Post by: 3dvapor on October 07, 2016, 10:18:38 AM
Post by: SteelheadTed on October 07, 2016, 12:45:50 PM
Post by: Becky on October 07, 2016, 12:54:21 PM
Someone good with photoshop could do this but why? It's part of your story, go with it! Editing it in this case would be a lie IMO. Everytime you look at that edited photo in the future you'll know it isn't real.
Some food for thought though - there's people that actually advocate to edit out extra gruesome/or bloody photos before posting it on social media so the antis don't have fodder to freak out over... but this is an interesting question. Curious myself on the reasoning OP wants the edit?
Post by: SteelheadTed on October 07, 2016, 01:03:20 PM
I can..Someone good with photoshop could do this but why? It's part of your story, go with it! Editing it in this case would be a lie IMO. Everytime you look at that edited photo in the future you'll know it isn't real.
Some food for thought though - there's people that actually advocate to edit out extra gruesome/or bloody photos before posting it on social media so the antis don't have fodder to freak out over... but this is an interesting question. Curious myself on the reasoning OP wants the edit?
Yeah, I am aware those that advocate this and I agree we should think about where we post our hunting photos. I also believe that those who are opposed to hunting, those that would be "offended" by hunting photos like this aren't worth catering to. Dumbing down the experience of hunting will only play into their hands. We should be unashamed of what it means to be a hunter and blood and guts are part of it. To gloss over the messy parts is to miss a vital piece of what it is to eat sustainable meat. Butchering an animal is a messy business but when we hide the uncomfortable parts we are less connected to the animals and the land. It should be messy, to keep us grounded and respectful of the animals.
Post by: huntnphool on October 07, 2016, 01:09:13 PM
Post by: DaveMonti on October 07, 2016, 01:14:56 PM
Do you ever check your appearance before someone takes your picture? Why? Just because the OP prefers it that way. The rest is none of your business.
If you can't help him with his request, just ignore the post. No need to badger him and angle for a reason to criticize, and yes, criticizing IS your angle here.
Post by: Becky on October 07, 2016, 01:29:00 PM
If you can't help him with his request, just ignore the post. No need to badger him and angle for a reason to criticize, and yes, criticizing IS your angle here.
Actually I'm asking because I said I CAN, and there are numerous things that can be done to edit a photo depending on what he wants to do with the photo.. I've helped out many members with requests - usually print, so I keep that in mind and return a photo in the size they're wanting the print :P
Post by: WAnoob on October 07, 2016, 01:39:26 PM
I can..Someone good with photoshop could do this but why? It's part of your story, go with it! Editing it in this case would be a lie IMO. Everytime you look at that edited photo in the future you'll know it isn't real.
Some food for thought though - there's people that actually advocate to edit out extra gruesome/or bloody photos before posting it on social media so the antis don't have fodder to freak out over... but this is an interesting question. Curious myself on the reasoning OP wants the edit?
But you deliberately asked why for the edit in your last sentence. Not how he wanted edited.. :P :P :P :P
Post by: Becky on October 07, 2016, 01:45:13 PM
I can..Someone good with photoshop could do this but why? It's part of your story, go with it! Editing it in this case would be a lie IMO. Everytime you look at that edited photo in the future you'll know it isn't real.
Some food for thought though - there's people that actually advocate to edit out extra gruesome/or bloody photos before posting it on social media so the antis don't have fodder to freak out over... but this is an interesting question. Curious myself on the reasoning OP wants the edit?
But you deliberately asked why for the edit in your last sentence. Not how he wanted edited.. :P :P :P :P
Yep! I said "Curious myself on the reasoning OP wants the edit?" ... the first sentence, in case you missed it, I defended reasons for people wanting to edit out the blood from photos :tup: .. Not sure what you think I said. After DaveMonti's post saying basically "don't ask unless you can help" and I said "I can help" (as in, I can help him so am I allowed to ask?). So what exactly are you pointing out? :)
Also gotta note since when are we not allowed to ask questions to an OP in a thread that's posted on here? :chuckle:
Post by: huntnphool on October 07, 2016, 01:46:02 PM
Post by: DaveMonti on October 07, 2016, 01:51:33 PM
As soon as I saw the title of this post, I knew, without reading, that someone would reply and tell the OP that photo shopping would be a "lie" and "not real" and we need to "keep it real". Clearly you indicated you could help and although you're curious at to why, you're not telling the OP they are wrong for wanting to do so.
Post by: Bean Counter on October 07, 2016, 01:53:39 PM
Post by: Bean Counter on October 07, 2016, 01:59:19 PM
I'm not directing it at you SG.
As soon as I saw the title of this post, I knew, without reading, that someone would reply and tell the OP that photo shopping would be a "lie" and "not real" and we need to "keep it real". Clearly you indicated you could help and although you're curious at to why, you're not telling the OP they are wrong for wanting to do so.
Scott Kelby, one of the Who's Who of the photography world, on why we 'Photoshop' people.
Post by: WAnoob on October 07, 2016, 02:04:20 PM
I can..Someone good with photoshop could do this but why? It's part of your story, go with it! Editing it in this case would be a lie IMO. Everytime you look at that edited photo in the future you'll know it isn't real.
Some food for thought though - there's people that actually advocate to edit out extra gruesome/or bloody photos before posting it on social media so the antis don't have fodder to freak out over... but this is an interesting question. Curious myself on the reasoning OP wants the edit?
But you deliberately asked why for the edit in your last sentence. Not how he wanted edited.. :P :P :P :P
Yep! I said "Curious myself on the reasoning OP wants the edit?" ... the first sentence, in case you missed it, I defended reasons for people wanting to edit out the blood from photos :tup: .. Not sure what you think I said. After DaveMonti's post saying basically "don't ask unless you can help" and I said "I can help" (as in, I can help him so am I allowed to ask?). So what exactly are you pointing out? :)
Also gotta note since when are we not allowed to ask questions to an OP in a thread that's posted on here? :chuckle:
I'm sensing this is another thread where no moderators can be wrong, even though there post is littered with sarcasm. -
Post by: jackelope on October 07, 2016, 02:21:15 PM
I can..Someone good with photoshop could do this but why? It's part of your story, go with it! Editing it in this case would be a lie IMO. Everytime you look at that edited photo in the future you'll know it isn't real.
Some food for thought though - there's people that actually advocate to edit out extra gruesome/or bloody photos before posting it on social media so the antis don't have fodder to freak out over... but this is an interesting question. Curious myself on the reasoning OP wants the edit?
But you deliberately asked why for the edit in your last sentence. Not how he wanted edited.. :P :P :P :P
Yep! I said "Curious myself on the reasoning OP wants the edit?" ... the first sentence, in case you missed it, I defended reasons for people wanting to edit out the blood from photos :tup: .. Not sure what you think I said. After DaveMonti's post saying basically "don't ask unless you can help" and I said "I can help" (as in, I can help him so am I allowed to ask?). So what exactly are you pointing out? :)
Also gotta note since when are we not allowed to ask questions to an OP in a thread that's posted on here? :chuckle:
I'm sensing this is another thread where no moderators can be wrong, even though there post is littered with sarcasm. -
Why even take it there? A simple question was asked, that's all. If the guy doesn't want to answer, he won't. Maybe he wants to hang it on the wall in his house and doesn't want the bloody photo there for all to see. I feel like it's a question that doesn't need to be asked in the first place, and the follow up is also uncalled for.
:twocents:
Post by: WAnoob on October 07, 2016, 02:30:59 PM
I can..Someone good with photoshop could do this but why? It's part of your story, go with it! Editing it in this case would be a lie IMO. Everytime you look at that edited photo in the future you'll know it isn't real.
Some food for thought though - there's people that actually advocate to edit out extra gruesome/or bloody photos before posting it on social media so the antis don't have fodder to freak out over... but this is an interesting question. Curious myself on the reasoning OP wants the edit?
But you deliberately asked why for the edit in your last sentence. Not how he wanted edited.. :P :P :P :P
Yep! I said "Curious myself on the reasoning OP wants the edit?" ... the first sentence, in case you missed it, I defended reasons for people wanting to edit out the blood from photos :tup: .. Not sure what you think I said. After DaveMonti's post saying basically "don't ask unless you can help" and I said "I can help" (as in, I can help him so am I allowed to ask?). So what exactly are you pointing out? :)
Also gotta note since when are we not allowed to ask questions to an OP in a thread that's posted on here? :chuckle:
I'm sensing this is another thread where no moderators can be wrong, even though there post is littered with sarcasm. -
Why even take it there? A simple question was asked, that's all. If the guy doesn't want to answer, he won't. Maybe he wants to hang it on the wall in his house and doesn't want the bloody photo there for all to see. I feel like it's a question that doesn't need to be asked in the first place, and the follow up is also uncalled for.
:twocents:
Agreed, the sarcastic question comment/question was unwarranted and so was mine.
Post by: MtnMuley on October 07, 2016, 02:40:26 PM
Post by: Antlershed on October 07, 2016, 02:44:33 PM
Just send the pic to phool and have him do an outstanding job like he's always done for me and my friends. I can't believe this simple request turned into this ridiculous mess. Pathetic.:yeah:
Post by: 3dvapor on October 07, 2016, 03:08:00 PM
Post by: coachcw on October 07, 2016, 04:18:12 PM
Post by: Becky on October 07, 2016, 04:19:34 PM
I'm sensing this is another thread where no moderators can be wrong, even though there post is littered with sarcasm.
Wow.
You tried to call me out? or something, I don't understand what you were pointing out. I wasn't being sarcastic, I agreed with you that I asked a question. I explained myself (which, sorry Dave I see what you're saying :) just wanted to be sure). I don't know how there is a right or wrong, or what being a moderator has to do with asking someone questions :dunno: sorry it made you upset.
Anyway, 3d - glad you'll be taken care of, sounds like a gnarly story in the making. :tup:
Post by: huntnphool on October 07, 2016, 04:42:17 PM
What is wrong with that? :dunno:
Post by: Becky on October 07, 2016, 05:29:56 PM
I guess I don't see the issue some have with retouching the images. Here is a example of a members goat image. First I adjusted the lighting (don't have the before for that), which resulted in the first image. Then removed the date stamp, flash reflection in the eye and blood, resulting in the second image.:yeah:
What is wrong with that? :dunno:
One of many good article write-ups: http://www.sportingshootermag.com.au/hunting-skills/how-to-take-better-hunting-photos
Also some magazine submissions for articles require minimized blood/gorey views. I don't see anything wrong with cleaning up a success photo.
Post by: SteelheadTed on October 08, 2016, 05:18:43 PM
I don't think the OPs reason matters. Sounds to me like the OP will face judgement from someone on either side of the issue. Clean it up and get ripped by hunters for not being "real" or let it be and get ripped by antis for the bloody, cruel, crude blood and guts. I already hear the judgement from the hunter side of things in this very post.
Do you ever check your appearance before someone takes your picture? Why? Just because the OP prefers it that way. The rest is none of your business.
If you can't help him with his request, just ignore the post. No need to badger him and angle for a reason to criticize, and yes, criticizing IS your angle here.
Thank you for your criticism of my criticism.
Post by: funkster on October 08, 2016, 06:59:03 PM
Post by: Dan-o on October 08, 2016, 07:24:07 PM
And Smossys Girl, as for you......
How dare you continue to offer to be helpful????! Why, if everyone went around just doing helpful stuff like you, then.... then.... then.... well then I don't know what but I don't want to live in a world where people are so helpful.
>:(
Post by: huntnphool on October 08, 2016, 09:16:46 PM
Huntnphool, nice work :tup:
Thanks funkster ;)
You guys should be watching for 3dvapor posting up a pic and story of his hunt, it will be worth checking out if he does! :o
Hell of a bull 3D! :tup: