Hunting Washington Forum
Big Game Hunting => Elk Hunting => Topic started by: norsepeak on September 27, 2009, 10:50:18 PM
-
As many of you know the bulls were acting very strange this season, bugling and then moving off, or just plain hanging up, or just not talking. We we had three clients in Peaches this year and we were very successful in calling huge bulls, ( antler growth was awsome this year) and getting our clients shots, but thats were the fun ended. First client got a shot at a nice 6pt, made a hit, I don't know where because I wasn't there, but they followed the blood trail for two days with no recovery. Second client got a 30 yard shot at a very big 6pt with crazy long daggers. I did see this one because it was on video. Hunter shot a little too far foward and stuck it in the shoulder bone, arrow didn't penetrate more than an inch or two.....again no recovery.....I know, I know it sucks believe me.
So third client hunted with me for the whole second week. We got lots of bulls to play, but couldn't get a shot until day 5. We tried a "secret" and very aggressive tactic in a clearcut, and it worked awsome. Had a MONSTER 7pt 340-350ish bull come walking right out into the clearcut with us. I stopped him at 44 yards completley broadside. Client takes the shot, hits good behind the shoulder, but pretty high, not sure about the shot when we see the bull run into the timber. So we gave him 6 hours before the search. We 10, count 'em 10 people go in for the recovery. We put in 40+ man hours searching, circling, griding and sniffing and no bull. I wanted to throw up. I felt completley exhausted, dissappointed and disgusted that this happend.
So for archery season this year instead of several happy clients with big smiles and hero shots....all we got was three guys crying for the cover of next years brochure....sorry for the bad news, but I thought I'd let you know how our season went. In a word, horrible!
-
Whole story whole truth. Takes a real no BS kinda guy to lay it done like that, Bummer deal.
-
Dang that sucks,talk about bad luck.Do you have very many muzzy hunters hunting the peaches with you?
-
Dang that sucks,talk about bad luck.Do you have very many muzzy hunters hunting the peaches with you?
good question.......the elk might still be call worthy......
-
appreciate that hornhunter, I just tell it like it is, no fluff.
we have two possible muzzloaders, but they haven't committed due to job issues. No Oct. 1 rifle clients yet which is strange, usually we have a couple. To bad too, we've got some stud bulls located, just waitin for a shooter.
-
one more year wont hurt those bulls any, probably wont hurt your brochure cover next year or the year after either ;)
-
Thanks ftthe update norse, and sorry to hear about 3 bad shots :bash:
How was Oregon? What did you get?
Pete
-
Do you have your clients shoot there bow for you?
-
That is horrible. Sorry to hear about the tough season.
-
Did you take a father son out? Gregs brother told me they ended up sticking 4, between the 2 of em, recovering none.... Not to mention a 360&380 bull stuck and lost in the Dayton, within 24 hours by another pard, that wasn't shooting, but did the calling. The 360 was recovered 2 days later. You had nothing to do with the Dayton bulls oviously, just saying, getting real tired of guys taking hurried shots, not being proficient with their equipment, etc.
-
Thats tough on a guide, I feel for ya. Maybe you should have your clients prove their bows and shooting ability before the hunt.
-
Did you take a father son out? Gregs brother told me they ended up sticking 4, between the 2 of em, recovering none.... Not to mention a 360&380 bull stuck and lost in the Dayton, within 24 hours by another pard, that wasn't shooting, but did the calling. The 360 was recovered 2 days later. You had nothing to do with the Dayton bulls oviously, just saying, getting real tired of guys taking hurried shots, not being proficient with their equipment, etc.
:( :( I think my neighbor was the guy who stuck the 380+ in the Dayton. He said it was a monster 7x7 and he looked for it for almost 10 hours with no recovery... He even went back the next weekend and nothing??? :bash:
-
Sorry to hear things went so bad!
I have never hunted in peaches before last week but I went in for 3 days with a hunt-wa peaches tag holder and it wasnt what he has seen there before.
we did get on some bulls but they werent talking much and the few that came all the way in were damn sure nervous to say the least!
stay after it brother!
-
Did you take a father son out? Gregs brother told me they ended up sticking 4, between the 2 of em, recovering none.... Not to mention a 360&380 bull stuck and lost in the Dayton, within 24 hours by another pard, that wasn't shooting, but did the calling. The 360 was recovered 2 days later. You had nothing to do with the Dayton bulls oviously, just saying, getting real tired of guys taking hurried shots, not being proficient with their equipment, etc.
:( :( I think my neighbor was the guy who stuck the 380+ in the Dayton. He said it was a monster 7x7 and he looked for it for almost 10 hours with no recovery... He even went back the next weekend and nothing??? :bash:
From what i've been hearing, your neighbor was the third... >:( If I'm correct Jud's pard called in the 380 first for the guy he was hunting with, then hooked up with a kid that was over there and called in the 360 bull. At least the kid punched his tag on the 360 bull from what i've heard.
-
This has been the worst year I can remember for these kind of stories. Not sure the reason but I have a pretty good theory. Makes me sick :bash:
-
This has been the worst year I can remember for these kind of stories. Not sure the reason but I have a pretty good theory. Makes me sick :bash:
I was thinking the same thing. :dunno:
-
This has been the worst year I can remember for these kind of stories. Not sure the reason but I have a pretty good theory. Makes me sick :bash:
Don't hold us in suspence, whats your theory :dunno:
-
Don't hold us in suspence, whats your theory
Archery hunting participation has increased dramatically over the last few years either from multiseason tags, media, internet or whatever. There is a ton of new archers hunting that will get the latest technology, stand out in there yard in the summer and shoot 50-75 yards all day long. Technology has made archery relatively easy to learn in a short amount of time. Then comes hunting season these folks get an animal out there-they have made that shot 100 times at the backyard taget and the game totally changes. The animal moves, jumps, jacket gets caught in the string, etc.. There is a ton of inexperience out in the field. I am not saying everyone can't enjoy archery but I think a mandatory bowhunter education wouldn't be a bad idea. I know you can't fix stupid but it has to help.
-
If the bulls are jumpy, i guess it is because so many of them appear to be pricked
-
My first thought was the multiseason tags. How many jokers pick up a bow just b/c they now get more time to hunt?
-
how much of this are we hearing about now that the internet is alive and well in the hunting community? how much did we just not hear about on here before we had 4k members posting all their stories?
i know of 2, maybe 3 wounded not recovered animals shot by hunters who are long experienced bow hunters.
all these wounded animals we are hearing about is ridiculous. i completely understand *censored* happens at times, and it will happen to the best of us...as much as we don't like to think about it.
what surprises me more is the number of people airing it out for the world to see. God forbid it happens to me, but if it does, i won't be posting stories about it on the net for all the world to see.
mandatory bowhunter ed is a great idea.
-
My first thought was the multiseason tags. How many jokers pick up a bow just b/c they now get more time to hunt?
:yeah:
-
Did you take a father son out? Gregs brother told me they ended up sticking 4, between the 2 of em, recovering none.... Not to mention a 360&380 bull stuck and lost in the Dayton, within 24 hours by another pard, that wasn't shooting, but did the calling. The 360 was recovered 2 days later. You had nothing to do with the Dayton bulls oviously, just saying, getting real tired of guys taking hurried shots, not being proficient with their equipment, etc.
:( :( I think my neighbor was the guy who stuck the 380+ in the Dayton. He said it was a monster 7x7 and he looked for it for almost 10 hours with no recovery... He even went back the next weekend and nothing??? :bash:
From what i've been hearing, your neighbor was the third... >:( If I'm correct Jud's pard called in the 380 first for the guy he was hunting with, then hooked up with a kid that was over there and called in the 360 bull. At least the kid punched his tag on the 360 bull from what i've heard.
Yup, you guessed it Joe. 380 was conservative, pard said it was more like 400. Felt like puking. Felt bad for all invoved. I've have also heard of several more. I also am for a bowhunter course/test of some kind.
-
how much of this are we hearing about now that the internet is alive and well in the hunting community? how much did we just not hear about on here before we had 4k members posting all their stories?
i know of 2, maybe 3 wounded not recovered animals shot by hunters who are long experienced bow hunters.
all these wounded animals we are hearing about is ridiculous. i completely understand *censored* happens at times, and it will happen to the best of us...as much as we don't like to think about it.
what surprises me more is the number of people airing it out for the world to see. God forbid it happens to me, but if it does, i won't be posting stories about it on the net for all the world to see.
mandatory bowhunter ed is a great idea.
:yeah: :yeah: :yeah: :yeah:
-
Did you take a father son out? Gregs brother told me they ended up sticking 4, between the 2 of em, recovering none.... Not to mention a 360&380 bull stuck and lost in the Dayton, within 24 hours by another pard, that wasn't shooting, but did the calling. The 360 was recovered 2 days later. You had nothing to do with the Dayton bulls oviously, just saying, getting real tired of guys taking hurried shots, not being proficient with their equipment, etc.
:( :( I think my neighbor was the guy who stuck the 380+ in the Dayton. He said it was a monster 7x7 and he looked for it for almost 10 hours with no recovery... He even went back the next weekend and nothing??? :bash:
From what i've been hearing, your neighbor was the third... >:( If I'm correct Jud's pard called in the 380 first for the guy he was hunting with, then hooked up with a kid that was over there and called in the 360 bull. At least the kid punched his tag on the 360 bull from what i've heard.
Yup, you guessed it Joe. 380 was conservative, pard said it was more like 400. Felt like puking. Felt bad for all invoved. I've have also heard of several more. I also am for a bowhunter course/test of some kind.
Figured that was what went on Jud.
I too am for mandatory bowhunter education. It'd at least weed out the guys that didn't REALLY want to do it. I don't think its a "cure all", but it definitely wouldn't hurt.
-
I think the draw odds have alot to do with it. Rifle hunters and ML hunters put in for 10-15 years without getting drawn and then you have people getting drawn for peaches and toutle regularly with 5 points.
-
Don't hold us in suspence, whats your theory
Archery hunting participation has increased dramatically over the last few years either from multiseason tags, media, internet or whatever. There is a ton of new archers hunting that will get the latest technology, stand out in there yard in the summer and shoot 50-75 yards all day long. Technology has made archery relatively easy to learn in a short amount of time. Then comes hunting season these folks get an animal out there-they have made that shot 100 times at the backyard taget and the game totally changes. The animal moves, jumps, jacket gets caught in the string, etc.. There is a ton of inexperience out in the field. I am not saying everyone can't enjoy archery but I think a mandatory bowhunter education wouldn't be a bad idea. I know you can't fix stupid but it has to help.
Good points Ryan, I also tend to think it has become increasingly easy to go down and pick up a bugle and go out and call in bulls, hence them being call shy! Sorry to hear that Norse, I am sure you guy's have worked hard and for it to play out like that sucks!
-
Here's a great example for ya. Last year on my way to work, I spotted a good bull, 270 type bull, good one for over here. Called shep and Pete,"pards', they were already balls deep into walk in unit. Last resort, call a guy up the road that I've known for 20 years, one of my bro's pards. He rips down, I bail in with him, Dave hands me 3 arrows, and a 3 pack of broadheads, tells me, "you wanna put those together for me"? I bout *censored* my pants!! Huh? you don't spin test your arrows/broadheads? Practice with them? Nah, just screw em on and go! Thankfully the bull hit the re-prod before he got into action. 2 days later another guy stuck it, never to be seen again until rifle season, then it met its demise to a 300 Roy. Buddy dug the broadhead outta its shoulder. Here's said bull...
-
Really? A bow hunters test...lol. That is ridiculous. Its not like this is really going to improve the issue of animals being wounded. Do you really think that this is going to improve the number of wounded animals? Guys need to be more responsible, ethical and fricken practice shooting their bows for more than 2 or 3 weeks before the season. Try shooting through out the year and oh by the way actually shoot with their broadheads since field tips do not kill animals. Pus if you notice a majority of the wounded animals are from bowhunters trying to kill elk. Remember its not all about speed as much as it about penetration and shot placement. Buy heavier arrows, practice shooting the broadheads and fricken start taken more time.
-
Really? A bow hunters test...lol. That is ridiculous. Its not like this is really going to improve the issue of animals being wounded. Do you really think that this is going to improve the number of wounded animals? Guys need to be more responsible, ethical and fricken practice shooting their bows for more than 2 or 3 weeks before the season. Try shooting through out the year and oh by the way actually shoot with their broadheads since field tips do not kill animals. Pus if you notice a majority of the wounded animals are from bowhunters trying to kill elk. Remember its not all about speed as much as it about penetration and shot placement. Buy heavier arrows, practice shooting the broadheads and fricken start taken more time.
I believe with Idaho's bowhunter exam that shooting is a part of the test...
-
I'm all for a bowhunter ed class and proving my shots --- just as soon as the modern and ML folks take aim and get approved to shoot too.
I've watched two individuals miss an elk with modern rifles at 50 yards in the wide open and less than 30 yards in some brushy area a day apart. How many people take their rifles to "sight in day" at the range two weeks before the season opens...... Folks shooting rifles can't really say it's "just" an archery issue.
-
Consider this... the testing is a one time deal. We all have hunter safety education cards right and most of got them when we were 10 to 12 yrs old. Who checks us when we are rifle hunting for our abilities? The test may weed someout but mostly likely not. I bet in the long run the test would only apply to new hunters,
-
I've watched two individuals miss an elk with modern rifles at 50 yards in the wide open and less than 30 yards in some brushy area a day apart. How many people take their rifles to "sight in day" at the range two weeks before the season opens...... Folks shooting rifles can't really say it's "just" an archery issue.
This means nothing.
I sat next to my daughter who had buck fever so bad she missed a buck 3 times with in 80 yards. The barrel awas shaking so bad it was unbelieveable. My wife then droped it with a single shot.
Two days later she droped a doe with a single shot at 350 yards.
Each situation varys from time to time, even with the best hunters.
-
Thanks for the support guys, it is a terrible part of bowhunting for sure, but I felt like if on good years, I can bore you guys with pics of guys smiling and holding bulls, I thought I should be honest and tell you all about the "truth" of our season this year. Believe me it doesn't sadden anyone on this forum more than me that this has happened, but it's part of hunting. I agree on the bowhunter test, I think it's a good idea. We haven't had a problem like this in the past, so we didn't have these guys shoot there bows so we could see them, but they did shoot periodically during the week we hunted with them. My personal feeling is part of the problem is that everyone is so obsessed with speed that they sacrifice kinetic energy and penetration. I was surprised that the bull my client shot, he hit behind the shoulder and the arrow did not pass through. I shoot very heavy arrows with lots of Kinetic Energy and have had arrows hit ribs on both sides at 41 yards and go through the elk so fast that I never found them. With two gaping holes, bloods trails get real easy.
We have talked about changing our policies for bowhunters next year to help avoid this terrible issue again. Sorry some of you are upset about hearing these stories, but I'm just being honest....it happens.
-
I guess we should do it for muzzleloader hunters as well. Found out that a west side permit holder from last year shot and wounded 4 bulls!!! The last one he wounded was found dead 2 days later, the Game warden made him tag it.....
I know it seems we have been hearing about this alot this year, but it happens every year, with all weapons, yes even rifle! Guys go buy a box of Core-lokts and head for deer camp, havn't shot their rifle since last Oct.
Know yourself first!!! Then know your game!!!! Losing an animal sucks and is the worst feeling.........but you only feel that if you respect them. If you don't give a damn about them then fling away!!!!!!
-
Don't have to appogize man, if you're the guide that took the father son team out I'm referring too, you're a bull callin/huntin SOB!! You did your part, your clients didn't....
-
No apologies needed Norse, you did your part!
-
I've watched two individuals miss an elk with modern rifles at 50 yards in the wide open and less than 30 yards in some brushy area a day apart. How many people take their rifles to "sight in day" at the range two weeks before the season opens...... Folks shooting rifles can't really say it's "just" an archery issue.
This means nothing.
I sat next to my daughter who had buck fever so bad she missed a buck 3 times with in 80 yards. The barrel awas shaking so bad it was unbelieveable. My wife then droped it with a single shot.
Two days later she droped a doe with a single shot at 350 yards.
Each situation varys from time to time, even with the best hunters.
You're exactly right! I missed a 22''-24'' 2 point blacktail, with 3'' eyeguards, 4 times at 30 yards with a 300 mag that was stupid accurate. And I've killed a few critters.
-
Hey Norse, Don't apologize for bringing up a discusion that can be ugly but should be talked about.
There are a few states that require bowhunter education and I don't think its a bad idea.
-
My first thought was the multiseason tags. How many jokers pick up a bow just b/c they now get more time to hunt?
Actually I HAVE a Multi Season tag...but WONT hunt Archery JUST BECAUSE I KNOW I AM NOT GOOD ENOUGH TO HIT RELIABLY...
Now with my T/C Hawken or my Winchester 70 in 30-06...If I see it in range..its DEAD. I do NOT have confidence in what small archery skills I have...I'm still having trouble killing apples and pumpkins at anything like distance. Pie plates are dead out to about 35 yards...but aim small miss small...at least that is the theory...aim at the whole critter..liable to miss it.
-
I can relate to what you guys are talking about new bowhunters not doing there part, a buddy of mine decided he was going to switch to archery this year for deer and elk, he never picked up a bow in his life until he bought one in April of this year, I probably would not be to far off if I said he shot that bow only 15-20 times since he bought it, just barely enough to get it sighted in and get use to it, he can hardly hit a pie plate 5 out of 10 times at 40yds but feels he good out to 60yds :bash: he never bought broadheads until 5 days before season, I asked how they were shooting, he said oh their dropping 3" but good left to right "I'll just remember to compensate" :yike:.
-
This is a good discussion, just may get a little heated.
What type of policy are you talking about putting in place? Just curious.
-
whoowee actionshooter, now guys with multiseason tags are jokers? guess i was one of them cause i drew a permit and hunted archery. gettin deep in here, boy ive never heard of an expeirenced archer wounding anything "sarcasim".
-
This is a good discussion, just may get a little heated.
What type of policy are you talking about putting in place? Just curious.
Umm, an apprenticeship program with Boneaddict, killing 3 bucks, a bull, and a coyote with 1 arrow. grin...
-
were talking about making a 3-D range (approx. 5 animals) that they have to shoot BEFORE they can hunt. Just an idea right now, but we need to do something. Not only is it bad for business, but it just plain sucks to lose an animal and we want to try to avoid it happening again as much as we can.
-
whoowee actionshooter, now guys with multiseason tags are jokers? guess i was one of them cause i drew a permit and hunted archery. gettin deep in here, boy ive never heard of an expeirenced archer wounding anything "sarcasim".
:yeah:
-
This is a good discussion, just may get a little heated.
What type of policy are you talking about putting in place? Just curious.
You might be right? Dummy's will still screw broadheads on en-route to kill a bull, guys will still get excited when a bull comes in all horned up to a bugle, not waiting for the optimum shot. But, maybe, just maybe it'll make a few more guys mindfull of thier actions, a test that is. if thats the case, we've succeeded. IMO
-
were talking about making a 3-D range (approx. 5 animals) that they have to shoot BEFORE they can hunt. Just an idea right now, but we need to do something. Not only is it bad for business, but it just plain sucks to lose an animal and we want to try to avoid it happening again as much as we can.
Great idea, but I know I would rather have to take the test before I paid, or be guaranteed a full refund if i did not pass the test. However the thought of losing a significant refund amount because I did not practice would probably get me out to the range allot more than normal.
Brandon
-
I've watched two individuals miss an elk with modern rifles at 50 yards in the wide open and less than 30 yards in some brushy area a day apart. How many people take their rifles to "sight in day" at the range two weeks before the season opens...... Folks shooting rifles can't really say it's "just" an archery issue.
This means nothing.
I sat next to my daughter who had buck fever so bad she missed a buck 3 times with in 80 yards. The barrel awas shaking so bad it was unbelieveable. My wife then droped it with a single shot.
Two days later she droped a doe with a single shot at 350 yards.
Each situation varys from time to time, even with the best hunters.
You're exactly right! I missed a 22''-24'' 2 point blacktail, with 3'' eyeguards, 4 times at 30 yards with a 300 mag that was stupid accurate. And I've killed a few critters.
I think we're on the same page. I've watched other threads where folks have suggested that archery hunters may not always finish the job. My only comments were that it can happen to folks shooting firearms too. Buck/Elk Fever, heart rate is high, etc.. If someone were to propose that archery hunters need to pass a statewide hunter safety exam and show proof of skills, it needs to be applied across the board.
But even then, you can't take the feelings of the moment out of the equation. I think the hunter ed class I took 20 years ago, just made sure you could handle the gun safely and basically hit the paper. Not so much of a test of marksmanship.
I appreciate the story Norsepeak.
I thought I read a couple years back about some outfitter in Colorado that had clients site in their rifles when they arrived. It was also sort of a qualifier to check how accurate of a shot they were out to ?? yards. It gave the guides an assessment of skills and how much work was ahead of them. Sounds a bit like what you folks are thinking.....
-
Thanks for the honesty tough situation been their it hurts all the way to your toes, :bash:
-
My first hunting party in Idaho stopped on the way to camp to check rifles. The first guy stepped up and said mine is always low and left as he layed it on the sand bag. I was shocked, this group of 4 came from Florida on a long planned hunt and this crud did not even sight his rifle, probably had not even fired in the last year. That made me really think about what I was getting into. Luckily the rest of the years were pretty good. My last year we had a party of 8 in the camp. At the range some of the guys had me on the side while the last guy was shooting. Took several shots before he and the group "expert" were satisfied. Come to find out his rear base screws were loose and would not hold. THis is the story where we tracked the bull for 2 days to find him just clipped through the brisket. I went with the hunter and his guide the first day of the tracking. When we were leaving camp I noticed believe it "DUCT TAPE" holding the back of his scope down. We quickly changed that deal for a rifle I had there. He figured he had 1 good shot when they left the range. In 8 years of guiding there that was the only bull we had trouble with. I won't point fingers at bow hunters, the new gear is really good. Modern and ML have their share of wounded animals also. Right now I'm sitting on a story that I said I would not disclose until the hunter did. Bad shots happen we just don't like the results.
mtncook
-
This has been the worst year I can remember for these kind of stories. Not sure the reason but I have a pretty good theory. Makes me sick :bash:
Yeah no kidding!!! It comes down to hunters not practicing enough and not being able to grow a pair of nuts and keeping composure when making the shot on the real thing!!!! >:(
-
Know your equipment and your abilities.....otherwise stay home :bash:
-
I have not bow hunted for a few years but when I hunted I would make sure that I praticed everyday for 6 months. Now it may have only been 3-6 arrows in the back yard in a down pour but it was everyday. I also started with broadheads a month to 6 weeks prior to the hunt to make sure they were properly tuned.
Last time I went out in Washington (5+ years ago) I watched 3 "archers" shoot a dozen arrows at a deer in an effort to bring it down. They were shooting 80+ yards when I paced it off later.
I know even experienced loose animals and though we don't like it, it does happen. In my opinion it doesn't happen as much for those who really prepare.
I too am for a bowhunter class like Idaho has
-
Dang Norse! and I know you care and tried your best. Man this year sucks for this.
-
I am all for proficiency testing with broadheads to archery hunt. Used to be if you didn't practice extensively, the odds you would hit an animal, period, were very low. Now, very easy with levelized sights, drop-away rests, wrist leash, mechanical releases, etc. one can very quickly have a high probability of hitting an animal at 40-50 yards, and a reasonable chance of hitting an animal SOMEWHERE out to 80-100 yards. Based on what I have watched and what has been personally experienced by trusted friends, I'll comfortably state there is a significant proportion of ignorant, naive, and/or unethical bowhunters in the Colockum, and late season deer hunters in Swakane and Entiat.
-
I think with the invention of the multi tag, and the mass migration of folks throwing away the orange vest for something in camo, because of less pressure or the "better" season or later hunts, we will see more an d more of this. ESPECIALLY with equipment as you pointed out, make this weapon deadly out to 80+yards. This sort of thing does happen to good folks in the woods. But we don't only have it happening to them, but to all the un practiced folks, etc.
-
Didn't realize so many have been lost. Fortunately I have not lost one during archery season that I have hit.
-
When i was guiding in the Eagle cap in Oregeon we would get clients from all over the U.S, docotors, Layers and you could tell who was a hunter or not from the begining, but i would have them all shoot their bows for me before we went out hunting.. I had one guy miss 4 300 class bulls, clean misses, he was a return client came back the next year with all brand new *censored*, been practicing his shooting all year and stuck a 6x the first day of are hunt along with a nice buck.. you can tell when people practice it definatley shows..
-
whoowee actionshooter, now guys with multiseason tags are jokers? guess i was one of them cause i drew a permit and hunted archery. gettin deep in here, boy ive never heard of an expeirenced archer wounding anything "sarcasim".
You completely misunderstood the context of the statement. It was directed toward the "jokers" who go out and buy a bow and arrows at wal-mart a couple of weeks before season BECAUSE they drew a multi-season tag. Not toward the guys who hunt with archery, muzzleloaders and modern on a regular basis as many on the board do, myself included. I have had the multi-season tag before and hunted all the seasons, but guess what, I owned a bow (and practiced) BEFORE I drew the tag.
If your in need of boots reading this thread the BS isn't coming from here.
-
Wow, this is really sickening. I'm not often for new rules/regs but if we can't police ourselves better than this, an archery proficiency test should be instituted. I'm reading more about lost elk than harvested elk. >:( >:( >:(
-
Something seems to be in the air this year....
-
I have been bow hunting for about 12 years and Every year i hear more and more bad stories from people in the field making shots that never should be made. I understand that good shots go bad but come on people :bash:WAKE Up. Take responsibility. With people like that we wont be able to hunt because the tree huggers will win. :bash: :bash: :bash:
-
I don't want to sound overly critical or have this be a bash on anyone so I'm trying to keep it nice.
What I want to hear and see on these forums is success stories and ethical pictures of tagged animals and good hunting experiences. We all know that things don't always go the way we would like on a hunting trip, it's bound to happen sooner or later. But IMO if you make a poor shot, don't recover wounded game, stop searching after a couple hours, whatever......then keep the experience to yourself as something to reflect back upon on your own as something to learn from. Don't share it on an open public forum. I would prefer to hear you say that tag soup tastes bad and keep it at that. The antis are always lurking to find anything to shut down hunting, look at their latest push to shut down bear hunting.
If you have an experience about any hunt, let alone one of the coveted tags for elk, deer, sheep, moose, goat, wolf(Idaho-MT), please be discrete and careful what you post. :twocents:
Flame away...
-
Good point!!!
-
Sorry you and your clients had a hard time this year that sucks. But what I think Really sucks is that this post is getting more response's than Flyguide's great post about his efforts to harvest two great elk. One with a Friend and the other by himself. It just seems like a lot of people focus on the negative and not the postive enough. I agree with Cabin308. Dont air your dirty laundry. Again just my :twocents:
-
Cabin308,
Thank you for your post. I completely agree.
My :twocents:
Now, don't get me wrong, I have been hunting for many years and things can and do happen. As such, I will VERY RARELY pass any judgement about another hunter.
Unfortunately, every time us hunters (archers, muzzle loaders, modern firearm) post something negative about our passion, those people that sit on the fence of weather they approve of hunting or not, lean a little further towards the anti's. I understand the need to vent and share the things that go wrong. But those things need to be shared only between close hunting partners, with a sorrowful tone and a willingness to completely evaluate what went wrong and why.
I appreciate Noreses willingness to share his story with us all. He is a super nice guy and a great guide! (My group has hunted with him and they offer a great service!!!!), but as the thread continued and stories continue to mount, it saddens me to think of not only the lost animals, but the damage we are doing to ourselves.
Just my :twocents:
-
i realize nobody likes to hear about wounding animals but id like to think these guys as well as other members can use there bad experience as a learning tool whether it was bad shot placement wrong broadheads, arrow weight, distance, and what to do when a bad shot is made. how long to wait, when to leave a area and come back. sometimes we have been able to turn a bad scenario into a success story by knowing what to do and taking emotion out of the situation which weighs heavy on the shooter.
-
were talking about making a 3-D range (approx. 5 animals) that they have to shoot BEFORE they can hunt. Just an idea right now, but we need to do something. Not only is it bad for business, but it just plain sucks to lose an animal and we want to try to avoid it happening again as much as we can.
Great idea, this is really on the hunter and not you guys. Best of luck next year!
-
bum deal to say the least
-
Wow, this is really sickening. I'm not often for new rules/regs but if we can't police ourselves better than this, an archery proficiency test should be instituted. I'm reading more about lost elk than harvested elk. >:( >:( >:(
Yea it's sickening. I talked to one guy that hunted the Clockum and he mentioned that he ran out of arrows in his quiver and a few of the animals had arrows sticking out of them. This is the type of hunter that gives ethical hunters a bad name. I would much rather not get an animal than even attempt that.
-
"Thanks for the support guys, it is a terrible part of bowhunting for sure"
I dont have time to read the whole thread, so forgive me if I'm hitting on something that was already covered...
But... I will guarantee, more animals..BY FAR are wounded by muzzy and modern hunters every year and even more of a "percentage"... not just more because there are more rifle hunters...
I have seen and heard soooooo many tales of guys taking shots at 400-1000 yards...not seeing a reaction in the animals and NOT EVEN going to look and see if there was blood? Lets not concentrate on the bowhunters, sure we want to improve bowhunting ethics, proficiency and such...but dont make it sound worse than it is...
I am also with Ryan and others though, I've heard about more wounds this year than any previous year....
E
-
Damn I hate to hear stuff like this especially in those numbers of bad shots. >:( I bet those guys can all hit a pie plate at 40 yds consistently but... in the heat of calling in a bull and getting a terrible case of the shakes that most guys will, it is a different story. How can you guage your clients ability to shoot well under pressure? Perhaps have them run up a hill with their bow and take shots with heart pumping and lungs heaving.. or simply do not take shots over 30 yds?
I'm an archer and it is this kind of thing that gives archery a bad name. Is it too many guys getting into archery but not taking it seriously, not putting in the time with their equipment? We all need to know when to NOT take the shot. Respect the animal!
-
Think norsespeak has a valid point. When I lived in Maryland had to pass a shooting test to hunt military properties.
Had to put 5 out of 5 shots in the vitals of a 3d deer target at 20 yds in order to receive a permit to hunt.
Now shots in the midwest and east coast are typically at much shorter ranges because most hunting is done from tree stands.
Agree with using heavier arrows. I shoot at least 700 grains and most of my shots are pass thrus. Maybe have minimum arrow weight standards? Would this cut down on guys flinging 350 grain arrows with 80 grain broadheads at animals over 50 yds?
Been said before but think a lot of the blame is do to the hunting shows on tv and guys bragging on those shows about taking animals at super long distances. Seems like people have put too much emphasis on shots and not working on their hunting skills ( moving quietly, scent control, map reading, camo, tracking, reading sign etc.). Meet a lot of guys who think that hunting is just going out in the woods and pulling the trigger on your gun, ml or trigger release. And of course when you do work on your shooting make practice realistic and similar to hunting situations. I practice sitting, kneeling, off hand, snap shooting. Most of the animals I have taken over the years have been at relatively close ranges.
Nothing beats time in the woods. I think spending the off season, hiking, shed hunting, taking photos of animals -at close range-in the woods has really helped my hunting skills.
-
I think there's a lot of guys that can hit a quarter at 50 yards then fold on game . I think 308 is right on try to keep to yourself and learn from it , I know it's not just archers in this matter and wont elaberate. :bdid: .
-
First off, I agree with 308, lets keep dirty laundry as our personal learning experience. Hopefully any true hunter, that respects the animals, will learn from a mistake. I know that even the most prepared can have a bad day though. 4 years ago, I double lunged a cow at 25 yards, watched the arrow stick in the ground and her run off. My 8 year old(at the time) son and I recovered the arrow, waited 30 and then followed the double blood trail about 100 yards to twin pools of blood. At that point, blood stopped. I spent about a total of 16 hours in the next 2 days looking for her. Unfortunately it snowed that first night so grid searched to no avail. Problem was, she had doubled back, uphill and made it about 200 more yards onto private property that the owner had said no entry allowed so I never crossed his line in my search. Cow found 4 days after the shot by neighbor, said it looked like a good shot. This was in my 21st year of bow hunting, I practice a lot, with broadheads( destroy a lot of target though) and I did my Master Hunter shooting test with my bow. That said, this year, 2 days left on my Peaches archery tag, I had a small 5x5 at about 15 yards but due to the branches, I did not take the shot. I would never want to wound or loose another animal in my hunting career. Tag soup on a Bull tag does not taste good, but hopefully a nice cow will fill my freezer come November. And yes, many new, non disciplined archery hunters in the woods any more.
-
My first thought was the multiseason tags. How many jokers pick up a bow just b/c they now get more time to hunt?
:yeah:
Exactly the reason I don't try archery with my multi-season tag. Guess I look at it differently. But then I'm betting there is more that don't than do.
-
Sorry for you guys who don't want to hear about others "dirty laundry" It's part of hunting and it happens, nobody likes it and nobody wants it to happen but it does. Not talking about things like this that happen doesn't do anybody any good. We can't view the world through rose colored glasses, we need to talk about things and learn from others experiences. For those of you who have never had this happen, congratulations, that is an excellent record to try to keep going, but for those of us who have had it happen it's a horrible part of hunting that we have to live with and try to learn why/how it happend and try to never let it happen again. Is it an equipment issue, inexperience, nerves, excitement or just plain bad luck? The only way to find out is to talk about it so that others can learn and not make the same mistake.
Again sorry for those who don't want to hear about it, but it's a free country and you don't have to read this post.
-
I'm with you norse I believe if you air out the problems with hunting in general maybe the newbies to the sport will think twice before they do something stupid. I dont really care what the anti hunters think anyway. They will need a lot more ammo than that to beat us anyway. Bottom line animals get lost probably every day during hunting season and that is just part of it. Nothing is perfect wether it is a broadhead or a bullet.
-
Sorry for you guys who don't want to hear about others "dirty laundry" It's part of hunting and it happens, nobody likes it and nobody wants it to happen but it does. Not talking about things like this that happen doesn't do anybody any good. We can't view the world through rose colored glasses, we need to talk about things and learn from others experiences. For those of you who have never had this happen, congratulations, that is an excellent record to try to keep going, but for those of us who have had it happen it's a horrible part of hunting that we have to live with and try to learn why/how it happend and try to never let it happen again. Is it an equipment issue, inexperience, nerves, excitement or just plain bad luck? The only way to find out is to talk about it so that others can learn and not make the same mistake.
Again sorry for those who don't want to hear about it, but it's a free country and you don't have to read this post.
Extremely well said Norse. We all have to get our hands bloody. No matter how we look at it we are all killers. Killing has never been pretty no matter how we choose to kill. It is still killing. Seems to me that alot of hunters on here have succombed to the Bambi propaganda. Deer and wild animals are feeble defenseless animals that are extremely week and feeble. I disagree. Wild animals are extremely tough and resilient creatures and they can endure alot more than we ever could. That should not be an excuse to be a sloppy hunter but people need to realise that every marginal hit on a animal is not an automatic death sentence. For crying out loud Bambi got shot and lived. :twocents: