Hunting Washington Forum
Other Hunting => Coyote, Small Game, Varmints => Topic started by: Kain on December 01, 2010, 09:08:41 AM
-
They are trying to back door ban coyote hunting at night. What to do?
N K to enforcement-web
show details Nov 22 (9 days ago)
Many units modern firearms seasons are over or will be this week. Can I start night hunting for coyotes, bobcats and raccoons? The regs on this are confusing.
Thank you for your time.
--
Naithan Kain
Hello and thank you for contacting the Washington State Department of Fish & Wildlife, Enforcement Program.
Per page 66 of the big game hunting pamphlet, as long as you are hunting outside the months of September, October, or November and you are not in an area open to any center fire rifle deer/elk season, you are fine for bobcat/raccoon, but not coyote. Although the pamphlet mentions that you can, the WAC does not support it. Additionally, you can find this regulation under WAC 232-12-289 http://apps.leg.wa.gov/wac/default.aspx?cite=232-12-289 (http://apps.leg.wa.gov/wac/default.aspx?cite=232-12-289)
Thank you,
Sean Carrell
WDFW, Enforcement Program
360-902-2936
FAX: 360-902-2155
N K to Enforcement
show details Nov 23 (8 days ago)
I looked at the WAC you provided and it only applies to "OFFICIAL HUNTING HOURS FOR GAME ANIMALS AND FOREST GROUSE*". It makes an exception for bobcats and raccoons but not for coyotes because they are not "game" animals. According to WAC 232-12-007 coyotes are not game animals so the legal hunting hours would not apply to them. http://apps.leg.wa.gov/wac/default.aspx?cite=232-12-007 (http://apps.leg.wa.gov/wac/default.aspx?cite=232-12-007)
http://wdfw.wa.gov/living/coyotes.html#legal (http://wdfw.wa.gov/living/coyotes.html#legal)
"Legal Status
The Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife does not classify coyotes as game animals, but a state license is required to hunt or trap them (RCW 77.32.010). The owner, the owner's immediate family, employee, or a tenant of real property may kill or trap a coyote on that property if it is damaging crops or domestic animals (RCW 77.36.030). A license is not required in such cases. Check with your county and/or local jurisdiction for local restrictions. Except for bona fide public or private zoological parks, persons and entities are prohibited from importing a coyote into Washington State without a permit from the Department of Agriculture and written permission from the Department of Health. Persons and entities are also prohibited from acquiring, selling, bartering, exchanging, giving, purchasing, or trapping a coyote for a pet or export (WAC 246-100-191)."
Just to clarify: I have to wait until Dec 1st to start night hunting bobcats, raccoons and coyote even though there is no center fire rifle deer or elk season open? If I wanted to hunt the Battleground unit at night I would be fine as long as there is no modern firearms season open because that unit is never open to center fire rifle seasons. True?
Thanks for you time,
Naithan Kain
Hey Lori -
Nathain is pretty articulate regarding this inquiry, but I'm not sure if his assumption is correct. Maybe so. What do you think?
Thank you,
Sean Carrell
WDFW, Enforcement Program
360-902-2936
FAX: 360-902-2155
Preuss, Lori (DFW) to Enforcement, me
show details 8:37 AM (28 minutes ago)
Hi, Naithan. It is illegal to hunt coyote at night, but WDFW’s laws and rules about this are conflicting. Coyote are included in the definition of “wildlife” in RCW 77.08.010(63). However they are not defined as “game animals” in WAC 232-12-007. To further confused the issue, they are included in WAC 232-28-342, which sets the seasons for small game. This WAC does not allow night hunting of coyote.
We will fix this discrepancy. In the meantime, to be safe, you shouldn’t hunt coyote at night.
Please let me know if you have any questions.
-
:bash: :bash: give me a break....
-
"grey area". I'd check with the local enforcement officers and see how they interpret the law. If they're OK with night hunting, I would do it.
-
wtf??? :o :dunno: What a hot mess...
-
QUOTE "To further confused the issue, they are included in WAC 232-28-342, which sets the seasons for small game. This WAC does not allow night hunting of coyote."
I am not reading that in the WAC 232-28-342 does not allow hunting of coyote at night. Am I missing that?
All I can see is this
It is unlawful to hunt any wildlife at night or wild animals with dogs (hounds) during the months of September, October, or November in any area open to a modern firearm deer or elk season. The use of hounds to hunt black bear, cougar (EXCEPT by public safety cougar removal permit (WAC 232-12-243) or a commission authorized hound permit (WAC 232-28-285)), coyote, and bobcat is prohibited year round.
Also maybe she means that they will fix the discrepancy to allow night hunting? :dunno:
-
Kain,
Not sure if you have responded to Lori. But I would respond with "ask for clarification" on their intent to "fix" the discrepancy. People have been hunting Coyotes at night for years, and if they intend to do away with it we need to know now. I disagree with Lori's interpretation.
just my two cents on the moving forward.
frustrating that they can't come out and make the statement.
-
Kain,
Not sure if you have responded to Lori. But I would respond with "ask for clarification" on their intent to "fix" the discrepancy. People have been hunting Coyotes at night for years, and if they intend to do away with it we need to know now. I disagree with Lori's interpretation.
just my two cents on the moving forward.
frustrating that they can't come out and make the statement.
I have not responded yet. I am trying to calm down a little first. I will send a polite letter asking for clarification on which direction the clarifications are going. I know a few of you have letters from WDFW officers regarding night hunting coyotes, can you post a copy here.
-
My email. I will let you know the response. After that I will wait and see what the rest of you want to do. I get the impression she is trying to say WAC 232-28-342 set the rules for small game, and it includes coyotes, that that makes them a "game" animal. If she can say they are a "game" animal then there is no exception in the legal hunting hours for hunting coyotes at night. The definition of game animal does not include coyotes so that is a very weak argument but she seems to have a real hard on for ending night hunting.
Lori,
Thank you for the response. I read WAC 232-28-342 and I am not seeing where it prohibits night hunting for coyotes. Can you please clarify which part you are referring to. Could you also clarify on what you mean fixing the discrepancy. Is that to continue to allow coyote hunting at night or to make it illegal?
Thanks again for the response.
Naithan Kain
-
I got this from Sean Carroll several months ago:
As per page 56 of the big game pamphlet, coyote may be hunted at night EXCEPT that it is unlawful to hunt any wildlife at night during the months of September, October, or November in any area open to a centerfire rifle deer or elk season.
Thank you,
Sean Carrell
WDFW, Enforcement Program
360-902-2936
FAX: 360-902-2155
-
When she says "we will fix this discrepancy" I have to assume that she means they will make the law more clear that coyote hunting at night is illegal, as it sounds like that is how SHE wants it to be. :rolleyes:
-
Here's part of an email from Lori Preuss on April 6th:
"We have not yet formulated any changes to our nighttime hunting rule, and we may not change anything at all. If we do, you will see it on the Internet at our Website on June 23rd, and you will be able to testify at the Fish and Wildlife Commission meeting in August if you want to. Again, we haven’t done anything at this point, and we may decide to scrap any changes. I’ll keep you updated."
Subsequently she sent me an email saying that they had decided to forgo any changes in the night hunting rules for this year. Regrettably, I deleted it.
These people are literally OUT OF CONTROL.
-
Here's part of an email from Lori Preuss on April 6th:
"We have not yet formulated any changes to our nighttime hunting rule, and we may not change anything at all. If we do, you will see it on the Internet at our Website on June 23rd, and you will be able to testify at the Fish and Wildlife Commission meeting in August if you want to. Again, we haven’t done anything at this point, and we may decide to scrap any changes. I’ll keep you updated."
Subsequently she sent me an email saying that they had decided to forgo any changes in the night hunting rules for this year. Regrettably, I deleted it.
These people are literally OUT OF CONTROL.
I have a copy of it. They had no support for it so now they are trying to back door a ban.
Hello. I told all of you months ago that I would be drafting proposed changes to our night-hunting rule and would send you the draft for review. After much discussion between the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife (WDFW) Enforcement Program and WDFW’s Wildlife Program, we have decided to hold off on making changes, if any, to this rule until early 2012. That is when the Wildlife Program will be considering amendments to many of the hunting rules as part of their 3-year cycle. To see the proposed hunting rule changes in early 2012, or to check the status of current rules in development at any given time, go to the “Current Rule Making Activity” page of WDFW’s website at http://wdfw.wa.gov/about/regulations/development.html. (http://wdfw.wa.gov/about/regulations/development.html.)
Lori Preuss, WSBA #33045
WDFW Criminal Justice Liaison &
Administrative Regulations Coordinator
Lori.preuss@dfw.wa.gov
360.902.2930
Fax 360.902.2155
-
>:( >:( >:( >:(
Preuss, Lori (DFW) to me, Enforcement
show details 10:56 AM (4 minutes ago)
Hi, Naithan. In WAC 232-28-342, there are “Exceptions” to the official hunting hours for game animals and forest grouse. It says, “Bobcat and raccoon are exempt from hunting hour restrictions during established bobcat and raccoon seasons…” It doesn’t mention coyote, and that’s how we know you can’t night-hunt coyote.
I would like to change the WAC to allow night-hunting of coyote. However, the governor just ordered all state agencies to stop rule-making, except in very specific circumstances where rules are necessary to prevent immediate threat to wildlife, to generate revenue, etc. Her moratorium on rule-making covers all of 2011. So, if and when we change the rule, whether it is to allow night-hunting of coyote or not, it won’t happen until 2012.
I hope this helps.
-
frustrating that they can't come out and make the statement.
They can't make a statement because the WAC's are conflicting. Its not like anyone within WDFW can override them. The WAC's are enforced as law.
This issue should be brought up to the state Attorney General's office for clarity, and have the conflicting WAC's modified per the original intent of the laws as they were written. You could also bring this issue to your local legislative representative. The no night hunting of yotes during modern firearm deer and elk seasons was both to aid in safety of hunters in the field and discourage deer and elk hunters from being able to shoot big game beyond the posted daylight shooting hours.
-Steve
-
BS!!
That's not directed at you Steve.
I have an e-mail from Sean Carroll that says yote hunting at night is legal, I will carry it with me while I continue to night hunt for yotes. I'll also show it in court if I ever have to.
-
Lori,
I still dont see where WAC 232-28-342 say anything about hunting hours. I guess I dont understand why you are including coyote as a game animal. That would be a change in the rules that you said you are order not to do. WAC 232-12-007 does NOT classify coyote as "game" animals therefore an exception in WAC 232-12-289 to include coyote is not necessary for rules governing hunting hours for game animals. You would actually have to make a rule change to include them as a game animal not just to leave them as it is, unclassified wildlife. I dont know if this is a personal opinion or the opinion of the WDFW but even if you are going to tell me that night hunting coyotes is illegal because there is not exception made in WAC 232-12-289 what happens on Feb 1st? The legal hunting hours only govern game animals from Sept 1st-Jan 31st. Coyote season is year round so on Feb 1st there are no law saying coyote hunting is illegal at night. Correct?
Thanks for the fast response
Naithan Kain
-
In the 2010 big game pamphlet the rule is on page 66. I would go by that. Keep it with you while hunting, if a warden questions what you are doing, show him the rule on page 66 that says:
-
In the 2010 big game pamphlet the rule is on page 66. I would go by that. Keep it with you while hunting, if a warden questions what you are doing, show him the rule on page 66 that says:
:yeah: :yeah:
-
It's dumb that it says right in the regulations that you can hunt coyotes at night, yet they tell you different. :rolleyes:
-
So In my hunting regs on page 66 under night hunting and hound hunting during deer and elk hunting seasons it states:
Bobcat, raccoon, and coyote may be hunted at night during established bobcat and racoon seasons, EXCEPT that it is unlawful to hunt any wildlife at night or wild animals with dogs(hounds) during the months of september, october, or november in any area open to a centerfire rifle deer or elk season. the use of hounds to hunt black bear, cougar, bobcat, or coyote is prohibited year round except durion commission authorized hunts.
So they need to get there story straight. I clearly said coyotes in that and doesnt say its illegal.
-
So In my hunting regs on page 66 under night hunting and hound hunting during deer and elk hunting seasons it states:
Bobcat, raccoon, and coyote may be hunted at night during established bobcat and racoon seasons, EXCEPT that it is unlawful to hunt any wildlife at night or wild animals with dogs(hounds) during the months of september, october, or november in any area open to a centerfire rifle deer or elk season. the use of hounds to hunt black bear, cougar, bobcat, or coyote is prohibited year round except durion commission authorized hunts.
So they need to get there story straight. I clearly said coyotes in that and doesnt say its illegal.
It says its legal to hunt them at night but then they tell you its illegal and the next breath she says they cant make any rule changes. :chuckle: All this and all I wanted to know was whether I had to wait until Dec 1st to start night hunting.
-
I think you would have been better off to have never asked the question. The regulations clearly state that night hunting for coyotes is legal. There's no way anybody can argue otherwise, from the rule on page 66 that says "COYOTE MAY BE HUNTED AT NIGHT."
-
I think you would have been better off to have never asked the question. The regulations clearly state that night hunting for coyotes is legal. There's no way anybody can argue otherwise, from the rule on page 66 that says "COYOTE MAY BE HUNTED AT NIGHT."
Yes but it also say that you cannot hunt them at night during Sept Oct and Nov in areas that are open to center fire rifle deer and elk. My question was now that those season are closed do I still have to wait until Dec 1st. I wasnt asking if it was legal to hunt at night, just when I could start. You cant blame me for wanting to clarify the regs...can you?
-
No don't blame you for that. As you said, the the Battleground GMU should be open for night hunting even in Sept, Oct, and Nov. But now Lori is saying don't do it at all! ??? :bash:
-
So now what about outside of bobcat/raccoon season? (Sept 1 to Mar 15) It almost sounds like night hunting for coyotes is only legal during that season, but I don't think that's the case, correct?
-
My question was now that those season are closed do I still have to wait until Dec 1st.
I think that's pretty much in black and white.. Yes you can hunt there if the area is not open to modern firearm hunting of big game.
You need to take into account, permit hunters for the area you're planning on hunting yotes at night. If it is open in any way to a person with a legal modern firearm tag for deer or elk, then you need to wait. That may include tribal hunters with rights to public land too. :dunno:
-Steve
-
How would a guy possibly know if tribal hunters might be hunting the area? I hope WDFW doesn't think about that........don't give them any ideas. :o
-
Many areas have rifle special permits going to the end of January, or in some cases I believe even into March. :yike:
-
My question was now that those season are closed do I still have to wait until Dec 1st.
I think that's pretty much in black and white.. Yes you can hunt there if the area is not open to modern firearm hunting of big game.
You need to take into account, permit hunters for the area you're planning on hunting yotes at night. If it is open in any way to a person with a legal modern firearm tag for deer or elk, then you need to wait. That may include tribal hunters with rights to public land too. :dunno:
-Steve
There have been many discussions where there is confusion on when we can start night/hound hunting so I dont know if its that black and white. Some say you can start as soon as rifle season is over others say you have to wait until Dec. Thats all I was trying to get clarification on. As far special permits and tribal hunters that is a whole other confusing matter. Maybe we should just delete this thread so the rest of you can pretend you never heard anything like this and keep on hunting according to the regs as written. :dunno:
-
Kain someone has to be the Guinna pig? Sometimes... Many times it is better to ask for forgiveness than permission.... If you go by what is in the regs and carry it with you, how can they fine you for that? and if they do do you think it would really hold up in court? They print the damn thing to "educate hunters" of the rules and regs, so if they cannot get their story straight then maybe we need a give them a foot to straighten it out???? :bash:
-
Sure doesnt seem like it pays to be responsible. They were looking for some kind of loophole all along to change or eliminate night hunting. This is pretty weak though. I dont think it could ever hold up in court but how much would it cost to find out? I know I dont have the resources.
-
this is the Lady that is going to change night because the Game Warden was killed at night in GA. Glad i didnt buy a new Light. this is why i waited. dont piss Her off Please or we will Lose alot more. Rick
-
Makes me wonder if she doesn't have anything better to worry about................
-
I love how our State Government agencies have the ability to use their own interpretation against their own printed materials on laws that have been established for long periods of time.
Kain,
Print the entire dialogue and forward to Representative Ed Orcutt from the Longview area.. Let him in on the rule making that Lori is putting forth without actually going through the Rule Making process. The legislature slapped Mike Kreidler, Insurance Commissioner's, hands for the same sort of activity about 5 years ago. They called it Rule Making without going through the process......It is a political no no for appointed positions. Happens with Department of Revenue, Labor and Industries, Insurance Commissioner and others
Ed Orcutt may be one of your legislators as he represents most of Clark and Cowlitz counties and is passionate about the outdoors. He has gone toe to toe with WDFW on prior occassions specific to the falsified information provided by WDFW on the winter kill of the St Helens Elk Herd about 4 years ago. (wdfw quit counting bodies when they reached the number that proved their estimates to be accurate, when in reality the number was much greater).
Again, let Ed know that he needs to be gentle as she is in a position to work against sporstsmen and women, but something needs to be done. Can't let people put their own agenda in front of printed materials. This has BS written all over it.
-
I will wait a couple of days. So far they seem to be willing to have a dialog and maybe they may change their minds. :dunno: I have presented my case and provided sources that, I feel, backs it up. I am going to try and give them the benefit of the doubt and not assume they are out to eliminate hunting opportunity on a whim or personal objections even though it seems like it. Sean Carrell seems like he might just be stuck in the middle and is not making decision but providing information he is given.
This could potentially effect all of us so I dont want to get them all riled up and on the defensive or go over their heads because I have a slanted opinion of the department as a whole. Any advice is welcome though and I will keep you all posted on what happens.
-
Good info Whacker1, learn something new everyday. Thanks.
-
Kain... I think that is the best course of action.. If there is a discrepancy in the rules/law then the discrepancy should be fixed... Maybe letting the rep know about the discrepancy is all that is necessary if the WDFW does not fix it....
-
Kain - good call. Give it a couple of days to think and let them do the same.
Thanks for bringing us into the loop. I assume the worst with WA State government agencies as I ran into some other issues with Dept of Commerce and L & I today. Doesn't directly affect me, but must shake my head wondering what is going through these people's heads.
-
I always carry the current regs with me while hunting, so, if I kill a coyote at night, I have written proof of legality, from the state. It says it plain as day, night hunting of coyotes is legal. I don't care what some desk jockey woman thinks about it. It's in print, from the WDFW.
-
Go hunt the damn dogs. I would not cave to her "interpretation" of anything. I would continue to do what you have done for years. If cited, fight it. If she gave you an interpretation that said no hunting of anything would we comply until a better interpretation floated by?
-
I wonder if anyone knows what is going on there sometime...
I had a warden tell me this year that scents (Bear bombs) were not baiting, but shooting a bear over a gutpile of a legally killed animal was. :dunno: :chuckle:
I would hunt the dogs, as it is stated in the regs. Piss on what she says.
-
Kain,
You might want to send this guy a copy of your emails.
Deputy Chief Mike Cenci, Field Operations
Mike.Cenci@dfw.wa.gov
-
I think it is good to get clarification, however i would put the regs in a gallon zip lock and go hunting... We are ALL doing something illegal in some way nearly every day... If i get a ticket or warning from an officer I am very polite, but ask to have them show me the law or rule i broke so that i understand... it is so difficult trying to keep up with all the regs we have in our life you could have a full time job just to clarify what you are doing is legal... The most important thing when going this route is not failing the attitude test when talking with the officer... I had a short chat with a Commercial Vehicle Enforcement Officer not so long ago (CVEO are Washington State Patrol) About a rule change i got a written warning on...No fine.. I asked him how i would know of this change in statute... His reply was that it changes so much he can barely keep up with all the nuances of the law... If a Cop has problems keeping up with changes how the hell can Citizens who are just trying to live life?
-
I have hunted yotes after dark and have always contacted the local warden for the area. That way they know my intent. Some times they have requested I hold off until the late archery season has closed. That's an easy request to honor! I tell them where I'm going to be hunting so they don't have to get out of their Jammies to drive over and find me doing something that is legal. But it also works in their favor as well I have been contacted by them asking if I had heard any thing out of the ordinary as well. :twocents:
-
Yep got the local officers card in my wallet.
-
Way to handle the situation Kain, well done
All over coyotes.... :dunno:
-
yeah I dont get it either. Ask a simple question and open a can of worms. Seems like "Legal Services Lori Preuss, Criminal Justice Liaison/Rules Coordinator" wants to reinvent the wheel.
We will fix this discrepancy. In the meantime, to be safe, you shouldn’t hunt coyote at night.
You believe that? Will I be breaking the law or not? >:( It would be funny if it wasnt so sad.
-
This is from the WDFW's own website:
Legal Status
The Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife does not classify coyotes as game animals, but a state license is required to hunt or trap them (RCW 77.32.010).
-
I quoted that in my reply to the enforcement dept. Thats when they sent it off to Lori for clarification.
-
You don't need to make an exception for coyotes, like they did for coons and bobcats, BECAUSE they are NOT game animals.
-
Until they've updated the 2011 regs and its in writing... I'll gladly take the ignorant route and continue spotlighting yotes
Lori didn't even sound sure, so until they have this worked out internally and make it official, no dice wdfw.
-
You have to remember that WDFW employees have no reason to stick thier head out and make a decision... If they screw up and say something wrong in writing then the WDFW has a spokesman making policy in writing... Gov Beurocracies will ALWAYS lean twoard CYA rather than an honest judgement call... Its just not in an employees best intrest... Just look at past member WDFWinsider... He tried to just answere boilerplate questions when he worked their and got canned... Now he's looking for a job and the WDFW is F-ing him when his prospective employers call his reference... So how is it in thier best interest? Stupid huh? :bash:
-
What fricking crock of crap. Sounds like Lori as her own thoughts on this.
-
They are going to adopt an emergency rule to say what the regs already say. :bash: Ah tax dollars hard at work.
On Thu, Dec 2, 2010 at 10:34 AM, Preuss, Lori (DFW) <Lori.Preuss@dfw.wa.gov> wrote:
Hi, Naithan. I believe our Wildlife Program is going to issue an emergency rule to clarify that you can hunt coyote at night during established bobcat and raccoon seasons, with the exception of the months of September, October, and November in any area open to a centerfire rifle deer or elk season. The Governor’s rules moratorium does not kick in until 2011, and it exempts emergency rules, which is why we have the authority to do this. You might want to check our Website’s rule-making pages at http://wdfw.wa.gov/about/regulations/ (http://wdfw.wa.gov/about/regulations/) starting tomorrow, to see if the emergency rule has been implemented.
-
Unbelievable. :bash:
-
:chuckle: LMAO
I bet they read this thread. And I agree, it's stupid to make a new rule that doesn't change anything. :rolleyes:
-
I still don't get what it has to do with bobcat/raccoon season ??? What about AFTER bobcat/raccoon season is over? Can you no longer hunt coyotes at night?
-
I still don't get what it has to do with bobcat/raccoon season ??? What about AFTER bobcat/raccoon season is over? Can you no longer hunt coyotes at night?
You could before maybe they are going to mess with that now. Machias posted an email earlier in this thread where he was told night hunting was legal year round for coyote except where prohibited.
-
I still don't get what it has to do with bobcat/raccoon season ??? What about AFTER bobcat/raccoon season is over? Can you no longer hunt coyotes at night?
You could before maybe they are try to mess with that now. Machias posted an email earlier in this thread where he was told night hunting was legal year round for coyote except where prohibited.
That is exactly right. Since coyotes are not classified as a "game" species, they only let you know when it is prohibited to hunt them. Everything else is fair game.
-
I understand that but I still don't see why the phrase "during established bobcat and raccoon seasons" needs to be in there ??? Maybe I'm just slow. :dunno:
-
Not slow, they just phrase everything in a crappy way. Kind of like how they describe an antler point for an elk.
-
My wife made owners manuals for a manufacture for a while... you REALLY have to have some one who 1 knows thier stuff really well, and 2 some one that can write better than the Engrish we normally speak/wright.... :twocents: Its harder than you would think to put aout a quality product.. But if they actually listened to hunter/fisherman sugestions they wouldn't have so much trougble....To bad they don't have a PR person or leasion that works with the sportsman AND the system...
-
Not slow, they just phrase everything in a crappy way. Kind of like how they describe an antler point for an elk.
So crappy that even the Criminal Justice Liaison/Rules Coordinator has a hard time with them. To give her credit she did come around to the correct interpretation. Hopefully this doesnt happen again though. What a mess.
-
Goodness gracious. :chuckle:
-
Kain P.M. sent.
-
does christies left hand know what her right hand is doing :bash:
-
Here is a link to an updated thread on this issue. From the W.W.P.H.A. website
http://wwpha.com/index.php?option=com_kunena&Itemid=0&func=view&catid=15&id=1163 (http://wwpha.com/index.php?option=com_kunena&Itemid=0&func=view&catid=15&id=1163)
The update for this post is on page 2 of the thread.
-
Well I didn't read all the posts,but a lot of the first page
And I'm not a lawyer.
BUT,one thing I do know is that if there is a contradiction in the own rules,they will have a very hard time convicting anyone of anything.
So if everything else you are doing while night hunting is legal,they can't really do too much.
No? :dunno:
-
The funny thing is is that there is NO conflicting WAC's or rules. That is what I have been trying to explain to them. The WAC doesnt mention coyote because its not supposed to.
-
OK in the information available to you from either the manual or personal e-mails from uninformed department staff.
Seems they would have to issue an official update and post it at stores and their web page
Just don't see how they can do much in court.
Oh take your least favorite rifle to test this.
-
There is an errata section for the game regs. It is the first couple of pages on the online pdf.
http://wdfw.wa.gov/publications/00766/wdfw00766.pdf (http://wdfw.wa.gov/publications/00766/wdfw00766.pdf)
There is also a little section on page 9 that is kind of scary also.
WAC Summary Information
This pamphlet is a summary of the hunting regulations and seasons adopted
by the Washington Fish and Wildlife Commission. This pamphlet does not
contain nor is it intended to contain all Department regulations. Regulations
specific to the hunting seasons described in this pamphlet are found in
Sections 232-28-248 through 232-28-516, and 232-12-001 through 232-12-
830, of the Washington Administrative Code.
So just going by the regs in the pamphlet they still might be able to mess with you.
-
That is a CYA statement to cover their a$$! If you think they are going to hang you out to dry over Shooting some coyotes with their book in hand you must be spotlighting around the Redmond- Issaquah area.... I have had a couple of contacts with sheriffs wanting to know if it was legal to be hunting where i was at.... I said sure you bet... and ended the conversation... They have to prove you did something wrong, AND most times you will be contacted by a Sheriff that has few clues about the details of said law... Carry the book and if they want to charge them make them SHOW YOU THE STATUTE! No reason to be scared, We all bitch about how lightly they treat poatchers... WTH do they think they are gona do when you shooting Yotes? IVARHUSA had a post on here recently talking about how he accidentally trespassed near tricites shooting yotes.... The owner just informed him and he was on his way... Yotes aren't like deer or elk.... I know we all want to stay on the right side of the law, but when THEIR info is so convoluted you can A not go out, or B be smart and go out....I get so tired of being pushed around by Bureaucratic red tape it makes me furious! >:(
-
Without including all applicable rules in the main pamphlet we all use/receive, I don't see how they could expect to win against a violator in court :twocents:
Thats like saying ok, heres the book of law(s)...... buuuut we kept some out of it, so if you want to check what those are, do ______
-
You are right. I was just saying the scary parts is that they can make changes to regs after they are printed and make something illegal when it clearly says its OK in the regs. I doubt any officer is going to mess with you over it and will probably just inform you of the changes.
-
Here is a link to an updated thread on this issue. From the W.W.P.H.A. website
http://wwpha.com/index.php?option=com_kunena&Itemid=0&func=view&catid=15&id=1163 (http://wwpha.com/index.php?option=com_kunena&Itemid=0&func=view&catid=15&id=1163)
The update for this post is on page 2 of the thread.
Great work Adna!
It goes to show how things can get twisted when the department is "overthinking" an issue.
All right guys.......get a light and get some dogs at night. Let the pic parade begin.
-
:)You guys ever heard of the "Right to Hunt" change to the state constitution? Now do you think it is important?
duh
Carl
-
So now what about outside of bobcat/raccoon season? (Sept 1 to Mar 15) It almost sounds like night hunting for coyotes is only legal during that season, but I don't think that's the case, correct?
:yeah:
This is also my question. The way it's worded it looks like you CANNOT hunt at night outside of the bobcat/ racoon seasons. :twocents:
-
You are right. I was just saying the scary parts is that they can make changes to regs after they are printed and make something illegal when it clearly says its OK in the regs. I doubt any officer is going to mess with you over it and will probably just inform you of the changes.
Don't count on it. Its up to us to know the laws. All the rule changes going on drives me buggy. I won't get into that now..lol, but with much of the fishing changes. I understand why as they are dealing with unknowns. This is different. I read all the posts. Kain I understand your frustration. I say go hunting if worrying about this doesn't take the fun out of it. Being right, and having to argue about it with a wdfw officer that isn't sure of the laws him, or herself is no fun. I say that with experience.
I need to stop now. >:( Thanks for sharing. :chuckle:
-
I think it all got resolved. I went out for one night hunt so far but no luck. It is still late archery deer for me so I have not had lots of extra time and money to get out for the predators. Starting in January I plan on lots of time in the brush day and night for the rest of the season.
-
we dont hunt coyotes at night we just "kill" coyotes at night there is a difference hehe j/k
-
i know this thread is all but dead bud i was cleaning out my saved emails and came across a correspondance i had with the mill creek office. It seams like they gave me a straight forward answer the first time i asked. Sounds like there wasn't any confusion to them they must be smarter. lol :chuckle:
(Their reply)
That rule about hunting at night during bobcat and raccoon season refers strictly bobcats and raccoons as they have set established season. Coyotes are year round (unless using hounds). You just need to make sure there is not a modern firearm season open for deer or elk. Hope this helps.
Sincerely,
Region 4 Customer Service
>>> <spoons5332@aol.com> 07/22/2008 2:05 PM >>>
(my email to them)
i was reading the hunting regulations and it states that it is legal to hunt Coyotes at night during bobcat and raccoon season. as long as there is no centerfire season open for deer or elk. I was wondering if it is only ok to hunt coyotes at night during bobcat and raccoon season. or can i hunt them at night during the winter/ summer too. as long as there is no modern rifle season open? i would apreciate any help you could give me on this. thank you.
-
Guess who has two thumbs and is going spotlighting tonight?.............. 8) This guy!
-
Guess who has two thumbs and is going spotlighting tonight?.............. 8) This guy!
Good luck, take pics.
-
>:(
Yeah... I hate to bring this up, but I would also hate for anyone to get in trouble, so...
I was told by Lori Preuss at Fish and Game that night hunting is allowed ONLY from Sept 1 - March 31, and only when no other rifle season for big game was open. I am hoping that meant Elk and Deer, NOT Bear and Cougar! This all started when I asked about using a crossbow for non-game animals like Coyotes. See below...
Email 1 to her.
Lori,
I need to ask a question for a buddy of mine. He has his "crossbow exemption" card for deer hunting during archery, and wanted to know if using a crossbow was legal for him for Coyotes at night. Would it be legal for someone without the exemption?
(now if I can just figure out a way to mount that Night Vision scope on a crossbow...)
Thank you,
Reply 1.
If he has a special use permit, he can hunt with a crossbow in any season that allows archery equipment. If he doesn’t have a special use permit, he cannot hunt with a crossbow.
You know you can’t mount a night vision scope on a crossbow. :)
Lori
Email 2.
For Big Game, yes. I thought Coyotes were a non-game species? (which is why I asked about the use of them for Coyote hunting by non-handicapped hunters).
If I understand your first email correctly then, it is OK to hunt Coyotes (only) at night anytime of the year EXCEPT during the days and areas where a big game centerfire season is open.
THANK YOU for your time on this. I just want to be sure we are legal.
Jeff
Reply 2.
You’re only allowed to hunt coyote during established bobcat and raccoon seasons
Email 3.
Oh Boy, now I am confused! Is this for night hunting only, or day as well?
Reply 3.
That’s for night hunting. The season for coyote is open year-round for daytime hunting. I’m sorry to confuse you
Email 4.
That's OK, I am easilty confused!
So - if I am reading you correctly, night hunting for Coyote is legal (this year) from Sept 1st through March 15th, except for the months of Sept, Oct and Nov where big game centerfire seasons are in effect. It is totally legal at night during muzzleloader and archery, just not centerfire.
Thanks,
Reply 4.
Correct!
Email 5.
We are almost there...
Since Coyote is a non-game species, can I (a non-disabled hunter) use a crossbow either during the day or night to hunt them?
Reply 5.
No, you can’t use a crossbow. Even though coyote are non-game species, the general weapons rules still apply. Otherwise, we’d have folks using automatic rifles on coyote
Email 6.
Again, thank you so much. I am sure you typically don't have someone burning your day over Coyotes! I do have a question. Why no night hunting for a non-game species (Coyotes) from April - Aug? Is this a non-game rule or a night hunting rule?
Reply 6.
It’s a night hunting rule, and the reason for it is that we have lots of folks in the state who wander around in the wilderness from April through August. We don’t want any of them to get shot. September should probably also be included, for that reason, but it’s not. I’m not implying that coyote hunters have bad aim or are careless. It’s just difficult to see folks bedded down in the dark
-
>:(
Yeah... I hate to bring this up, but I would also hate for anyone to get in trouble, so...
I was told by Lori Preuss at Fish and Game that night hunting is allowed ONLY from Sept 1 - March 31, and only when no other rifle season for big game was open. I am hoping that meant Elk and Deer, NOT Bear and Cougar! This all started when I asked about using a crossbow for non-game animals like Coyotes. See below...
Email 1 to her.
Lori,
I need to ask a question for a buddy of mine. He has his "crossbow exemption" card for deer hunting during archery, and wanted to know if using a crossbow was legal for him for Coyotes at night. Would it be legal for someone without the exemption?
(now if I can just figure out a way to mount that Night Vision scope on a crossbow...)
Thank you,
Reply 1.
If he has a special use permit, he can hunt with a crossbow in any season that allows archery equipment. If he doesn’t have a special use permit, he cannot hunt with a crossbow.
You know you can’t mount a night vision scope on a crossbow. :)
Lori
Email 2.
For Big Game, yes. I thought Coyotes were a non-game species? (which is why I asked about the use of them for Coyote hunting by non-handicapped hunters).
If I understand your first email correctly then, it is OK to hunt Coyotes (only) at night anytime of the year EXCEPT during the days and areas where a big game centerfire season is open.
THANK YOU for your time on this. I just want to be sure we are legal.
Jeff
Reply 2.
You’re only allowed to hunt coyote during established bobcat and raccoon seasons
Email 3.
Oh Boy, now I am confused! Is this for night hunting only, or day as well?
Reply 3.
That’s for night hunting. The season for coyote is open year-round for daytime hunting. I’m sorry to confuse you
Email 4.
That's OK, I am easilty confused!
So - if I am reading you correctly, night hunting for Coyote is legal (this year) from Sept 1st through March 15th, except for the months of Sept, Oct and Nov where big game centerfire seasons are in effect. It is totally legal at night during muzzleloader and archery, just not centerfire.
Thanks,
Reply 4.
Correct!
Email 5.
We are almost there...
Since Coyote is a non-game species, can I (a non-disabled hunter) use a crossbow either during the day or night to hunt them?
Reply 5.
No, you can’t use a crossbow. Even though coyote are non-game species, the general weapons rules still apply. Otherwise, we’d have folks using automatic rifles on coyote
Email 6.
Again, thank you so much. I am sure you typically don't have someone burning your day over Coyotes! I do have a question. Why no night hunting for a non-game species (Coyotes) from April - Aug? Is this a non-game rule or a night hunting rule?
Reply 6.
It’s a night hunting rule, and the reason for it is that we have lots of folks in the state who wander around in the wilderness from April through August. We don’t want any of them to get shot. September should probably also be included, for that reason, but it’s not. I’m not implying that coyote hunters have bad aim or are careless. It’s just difficult to see folks bedded down in the dark
Welcome to the DEPT of RECREATION and Conservation! :bash: :bash:
-
bobcat,raccoon,and coyote may be hunted at night during established bobcat and raccoon seasons. hers what you guys arent seeing Except that is unlawful to hunt [any ] wildlife at night or wild animals with [dogs [hounds during the months of september,october, or november. in any area open to a [centerfire rifle or elk season'''''''''''' bobcat,fox coyote, raccoon sept. 1 to march 15 this is the season there is no center fire rifle season until oct 16 to the 31 in whatcom county you cant hunt at night during those months during the center fire season with hounds this is what it is saying.doesnt say anything about archery seasons only centerfire seasons it also doesnt say anything about hunting without hounds at night during those times . the way i read it is you can hunt at night during those seasons as long as you are not using hounds Forgot to put in deer season and coyote is open year round
-
>:(
Yeah... I hate to bring this up, but I would also hate for anyone to get in trouble, so...
I was told by Lori Preuss at Fish and Game that night hunting is allowed ONLY from Sept 1 - March 31, and only when no other rifle season for big game was open. I am hoping that meant Elk and Deer, NOT Bear and Cougar! This all started when I asked about using a crossbow for non-game animals like Coyotes. See below...
Email 1 to her.
Lori,
I need to ask a question for a buddy of mine. He has his "crossbow exemption" card for deer hunting during archery, and wanted to know if using a crossbow was legal for him for Coyotes at night. Would it be legal for someone without the exemption?
(now if I can just figure out a way to mount that Night Vision scope on a crossbow...)
Thank you,
Reply 1.
If he has a special use permit, he can hunt with a crossbow in any season that allows archery equipment. If he doesnt have a special use permit, he cannot hunt with a crossbow.
You know you cant mount a night vision scope on a crossbow. :)
Lori
Email 2.
For Big Game, yes. I thought Coyotes were a non-game species? (which is why I asked about the use of them for Coyote hunting by non-handicapped hunters).
If I understand your first email correctly then, it is OK to hunt Coyotes (only) at night anytime of the year EXCEPT during the days and areas where a big game centerfire season is open.
THANK YOU for your time on this. I just want to be sure we are legal.
Jeff
Reply 2.
Youre only allowed to hunt coyote during established bobcat and raccoon seasons
Email 3.
Oh Boy, now I am confused! Is this for night hunting only, or day as well?
Reply 3.
Thats for night hunting. The season for coyote is open year-round for daytime hunting. Im sorry to confuse you
Email 4.
That's OK, I am easilty confused!
So - if I am reading you correctly, night hunting for Coyote is legal (this year) from Sept 1st through March 15th, except for the months of Sept, Oct and Nov where big game centerfire seasons are in effect. It is totally legal at night during muzzleloader and archery, just not centerfire.
Thanks,
Reply 4.
Correct!
Email 5.
We are almost there...
Since Coyote is a non-game species, can I (a non-disabled hunter) use a crossbow either during the day or night to hunt them?
Reply 5.
No, you cant use a crossbow. Even though coyote are non-game species, the general weapons rules still apply. Otherwise, wed have folks using automatic rifles on coyote
Email 6.
Again, thank you so much. I am sure you typically don't have someone burning your day over Coyotes! I do have a question. Why no night hunting for a non-game species (Coyotes) from April - Aug? Is this a non-game rule or a night hunting rule?
Reply 6.
Its a night hunting rule, and the reason for it is that we have lots of folks in the state who wander around in the wilderness from April through August. We dont want any of them to get shot. September should probably also be included, for that reason, but its not. Im not implying that coyote hunters have bad aim or are careless. Its just difficult to see folks bedded down in the dark
Lori has a history of inaccurate and confusing emails.
-
Email 6.
Again, thank you so much. I am sure you typically don't have someone burning your day over Coyotes! I do have a question. Why no night hunting for a non-game species (Coyotes) from April - Aug? Is this a non-game rule or a night hunting rule?
Reply 6.
It’s a night hunting rule, and the reason for it is that we have lots of folks in the state who wander around in the wilderness from April through August. We don’t want any of them to get shot. September should probably also be included, for that reason, but it’s not. I’m not implying that coyote hunters have bad aim or are careless. It’s just difficult to see folks bedded down in the dark
Her last response is very scary and it is that mentality that closes seasons.
-
She probably graduated from Evergreen State (liberal hippie college). :dunno:
-
Email 6.
Again, thank you so much. I am sure you typically don't have someone burning your day over Coyotes! I do have a question. Why no night hunting for a non-game species (Coyotes) from April - Aug? Is this a non-game rule or a night hunting rule?
Reply 6.
It’s a night hunting rule, and the reason for it is that we have lots of folks in the state who wander around in the wilderness from April through August. We don’t want any of them to get shot. September should probably also be included, for that reason, but it’s not. I’m not implying that coyote hunters have bad aim or are careless. It’s just difficult to see folks bedded down in the dark
Her last response is very scary and it is that mentality that closes seasons.
How many people are hunting coyotes in the "wilderness"? Maybe she didn't really mean for that word to be taken literally but it just shows how out of touch with reality she is. And if that's the case, why is September through March any different? I wrote two letters to Fish & Wildlife last night in regards to the proposed 2011 hunting seasons- I wish I would have thought to say something about how we need this night hunting rule clarified so there's no ambiguity. It's ridiculous when you get different answers as to what is legal when you ask different WDFW employess.
-
Every thing is illegal! you have 3 choices... 1 pay the man 2 try and defend yourself 3 don't get caught in the gray area.. :bash:
-
Yeah I think #3 is the best option. If you're hunting at night, avoid people as much as possible. You never know who might call the police when they hear a gunshot and/or a spotlight at night, and you'll end up dealing with one of the officers who does believe it is illegal to hunt at night.
-
As posted before have a real problem with poaching where I live, Guys come out at night and spotlight and shoot from their vehicle at animals on located on private property. They shoot a yotes, coons, deer, elk horses etc. And often shooting while standing on the road.
No problem with night hunting but if spotlighting animals from your vehicle and shooting animals located on private property I will report you. I have confronted quite a few guys doing this and a good majority were drinking.( I could smeel the alcohol on their breath and in the vehicle) Spoke to a Gamie recently cannot use your vehicle to spotlight an animal and shoot it. Big fine will result.
Ok obviuosly to use a hand held light away from the road to hunt yotes. Can't use your vehicle to hunt. Apparently a lot of people do not know this
-
Ok obviuosly to use a hand held light away from the road to hunt yotes. Can't use your vehicle to hunt. Apparently a lot of people do not know this
Probably because F&W have told peole that they can. One of my hunting partners was told by F&W that he could shoot from the top of his vehicle as long as he was pulled off to the side of the road. He had built a little stool on the rack and wanted to shine from up there.
-
What good is a law, if Enforcement cannot keep track of the rules? :dunno:
-
AND if they cannot keep track of them and its their JOB! How the F#$@ are we supposed to?
-
The hunting and fishing laws in this state can be frustrating to say the least.
But common sense can be of help. :twocents: Don't appreciate guys that are drinking and shooting towards my house or towards my neighbors' houses and lifestock at night with high powered rifles. :twocents:
-
Go hunt!
It is oh so apparent that those staffing the email service at wildlife are a bunch of morons. :bash:
-
Go hunt!
It is oh so apparent that those staffing the email service at wildlife are a bunch of morons. :bash:
:yeah: :yeah:
-
It is very frustrating as I am about 3 weeks away from dropping major coin ($4K) on some night vision gear only to get conflicting answers. Considering the totally "safe" months (no rifle open for Elk or Deer) are Jan, Feb and March I am debating the purchase. If your not aweare it tends to RAIN here during that time!
:)
-
Ok obviuosly to use a hand held light away from the road to hunt yotes. Can't use your vehicle to hunt. Apparently a lot of people do not know this
Probably because F&W have told peole that they can. One of my hunting partners was told by F&W that he could shoot from the top of his vehicle as long as he was pulled off to the side of the road. He had built a little stool on the rack and wanted to shine from up there.
I would advise against shooting from any portion of a vehicle, stopped or not. Most enforcement officers I've known would cite the shooter. I know of more than one hunter who was cited for simply leaning a loaded gun against a vehicle. Maybe it's different at night, but the regulations are pretty clear about not doing it.
-
I do have a question... Can you spot from the vehicle ONLY (not shoot) with a red light taht is not attached to the truck?
Thank you in advance,
Jeff
-
I do have a question... Can you spot from the vehicle ONLY (not shoot) with a red light taht is not attached to the truck?
Thank you in advance,
Jeff
If a gun is in the vehicle I believe it is illegal then.
-
Ok obviuosly to use a hand held light away from the road to hunt yotes. Can't use your vehicle to hunt. Apparently a lot of people do not know this
Probably because F&W have told peole that they can. One of my hunting partners was told by F&W that he could shoot from the top of his vehicle as long as he was pulled off to the side of the road. He had built a little stool on the rack and wanted to shine from up there.
I would advise against shooting from any portion of a vehicle, stopped or not. Most enforcement officers I've known would cite the shooter. I know of more than one hunter who was cited for simply leaning a loaded gun against a vehicle. Maybe it's different at night, but the regulations are pretty clear about not doing it.
I would (and did) advise against this as well, but he fully planned on doing it because he was told it was legal. Then the rig got stolen and the whole rack torched off.
-
Ok obviuosly to use a hand held light away from the road to hunt yotes. Can't use your vehicle to hunt. Apparently a lot of people do not know this
Probably because F&W have told peole that they can. One of my hunting partners was told by F&W that he could shoot from the top of his vehicle as long as he was pulled off to the side of the road. He had built a little stool on the rack and wanted to shine from up there.
That would be legal shooting from a vehicle off a well maintaned road with vehicle turned off if they had a disable hunter.
-
Damn! I knew my buddy had a good use! He has his disabled hunter card!!!!!
:chuckle:
-
I have hunted at night no issues yet. makes me think twice now tho
-
So are they trying to say that on page 66 in the hunting regs is incorrect? "Night hunting and hound hunting during deer and elk hunting seasons. Bobcat, raccoon, and coyote may be hunted at night during established bobcat and raccoon seasons, EXCEPT that it is unlawful to hunt any wildlife at night or wild animals with dogs (hounds) during the months of September, October, or November in any area open to a centerfire rifle deer or elk season. The use of hounds to hunt black bear, cougar, bobcat, or coyote is prohibited year round except during commission authorized hunts."
Bobcat and raccoon season is Sept 1- March 15. Sounds like yotes can be hunted between these months at night in my opinion......... Maybe Im beating a dead horse here but if the hunting regs aka bible says its ok then its ok right?
-
We have hunted coyote at night for years. My son asked the local warden again late last year and he confirmed again that we could hunt at night. :twocents:
-
So are they trying to say that on page 66 in the hunting regs is incorrect? "Night hunting and hound hunting during deer and elk hunting seasons. Bobcat, raccoon, and coyote may be hunted at night during established bobcat and raccoon seasons, EXCEPT that it is unlawful to hunt any wildlife at night or wild animals with dogs (hounds) during the months of September, October, or November in any area open to a centerfire rifle deer or elk season. The use of hounds to hunt black bear, cougar, bobcat, or coyote is prohibited year round except during commission authorized hunts."
Bobcat and raccoon season is Sept 1- March 15. Sounds like yotes can be hunted between these months at night in my opinion......... Maybe Im beating a dead horse here but if the hunting regs aka bible says its ok then its ok right?
Yes you can for the most part.
"EXCEPT that it is unlawful to hunt any wildlife at night or wild animals with dogs (hounds) during the months of September, October, or November in any area open to a centerfire rifle deer or elk season."
-
:beatdeadhorse:
-
:beatdeadhorse:
:yeah: :chuckle:
It all depends who you talk to. The way I read it is it's only legal during bobcat/raccoon season.
-
Hi all,
If it isnt illegal now which I dont think it is, It will be soon. The WDFW already tried to make all night hunting illegal last summer and an out poor of hunter's emailed them and stopped it. So here['s the deal a game warden was shot and killed by yote hunters back east, and Washington being liberal as hell wanted to set an example and try to show good faith by supporting the fallen game warden. Well it didn't work so the first step was to outlaw hunting yotes with hounds, witch most if not all hound hunters don't hunt them with hounds in the first place. Next will be to end hunting yotes at night because most guys use something bigger than a rimfire 22.
Here is the email from the WDFW back to me
Hello. I told all of you months ago that I would be drafting proposed changes to our night-hunting rule and would send you the draft for review. After much discussion between the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife (WDFW) Enforcement Program and WDFW’s Wildlife Program, we have decided to hold off on making changes, if any, to this rule until early 2012. That is when the Wildlife Program will be considering amendments to many of the hunting rules as part of their 3-year cycle. To see the proposed hunting rule changes in early 2012, or to check the status of current rules in development at any given time, go to the “Current Rule Making Activity” page of WDFW’s website at http://wdfw.wa.gov/about/regulations/development.html. (http://wdfw.wa.gov/about/regulations/development.html.)
Lori Preuss, WSBA #33045
WDFW Criminal Justice Liaison &
Administrative Regulations Coordinator
Lori.preuss@dfw.wa.gov
360.902.2930
Fax 360.902.2155
-
In case anyone is reading this thread for clear information on the legality of hunting coyotes at night, the changes made in the regs for 2011-12 regarding night hunting are actually good, they clear up the issue.
If you look on page 62 of the 2011-12 Big Game regs, it clearly states: "Coyote may be hunted at night year round, EXCEPT it is unlawful to hunt coyote at night during the months of September, October, or November in any area
open to a centerfire rifle deer or elk season."
So go shoot some coyotes one of these night, I know I will be!
-
thanks, good info, glad this was cleared up in a positive way... :tup: