only way to go
-
Hammock and rainfly.
Only way to go
As long as you're below the timberline ;)
-
Hammock and rainfly.
Only way to go
As long as you're below the timberline ;)
It would certainly be awkward with no trees and all.
I have a BA Fly Creek UL1 I'd sell or trade for a 2 person tent of equal value if anyone is interested.
:dunno:
-
Boulders work great for anchor points. Small alpine trees are a little questionable though.
-
Hammock and rainfly.
Only way to go
As long as you're below the timberline ;)
It would certainly be awkward with no trees and all.
I have a BA Fly Creek UL1 I'd sell or trade for a 2 person tent of equal value if anyone is interested.
:dunno:
You must have gotten tired of your head being in the vestibule. :chuckle:
-
Hammock and rainfly.
Only way to go
As long as you're below the timberline ;)
It would certainly be awkward with no trees and all.
I have a BA Fly Creek UL1 I'd sell or trade for a 2 person tent of equal value if anyone is interested.
:dunno:
You must have gotten tired of your head being in the vestibule. :chuckle:
I'm blessed, bro.
:chuckle:
-
I'll tell you what, I'm only 5' 8" but a one man tent is like being in a dog kennel. And I wouldn't split a two man with anybody I wouldn't share a bed with :yike:
-
You guys aren't doing anything to promote the sale of my tent.
-
Is this the classifieds section? :chuckle:
-
Yeah I guess that wasn't terribly helpful.
-
Ha, PM me a cash price jack and we might make a deal..... :chuckle: :tup:
-
I'll add my amateurish setup.
Coleman tube tent.
8 bucks. Will last a few trips. Cover and ground cloth all in one. Indescribably light.
It's not a tent but works as good as most tarp set ups.
I grew up under 6 mil poly. A little bug net over the face for mosquitos and I'm good.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using Tapatalk
-
I love a tarp and bivy but my backpacking and hunting partners are too wimpy for it so Ive gone back to a tent...
-
Parachute cut to fly shape, with a nylon string.
-
Parachute cut to fly shape, with a nylon string.
Where do you get a parachute?
-
Parachute cut to fly shape, with a nylon string.
Where do you get a parachute?
PARACHUTE STORE. :chuckle:
SURPLUS STORES, EBAY ETC...
http://www.ebay.com/bhp/parachute-canopy
-
Parachute cut to fly shape, with a nylon string.
Where do you get a parachute?
PARACHUTE STORE. :chuckle:
SURPLUS STORES, EBAY ETC...
http://www.ebay.com/bhp/parachute-canopy
Lol thanks :tup:
-
Huge personal preference factors in choosing a backpacking shelter. I've slept on the ground well over three years of my life in total and way prefer a simple flat tarp. It is infinitely adaptable to fit any space and option, does not require a certain footprint space or shape nor certain tree spacing etc. I made my own 8' x10' from super light material from Seattle Fabrics and it is very light weight and compact. I'd make it bigger next time even for one person though two of us have slept under it on backpack hunts a time or two.
I rarely camp above timberline with my flat tarp. If you plan to camp above timberline, get a tent.
If it is bug season, and most Fall hunting is after the bugs where I hunt, then take a separate mosquito net as several have suggested. I use the regular net from REI made to cover a full size bed, and tie up one end over my head enough to let me sit up under it while the remainder drapes down to the ground and slopes down to drape around my sleeping bag at about my hips. I could trim off at least half of the net. Rig it sideways and up to three people can sleep side by side with heads and shoulders under the bug free space.
I own three backpack tents, a pre-shaped silnylon tarp tent and a 6 man tipi. I use them for compact car camping but have never backpacked any of them except for the tarptent and it did not work well at one of the places I carried it. My wife way prefers the privacy and sense of protection from a tent. YMMV. My next really cold winter backpack hunt I will take the tipi if others go with me. Solo, I flat tarp it.
-
As others have already mentioned, it all depends on the situation. Generally speaking, the weight increases with anticipated weather & exposure and to a certain degree how long I anticipate being in a particular area.
For summer scouting trips where bugs are really bad, I'm on the move and I don't want to bother with finding level ground to sleep, I use my Hennessey Hammock assuming I'll have access to good sized trees.
http://hennessyhammock.com/products/explorer-ultralite-asym-zip
If I want to go bare bones in awesome weather where I can find a flat spot and bugs aren't an issue, my Hilleberg Bivanorak gets the nod. If bugs might be an issue, I'll bring a little net that I can tuck my head and shoulders into over my bag. Works great.
If the weather looks like the dew might be heavy or if there is a very small chance of precipitation, in addition to the Bivanorak I'll bring the small silnylon tarp from my Hennessey Hammock, particularly if I know I can get down in the sub-alpine and out of most of the wind.
If there's a bigger chance of rain and maybe a little more wind, I'll use a bigger tarp, usually my Exped Helium.
If there is a good chance of a high wind variability (gusting and multi-directional), with minimal rain or humidity, and I know I can use pegs, I'm jumping up to using my Kifaru MegaTarp & Annex with the Bivanorak. Assuming you can get good purchase with pegs, the MegaTarp and Annex is bombproof and is palatial. It will easily accommodate two guys and their gear. Three in a pinch.
If conditions are the same as above, but temps are going to consistently be freezing AND there is access to decent wood, I'll bring a little wood stove to take the edge off in the mornings and night. This setup works really well for longer trips where hauling additional fuel canisters is offset by a wood stove that not only boils water, but also heats the shelter and dries out wet clothing.
If the same as above, but there will be consistent humidity, precipitation and wind, I'll add a liner to the above Bivanorak, MegaTarp, annex and wood stove combo. If you don't add the liner, you might as well be sleeping outside when once the stove dies from all the condensation that forms on the inside of the single wall shelter. ;)
https://store.kifaru.net/megatarp-p85.aspx
Note that the constant with the combinations above is the use of the Hilleberg Bivanorak. I like to have it in the pack if I need to emergency spike out from my main base camp. Is it perfect and made of the latest, greatest, lightest most breathable fabric on the planet? No. But, it is an extremely versatile piece of kit. There's nothing quite like carefully setting a small tea-light candle, jetboil or other small stove down between your feet when you want to soak up some heat mid-day when glassing.
http://us.hilleberg.com/EN/shelters/bivanorak/
If doing something like High Buck in some of the more exposed places I like to go where it's oftentimes iffy finding enough footprint room and good soil for pegging down the MegaTarp and there is a strong chance of some super crappy rain, wind, snow, sleet, spindrift, etc., then the Hilleberg Soulo gets the nod. Freakin' awesome freestanding bombproof 1-person tent. Love the modularity and I sleep like a baby at night regardless of what Mother Nature decides to dish out.
http://us.hilleberg.com/EN/tent/red-label-tents/soulo/
-
If I'm going deep I just take my GI sleeping bag system
Good to about -10 or so
Waterproof and warm
That and a space blanket if it's raining
this.. probably end up getting this if i get real serious about going up high
-
Hammock and rainfly.
Only way to go
As long as you're below the timberline ;)
Then it becomes a ground cloth and rainfly. Love versatile gear. ;)
-
Im using a MSR Hubba 1 person tent atm. Has a small footprint ... and I still hate finding a flat spot for it. Is actually fairly narrow compared to other 1 person tents I looked at when I bought it a few years ago, but it widens towards the top so it feels much wider than it is. With the rain fly on it doesnt make it feel too cramped because it goes off to your left and right. I have a 2 person tent that its like sliding down into a tube ... this feels much less cramped. Also has good head space. Hammock and tarp is on the want ... NEED list(if the wife asks). I sleep like #$@& on the ground. Something is always sore or falling asleep. Ive used just tarps a few times. All depends on where Im hunting, weather, time of year, distance traveling, length of time, how comfortable I want to be.
-
Hammock and rainfly.
switched to this setup this year and it's the best sleep I've had in the backcountry
-
Everyone has a preference, I started with using a tarp and making my own shelter. Then went to a hilleberg tarp for weight and quality. After having the multiple experience of small critters coming into my sleeping area at night and causing me to not get any sleep. I switched to a KUIU ultralight 1p. It is 17 ounces and is easy to setup, I've been through heavy rain at night with it, I am 6-4' and I have enough room inside the tent to be comfortable. My one small complaint is it does condensate easily inside. But zero critters have woken me up lately.
-
Every tent/ shelter set up has its place. I know a lot of guys like floorless, I always wonder how many of those guys hunt the wetside of the mountains in October rainstorms? I was on top of a ridge in my hillberg the first week of September in breezy conditions and an absolute downpour at about 38 degrees. When I woke up it felt like a waterbed, the area I pitchedy my tent was a small pond. I was sure glad I had a floor! I stayed completely dry and warm for 3 days despite the conditions. I use a hillberg nallo gt for nasty conditions and an 25oz single wall Cuban fiber tent during summer or when conditions allow. I have not tried floorless yet, but I hope to some day. My current hunting locations/ schedule is better suited to a tent
-
tagging
-
Every tent/ shelter set up has its place. I know a lot of guys like floorless, I always wonder how many of those guys hunt the wetside of the mountains in October rainstorms? I was on top of a ridge in my hillberg the first week of September in breezy conditions and an absolute downpour at about 38 degrees. When I woke up it felt like a waterbed, the area I pitchedy my tent was a small pond. I was sure glad I had a floor! I stayed completely dry and warm for 3 days despite the conditions. I use a hillberg nallo gt for nasty conditions and an 25oz single wall Cuban fiber tent during summer or when conditions allow. I have not tried floorless yet, but I hope to some day. My current hunting locations/ schedule is better suited to a tent
What 25oz cubed fiber tent are you using? Z-packs?
-
Every tent/ shelter set up has its place. I know a lot of guys like floorless, I always wonder how many of those guys hunt the wetside of the mountains in October rainstorms? I was on top of a ridge in my hillberg the first week of September in breezy conditions and an absolute downpour at about 38 degrees. When I woke up it felt like a waterbed, the area I pitchedy my tent was a small pond. I was sure glad I had a floor! I stayed completely dry and warm for 3 days despite the conditions. I use a hillberg nallo gt for nasty conditions and an 25oz single wall Cuban fiber tent during summer or when conditions allow. I have not tried floorless yet, but I hope to some day. My current hunting locations/ schedule is better suited to a tent
First of all, don't set up in a low spot that will turn into a pond when it rains. :) My son and I have tarp camped many times on October and November Western WA backpack hunts. On our worst one it rained sideways after dumping a foot of snow that mortar bombed us as if fell off of limbs in huge chunks. It was critical to pitch the tarp and sleep on a raised spot that was not a puddle nor running water. Finding such a spot is usually easy for one person, more difficult for each body added.
Lest I get backed into sounding like a stronger advocate for tarps than makes me comfortable, please carry however much weight and stuff you want to provide the comfort level you want. Anyone can do that without putting down folks who choose lesser options that work if the user knows how to use them. Have a great hunt!
FWIW, I love the concept of a hammock in our wet forest but when I tried a Hennessey it was too claustrophobic or something for me to sleep well and I returned it. My loss but a man has to be comfortable with his own gear to hunt well.
-
Thanks for all the feedback. I am likely going to sell my new Nemo Losi 3P and pickup a Seek Outside shelter. I anticipate using this shelter on the eastside so I like the idea of a floor less shelter with the possibility of a stove for late season.
-
Parachute cut to fly shape, with a nylon string.
Where do you get a parachute?
He got it at The Gettin' Place
:chuckle:
-
Rain is one thing. Dry fine snow is quite another. Yes it shakes off but more than a few days of wind and fine snow that gets everywhere make a sealed shelter a happy place indeed. Take care of yourself is rule #1. If you have a easy exit plan you can experiment. 2 cents
-
Floorless shelters, especially tipis are awesome in the snow. The snow insulates around the bottom and you don't have to worry about getting pebbles and snow on the floor.
I've never felt more sealed than when I was in a large tipi with 4" of snow around the base and a stove inside :tup:
-
Floorless shelters, especially tipis are awesome in the snow. The snow insulates around the bottom and you don't have to worry about getting pebbles and snow on the floor.
I've never felt more sealed than when I was in a large tipi with 4" of snow around the base and a stove inside :tup:
Do you just scrape the ground clean before you pitch your tent?
-
Floorless shelters, especially tipis are awesome in the snow. The snow insulates around the bottom and you don't have to worry about getting pebbles and snow on the floor.
I've never felt more sealed than when I was in a large tipi with 4" of snow around the base and a stove inside :tup:
Do you just scrape the ground clean before you pitch your tent?
Most places that I hunt I just leave it all there. Pine needles, dead grass etc. those types of substrates are perfect. Much better than bare dirt. Sometimes in early season it can be hard to find a spot that wouldn't require pulling a bunch of plants. Still easier than a floored shelter though.
A few weeks ago, I slept in a floor less tipi that had a big clump of beargrass right in the middle. Would have been super awkward for a floored shelter but we just put the center pole there and slept on either side of it.
-
Sorry, I meant scrape the snow way
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Sorry, I meant scrape the snow way
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Oh haha! If it is less than a foot deep then yeah but with double folded Tyvek, I sleep right on top of it.
-
Another one for Hammock and tarp. I backpack year around even with snowshoes and a pulk and I still use a hammock setup. If you cant find trees (Rare out here) I can put up the tarp with my trekking pole or branches for one night. As for being cold, if you get the right equipment I found its warmer than a tent.
-
Well from reading all the reviews here on floor less shelters I decided to give one a go.. I've only set it up in the yard so far, but I'm pretty stoked to get it out in the woods for a few nights.. It's a customized Jimmy Tarp Skyline. Sets up nice and it's insanely light (Silpro). I got the 9x9 and I think it weighs 11 oz..
-
This was my early season SoCal mule deer hunt set up...
-
Great looking set up. Cool picture too.
-
Thanks man! One thing I've learned with quality ul equipment is that it's pretty spendy, so I do my research and spend my money wisely, but it's nice having a comfy little camp set up and it weighs almost nothing..
I'm really excited to try out my floorless this year.. Decided though not to use it in desert snake country.. I'm okay with bugs and mice and such, but diamond back rattlers, Tarantulas and scorpions........ No thanks, gotta draw my line somewhere! Haha!
-
light weight, and drys quickly