Hunting Washington Forum

Community => Advocacy, Agencies, Access => Topic started by: trophyhunt on May 26, 2015, 07:49:33 PM


Advertise Here
Title: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: trophyhunt on May 26, 2015, 07:49:33 PM
There was a bunch of good idea's, too many to put on a poll.  Probably have to many already, so I tried to narrow it down to the most popular.  You can vote for your top 3
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: mfswallace on May 26, 2015, 08:26:35 PM
)One tag per species, once you draw for elk your done, from quality to bull to cow. Same with other species, no more waisted tags.

For life?? all tags become oil' s ??
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: mp.hunter on May 26, 2015, 08:28:50 PM
No, you just don't draw any other categories for that year.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: MtnMuley on May 26, 2015, 08:33:12 PM
I think you need more options. How about, Only 1 OIL app per year with all the money up front (not allowed to build points in the other 2). Also, how about only one deer and elk choice per year. Either quality, bull/buck, or antlerless. (no building points in the other categories). 2nd tags excluded. I like your 1 OIL choice, but not the still being able to build points in the other two. Just my thoughts.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: bobcat on May 26, 2015, 08:33:58 PM
I like the waiting periods but I don't agree that someone should be able to build points during the waiting period.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: mp.hunter on May 26, 2015, 08:38:33 PM
I don't see much difference of a waiting period or having a minimum amount of points to draw. Also, the game department would never go for not being able to build points, lost REVENUE😁


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: MtnMuley on May 26, 2015, 08:40:20 PM
Up the cost. ;)
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: bobcat on May 26, 2015, 08:40:42 PM
I only voted for one of the choices: limiting non-residents to 10%. Actually I think it should be even less. Oregon limits non-residents to 5% of their deer and elk tags and 3% of antelope. That's about where we should be, IMO.

As for the wasted tags, there is no such thing. If a person draws an elk permit in the bull category and the quality category, he can still use both permits. Just can't kill two elk. It's up to each person if they want to take the chance of drawing more than one permit per species. I applied for antlerless elk and quality elk this year, so in the quality category I only applied for a point.

Having a minimum number of points to draw would complicate the system even more. If anything, I'd rather simplify the system. This is not a preference point type of system. If we want to change to that, we'd have to do away with squaring the points.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: X-Force on May 26, 2015, 08:53:49 PM
Shouldn't deer and elk or oils be deer and elk or 1 oil?
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: Tbar on May 26, 2015, 11:17:11 PM
Elimination of categories would help a bunch.  This would separate the meat hunters from the trophy hunters to a certain degree and have options for those in the middle.  There are too  many choices from species to hunt choices. If we could put in one category per species with maybe two options (for hunts) .
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: stevemiller on May 26, 2015, 11:19:18 PM
I really wanted to vote but my A D D took over and I lost interest in the poll. lol.Seriously though I think the system is fine,every year people complain about how it is,Seems haters gonna hate.I would like to see some of the people that claim to have over 16 points show us a pic of it.Thats right if you have more than 16 points  :tup: in anything other than an oil take a pic of your last years draw results cover up your info and post it here,I really want to see if many actually have that many. Thanks. No offense meant either if people do have that many its rediculous.And I would be looking for a change also but if not.  :cryriver:
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: stevemiller on May 27, 2015, 01:18:35 AM
Cool we should get a lot of pics then.I dont want to hear about these points I want to see them or they dont have them hows that?
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: trophyhunt on May 27, 2015, 05:47:03 AM
I really wanted to vote but my A D D took over and I lost interest in the poll. lol.Seriously though I think the system is fine,every year people complain about how it is,Seems haters gonna hate.I would like to see some of the people that claim to have over 16 points show us a pic of it.Thats right if you have more than 16 points  :tup: in anything other than an oil take a pic of your last years draw results cover up your info and post it here,I really want to see if many actually have that many. Thanks. No offense meant either if people do have that many its rediculous.And I would be looking for a change also but if not.  :cryriver:
i know it's a bit scattered, I'm not that good this kind of stuff, im just not that organized.  I'd like to take the top 4 or 5 opinions to the wdfw. 
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: Katmai Guy on May 27, 2015, 07:49:30 AM
i know it's a bit scattered, I'm not that good this kind of stuff, im just not that organized.  I'd like to take the top 4 or 5 opinions to the wdfw. 


Why would you do this?  The 97 people who have voted at the time of this post aren't even 1/10th of 1% of the WA hunting community.
   
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: trophyhunt on May 27, 2015, 07:57:23 AM
i know it's a bit scattered, I'm not that good this kind of stuff, im just not that organized.  I'd like to take the top 4 or 5 opinions to the wdfw. 


Why would you do this?  The 97 people who have voted at the time of this post aren't even 1/10th of 1% of the WA hunting community.
 
i was hoping for some changes that the wdfw would consider, there are some good points on here.  I've talked to the permit manager in the past and thought if I could put some numbers behind some of these opinions it would create changes.  I'm fully aware that only a small percentage of the over 18,000 members are responding, but a lot of members are not as committed to this site as the rest of us losers!  :chuckle:
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: timberfaller on May 27, 2015, 08:03:13 AM
 :dunno: NO option for scraping the whole system?  :dunno:  Whats with that!!!! :o
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: trophyhunt on May 27, 2015, 08:05:33 AM
:dunno: NO option for scraping the whole system?  :dunno:  Whats with that!!!! :o
they would never consider that option, even if 100% of us wanted it. The revenue is too much to lose.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: jackelope on May 27, 2015, 08:16:56 AM
:dunno: NO option for scraping the whole system?  :dunno:  Whats with that!!!! :o

Why would you want to scrap the whole system?
What would you prefer? Please don't say open seasons for everything...
What would you do, Timberfaller?
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: Curly on May 27, 2015, 08:19:33 AM
I wish they would go back to the old system before the multiple categories started.  I wonder if that is what Timberfaller was talking about doing?

Seems like whenever they change the system they make it worse. 
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: mfswallace on May 27, 2015, 09:26:59 AM
I like the idea of buy a second tag if u draw antlered and antlerless in same year!!!!!!!!!!! Quotas have been set and hunter has paid his money.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: Karl Blanchard on May 27, 2015, 10:35:57 AM
Tagging
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: trophyhunt on May 27, 2015, 10:42:23 AM
I am in no way expecting our small group to be part of changing the draw system, I quite smoking the green stuff a long time ago.  But what if a couple ideas that are popular here get in the minds of the wdfw?  It would be nice to see more numbers on the voting, I know most feel it's a waste of time, but you never know?
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: trophyhunt on May 27, 2015, 04:39:33 PM
More votes please.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: stevemiller on May 27, 2015, 04:55:01 PM
Cool we should get a lot of pics then.I dont want to hear about these points I want to see them or they dont have them hows that?

Nobody needs to show you a thing and nobody cares what you want to hear about. Are you calling people liars here? Pretty clear you haven't been hunting long. Listen more, pop off less and you just may learn something.
YES
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: trophyhunt on May 27, 2015, 06:35:32 PM
I added a question to the poll, I know most have already voted.  It was a opinion that really makes sense.  If you want to vote for it and it won't take your vote cause you have already voted, maybe just insert a quote how you would rate it? Not sure what else to do but I think it's worth looking at. 
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: stevemiller on May 27, 2015, 07:53:14 PM
I see that earlier permit deadline and results is number one,This would be nice but we would have to ask for so much more,For example we would need the regs to be out earlier as well in order for our choices to be out.I think the special app deadline is pretty close to spot on and I think that since they can do daily lotto there should be no prob. with having these results out in 2 to 3 days.  :twocents: So question on this poll only is deadline to when?If your like me and you go buy your license and apps when they first become available we will still have to wait 2 months no matter how fast they put out the results unless we get less time to buy them.That may be ok with some of us but not all and that just might put a damper on some.IE income tax refunds allows a lot of sportsman the ability to do their hunts.  :twocents:
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: adamR on May 27, 2015, 08:09:49 PM
I like the idea of buy a second tag if u draw antlered and antlerless in same year!!!!!!!!!!! Quotas have been set and hunter has paid his money.
I think this would drastically decrease draw odds.  Knowing that drawing two tags gets you a second elk would cause more people to apply who don't already and people that already do apply to apply for more or different units just so they can kill two elk.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: stevemiller on May 27, 2015, 08:58:59 PM
i agree,this one is way out there,give it to another hunter that appllied,seems like this whole thread isd based on all the supposed hunters that have max points and all that,you would think that they would want more hunters drawing a tag not hunters drawing more apps.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: timberfaller on May 27, 2015, 10:00:35 PM
:dunno: NO option for scraping the whole system?  :dunno:  Whats with that!!!! :o

Why would you want to scrap the whole system?
What would you prefer? Please don't say open seasons for everything...
What would you do, Timberfaller?

not for "open" seasons except on Coyotes, Wolves and other pests of game animals! :chuckle:

First thing I would do is Split the agency back apart, let fishery's fend for themselves.  Yes I prefer the way things used to be, before all the varying seasons and units.  I'd even go back to having just the East and West side as  units.  Never been a fan of any thing dealing with "Points" collecting to recreate.

I can understand "controlling people" but if I know my own back yard, why should I be kept from enjoying it???   Oregon has come to that, and WA is doing their best to follow OTHER states instead of doing their own thing.

I still have a copy of the 1973 game/hunting pamphlet.  Wow how things have changed, less wildlife, less hunters NOW  and the 73 pamphlet was smaller then the state map and covered ALL hunting seasons.

But then some people have never seen the days of "herds" of deer and elk and all they have to go on is what they see today.   AND the "habitat" is still there but the "herds" are gone, so I'll squelch the "loss of habitat" argument here and now, even though habitat loss does take place.

I probably haven't given any real answers, but then I've never gone along with the crowd and especially the PC crowd.

Don't even get me started on "fishing"!  Bought my first license last year after having stopped fishing over 15 years ago, Only because of grandkids now.

 :twocents: :hello:

Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: JLS on May 27, 2015, 10:07:16 PM
Just because habitat "looks" the same as it was 20 years ago certainly doesn't mean that it is.

I would scrap the whole system.

Choose one deer and one elk category.
Choose one of moose, sheep, and goat.
No points.
OIL for moose, sheep, goat.
3 year wait for deer and elk.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: bobcat on May 27, 2015, 10:09:48 PM
Just because habitat "looks" the same as it was 20 years ago certainly doesn't mean that it is.

I would scrap the whole system.

Choose one deer and one elk category.
Choose one of moose, sheep, and goat.
No points.
OIL for moose, sheep, goat.
3 year wait for deer and elk.

Sounds similar to Idaho!   :tup:
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: mfswallace on May 27, 2015, 10:37:27 PM
I like the idea of buy a second tag if u draw antlered and antlerless in same year!!!!!!!!!!! Quotas have been set and hunter has paid his money.
I think this would drastically decrease draw odds.  Knowing that drawing two tags gets you a second elk would cause more people to apply who don't already and people that already do apply to apply for more or different units just so they can kill two elk.
[/]

And if u win the lottery twice the state should give your second winnings to some other schmuck because while he might have done the same thing he didn't draw anything???  Isn't the point of any draw system points or not, to make all results random and not leave it to human interpretation?
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: stevemiller on May 27, 2015, 10:49:11 PM
I like the idea of buy a second tag if u draw antlered and antlerless in same year!!!!!!!!!!! Quotas have been set and hunter has paid his money.
I think this would drastically decrease draw odds.  Knowing that drawing two tags gets you a second elk would cause more people to apply who don't already and people that already do apply to apply for more or different units just so they can kill two elk.
[/]

And if u win the lottery twice the state should give your second winnings to some other schmuck because while he might have done the same thing he didn't draw anything???  Isn't the point of any draw system points or not, to make all results random and not leave it to human interpretation?
Thats a good point  :yeah: Didnt really think of it like winning money but Still its a good point.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: stevemiller on May 28, 2015, 09:02:04 AM
Cool we should get a lot of pics then.I dont want to hear about these points I want to see them or they dont have them hows that?

Nobody needs to show you a thing and nobody cares what you want to hear about. Are you calling people liars here? Pretty clear you haven't been hunting long. Listen more, pop off less and you just may learn something.
I guess no one has as many points as they want everyone to believe.No your right no one needs to show,no one has to show.I think your off a little with the no one cares though,Plenty are tired of hearing the I have 20 points in this or that and I never get picked(Im gonna stop spending my money in WA.)  :cryriver:
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: LabChamp on May 28, 2015, 09:12:55 AM
Cool we should get a lot of pics then.I dont want to hear about these points I want to see them or they dont have them hows that?

Nobody needs to show you a thing and nobody cares what you want to hear about. Are you calling people liars here? Pretty clear you haven't been hunting long. Listen more, pop off less and you just may learn something.
I guess no one has as many points as they want everyone to believe.No your right no one needs to show,no one has to show.I think your off a little with the no one cares though,Plenty are tired of hearing the I have 20 points in this or that and I never get picked(Im gonna stop spending my money in WA.)  :cryriver:

I think it's hilarious some of you guys cry about reading someone's comments about the system and at the same time voice their point of view. Typical Washington style
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: stevemiller on May 28, 2015, 09:25:07 AM
I agree  :yeah: I also think it is hilarious that some members on here have so much to say about a subject and then when the question is asked how,when, or in this case how much earlier for the results to come out,No one responds just crickets every time.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: LabChamp on May 28, 2015, 09:27:16 AM
I agree  :yeah: I also think it is hilarious that some members on here have so much to say about a subject and then when the question is asked how,when, or in this case how much earlier for the results to come out,No one responds just crickets every time.

Status quoe
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: stevemiller on May 28, 2015, 09:28:47 AM
Exactly.  :tup:
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: birddogdad on May 28, 2015, 09:37:34 AM
how about scrap the whole points thing, equal chance every year, if drawn 3 year wait to redraw by animal type, of course keep OIL draws.

for those of us who served and were shuffled all over the country every 3 years, points building is not a good method for any state we are transferred too and from. We gain and loose residency for hunting and it becomes a dream to draw special tags..... I know dumping points will strike a sore nerve, but just my thought here...
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: LabChamp on May 28, 2015, 09:40:35 AM
I like the wait idea after drawing
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: trophyhunt on May 28, 2015, 10:35:02 AM
I like the wait idea after drawing
i take it you mean a wait period after drawing successful?  If so, 3 or 5 years?
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: Wacenturion on May 28, 2015, 11:25:15 AM
First item on poll should have been one choice for all, not just quality elk or deer.  I'm assuming many like myself voted for it thinking it was for all, as I just focused on limiting to one choice.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: X-Force on May 28, 2015, 01:00:40 PM
Just because habitat "looks" the same as it was 20 years ago certainly doesn't mean that it is.

I would scrap the whole system.

Choose one deer and one elk category.
Choose one of moose, sheep, and goat.
No points.
OIL for moose, sheep, goat.
3 year wait for deer and elk.

Sounds similar to Idaho!   :tup:

Im liking this idea but i think Idaho has it right when it comes to 1 oil or both deer and elk. With as few oil tags, really permits in general, as washington has and as many hunters as we have it would be nice to shrink the pool of people who put in for all tags not just oils. Most people I know who put in for Oils only do it because they dont have to choose.

I think this year I spent roughly $125 on applications if I had to choose I would rather spend that $125 on a single Goat or Sheep app where my odds were 1/50 or better. I would also rather spend $60 apiece on single elk or deer category where my odds are 1/20 or better.
Either way the state would be getting the same cash out of me (us) and I (we) would have better odds of drawing the permits I (we) really want.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: trophyhunt on May 28, 2015, 01:13:02 PM
First item on poll should have been one choice for all, not just quality elk or deer.  I'm assuming many like myself voted for it thinking it was for all, as I just focused on limiting to one choice.
the option was meant for only having 1 choice for quality deer, elk, sheep, goat and moose.  I didn't think people would care too much about the others.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: Wacenturion on May 28, 2015, 04:01:40 PM
First item on poll should have been one choice for all, not just quality elk or deer.  I'm assuming many like myself voted for it thinking it was for all, as I just focused on limiting to one choice.
the option was meant for only having 1 choice for quality deer, elk, sheep, goat and moose.  I didn't think people would care too much about the others.

Respectively disagree.  I think people do care, that's why the high vote total.  If you look at the other thread, you will see that the focus of the discussions of one choice and the examples was across the board and not limited to quality.  My example of Blue Mtn. West is a Buck deer draw.  Antlerless permittees putting in for buck and quality was also discussed.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: stevemiller on May 28, 2015, 04:16:26 PM
I like the wait idea after drawing
This would work and I dont think many would have a problem with it if they were able to still build points during the wait time,If not I think once drawn most would stop buying.  :twocents:
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: trophyhunt on May 28, 2015, 04:17:10 PM
First item on poll should have been one choice for all, not just quality elk or deer.  I'm assuming many like myself voted for it thinking it was for all, as I just focused on limiting to one choice.
the option was meant for only having 1 choice for quality deer, elk, sheep, goat and moose.  I didn't think people would care too much about the others.

Respectively disagree.  I think people do care, that's why the high vote total.  If you look at the other thread, you will see that the focus of the discussions of one choice and the examples was across the board and not limited to quality.  My example of Blue Mtn. West is a Buck deer draw.  Antlerless permittees putting in for buck and quality was also discussed.
Ok, when I get time this weekend I will take the results and write them down in order of popularity to give to the wdfw when I'm there.  I will adjust that topic to include all special permits be ONE choice.  Wouldn't it be cool if we saw even a couple changes in the future??
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: trophyhunt on May 28, 2015, 04:18:38 PM
I like the wait idea after drawing
This would work and I dont think many would have a problem with it if they were able to still build points during the wait time,If not I think once drawn most would stop buying.  :twocents:
I would think most would want the opportunity to buy your points if there was a waiting period, for sure.  That point will be in the letter I deliver.
Title: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: bobcat on May 28, 2015, 04:29:15 PM
I absolutely hate the idea of being able to apply for a point when you're not eligible to apply for an actual hunt. Like if there was a waiting period, or if we were only able to apply in one category per species. That should include applying for a point.

The very best way to improve odds would be to go back to only one deer category and one elk category. You have your deer points and you have your elk points. You choose to apply for an antlerless deer tag and you draw? Lose your deer points.

Want to apply for a "quality" deer hunt the following year? You're in with only 1 point. That was your choice. It makes it a heck of a lot easier to draw for those who just want a meat hunt. And it also takes some pressure off the so called quality permits.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: Wacenturion on May 28, 2015, 04:31:29 PM
First item on poll should have been one choice for all, not just quality elk or deer.  I'm assuming many like myself voted for it thinking it was for all, as I just focused on limiting to one choice.
the option was meant for only having 1 choice for quality deer, elk, sheep, goat and moose.  I didn't think people would care too much about the others.

Respectively disagree.  I think people do care, that's why the high vote total.  If you look at the other thread, you will see that the focus of the discussions of one choice and the examples was across the board and not limited to quality.  My example of Blue Mtn. West is a Buck deer draw.  Antlerless permittees putting in for buck and quality was also discussed.
Ok, when I get time this weekend I will take the results and write them down in order of popularity to give to the wdfw when I'm there.  I will adjust that topic to include all special permits be ONE choice.  Wouldn't it be cool if we saw even a couple changes in the future??

Thanks. :tup:
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: stevemiller on May 28, 2015, 04:32:12 PM
Thanks but no offense only a couple on here make any sense at all.I would like someone any one member to post a good way for the deadline and results to happen.I posted it long ago on here and nothing.I strongly feel that it is as I have stated There really is no better way or time.Also why is it so hard for anyone to show that they really do have 16-20 points in any category other than oil?Again I strongly feel its because as I have stated it is not true.  :twocents:
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: LabChamp on May 28, 2015, 04:32:33 PM
I absolutely hate the idea of being able to apply for a point when you're not eligible to apply for an actual hunt. Like if there was a waiting period, or if we were only able to apply in one category per species. That should include applying for a point.

The very best way to improve odds would be to go back to only one deer category and one elk category. You have your deer points and you have your elk points. You choose to apply for an antlerless deer tag and you draw? Lose your deer points.

Want to apply for a "quality" deer hunt the following year? You're in with only 1 point. That was your choice. It makes it a heck of a lot easier to draw for those who just want a meat hunt. And it also takes some pressure off the so called quality permits.

Love it, add the earlier draw, and maybe a % of the tags going to highest point holders and I'm sold
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: stevemiller on May 28, 2015, 04:39:18 PM
I absolutely hate the idea of being able to apply for a point when you're not eligible to apply for an actual hunt. Like if there was a waiting period, or if we were only able to apply in one category per species. That should include applying for a point.

The very best way to improve odds would be to go back to only one deer category and one elk category. You have your deer points and you have your elk points. You choose to apply for an antlerless deer tag and you draw? Lose your deer points.

Want to apply for a "quality" deer hunt the following year? You're in with only 1 point. That was your choice. It makes it a heck of a lot easier to draw for those who just want a meat hunt. And it also takes some pressure off the so called quality permits.
Ok,this is perfect,People say they have 20 points 16 points whatever,that means they have been waiting 16 to 20 years for some of these apps.say these people put in for quality deer every year and most others do also you could be waiting 16 to 20 to draw this tag then try to draw another is also 16 20 years and then, you could make all apps oil and it would turn out close to the same thing so I say no no no to all of these changes  :twocents: the only one that would make any sense at all to me anyways would be a wait after a successful draw in that category only.Be able to still build points while you wait.Fair who said life was fair?If you want better odds at a draw lower your expectations as to where you want drawn.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12
Post by: bobcat on May 28, 2015, 04:53:52 PM
I'd also be fine with leaving it as is other than waiting periods for those who draw quality deer or elk hunts. But NO to the building points during the waiting period. That's insanely stupid and defeats the entire purpose of having a waiting period.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: bobcat on May 28, 2015, 04:55:41 PM
I also agree with Steve in that if you haven't drawn a deer or elk permit in 20 years you need to start applying for some of the less popular hunts.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: stevemiller on May 28, 2015, 04:56:14 PM
but if you draw in this instance  :yeah: what would your chances of ever drawing again if you have to wait 5 years to start building points again?It would almost be like an O I L tag, would it not?
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: bobcat on May 28, 2015, 04:57:49 PM
Then just have a 1 or 2 year waiting period.  :dunno:

By the way, I've drawn quality deer permits in 2000, 2004, 2008, and 2012. So from my perspective, the odds really aren't that bad. You just need to apply for permits that aren't the most popular.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: stevemiller on May 28, 2015, 05:05:08 PM
 :tup: I think you can appreciate the complexity of this poll bobcat.There are a lot of knee jerk votes in this lot that dont really make any sense to me.This one that we are discussing does make sense.  :tup: The earlier deadline and results one well I dont get it lol.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: stevemiller on May 28, 2015, 05:06:51 PM
Then just have a 1 or 2 year waiting period.  :dunno:

By the way, I've drawn quality deer permits in 2000, 2004, 2008, and 2012. So from my perspective, the odds really aren't that bad. You just need to apply for permits that aren't the most popular.
All while you are still applying and building points though right?
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: bobcat on May 28, 2015, 05:09:06 PM

Then just have a 1 or 2 year waiting period.  :dunno:

By the way, I've drawn quality deer permits in 2000, 2004, 2008, and 2012. So from my perspective, the odds really aren't that bad. You just need to apply for permits that aren't the most popular.
All while you are still applying and building points though right?

Yes, of course.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: stevemiller on May 28, 2015, 05:14:03 PM
so if you are still building points its taking every 4 years to get drawn again so if we have to sit 1 year out no point building we would maybe get drawn every 5 years.  :tup: I can live with that,Of course I realize that this is with lowered expectations on hunt choices.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: X-Force on May 28, 2015, 07:27:21 PM
e author=bobcat link=topic=175423.msg2321265#msg2321265 date=1432857341]
I also agree with Steve in that if you haven't drawn a deer or elk permit in 20 years you need to start applying for some of the less popular hunts.
[/quote]

I agree but... The multiple categories per species is unsustainable.

What was the point creep before multiple categories? What is it now?
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: bobcat on May 28, 2015, 07:35:54 PM
We don't have point creep because our system is not a preference point system. All we have is impossible odds.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: X-Force on May 28, 2015, 08:39:54 PM
We don't have point creep because our system is not a preference point system. All we have is impossible odds.

We have impossible odds partially because of the multiple category system (in deer and elk) we also have a point creep because since the inception of the multiple category system the amount of people applying to every possible tag. 2008 Gardner rifle tag Nov 1-20  average points per permit recipient was 5, 2014 is 9 points. I don't have the old games regs on me but I can post up multiple similar comparisons tomorrow.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: Curly on May 29, 2015, 07:44:21 AM
Thanks but no offense only a couple on here make any sense at all.I would like someone any one member to post a good way for the deadline and results to happen.I posted it long ago on here and nothing.I strongly feel that it is as I have stated There really is no better way or time.Also why is it so hard for anyone to show that they really do have 16-20 points in any category other than oil?Again I strongly feel its because as I have stated it is not true.  :twocents:


I started a poll to see how many points people have going into the draws.

http://hunting-washington.com/smf/index.php?topic=175533.new#new
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: KNOPHISH on May 29, 2015, 10:41:57 AM
I kinda like if you get drawn for more than 1 you could return it & keep your points. or they could go the other way & say you got drawn for bull & cow tags they let you buy a 2nd tag since you just blew all your points.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: gee_unit360 on May 29, 2015, 11:08:17 AM
What's a max point holder? How many points? I didnt know it existed.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: bobcat on May 29, 2015, 11:42:33 AM
What's a max point holder? How many points? I didnt know it existed.

That's just referring to the most points a person could have if they started applying from the beginning of the point system, which was 1996. So this year the maximum points you could have is 20.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: Jingles on May 29, 2015, 01:20:30 PM
Did not see an option to just do away with special permit system except for OIL and the doing away with the ability to accumulate points from previous years for those OIL every year everyone that wants a chance has one ticket in the pool
Just open the seasons for everyone  You buy a license you can hunt until your tag is filled with any weapon during the respective seasons and no you don't have to declare what you want to hunt with.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: trophyhunt on May 30, 2015, 08:22:56 AM
Did not see an option to just do away with special permit system except for OIL and the doing away with the ability to accumulate points from previous years for those OIL every year everyone that wants a chance has one ticket in the pool
Just open the seasons for everyone  You buy a license you can hunt until your tag is filled with any weapon during the respective seasons and no you don't have to declare what you want to hunt with.
There are a bunch of options, just can't put them all up. The option your talking about would be popular with hunters but wdfw will never give up this money machine they have made.  unfortunately most changes will have to not decrease revenue if any happen.  This poll is probably for nothing, but I will take these examples with me at the drawing  and try to pass them on, hopefully with an explanation about them, to the right person.  Who knows, maybe the new director will be there?  We need more numbers to show them, I'm not too sure 175 votes will impress them much.  I will probably leave out the number of votes and just show the percentages. 
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: mfswallace on May 30, 2015, 08:55:08 AM
Don't forget the last option was added after most people voted and we can't go back and pick it as one of our choices.....
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: trophyhunt on May 30, 2015, 09:13:27 AM
Don't forget the last option was added after most people voted and we can't go back and pick it as one of our choices.....
Yes, that will definitely be on the list.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: bobcat on May 30, 2015, 09:30:06 AM
That last option would make odds for all deer and elk permits much worse, but at least it would make it worth applying in multiple categories. The WDFW might go along with it because they'd be sure to sell more applications. I might even think about applying in the bull category. This year I only applied for an antlerless elk permit. I applied for quality elk as well, but only for a point.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: X-Force on May 30, 2015, 09:46:46 AM
I am amazed at the support for max point holders really, 25-50% of permits including oils going to them then everyone else draws? There are enough max point holders in moose, sheep, goat and elk that those people will be getting 25-50% of the permits for perpetuity. Meaning the there aren't enough permits to move down a level, say 20 down to 19, ever.

I'm not worried about the state taking the proposal seriously because it would alienate to many people but coming from guys complaining about a "fair" system its asinine.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: notsosneaky on May 30, 2015, 09:49:40 AM
i feel like all the suggested changes won't have the impact you'd think.
For instance: I initially like the idea of a waiting period after you draw a quality tag.
The problem is, under the current system, the number of quality tags going to applicants with 1-3 points is around 15% for deer and elk. applicants with 1-3 points account for the highest percentage of people in the draw(greater percentage of people getting a lower percentage of tags)

If those tags go to applicants with 4 points or more then in three years that same greater number of people will be drawing the same percentage of the tags they are today. Then we will all cry "extend the wait to 5 years"

The more I think about it the more I want no changes. Every change has consequences that benefit some and hurt others. That said, I've always been in favor of a drawing only hunting season.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: splitshot on May 30, 2015, 09:58:29 AM
   up the cost.        not much diff between quality and buck and not much between bull and quality                combine them and charge more.            this will not be popular, charge west side residents out of state to hunt eastside.  lol.    a money maker but wont fly.     mike w
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: bobcat on May 30, 2015, 10:12:22 AM
I agree with notsosneaky that I'd rather there not be any changes. I think it's better to just leave it alone and let people get used to it. But I also agree with splitshot that there should only be one buck category and one bull category. There's no need for a separate quality category, other than so the state can sell more applications.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: grundy53 on May 30, 2015, 10:12:30 AM
   up the cost.        not much diff between quality and buck and not much between bull and quality                combine them and charge more.            this will not be popular, charge west side residents out of state to hunt eastside.  lol.    a money maker but wont fly.     mike w
Good luck with that...
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: notsosneaky on May 30, 2015, 10:29:59 AM
For the record by my count this year there are 1092 people with 15 or more points in quality elk and 484 for quality deer. There is sure to be more as this data comes from 2014 applicants so folks who ghost pointed are not included.

It really comes down to lots of hunters and few tags, but all the data suggests that the more points you have the better your odds. As unpopular as it will sound the system works.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: X-Force on May 30, 2015, 10:53:01 AM
For the record by my count this year there are 1092 people with 15 or more points in quality elk and 484 for quality deer. There is sure to be more as this data comes from 2014 applicants so folks who ghost pointed are not included.

It really comes down to lots of hunters and few tags, but all the data suggests that the more points you have the better your odds. As unpopular as it will sound the system works.

I agree the system works. Is just sad to me that the meat hunters got screwed with the new category system. Before meat guys could draw every year or 2 but now everyone is putting in for those meat hunts because they have nothing to lose and vise versa with the quality guys having increased competition.

Its been said a bunch but there should be another poll option and that is to return back to the pre category system; just deer, elk, moose, goat, sheep... And increase the price of applications to fix the revenue problem.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: bobcat on May 30, 2015, 11:00:47 AM
"Meat hunters" also got screwed because they gave everyone their current deer and elk points in every new category.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: grundy53 on May 30, 2015, 11:49:11 AM
For the record by my count this year there are 1092 people with 15 or more points in quality elk and 484 for quality deer. There is sure to be more as this data comes from 2014 applicants so folks who ghost pointed are not included.

It really comes down to lots of hunters and few tags, but all the data suggests that the more points you have the better your odds. As unpopular as it will sound the system works.

I agree the system works. Is just sad to me that the meat hunters got screwed with the new category system. Before meat guys could draw every year or 2 but now everyone is putting in for those meat hunts because they have nothing to lose and vise versa with the quality guys having increased competition.

Its been said a bunch but there should be another poll option and that is to return back to the pre category system; just deer, elk, moose, goat, sheep... And increase the price of applications to fix the revenue problem.
Agreed
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: Curly on May 31, 2015, 07:51:55 AM
I'm glad to hear more comments about wanting the old system back or at least combining bull/quality bull and buck/bull.  I brought up the idea in the other thread and got shot down immediately.

I also don't like the idea of giving a percentage of permits to high point holders. I am sure that the majority of high point holders have always applied for the hardest to draw permits.  That was their choice and a gamble to try for those permits. Then as bobcat pointed out, when the category system started, the guys with high points were practically gifted permits in the buck, bull, antlerless, over 65 categories (because of the point distribution into all categories).

Wdfw (Dave Ware in particular ) really screwed up with this "new" system. Sure it is a money maker, but they spent a ton of money creating and implementing it when it would have been better to just keep the old one and raise the application fees to gain more revenue.  It would have been much better than this current system.  Probably not a realistic option at this point to scrap this system but I don't think it's too late to eliminate some categories. :twocents:
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: grundy53 on May 31, 2015, 08:19:47 AM
:yeah:
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: elk247 on May 31, 2015, 08:56:02 AM
Too many people, with too many points, putting in for too many hunts, with too few tags to go around. My suggestion would be to eliminate ghost points altogether, move the quality hunts into the buck/bull category. Increase the amount of permits given out. And lastly to make up for the revenue loss created by the removal of the ghost points, triple the prices of applications.  My thoughts are if you can speed up the process of getting drawn and at the same time restrict people from collecting so many points it will slowly get better over time once the high point holders get drawn. One problem with my plan is the OIL tags, I think there needs to be a limit on how many animals you can put in for but I don't know the best way to go about that. Meat hunts/antlerless/second deer and mulit season deer should all be OTC. Multi season elk need about 1,000 more tags.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: trophyhunt on May 31, 2015, 09:11:17 AM
I think the only way to improve odds on the OIL tags unfortunately, is make people buy the tags before they put in.  You would see a huge drop in people putting in for all three tags, not including the tags for the female species and ewe's.  That or making you choose between one of those tags a year and letting you put in for all of them.   
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: adamR on May 31, 2015, 09:16:43 AM
What about a secondary draw?  If, and only if, a person is drawn in multiple categories give them the choice of their favorite, they give up the other choices, their points for those categories are returned and all these surplus tags go into another draw.  Have that other draw in like July and charge the permit application fee to apply for them.  Wdfw makes more money, hunters don't have to sacrifice points for something they aren't going to hunt, and there are more opportunities across the board.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: adamR on May 31, 2015, 09:19:25 AM
I would be ok with only puttin in for one oil tag at a time as well.  I really only want a sheep tag but put in for the others because I might as well.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: trophyhunt on May 31, 2015, 09:24:58 AM
I have had a very busy weekend, had plans yesterday to type out these questions with a brief explanation of each one and then show the percentage of support they received.  Then I planned to put it in letter from to take with me to the draw to give to someone of importance or if given the chance, talk to someone about the subject.  Yesterday didn't go as planned.  My dad moved from cowiche to graham and called in the morning for a last trip that I didn't know about, no big deal it's my dad so off we go.  Well, just past packwood my 06 duramax starts loosing diesel out from somewhere under my engine.  Had to sit and wait for a tow truck and a friend to come get the car dolly I was towing.  Finally got home at 7:30 at night, exhausted.  I will get this done if I have to, but, I was wondering if anyone on here is good at turning this info into a letter form and emailing it to me?  You never know, some people like doing this kind of stuff so I thought I'd ask. I need to get this done soon, the phone call could come any time I suspect.  Any takers?
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: trophyhunt on May 31, 2015, 09:28:30 AM
What about a secondary draw?  If, and only if, a person is drawn in multiple categories give them the choice of their favorite, they give up the other choices, their points for those categories are returned and all these surplus tags go into another draw.  Have that other draw in like July and charge the permit application fee to apply for them.  Wdfw makes more money, hunters don't have to sacrifice points for something they aren't going to hunt, and there are more opportunities across the board.
I talked to them about that last year, the guy I was talking to about it said it cost too much to run another draw.  But I disagreed with him saying the money would come back considering all the new applicant fee's.  It's a great Idea and I'm with you 100%, it's a great way for them to collect more revenue and it will help solve the wasted tag issue.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: Halo on May 31, 2015, 09:47:31 AM
Remember when the regulations were about game management and opportunity and not purely about revenue and politics? Those were the days weren't they.
Title: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: bobcat on May 31, 2015, 10:13:26 AM
I don't think there are many wasted permits.  I know it does happen, but I just don't think there's enough people drawing in more than one category per species to justify a second draw.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: grundy53 on May 31, 2015, 10:14:29 AM
Remember when the regulations were about game management and opportunity and not purely about revenue and politics? Those were the days weren't they.
Yup, the good ole days...
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: BOWHUNTER45 on May 31, 2015, 11:04:46 AM
Remember when our Dads talked about the good old days ? Then we talked our good old days ? What will our kids have to say about their good old days  :dunno: Maybe if they were lucky enough to draw a quality deer or elk tag then that would be the best of their good old days ...Now the timber companies are ready to cash in on the revenue they can receive from Motorized and Non motorized permits . It is a matter of when , when all timber companies will follow ...our kids are sc----d !
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: Curly on May 31, 2015, 11:38:57 AM
I think that's the thing about good old days...you don't realize how good you have it til things change.  I look back now and see how good we had it in the 80's and even into the 90's. Back then my dad would look back and say the 60's were the good old days.

I suppose to some young guys, today will look like good old days to them in 20 years.
Title: Re: Poll for changes to draw system, only 3 votes not 12.
Post by: trophyhunt on June 01, 2015, 06:47:22 AM
The good ole day's as far as just grabbing the gun and kid to go for a weekend deer/elk hunt are gone.  There are some places you can still just drive to but very few that don't require a permit or pass of some sort.  I'm talking on the west side, pretty sad.
SimplePortal 2.3.7 © 2008-2025, SimplePortal