Hunting Washington Forum
Big Game Hunting => Other Big Game => Topic started by: BOWHUNTER45 on January 12, 2014, 11:52:31 AM
-
I hope everyone is feeling lucky when it comes to drawing a moose tag ...what is the chances of one family drawing 3 moose tags ? Well pretty dang good for a family in Western Washington ...yep that's right ...Father mother and daughter have all drawn a moose tag and all 3 have killed a moose :yike: that is just crazy but good for them :bow: :kneel: :cue:
-
One of them probably works for fish and game dept.
-
Here's the story:
http://www.goskagit.com/sports/ (http://www.goskagit.com/sports/)
None are employed by the WDFW
-
I wonder how many years in between each tag?
-
I wonder how many years in between each tag?
They usually get a Tag about every 4yrs. P.S Jeff called me this morning saying he's gonna try & get a Moose Dynasty show. :chuckle:
-
Lucky dogs, I think I have 12 points now.
-
i wont ever draw because i never put in, however i have put my son in since he was 9 or 10, well actually trophy hunt puts him in, he takes care of are permit apps cause he digs that kind of stuff, but dakota is now 18 so he has a few points, mybe by the time he retires he might draw one of those elusive moose tags :chuckle: :tup:
-
What about a guy drawing 4 margerat tags in a row?? Cant tell me there aint some shady stuff with are BS drawing system!
-
getting off thread with this one but i know a guy my age that drew the peaches ridge big bull tag 3 out 4 years and guys that have been putting in for it foerever that still havent been drawn :dunno: they could definatly do something, especially for the guys that are truly huntn for a trophy, alot of people put in for places that dont have a clue of what they are putting in for, i am sure there is a better way to do it :twocents: THOSE moose that the family got, is there any pics of them, i couldnt find anything in that link thing that was posted :dunno: :tup:
-
Odds are not as bad as mega-millions lottery jackpot odd...but they are not good either. On the upside, your odds improve overtime at least as you continue to put in.
-
With max points odds are about 1 in 100.
-
It gets worse each year if you have max points. I have too many points and still delusionally think I'll draw. My backup plan is 8 years away for a Yukon or Alaska moose hunt if I still am trying to qualify in Washington.
-
My old man got drawn for a moose tag years ago & then won the raffle later. I was 1st alternate hoping the other guy would not purchase his tag but not sure 2 moose would have fit in the truck. :tung: He has 2 moose from WA & 1 in Montana. Moose meat is terribly good. :tup:
-
your odds improve overtime at least as you continue to put in.
I think this is the biggest lie that they try to sell you with points.
YES, your points go up, but so do the other 10,000 (arbitruary number) that don't draw.
YES, your points are squared, but so are the other 10,000.
Then think about our youth, our kids coming into the system with nothing. Mathematically are their odds really tat much less than yours. There is some interesting Math involved.
-
:yeah:when I started applying there were around four thousand people applying for the most popular tag. now there is over fifteen thousand.so even though my points are going up my odds seem to be much worse.not sure if odds even come into play its just pure luck,if there were fifteen thousand people applying when I started I would have never started, now I feel I have to much invested to stop
-
Probably around 1/5. Lol
-
Your odds certainly are better with max points versus someone putting in for the first time. 19 points will be max this year, and with that number a person would have a 361 times greater chance of drawing than a person with only 1 point.
-
The link to story didnt work. Im wonderin their names? Or where they are from? Think i may know them haha
-
Here are the actual odds for 49 Degrees North Any Moose, based on points in the 2012 draw.
There were 12,380 applications from 13,068 applicants.
The total number of “names in the hat” was 890,434.
There were 21 permits. Odds of drawing one of the 21 permits with the following number of points is shown below:
Points Odds "1 in…"
19 0.85% 118
18 0.76% 131
17 0.68% 147
16 0.60% 166
15 0.53% 189
14 0.46% 217
13 0.40% 251
12 0.34% 295
11 0.28% 351
10 0.24% 424
9 0.19% 524
8 0.15% 663
7 0.12% 866
6 0.08% 1178
5 0.06% 1697
4 0.04% 2651
3 0.02% 4712
2 0.01% 10601
1 0.00% 42402
-
so your telling me there's a chance
-
Your odds of winning $1,000 in the WA state lottery is better than drawing a moose permit with only 1 point.
-
so your telling me there's a chance
:chuckle:
:yeah:
-
I have max points for moose in Washington and Montana and 13 years worth of points in Wyoming & Colorado and 5 moose points in Utah and I'm not betting I'll be eating moose meat this fall.
-
Getting close to a few units in Wyoming worth drawing with 13.....
-
Here are the actual odds for 49 Degrees North Any Moose, based on points in the 2012 draw.
There were 12,380 applications from 13,068 applicants.
The total number of “names in the hat” was 890,434.
There were 21 permits. Odds of drawing one of the 21 permits with the following number of points is shown below:
Points Odds "1 in…"
19 0.85% 118
18 0.76% 131
17 0.68% 147
16 0.60% 166
15 0.53% 189
14 0.46% 217
13 0.40% 251
12 0.34% 295
11 0.28% 351
10 0.24% 424
9 0.19% 524
8 0.15% 663
7 0.12% 866
6 0.08% 1178
5 0.06% 1697
4 0.04% 2651
3 0.02% 4712
2 0.01% 10601
1 0.00% 42402
Here's a little more cheerful news. If everyone that applied in this example applied the next year, and no new applicants entering the draw, the odds would get worse for everyone with more than ten points. Applicants with 19 points would have 20 points the next year, and so forth. Because there are so many applicants with not many points, they tip the odds towards the lower end: the 1100 applicants with 1 point would have a total of 1100 names in the hat in the first year, but the second year they would have 4400. The applicant with a maximum 19 points would have a 1 in 118 chance the first year, but only a 1 in 130 chance the next.
Points "1 In" odds Points "1 In" odds
19 118 20 130
18 131 19 144
17 147 18 160
16 166 17 179
15 189 16 203
14 217 15 230
13 251 14 264
12 295 13 307
11 351 12 360
10 424 11 428
9 524 10 518
8 663 9 639
7 866 8 809
6 1,178 7 1,056
5 1,697 6 1,437
4 2,651 5 2,069
3 4,712 4 3,233
2 10,601 3 5,747
1 42,402 2 12,931
-
Like I said, some interesting math involved, and folks would be surprised with it out on paper. There are some things the WDFW could do to help, but they wont with the current system.
-
Anything the WDFW did to "help," would help some but hurt others. The only thing to actually help, as in increasing odds of drawing, would be to increase the number of permits. And of course they can't do that unless moose numbers go up.
-
And the likelihood of moose #'s increasing is slim with all the wolves, bears, and cougars around. :(
-
Anyone that really wants to hunt moose, mountain goat, or bighorn sheep in his lifetime needs to look to other states.
Hope springs eternal, and everyone knows someone who "drew with just one point", or they look at "average points" and conclude they'll draw in the near future. Unfortunately, it just isn't so.
WDFW loves stories like the family that drew three moose permits. :tup:
-
Go to Idahos system. Best chance of drawing OIL.
Front the cash
One choice
One species
Choose OIL or elk and deer special permits
No points.
The latter not being possible really at this point without a civil war.
You have a better chance of drawing a moose tag right now in Washington, than a chance of them fixing their system. They have their hands in your pockets and those hands aren't coming out. Even all the incentive tags and multiple raffle tags and auction tags are ways to get more money out of your pockets.
-
Yep, the $2k up-front fee (all but $14 refundable) to put your name in the ID moose draw is a tough pill to swallow but it's the best odds in town. I got to fulfill a life long dream of killing a moose this past year with it being my first year applying. I don't advertise that too much because I appreciate having air in my tires :chuckle:
-
They also keep the 150 dollars and give you an Idaho license.
-
True, but I chalk that up as a required expense as I hunt ID anyways. If you're only looking for a Moose then the price to pay is ugly.
-
Stuff like this reaaaaaaaaaaly pisses off guys like me who have been applying for the big 3 oil tags for 29 years without even being drawn as an alternate. I HATE our OIL draw system!!!!!
-
Call me a hopeful romantic.
I have a few buddies that have drawn moose and sheep tags.
It's gonna happen.
Maybe not this year but it's gonna happen!
-
I think my chances are good this year to pull a tag, at least as good as anyone elses. Front the cash for the OIL tags is the way to goin my eyes. I think it keeps the folks who really want it in the running while weeding out the " well it's only $6.00 so i might as well".
-
i might start going for the idaho tag at some point, after ive had plenty of time to learn the country there. guess theres no hurry since its not a point based system. all the time in the world to scout before trying to get that tag. my thing is, i want to hunt moose HERE in my own stomping grounds where i know the lay of the land and where the moose are apt to be. i want to hunt moose right here where i hunt deer and bear and everything else. so im kind of screwed. may never happen.
-
I've applied for the OIL tags for 30+ years and have drawn goat, but I know odds are that even with max points I will likely never get sheep or moose. I think any system they use to distribute tags it all boils down to there are very few tags and a lot of us who would dearly love to get a tag. I just feel fortunate to have gotten one.
-
i might start going for the idaho tag at some point, after ive had plenty of time to learn the country there. guess theres no hurry since its not a point based system. all the time in the world to scout before trying to get that tag. my thing is, i want to hunt moose HERE in my own stomping grounds where i know the lay of the land and where the moose are apt to be. i want to hunt moose right here where i hunt deer and bear and everything else. so im kind of screwed. may never happen.
I drew first year, then applied for Idabooner and he drew first year. If you want to hunt moose, its the state to apply
-
I've applied for the OIL tags for 30+ years and have drawn goat, but I know odds are that even with max points I will likely never get sheep or moose. I think any system they use to distribute tags it all boils down to there are very few tags and a lot of us who would dearly love to get a tag. I just feel fortunate to have gotten one.
:yeah:
I also drew a goat tag back in the day. With luck and my max points I will draw a sheep or goat before I am in a wheel chair. The old quote lightning got to strike somewhere is always in my mind.
-
I've applied for the OIL tags for 30+ years and have drawn goat, but I know odds are that even with max points I will likely never get sheep or moose. I think any system they use to distribute tags it all boils down to there are very few tags and a lot of us who would dearly love to get a tag. I just feel fortunate to have gotten one.
:yeah:
I also drew a goat tag back in the day. With luck and my max points I will draw a sheep or goat before I am in a wheel chair. The old quote lightning got to strike somewhere is always in my mind.
"Back in the day" there were a few more goat tags.
[smg id=9377]
-
I wish that I could transfer my points over to my daughter. She might be able to draw by the time she is my age.
-
I wish that I could transfer my points over to my daughter. She might be able to draw by the time she is my age.
That would be nice but it won't happen.
You can certainly be buying points for her, however.
-
Just a thought. Would it be cheaper to go to canada or alaska for moose then give money every year to are state .
-
Looking at the points creep I'm glad I'm not in this game. There's also no way I would get my children started on this. Would be far better to start a savings account in their name and save up for Idaho or Alaska. Can only imagine what the odds will be 30 years from now when max points are hovering around 50. :o
-
Just a thought. Would it be cheaper to go to canada or alaska for moose then give money every year to are state .
No, but at least you will get a to hunt moose. The vast majority of applicants in Washington will spend $15/year to apply for 20 to 30 years and not draw.
-
Just a thought. Would it be cheaper to go to canada or alaska for moose then give money every year to are state .
No, but at least you will get a to hunt moose. The vast majority of applicants in Washington will spend $15/year to apply for 20 to 30 years and not draw.
don't worry I won't put in for tags that's the last animal on my bucket list
-
I am sure glad I never took up the art of gambling :chuckle: No sense in me trying for a moose tag now ...I am almost an old fart ;)
-
100% in 2015 :tup: I can't wait. I thought I would never have a chance, but a great opportunity has been presented.
-
indulge us
-
Martin sending you on a hunt?
-
A buddy on the Sitka Pro-Staff invited me to hunt Canada :tup:
-
:tup:
-
The link to story didnt work. Im wonderin their names? Or where they are from? Think i may know them haha
http://www.goskagit.com/all_access/sedro-woolley-family-bonds-over-moose-hunting/article_ab06c882-2cc6-5242-a4ad-f49e06ff327e.html (http://www.goskagit.com/all_access/sedro-woolley-family-bonds-over-moose-hunting/article_ab06c882-2cc6-5242-a4ad-f49e06ff327e.html)
:tup:
-
As good as making it to retirement and getting back the money I put in. LOL
-
sorry guys but im actually going to start outting in for moose this year.. making your odds worse :sry:
-
A wolf just ate your moose. Now its just a steaming pile of hair
-
A wolf just ate your moose. Now its just a steaming pile of hair
That's funny!
:chuckle:
-
Here’s a thought if you draw any OIL tag you can’t put in for the other two. Yes I know in the grand scheme of thing it is not going to change the odds any real amount, But it would make me feel better knowing I don’t to listen to another I have drawn all three story. Also it would be a little more fair. While I’m on the subject I think any tag with more the 100:1 odds be it elk, deer or whatever should be OIL also just my :twocents:
-
One of the states I put in for if you draw a tag, whether it be deer or whatever, you cannot draw anything else. Might make you consider what deer permit you put in for if your name is in the OIL buckets. Might be Utah. I cant remember at this second. I still contend Idaho has the best system.
-
One of the states I put in for if you draw a tag, whether it be deer or whatever, you cannot draw anything else. Might make you consider what deer permit you put in for if your name is in the OIL buckets. Might be Utah. I cant remember at this second. I still contend Idaho has the best system.
One and done huh? Wyoming doesnt seem to have too bad of a system. I don't think you should only be able to fill one of the oil tags. The goal is to be the lucky sob that gets drawn and fills them all. I only have one main goal this year. And that is to fill a bear tag. I've had no luck with those dang things. I'll deer hunt hard and look for a trophy but if I don't get my buck and get a bear id be thrilled.
I personally have no urge to get a goat. Id like to get a big horn but the main oil tag i really want to get is a bull moose.
-
Here’s a thought if you draw any OIL tag you can’t put in for the other two. Yes I know in the grand scheme of thing it is not going to change the odds any real amount, But it would make me feel better knowing I don’t to listen to another I have drawn all three story. Also it would be a little more fair. While I’m on the subject I think any tag with more the 100:1 odds be it elk, deer or whatever should be OIL also just my :twocents:
Do you put in for other states? That would increase your chances of getting drawn for an OIL tag...
-
been reading and enjoying posts hear for some time. its well over due but I decided to join up and help with my 2 cents when asked and maybe even ask for some info from time to time. love all the stories and pictures you good folks put on here, and I hope to share some too. 3 moose tags in one family is amazing on that note of oil tags has anyone here drew all 3 oil tags and was successful on getting all 3. just asking thanks all and I look forward to checking out all responses.
-
I think I'm going to put in for Idaho this year...... maybe that will be the kicker to get my 18 points in Washington to draw. My luck I get drawn for both and can't hunt one......
That being said anyone want to PM some ideas for Unit 1 or 2 in Idaho? Been a million years since I did anything over there but huckleberry and fish for pike.
-
I would love to shoot a moose with my bow but since I have 0 points and some of your guys have more than you need I guess I just forget about that happening :dunno: :chuckle:
-
I know another family that drew 3 moose tags in 2 years. One Idaho tag and 2 Washington tags. It can happen.
-
Put me down for a permit for 2014.
I am feeling lucky!
-
Think of it this way, you will wait, most likely twice as long to draw a moose tag, as the average murderer in this state will serve in actuall time. (thats about seven years for the Bad guy)
-
Think of it this way, you will wait, most likely twice as long to draw a moose tag, as the average murderer in this state will serve in actuall time. (thats about seven years for the Bad guy)
Yep, that's why ya'll might as well not even put in...... :chuckle:
-
It is all about luck, I had a friend draw Montana, Idaho and a Washington moose tag all in the same year. He harvested a Washington and Idaho moose, and turned down several in Montana. It must have something to do with living right or someone else watching over, as he has also drawn some good sheep tags too.