I've been seriously considering trying for cougar (and/or bear) this year and I keep wondering about the likelihood of being hunted myself. I've tried browsing past topics about cougar hunting and have read the following:
1. Cougar hunting is not effective without dogs.
2. You've got to be in great shape to even consider chasing cats. (how great of shape?)
3. The likelihood of finding a cougar is extremely small.
4. Cats sneaking up on hunters
I'm still a newbie hunter, so I'm wondering how realistic any of these thoughts are before I devote a bunch of time to it. But also have been watching the game camera threads and seeing how the animal populations are changing from ungulates to predators. And if hunting should continue, I should be working on predators too, right? Doing a guided trip is definitely not in the budget this year.
Thoughts?
I'll chime in on your initial questions here too...
1.) Depends on your definition of "Effective."
To go out and harvest one? Yes, dogs for sure, and those of an outfitter who has been out locating and identifying Lions for many season in his area, and already that season as well.
But to have the chance to kill one, effective? Tracking and calling are both also effective. Just not as high percentage.
I rate calling higher than tracking (you can tell by my website), but I'm not a mountain goat! I know a few guys who can give a mt goat a run for their money, and they have a good chance! This relates to question 2 and question 4 as well. Get on a hot track and just GO! You can imagine....
2.) Yes, to track one down. You can't be crippled to call, but you don't have to be a triathlete. No small feat to chase dogs either, honestly.
3.) Anymore, in Washington, Oregon, most of the west, actually... there's a lot of cats. You get in the right areas in the right conditions, you might be amazed. I've crossed 4 different cats in the same day on the peninsula. I know a 7 mile ridge in NE that probably had 5 cats on it at the same time. There are places like that in SE. There are lots of cats. You do have to invest some gas and leather into locating, but there's lots of cats. Most times, especially with calling, you don't know you found one until they're already gone. Many times you never know. Part of the thrill and challenge when you find out you had one looking at you and didn't realize it.... but that probably frustrates the pudding out of the hound guys!
4.) As was mentioned, the called cat is coming to the call sound. Either in your hand, or set up out in front of you. But they're not coming in to a human... as far as they know. The dynamic of the cat personality is changing slightly with the overpopulation we're experiencing, but for the most part, they are not aggressive predators. They're very shy. They prefer to not be seen. They mostly are unseen. Things are changing with the huge numbers (relative to their lifestyle and territorial patterns) we have now, and I can't guarantee one won't come across an aggressive cat... but it's just not normal. They're an elusive, stealth, patient animal. It's not normally to be feared. (It's a longer discussion than that, all of these are, but that's the nutshell.)
Do it. December, on into the spring in some areas. Lite snow shows you tracks and will put you miles ahead, but patterning and locating kills can get you within earshot... go for it! It's FUN!