Hunting Washington Forum

Big Game Hunting => Bear Hunting => Topic started by: Gutpile on December 16, 2010, 07:27:31 AM


Advertise Here
Title: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: Gutpile on December 16, 2010, 07:27:31 AM
Poached this from another site. I'm torn on this. I know I wouldn't do it myself, not quite sure what I think about it though.

Quote
Hunt for 703-pound bear attracts amazement, criticism

By Dave Buchanan
Wednesday, December 15, 2010

When hunter Richard Kendall crawled into the darkness of a bear den in late November, he was prepared to face the largest black bear he had ever tracked.

What he wasn’t prepared for was the 703-pound bear waiting for him or the firestorm that erupted after he left that den.

Kendall, 55, of Craig, said he’s had years of experience hunting black bears in Colorado and after seeing the 8-inch-wide tracks left by this bear, knew he had a potential record on his hands.

“I’ve been hunting bears all my life and that’s the biggest track I’ve ever seen,” Kendall said earlier this week.

The black bear season, which begins in September and runs through the deer and elk season, was in its final weekend when Kendall tracked the bear to its den in the Danforth Hills near Wilson Creek north of Meeker.

Kendall and a friend rushed into Meeker for a license and the next morning they were at the den.

Not knowing exactly how big the as-yet unseen bear was, “I really didn’t want to go in there so I sat on the den for five hours, hoping he’d come out or maybe already was out,” Kendall said.

Finally, Kendall decided the bear was home and cautiously squeezed into the den.

“I went in about 6 feet, and I could just see the tip of his nose without a flashlight,” Kendall said. “He was growling and snapping his jaws at me.”

Kendall said that after he shined his flashlight on the bear, the bear laid back its ears.

“A buddy told me when they lay back their ears they’re usually going to charge, so I decided I better shoot while I have the chance,” said Kendall, who was carrying a .45-70 caliber lever-action rifle.

It took Kendall and several of his friends most of an hour to drag the bear out of its den and another 30 minutes to get it to Kendall’s truck.

The bear weighed 703 pounds. That is about 50 percent more than most large black bears, which usually top out at 450–500 pounds.

The bear’s skull, which is how official scorers from the Boone & Crockett Club determine record-worthy animals, measured prior to drying at 22 and 5/8 inches. The state record bear, killed in Mesa County in 2007, measured 22 and 9/16th inches.

Kendall’s bear, which stretched 9-foot, 6-inches from nose to toes, will be remeasured after a 60-day drying period.

Kendall said once the word got out about the immense bear, people stopped him on the street to congratulate him.

“People I don’t even know would stop and talk about that bear,” said Kendall, a native of Craig who teaches rifle and handgun shooting skills.

But Kendall soon discovered some reactions weren’t quite so positive.

After the Craig Daily Press ran a story on its website about the bear, most of the reader comments, nearly all of which were anonymous, were harshly critical of Kendall’s actions.

One anonymous reader said, “This article & mentality behind the hunter makes me truly sick. How is shooting a bear in a cave ‘hunting’ ... ?”

Another reader wrote, “My family has been hunting for generations in Colorado, and I can tell you that this is not sportsmanship, it is just a plain case of cowardness.”

One of the few signed letters came from James Mense (no hometown given), who wrote he was a lifelong hunter but “the idea of shooting a bear after it has entered its den to begin hibernation is repulsive to me.”

The killing “may be legal, but it is definitely not ethical,” Mense wrote.

Kendall’s actions, while a bit unusual, were legal, said Division of Wildlife spokesman Randy Hampton.

“Currently, there are no regulations prohibiting someone from crawling into a den after a hibernating bear,” Hampton said. “This is the first instance we are aware of a bear being taken in this manner.”

Hampton said no one from the Division of Wildlife, other than the local officer who checked the bear as required by regulations, has spoken to Kendall about the bear incident.

“We are aware the bear was taken and we have heard from a number of concerned people regarding the manner in which this bear was harvested,” Hampton said.

While Kendall’s actions were legal, “the idea of shooting a hibernating animal certainly raises some ethical issues,” Hampton said.

Emphasizing there now are no regulations regarding hunting a denned animal, Hampton said division officials “are discussing” possible changes to the current rules.

Kendall, for his part, is dismayed and a bit angry over the continued rain of criticism.

“I think these (critics) are just jealous of what I did,” Kendall said. “It was something that was positive at first but then you get all these e-mails and letters and stuff.”

Kendall said he wanted no more publicity about his bear.

“I’m tired of people coming up to me and saying things that aren’t true to me and my wife,” Kendall said. “People are making more of it than what it was and I’m tired of dealing with all the (stuff).”
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: dirty24d on December 16, 2010, 07:34:35 AM
I dunno I really dont see how it's any different then shooting a spring bear... Most spring bears I've seen are oblivious to everything except gorging on anything they can find to get their strength and metabolism going again.  It wasnt sleeping based on the story this guys tells. In its den yes but sleeping no.  It's not really my cup of tea to crawl in an animals den to shoot it, but that doesnt make him a coward in my opinion.

It's not for me, i wouldnt do it but I'm not terribly up in arms about it either. Theres a signifigant amount of risk this fellow took going into that den like being mauled and eaten in a confined space.  So yeah is it ethical  ehhh  not really but to each their own i suppose..
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: krout81 on December 16, 2010, 07:35:41 AM
sounds to me like he used artifical light to kill big game.  Is that legal over there? 
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: Gutpile on December 16, 2010, 07:36:12 AM
I dunno I really dont see how it's any different then shooting a spring bear... Most spring bears I've seen are oblivious to everything except gorging on anything they can find to get their strength and metabolism going again.  It wasnt sleeping based on the story this guys tells. In its den yes but sleeping no.  It's not really my cup of tea to crawl in an animals den to shoot it, but that doesnt make him a coward in my opinion.

Well for one thing a spring bear can run away. A denned up bear is trapped. The more I think about this the more I dislike it. Coward? Not quite the word I'd use. Not to many "cowards" are going to crawl into a den that has 7"-8" tracks leading to it.  :chuckle:
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: boneaddict on December 16, 2010, 07:37:18 AM
I'm not impressed. :twocents:
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: Big10gauge on December 16, 2010, 07:40:51 AM
To each their own, Definitely not my cup of tea. Anymore it's the hunting aspect that turns my crank.
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: high country on December 16, 2010, 07:41:26 AM
a coworker of mine in alaska lost one of his friends because he poked his head in a bear hole. I have no problem with killing it in its den.....sans the light. guy is lucky to be alive. we could never pull that off here for the possibility of griz. so I guess my anser is congrats to you.....idiot.
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: BLKBEARKLR on December 16, 2010, 07:42:29 AM
Totally not hunting in my book. No respect for said hunter what so ever.


Joe

Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: krout81 on December 16, 2010, 07:45:38 AM
http://wildlife.state.co.us/Hunting/PlanYourHunt/ResourcesTips/Unlawful.htm (http://wildlife.state.co.us/Hunting/PlanYourHunt/ResourcesTips/Unlawful.htm)
Use artificial light to hunt wildlife. (Having a firearm with cartridges in the chamber or magazine, or loaded with powder or a ball, or a strung, uncased bow while trying to project artificial light into an area where wildlife can be found is prima facie evidence of a violation.)
He should be fined and the bear taken away he told the story and had it published if its not true tough *censored*
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: runamuk on December 16, 2010, 07:48:52 AM
too each there own as long as no laws were broken I dont really care....and this stuff is made into a brewha and just fuels the fire in the anti's agenda and adding to the divide among hunters.....so sad really that every hunt that is not what we might do is torn apart and dissected...just say congrats to the hunter or say nothing...thats a big bear and I sure wouldnt be sticking my head in a bear den.....

if that bear had been simply snoozing in a clearcut how many here would have passed  :dunno: I sure as hell wouldnt.
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: high country on December 16, 2010, 07:50:39 AM
should have speared it!
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: krout81 on December 16, 2010, 07:54:04 AM
Who cares where it was killed he broke the law to do it.  If he went in without a flashlight it would have been legal, stupid but legal.  HE broke the law according colorado state
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: bobcat on December 16, 2010, 07:54:35 AM
I don't have a problem with what he did. Sounds like an exciting hunt, and took a lot of skill in tracking that bear to its den. It's just a bear. Not like there's a shortage of them, and not only that, but it was a huge bear, and probably very old, and may not have lived much longer anyway.
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: RAMSFAN on December 16, 2010, 08:02:32 AM
MY  :twocents:, Sounds like shooting fish in a barrel to me, someone said something about if the bear was sleeping in the woods would it have been "ethical", I'd say so. At least the bear had an opportunity to hear,smell and had what I call "fair chase." Not the way I would have done it but for the guy to think he's not going to continue to hear crap about out, he's sorely mistaken. He's gotta know he was toeing the line a little bit, he's gotta deal with it.
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: cmiller85 on December 16, 2010, 08:25:47 AM
I'm not quite sure what the big deal is? This bear was in a hole? So what?

According to the article the bear was not sleeping. Following the biggest bear track you have ever seen into a den and shooting him is a whole hell of a lot more impressive to me than having 10 dogs run him up a tree. He was no less "trapped" in this den than he would have been up a tree.

The only issue I saw reading the article was the whole flashlight incident.
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: high country on December 16, 2010, 08:29:37 AM
I'm not quite sure what the big deal is? This bear was in a hole? So what?

According to the article the bear was not sleeping. Following the biggest bear track you have ever seen into a den and shooting him is a whole hell of a lot more impressive to me than having 10 dogs run him up a tree. He was no less "trapped" in this den than he would have been up a tree.

The only issue I saw reading the article was the whole flashlight incident.

I am in your camp. I have trouble with the light, and the fact that guys might read this and go poking their heads into a den.....all that aside, he did track and kill a bear
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: runamuk on December 16, 2010, 08:35:57 AM
according to the dept of wildlife no law was broken  :dunno:

Quote
Kendall’s actions, while a bit unusual, were legal, said Division of Wildlife spokesman Randy Hampton.

“Currently, there are no regulations prohibiting someone from crawling into a den after a hibernating bear,” Hampton said. “This is the first instance we are aware of a bear being taken in this manner.”
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: Ray on December 16, 2010, 08:40:46 AM
I wouldn't kill a bear in the den. I just don't see that the bear has much of a fighting chance once they hole up for the winter. I'm not saying the guy did not work at harvesting the bear. However once a bear dens up for the winter they are obviously a lot more vulnerable. I don't think it is quite comparable to a spring bear roaming as others have mentioned. In the end he seemed like he was protecting his life when he shot it so I don't have strong criticism against him. It's a bear and I am not upset he killed it. There are plenty more. As far as needing a light, it basically underscores why I don't believe that harvest is of the best way to go about it and I wouldn't shoot a bear in a wintering den and call it a hunt. Not sure if that bear was holed up for the winter, but seems like it might have been just about so.
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: Houndhunter on December 16, 2010, 08:42:34 AM
. Following the biggest bear track you have ever seen into a den and shooting him is a whole hell of a lot more impressive to me than having 10 dogs run him up a tree. He was no less "trapped" in this den than he would have been up a tree.


dogs are way more impresive, but thats just me :chuckle:

i would shoot it, be quite a rush i think. not as cool as seeing 10 dogs run one up a tree, but that bear wouldnt tree anyways
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: uplandhunter870 on December 16, 2010, 08:45:04 AM
i dont have a problem with this at all, well the flashlight part a little.  the dude is a crazy moron he lucky a bear that sized gave him some warning gestures instead of simply just swinging for the fences at the idiots head

you want to crawl into the den of a 6.5 foot bear while hes in it, head first, you go right ahead ill be sitting on a large rock a ways away writting your application to the darwin awards comittee
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: Gutpile on December 16, 2010, 08:46:09 AM
i dont have a problem with this at all, well the flashlight part a little.  the dude is a crazy moron he lucky a bear that sized gave him some warning gestures instead of simply just swinging for the fences at the idiots head

you want to crawl into the den of a 6.5 foot bear while hes in it, head first, you go right ahead ill be sitting on a large rock a ways away writting your application to the darwin awards comittee

 :chuckle:  :chuckle:  :chuckle:
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: Ray on December 16, 2010, 08:47:05 AM
I suspect the only reason he was able to crawl in there with the bear is because the thing was basically trying to hole up for the winter. Definitely a Darwin moment in my book. It's a fine bear and I am sure he will be telling that story for a long time.
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: Woodchuck on December 16, 2010, 08:47:44 AM
well said, i dont believe i have the sack for it, go right ahead buddy
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: Hornseeker on December 16, 2010, 08:55:29 AM
I concur with Miller... the bear was no more trapped than if we treed it with dogs... or caved it with dogs which I've done many times... I've also crawled into caves trying to pull dogs out...and let me tell ya, its a hair raising Muther Huncher, cause that bears not just chill and hanging out, hes in there fighting....

The guys got sack...if you say he doesn't, you've probably never tried crawling into a dark cave with a bear...

I'm also with Houndhunter... Much more exciting and fun having the dogs run him. But that bear would have never treed, which would have been more exciting yet, getting in and killing a bear that big on the ground would be the ULTIMATE!!! DAM!
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: cmiller85 on December 16, 2010, 08:57:09 AM
. Following the biggest bear track you have ever seen into a den and shooting him is a whole hell of a lot more impressive to me than having 10 dogs run him up a tree. He was no less "trapped" in this den than he would have been up a tree.


dogs are way more impresive, but thats just me :chuckle:

i would shoot it, be quite a rush i think. not as cool as seeing 10 dogs run one up a tree, but that bear wouldnt tree anyways

Well I must admit i've never actually witnessed first hand 10 dogs tree a bear. Being that your handle is Houndhunter, I will take your word for it.  :)

My point was that some hunting methods are more harshly scrutinized than others for reasons that sometimes don't make much sense. Well, at least to me.  :chuckle:
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: BlackRidge on December 16, 2010, 09:00:57 AM
I wouldnt do so, but I certainly wouldnt give anyone grief over it... he abide'd by the regs, so who cares what some non-hunters w/ their panties bunched up have to say. Wish they'd just stfu and worry about their own problems
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: the1rod on December 16, 2010, 09:36:57 AM
i have no problem with what he did. he was crazy enough to do it so good for him. if the flashlight was illegal im assuming something would have been done about it so im not going to get into that. what really bugs me about this story is all the comments from other hunters slamming this guy and bitching about it, because of the bitching the article mentions a possible rule change. i think its bs that someone is going to get their rights taken away because of someone elses ethical views. it you dont agree with what another hunter is legally doing then dont take part in it, but dont take action that is going to get hunting rights limited. us hunters need to stick together and not get someone else's rights taken away because of how one group may feel.
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: Tony 270 on December 16, 2010, 09:44:50 AM
Favorite quote in the article, “I think these (critics) are just jealous of what I did."

 :chuckle: the argument for when you have no argument, throw out the jealousy card  :chuckle:
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: YellowDog on December 16, 2010, 09:58:40 AM
The story said "when he shined the flashlight on the bear he laid back his ears" he did not specifically say that he had the light on him when he shot him.  I don't know home many of you would want to or could accurately fire a 45/70 lever action with one hand so my guess is that he shut the light off or dropped the damn thing and fired.  I'm not really in favor of this type of hunting but the Wildlife Officers determined no law was broken so as far as I can tell he broke no law and he should be left alone.  Its no different than the hate mail, threats, etc. that the wolf hunter in Idaho got when he killed the first wolf LEGALLY.  It was legal so leave him alone.  If you don't like the manner in which he killed the bear, push for a change in the law, don't bitch about the fact that he killed the bear. 

Again, I wouldn't have done what he did but we all make our own decisions on ethics when we go into the woods and as long as it is legal we should stand behind this individual as a legal hunter.  At the same time we are supporting him, if we disagree with the law, we can push for a change so it doesn't happen again. 

As we know, there are people who believe that hunting with hounds or over bait is unethical and look how easy it was for the antis to take that right away.  We need to stand together more often in my mind.  For the record, if I lived in that state, I would want the law changed so that you can't take a hibernating bear but if he was able to track the bear, crawl inside the cave, see it awake, growling, jaw popping, etc. in my mind it wasn't hibernating.  Like someone else said, if this is outlawed, I think you would have to outlaw shooting a bear when running hounds and they run them into a cave. 
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: grundy53 on December 16, 2010, 10:26:59 AM
Who cares where it was killed he broke the law to do it.  If he went in without a flashlight it would have been legal, stupid but legal.  HE broke the law according colorado state

maybe but the law might have been taken out of context. it seems to me that after all the public copmlaints to the game department they looked into it and said he didn't do anything illegal. I think that the game department in Colorado probably knows their laws better then us.
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: boneaddict on December 16, 2010, 10:38:00 AM
Crawl into a hole with one in Spetember and see how it turns out. 
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: TheHunt on December 16, 2010, 10:43:39 AM
To each their own.   Good for him.   I have no problem for what he did.  The tracked it, crawled in, no Alaska law law was broken. 
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: BLUEBULLS on December 16, 2010, 11:25:07 AM
I don't have a problem with what he did. Sounds like an exciting hunt, and took a lot of skill in tracking that bear to its den. It's just a bear. Not like there's a shortage of them, and not only that, but it was a huge bear, and probably very old, and may not have lived much longer anyway.

my thoughts as well.
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: croix on December 16, 2010, 11:43:10 AM
Crawl into a hole with one in Spetember and see how it turns out. 
:chuckle:
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: Machias on December 16, 2010, 11:58:30 AM
One thing, the title of this thread is not accurate, the bear was holed up, not sleeping.  :)  I've seen several videos of guys following hounds into caves and holes after bears, lions and bobcats.  I have followed a dog in a huge culvert/cave in ID after a lion.  It was NOT a good feeling, but I had to go in and get my dog out.  Cave got so small I couldn't get in any further and I never did know if it was still in there or not, tracks went in but did not come back out.  As long as he was legal, I don't have any issues with it.  Dang that was a HUGE black bear!!  The folks that are critical, what would you have the guy do?  Try and spook it out and then shoot it?  Wait for it to come out?  Wait till spring and then shoot it?  It's in a hole so it's safe?  So would you shoot a bedded deer/elk?  I know you'll say well they could get up and run away.  Trust me if that bear wanted out of that hole there wasn't much going to stop him...except the .45-.70.  :chuckle:  I have seen bears and cats on video unass a cave, lickty split!  They have an avenue of escape, might be over you or through you, but if you don't think a 703 pound animal could leave if it wanted to, your wrong.  :)
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: Kain on December 16, 2010, 12:00:04 PM
I would totally shoot a sleeping bear.  I dont see any difference between that and a bear up a tree, over bait or a five hundred yard shot.  All ethical IMO.  If I saw one snoozing in a clear cut that is just that much less chance of it jumping the string/gun.

We dont have to worry about hibernating bears here since the season only runs into Nov and they dont really do much hibernating here anyways.  I would try to stay away from a den though just because a denning bear is more likely to be a Sow with cubs and I would not like to be forced to shoot a bear because I put myself in a dangerous spot.  That is not self defense in my book that is carelessness.  
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: wsucowboy on December 16, 2010, 12:09:18 PM
I have no problem with what he did. Lucky he didn't get seriously hurt by the bear.Seeing as how no laws were broken it shouldn't be a big deal. He will probably be getting hate mail and everything else like the Idaho hunter who LEGALLY harvested the first wolf in the lower 48. 
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: Curly on December 16, 2010, 12:20:18 PM
I don't have a problem with what he did. Sounds like an exciting hunt, and took a lot of skill in tracking that bear to its den. It's just a bear. Not like there's a shortage of them, and not only that, but it was a huge bear, and probably very old, and may not have lived much longer anyway.

my thoughts as well.


+2
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: Ray on December 16, 2010, 12:33:44 PM
I'll bite  :)

Quote
The folks that are critical, what would you have the guy do?
I wouldn't have that guy do a thing. He can do whatever he wants. But I can also state without having to hide in a corner that I don't hunt animals that way. It doesn't mean I am going to write hate mails, am jealous or the like.

Quote
Try and spook it out and then shoot it?

Again, he is welcome to do as he pleases. But since people are talking about it openly I offered up my thoughts. There is a difference between what I would do and what he did. I thought that was what we were talking about. Not what we would have someone else do. People who hunt within the law are no problem for me.


Quote
Wait for it to come out?  Wait till spring and then shoot it?
I don't see why not.

Quote
It's in a hole so it's safe?
I didn't see a person make that claim that an animal is completely safe in a hole. Probably no more safe than I am in a building I suppose. Not sure where you were going with that one.


Quote
So would you shoot a bedded deer/elk?
Yes, Why not? It's not the same as being contained by earthen walls I suppose. I think the example is an attempt at drawing parallels between two examples, but it just doesn't seem to work out to me.


Quote
I know you'll say well they could get up and run away.  Trust me if that bear wanted out of that hole there wasn't much going to stop him...except the .45-.70.    I have seen bears and cats on video unass a cave, lickty split!  They have an avenue of escape, might be over you or through you, but if you don't think a 703 pound animal could leave if it wanted to, your wrong. 

I think the for most part you want to silence criticism. I think if the bear wanted to get up and run away he would have ate that guy for breakfast. Seems like he would rather have taken a nap. Well, he certainly took a dirt nap.

My criticism isn't meant to be translated as any sort of outrage. On the contrary. I think it's a fine bear. I also think it's fine to openly state I don't hunt that way and there's no shame in saying that and there's no bush I have to hide behind any more than this guy who killed the bear has to.  8)
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: flinger on December 16, 2010, 01:05:14 PM
Been in a bear den head first that is some spooky chit never with anything that big though.Killed a big bear cool for him
Should of done it like this though
Skin Grizz (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FcsXC2xFis4#)
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: grundy53 on December 16, 2010, 01:11:55 PM
Been in a bear den head first that is some spooky chit never with anything that big though.Killed a big bear cool for him
Should of done it like this though
Skin Grizz (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FcsXC2xFis4#)

Thats too funny me and my buddies were quoting that scene the whole week we were hunting in Idaho this year.  " can ya skin griz" "skin that one and i will get ya another one"  :chuckle: :chuckle: :chuckle:
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: Ray on December 16, 2010, 01:14:33 PM
LOL
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: Kain on December 16, 2010, 01:27:07 PM
Pat's black bear hunt.mpg (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eTl3nf2uGu4#)
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: Houndhunter on December 16, 2010, 01:34:52 PM
them dogs didnt know what to do :chuckle:
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: FC on December 16, 2010, 02:02:31 PM
I would totally shoot a sleeping bear.  I dont see any difference between that and a bear up a tree, over bait or a five hundred yard shot.  All ethical IMO.  If I saw one snoozing in a clear cut that is just that much less chance of it jumping the string/gun.  

Same here but I don't think I would be crawling into a big bear's den to see if he was home, that takes either huge balls, a lack of brain cells or some combination of the two.
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: steeleywhopper on December 16, 2010, 02:07:48 PM
This guy is truly stupid or has some huge ballz!
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: Machias on December 16, 2010, 02:10:56 PM
I'll bite  :)

Quote
The folks that are critical, what would you have the guy do?
I wouldn't have that guy do a thing. He can do whatever he wants. But I can also state without having to hide in a corner that I don't hunt animals that way. It doesn't mean I am going to write hate mails, am jealous or the like.

Quote
Try and spook it out and then shoot it?

Again, he is welcome to do as he pleases. But since people are talking about it openly I offered up my thoughts. There is a difference between what I would do and what he did. I thought that was what we were talking about. Not what we would have someone else do. People who hunt within the law are no problem for me.


Quote
Wait for it to come out?  Wait till spring and then shoot it?
I don't see why not.

Quote
It's in a hole so it's safe?
I didn't see a person make that claim that an animal is completely safe in a hole. Probably no more safe than I am in a building I suppose. Not sure where you were going with that one.


Quote
So would you shoot a bedded deer/elk?
Yes, Why not? It's not the same as being contained by earthen walls I suppose. I think the example is an attempt at drawing parallels between two examples, but it just doesn't seem to work out to me.


Quote
I know you'll say well they could get up and run away.  Trust me if that bear wanted out of that hole there wasn't much going to stop him...except the .45-.70.    I have seen bears and cats on video unass a cave, lickty split!  They have an avenue of escape, might be over you or through you, but if you don't think a 703 pound animal could leave if it wanted to, your wrong.  

I think the for most part you want to silence criticism. I think if the bear wanted to get up and run away he would have ate that guy for breakfast. Seems like he would rather have taken a nap. Well, he certainly took a dirt nap.

My criticism isn't meant to be translated as any sort of outrage. On the contrary. I think it's a fine bear. I also think it's fine to openly state I don't hunt that way and there's no shame in saying that and there's no bush I have to hide behind any more than this guy who killed the bear has to.  8)

I think you may have put a little more emphasis in my questions then what I was intending.  I wasn't trying to "silence" anyone, I was trying to understand why the folks who were critical...were critical.  I totally understand it's not everyones idea of how they want to harvest a bear, lion or any animal for that matter.  Just wondering, for those that found themselves in the same situation what you thought the guy should do.  I totally get the guys and gals who say nope, don't seem fair to me, I applaud you, I also applaud this guy, that's all my post was about.  heck this whole site is about the discussion and giving our points of view....maybe sway an opinion or change a person's mind along the way.  It's actually happen to me a time or two.  :)  The reference to being safe in the hole is me wondering why you wouldn't shoot a bear in a cave, obviously, maybe not so obviously, if he's in the hole/cave you deem him off limits...err safe?   ;)
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: boneaddict on December 16, 2010, 02:21:26 PM
I am along the lines as Ray.   I'm not sure anyone was even being critical of him.  Just it wasn't their cup of tea.   i don't think there was even any divide or conquer.   I've seen alot of bear in the middle of the winter and their bodies have basically shutdown do to natural causes.  I don't think I'd enjoy killing an animal that is not at its finest.   I didn't say crawling into a hole after one was either not sporting or briliiant.   Theres a badger hole up the road.  Anyone want to go in head first and see if badgers sleep in the winter or not.    It is very possible to disagree with someone without having to be considered critical.  half the people that will weigh in on this thread probably don't even understand hibernation, or have ever even seen a bear den, let alone with one in it.  If its legal, then he was well within his rights to do so.
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: Skyvalhunter on December 16, 2010, 02:26:13 PM
Intresting way of thinking.
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: steen on December 16, 2010, 02:28:53 PM
I think he put his life in danger and it could have been the other way around--dead hunter.  That being said.  I don't think it is any different than killing a treed bear or a baited bear.  It was a trophy and you work a little harder and even do dumb things to get it.  I just wonder in his tracking of this bear if he knew it was a blackbear.  If I came across tracks that big I'd want to know nor sure that I am shooting a black bear and not a griz and not try to figure it out in the den a few feet from it's nose.
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: BIGINNER on December 16, 2010, 02:32:34 PM
I am along the lines as Ray.   I'm not sure anyone was even being critical of him.  Just it wasn't their cup of tea.   i don't think there was even any divide or conquer.   I've seen alot of bear in the middle of the winter and their bodies have basically shutdown do to natural causes.  I don't think I'd enjoy killing an animal that is not at its finest.   I didn't say crawling into a hole after one was either not sporting or briliiant.   Theres a badger hole up the road.  Anyone want to go in head first and see if badgers sleep in the winter or not.    It is very possible to disagree with someone without having to be considered critical.  half the people that will weigh in on this thread probably don't even understand hibernation, or have ever even seen a bear den, let alone with one in it.  If its legal, then he was well within his rights to do so.

THATS BECAUSE THERE IS NO BEARS IN WASHINGTON TO MAKE BEAR DENS,   SO ALL YOUR ARGUEMENTS ARE INVALID   :chuckle: :chuckle:

Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: Machias on December 16, 2010, 02:46:18 PM
I guess I'm using all the wrong words today.   :chuckle:
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: boneaddict on December 16, 2010, 02:47:51 PM
Bad Fred
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: Machias on December 16, 2010, 02:53:11 PM
 :ACRY: :sry: :salute: :bow: :chuckle:
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: rasbo on December 16, 2010, 03:08:39 PM
wow through the whole story,I was wondering what kind of grease or oil the hunter used to get his balls in the den..I gotta feeling his hunting partners job is carrying his nutsak.Or a shoe horn to assist getting them in the den..That being said,he has more nads than I or a hound hunter that has a bear treed with dogs...It was legal so more power to him,not my cup of tea..
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: Ray on December 16, 2010, 03:43:26 PM
I was thinking Rasbo would be the first guy I'd send in. Meanwhile I'd man the camera.
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: d-rock on December 16, 2010, 04:07:51 PM
All I can think is:
1.  There will undoubtedly be a law against it next year or shortly thereafter.
2.  That is how our hunting rules and regs become so restrictive and confusing. (i.e. u can shoot an animal but only if ALL the following criteria is met...)
3.  I imagine that through excessive legislation we will slowly loose more and more hunting rights.   >:(
&
4.  Should be a non-issue because how many people can say they could track a bear to its den AND THEN have the guts or lack of brains (don't really know which) to go in after him?  Can't be a large % of the hunter population. 
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: Austrian Hunter on December 16, 2010, 04:20:07 PM
Crawl into a hole with one in Spetember and see how it turns out. 

 :yeah: :chuckle: :chuckle:
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: krout81 on December 16, 2010, 08:31:38 PM
If it was legal accroding to the game department then he is a stud.  I guess every state has confusing game laws.  Dont shine a light on wildlife with a loaded weapon seems pretty straight forward, but obviously there are exceptions like following a bear into its cave and shinning I light to see where it is then shooting.   
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: Hornseeker on December 17, 2010, 11:19:23 AM
(https://hunting-washington.com/smf/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fimg.photobucket.com%2Falbums%2Fv351%2Fhornseeker%2FSleepybearx.jpg&hash=c0eefe5dbadde6e84cc3b608f0a4b18dcc08cb8b)

Could you shoot this?? Awwwwwwwww......

I didn't...well...except with my Olympus!
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: Gutpile on December 17, 2010, 11:25:02 AM
thanks for the new wallpaper. Awesome pic
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: BlackRidge on December 17, 2010, 11:34:35 AM
It seems to only be an issue because of the internet and how quickly/easily word on this kinda stuff spreads, me-thinks thats why we're seeing so many changes in regs, or will in the future...

So...maybe its best to take a SSS-type approach to most situations NOT covered in the regs... or the grey areas that Libs will sh*t triangle bricks over  :rolleyes:
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: 7mmfan on December 17, 2010, 11:35:17 AM
All we know is that he shined the light on bear and saw his ears laid back. We DON'T know that he shot the bear with the light shining on it. Its a fine line but it is the line between legality and illegality. I can shine a flashlight on a deer during daylight and then shut it off and shoot it and I'm legal, who says he didn't do this. He stated earlier in the article that he could see the bears snout with his naked eye, thats all he needs to make the shot. I feel that if there was an issue with this hunt that the game dept there would have already taken care of it.  :twocents:
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: Kain on December 17, 2010, 11:42:11 AM
That is a great picture.  no I would not have shot it even if it was legal but I would if it was a coyote or raccoon.  :dunno:  I dont really know why that is and wouldnt care if someone else did shoot it.
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: 724wd on December 17, 2010, 11:44:34 AM
Could you shoot this??

YOU BET!   :chuckle:
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: KillBilly on December 17, 2010, 11:45:56 AM
I was thinking Rasbo would be the first guy I'd send in. Meanwhile I'd man the camera.

Rasbo would be the logical choice since he is the epitomy of YAR
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: grundy53 on December 17, 2010, 11:46:39 AM
(https://hunting-washington.com/smf/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fimg.photobucket.com%2Falbums%2Fv351%2Fhornseeker%2FSleepybearx.jpg&hash=c0eefe5dbadde6e84cc3b608f0a4b18dcc08cb8b)

Could you shoot this?? Awwwwwwwww......

I didn't...well...except with my Olympus!

in aheart beat.
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: runamuk on December 17, 2010, 11:49:40 AM
I was thinking Rasbo would be the first guy I'd send in. Meanwhile I'd man the camera.

Rasbo would be the logical choice since he is the epitomy of YAR

OK see when I first read the story the person I thought of was also Rasbo  :dunno: seems we have a consesus  :chuckle:

and that is a cool pic of the bear however that bear looks kinda pissed off  :dunno:
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: Buckmark on December 17, 2010, 11:50:46 AM
Is it just me, but my ears are ringing just at the thought of letting a 45/70 go inside a cave... :bdid:
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: BIGINNER on December 17, 2010, 11:53:59 AM
I was thinking Rasbo would be the first guy I'd send in. Meanwhile I'd man the camera.

Rasbo would be the logical choice since he is the epitomy of YAR

OK see when I first read the story the person I thought of was also Rasbo  :dunno: seems we have a consesus  :chuckle:

and that is a cool pic of the bear however that bear looks kinda pissed off  :dunno:

WE COULD SEND HIM IN WITH HIS FUR THING ON,   THEN MAYBE THE BEAR WILL EVEN WANT TO CUDDLE A LITTLE   :yike:  :bdid:
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: Kain on December 17, 2010, 11:55:22 AM
Is it just me, but my ears are ringing just at the thought of letting a 45/70 go inside a cave... :bdid:

I thought the same thing when I watched that video I posted.   :chuckle:
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: Hornseeker on December 17, 2010, 12:14:11 PM
I'd rather use a grenade.....
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: krout81 on December 17, 2010, 08:42:51 PM
Quote
Could you shoot this?? Awwwwwwwww......
YUPPPERS 
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: boneaddict on December 17, 2010, 09:00:20 PM
Probably shoot it the same way you did Ernie.  BUT one HELL of a photo!
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: Huntbear on December 17, 2010, 09:31:18 PM
I was thinking Rasbo would be the first guy I'd send in. Meanwhile I'd man the camera.

Rasbo would be the logical choice since he is the epitomy of YAR

OK see when I first read the story the person I thought of was also Rasbo  :dunno: seems we have a consesus  :chuckle:

and that is a cool pic of the bear however that bear looks kinda pissed off  :dunno:

WE COULD SEND HIM IN WITH HIS FUR THING ON,   THEN MAYBE THE BEAR WILL EVEN WANT TO CUDDLE A LITTLE   :yike:  :bdid:

 :yike: :yike:

My thought exactly as I read this..  :chuckle: :chuckle: :chuckle:
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: ser300wsm on December 17, 2010, 09:44:35 PM
WOW, that is one hell of a pic of that bear in its den.... It looks pissed off as hell.... Great pic though...  :yike: As far as shooting one in his den, I'm not going in there to do that is for sure... That to me is insane, you want to commit suicide go ahead. I think that guy just got lucky as hell... That reminds me of a hunting article i read in trophy hunter mag. about a guy on a guided brown bear hunt in the spring in Alaska. Him & his guide found huge tracks leading to his den in the side of a hill & waited for him to come out. Well they finally got tired of waiting & went over to the den & the guide goes right up to the den & sticks his head in there & after a roar from the bear the guide scrambles to get out of the way & lucky that the guy hunting for the bear has a cool head an shoots the bear as it is coming out of the den..... Unbelievable... I think very stupid....  :twocents: :yike:
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: saylean on December 19, 2010, 11:28:10 AM
Killing a denned bear....what say I...

whats the fun in that!?
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: alecvg on December 25, 2010, 11:43:00 PM
I dont see where it says he used a flashlight.  It said he could see the nose WITHOUT a flashlight.
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: ICEMAN on December 26, 2010, 08:09:36 AM
I dont see where it says he used a flashlight.  It said he could see the nose WITHOUT a flashlight.

Next line is where we read about the flashlight...

“I went in about 6 feet, and I could just see the tip of his nose without a flashlight,” Kendall said. “He was growling and snapping his jaws at me.”

Kendall said that after he shined his flashlight on the bear, the bear laid back its ears.




Alecvg, I was going to rib you and tell you to "pay attention now..." but I am famous for missing a few lines too....   :chuckle:
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: sakoshooter on December 27, 2010, 09:52:07 PM
As far as the actual shooting goes: Is it really different than shooting one out of a tree? I understand the hunt and following the hounds but as far as a treed bear goes, where can it go? Not really any different. Matter of fact, to make a fair comparison, the guy shooting the treed bear would need to climb the tree and get right in that bears face to be even with the guy that crawled into a den with a fully awake, jaw popping, ears laid back bear. After all, he did track it to it's den. Different only because we're not used to hearing about it in this way.
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: Boss .300 winmag on December 27, 2010, 09:57:16 PM
As far as the actual shooting goes: Is it really different than shooting one out of a tree? I understand the hunt and following the hounds but as far as a treed bear goes, where can it go? Not really any different. Matter of fact, to make a fair comparison, the guy shooting the treed bear would need to climb the tree and get right in that bears face to be even with the guy that crawled into a den with a fully awake, jaw popping, ears laid back bear. After all, he did track it to it's den. Different only because we're not used to hearing about it in this way.
I shot one out of a tree once kinda easy, the bad part was I treed him that was scary. He was sleeping next to a creek and I woke him up, he didn't know what I was I think, and he was cornered.  :yike:
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: tritt007 on December 27, 2010, 10:11:23 PM
when you get down to the nitty gritty it really seems as tho its more sportsmans like than waiting for it and blasting it (ambush) that bear had a fairer chance to maul the crap and kill that guy there than it would have if he waited outside for it. so if you ask me it was more sporting and he did it legally.
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: Michelle_Nelson on December 28, 2010, 12:54:36 AM
BTW I only read the first page and glanced through the rest.  

My  :twocents:

Who cares?  Do you really think that guy in the enterance was going to stop that bear from making an exit if it wanted to?  Sounds like the guy tracked it to it's den.   Kudos to him not a lot of people know how to follow a trail.

I see no real difference in shooting a bear in a den or watching a hill side packed with berries? or a bait site? or a carcass? river bank during salmon run? beach? Eventually a Bear is going to show up or you wouldn't be sitting there in the first place.

I believe hound hunting is a great way to hunt Bear and Cougar.  For starters if the animal is a small one or a female than you have a great opertunity to look the animal over before pulling the trigger or letting it walk.
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: bearpaw on December 28, 2010, 01:16:28 AM
I say good for the guy getting a huge bear, he did it by legal means during established hunting season.  :twocents:

Many hunters aren't even savvy enough to track the bear to his den and get it. Now that his hunt has been published everyone that's holier than him says its unfair, but before he killed a bigger bear than anyone else had, no one even cared if that method should be legal or not. I am amazed at the jealousy and the holier-than-thou-attitiudes in the hunting world.

Do none of you think that has not happened in Washington! Man get a grip, season goes until mid November, why do you think bear are hard to find in November. Now that this method has been publisized half the hunters will be looking all over trying to find a den and the other half will be trying to outlaw shooting in a den, or asking for an earlier season which the WDFW s currently trying to get away from...LOL   :chuckle:  :bash:

My congrats goes to the hunter....  ;)
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: Kain on December 28, 2010, 10:15:23 AM
I say good for the guy getting a huge bear, he did it by legal means during established hunting season.  :twocents:

Many hunters aren't even savvy enough to track the bear to his den and get it. Now that his hunt has been published everyone that's holier than him says its unfair, but before he killed a bigger bear than anyone else had, no one even cared if that method should be legal or not. I am amazed at the jealousy and the holier-than-thou-attitiudes in the hunting world.

Do none of you think that has not happened in Washington! Man get a grip, season goes until mid November, why do you think bear are hard to find in November. Now that this method has been publisized half the hunters will be looking all over trying to find a den and the other half will be trying to outlaw shooting in a den, or asking for an earlier season which the WDFW s currently trying to get away from...LOL   :chuckle:  :bash:

My congrats goes to the hunter....  ;)

Yep I would reference my post on the other thread.  "Hunters spend more time fighting each other than fighting FOR each other".   :chuckle: 
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: L8NITE on December 28, 2010, 10:38:42 AM
I dont think i would crawl into 703 pound bears den  :bdid:
Title: Re: Killing a sleeping bear? What say you?
Post by: Alan K on December 28, 2010, 10:39:37 AM
I don't think I'd enjoy killing an animal that is not at its finest.

Wow, that line kind of caught my eye. . .  That's like saying you'd never enjoy taking a trophy mule deer buck or bull pushed down during a late hunt. . . They're certainly not at their finest in comparison to when there isn't any snow and not consumed with feeding.   :dunno:

I really don't see any problem with this guys kill, like many have said, because in comparison to other hunting methods this is no less ethical to me (hounds & baiting).  I think it's actually pretty awesome to do that tracking and talk about a pair of nuts to go in after it!!!  Congrats to the hunter.

Can't believe I missed this when it was originally posted!
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: boneaddict on December 28, 2010, 10:46:37 AM
No, its not like saying that.   Metabolically, go take 15 hydrocodone, and have some guy break into your bedroom and see how you respond.  Unless that is of course the same thing as being horned up when someone breaks into your bedroom.   I wasn't attacking the hunt nearly as much as you think I was, though I believe from a non hunters perspective, if you were to advertise that you killed a bear while in its den, its going to be recieved more on a negative side than on a positive view.  Much like tying that bear on the front of your rig and driving down the interstate.  No its not illegal, but probably should not do it. If you don't believe me, see how it was recieved by a bunch of people who have no problem shooting a bear.    Again, its not for me, but I also don't think I said he shouldn't have done it.  Like Sayean, I don't think that is that cool.   Granted you won't find me crawing into a bear den in January or Sept.  I do have some sort of self preservation.
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: boneaddict on December 28, 2010, 10:50:48 AM
Did you miss the res of this post as well?
Quote
I am along the lines as Ray.   I'm not sure anyone was even being critical of him.  Just it wasn't their cup of tea.   i don't think there was even any divide or conquer.   I've seen alot of bear in the middle of the winter and their bodies have basically shutdown do to natural causes.  I don't think I'd enjoy killing an animal that is not at its finest.   I didn't say crawling into a hole after one was either not sporting or briliiant.   Theres a badger hole up the road.  Anyone want to go in head first and see if badgers sleep in the winter or not.    It is very possible to disagree with someone without having to be considered critical.  half the people that will weigh in on this thread probably don't even understand hibernation, or have ever even seen a bear den, let alone with one in it.  If its legal, then he was well within his rights to do so.

Question for you.  Have you ever hound hunted, hunted over bait, or have you seen a bear while in its den or watched or follow when when they come out.  Just curious.
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: Alan K on December 28, 2010, 10:53:37 AM
I guess it comes down to our own definitions of finest.  :dunno:  To me a deer is at it's finest in early October, when they're long out of velvet, largely nocturnal, and haven't yet become rut crazed.

And that wasn't necessarily related to the bear story at all, just the comment.


And I haven't hunted with hounds, over bait, or seen them in or coming out of their dens in the flesh, only on video.
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: Alan K on December 28, 2010, 11:16:26 AM
Oh I don't doubt that, I know you do it the challenging way. . . I just know that those late tags are pretty coveted over there, largely because the animals aren't (in my opinion) at their finest. That's why the comment stuck out to me.
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: Skyvalhunter on January 06, 2011, 05:50:26 AM
Colorado Considers Ban on Hunting Denned Bears
January 6, 2011.

The Wildlife Commission will consider a new regulation to prohibit the take of bears in their dens during its January meeting.

During the morning session, the Wildlife Commission will get a first look at a new den-hunting regulation drafted by Division of Wildlife staff following an incident this fall in which a potential state record black bear was taken by a licensed hunter while in its den.

The incident has prompted a discussion about whether taking hibernating black bears in their dens is ethical, safe, or adheres to the concept of fair chase.

According to the 2010-2020 Strategic Plan adopted by the Wildlife Commission, the Division should look to maintain and increase support for wildlife management activities by emphasizing ethics, safety and fair chase in hunting, fishing and other wildlife programs. Although no regulations currently prohibit den hunting in Colorado, other states such as Pennsylvania and Michigan have adopted regulations to ban the practice.

The proposed regulation is scheduled to receive a three-step review by Commissioners, who could approve a final rule in May.

Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: ICEMAN on January 06, 2011, 06:00:42 AM
Feel good legislation.

Better shut the season down as the denning approaches just to be sure...  :bash:
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: DOUBLELUNG on January 06, 2011, 06:04:54 AM
I'm not quite sure what the big deal is? This bear was in a hole? So what?

According to the article the bear was not sleeping. Following the biggest bear track you have ever seen into a den and shooting him is a whole hell of a lot more impressive to me than having 10 dogs run him up a tree. He was no less "trapped" in this den than he would have been up a tree.

The only issue I saw reading the article was the whole flashlight incident.
My thoughts exactly.  I question the artificial light thing too, but I don't trust reporters to get hunting details right, and DOW can make the call on whether or not a violation occurred.  That said, the guy is a flippin' idiot for publicizing his feat and not expecting a bunch of criticism.
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: DOUBLELUNG on January 06, 2011, 06:23:14 AM
I certainly hope the DOW turns down the proposed regulation.  The only way to tell for sure whether a bear is simply sleeping in a hole, or has entered hibernation, is to take a rectal temperature and see if the core temperature is suppressed. 
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: bearpaw on January 06, 2011, 11:36:21 AM
I certainly hope the DOW turns down the proposed regulation.  The only way to tell for sure whether a bear is simply sleeping in a hole, or has entered hibernation, is to take a rectal temperature and see if the core temperature is suppressed. 


 :chuckle: :chuckle: :chuckle:
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: seth30 on January 06, 2011, 11:40:39 AM
I have gone down in caves before, found some yote tracks but no bears. 
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: woodywsu on January 06, 2011, 11:44:20 AM
I certainly hope the DOW turns down the proposed regulation.  The only way to tell for sure whether a bear is simply sleeping in a hole, or has entered hibernation, is to take a rectal temperature and see if the core temperature is suppressed. 

 :chuckle: There is always the heartbeat to check.
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: boneaddict on January 06, 2011, 02:36:20 PM
Quote
I certainly hope the DOW turns down the proposed regulation.  The only way to tell for sure whether a bear is simply sleeping in a hole, or has entered hibernation, is to take a rectal temperature and see if the core temperature is suppressed.   
 
 
 

I nominate Rasbo.
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: gaddy on January 06, 2011, 02:56:18 PM
if after entering a bears den and checking the rectal internal temp,then determining weather the temp is suppressed or not, would you then ask the sleeping bear to wake up & step out side or would you take picts and consider this a new extreme sport?
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: DOUBLELUNG on January 06, 2011, 03:16:02 PM
if after entering a bears den and checking the rectal internal temp,then determining weather the temp is suppressed or not, would you then ask the sleeping bear to wake up & step out side or would you take picts and consider this a new extreme sport?
If, after taking these steps, you have determined the bear is sleeping and not hibernating, the most ethical harvest technique is to b*tch-slap it awake and kill it MMA style.
Title: Re: Killing a denning bear? What say you?
Post by: gaddy on January 06, 2011, 03:36:21 PM
double that seems kind of harsh after the intamasy that was shared
SimplePortal 2.3.7 © 2008-2025, SimplePortal