Hunting Washington Forum
Big Game Hunting => Elk Hunting => Topic started by: tbrady on June 28, 2015, 12:37:09 PM
-
About 99% of the time I am hunting alone (at best I may have a buddy in the same unit). Would an elk decoy help when trying to call in a bull solo? I typically steer away from most "gizmos" as I feel like they can easily do more harm than good but I'm curious what y'alls experience has been with these things...!
thanks
tim
-
They work great!
-
:tup: for the bulls that hang up during the rut and pre rut. Corey Jacobson summed it pretty great during the podcast on Rich Outdoors. When you get those bulls that stop at the 100-150 yd boundary you either have to sneak in on them or draw them closer. Depending on set up and terrain you might be forced to play your hand only one way. For those bulls you have nothing to loose. A decoy is just the visual conformation you need to finish painting the picture in the bulls mind that you are a hot cow.
I wouldn't call it a gimmick or say decoys are the only way to go ,but another deadly tool in the tool box when used correctly. Get a decoy that you can move quickly from setup to setup. There are tons of different decoys do your homework so you'll be happy with it.
-
I picked up two this year and going to try for the first time. I'm not sure how much I'll use "Ms September" but I know I'll benefit from having her in my pack than not. They just came in this week and I have her stretching her legs in my office! :-)
-
After calling guy after guy using a cow elk call in a bull only area, I would not use a decoy for fear of being shot. that's just my two cents, however if you have access to private land I would use them in a heart beat.
-
After calling guy after guy using a cow elk call in a bull only area, I would not use a decoy for fear of being shot. that's just my two cents, however if you have access to private land I would use them in a heart beat.
I'm using mine for archery if I can't get close enough to them. Always cautious for sure, but I'm less concerned than if I was using one during muzzie or modern.
-
We use them without hesitation. My buddy killed a huge 6 using a cow elk decoy. Bull came in and at 30 yards didn't see us behind the decoy. Awesome
-
Well, looks like I need to get one. :) I've done a bit of searching and see mainly 3 different ones that are popular. Does anyone have a totally unbiased opinion on which one is better? :chuckle:
-
:chuckle: it is all personal preference man.
-
I'd like to get one but they are pretty darn pricey for what they are
-
I own and use two decoys. The first will "always" be on my bow, they work and work very well.
http://www.poisonarrowgear.com/
The second is also a great tool in my elk kit but is deployed a bit more as the hunt dictates (I sometimes use the cow behind decoy slip and sometimes the camo slip). Plus, it's a great walking stick!
http://elkmtngear.com/
-
I own and use two decoys. The first will "always" be on my bow, they work and work very well.
http://www.poisonarrowgear.com/
The second is also a great tool in my elk kit but is deployed a bit more as the hunt dictates (I sometimes use the cow behind decoy slip and sometimes the camo slip). Plus, it's a great walking stick!
http://elkmtngear.com/
I bought one of the slips without the umbrella. I use 6 miniature bungies to drape it over bushes and it works great. I also use a Montana Elk decoy but am seriously thinking about the poison arrow decoy. How does it affect the release noise? Torque? Does it change the impact point?
-
I think I'd be way to afraid to use the one hanging my bow in cow units :yike:
-
The umbrella seems like one more thing to worry about in the woods but would be interested in others who have tried it.
The clip on cow to my bow is interesting, and I see the potential benefit but the height of the brush would have to be conducive otherwise it will appear like a floating head with two camo legs behind it. Again, would be interested in any consumer successes for those willing to share.
-
The umbrella seems like one more thing to worry about in the woods but would be interested in others who have tried it.
The clip on cow to my bow is interesting, and I see the potential benefit but the height of the brush would have to be conducive otherwise it will appear like a floating head with two camo legs behind it. Again, would be interested in any consumer successes for those willing to share.
That's why I just use the slip and attach it to bushes or between two saplings. The digital imagery is exceptional.
-
I think that I am going to invest in the Heads Up Cow decoy and give that a try this year. I will clip it to bushes as an attention grabber and for reassurance if a bull hangs up. Just hoping we still have an early season this year.
-
I own and use two decoys. The first will "always" be on my bow, they work and work very well.
http://www.poisonarrowgear.com/
The second is also a great tool in my elk kit but is deployed a bit more as the hunt dictates (I sometimes use the cow behind decoy slip and sometimes the camo slip). Plus, it's a great walking stick!
http://elkmtngear.com/
I just talked to my local archery shop about the poison arrow decoy and he said he'd looked at it but was concerned about bow stability in anything but the slightest wind. Can you address that concern, please?
-
Heads up for me. I really like it with two people even more. The caller can poke the head above the brush and draw the bull past the shooter. Very very mobile which fits my style perfectly.
-
I received one of the Poison Arrow decoys and I'm not sold on it. Seems like a big sail hanging off my quiver when deployed. I've "heard" of hunters walking up to bulls within bow range in the open with it deployed, but does anybody here actually have feedback using one?
-
I personally can't speak for how the PAG decoy affects point of impact in higher winds. I would assume that if you're hunting in a howling windstorm, the deployed decoy may affect ability to hold a pin on target but then again, I wouldn't be shooting very far with strong winds anyway...just my thoughts and not trying to be combative. I've shot my bow out to 60 yards with the decoy deployed at targets, with minimal wind, and had no issues hitting the objective; the thing weighs 3.3 ounces so I don't believe it causes any unecessary bow torque.
I think they're a game changer for sure. I deployed mine a handfull of times last September and literally had cows/calfs feeding right to me! They knew I was there and would periodically lift their heads and stare right at me and each time, I'd sway that sweet cow face back and forth slightly and they'd go back to feeding. Closest one little bunch came my way was less than 20 yards in a pretty open spot. I was calling them to me and really ticking off the little herd bull who remained on the other side of a patch of alder. Unfortunately, my buddy couldn't quite get a shooting lane on that guy. Fun times!
-
If you are in a wind you can pop it out of your quiver and hold it in your hand or tie it on a bush. It does not have to be used only on your bow.
You can also dedicate an arrow and put a broadhead on one end and a field point on the other. Then you have another option. Pop it out of your quiver and stick it in the ground.
This decoy is mounted to an arrow. It comes out as easily as removing an arrow. You do not have to only use it on your bow.
The huge benefit is the fact that it is ready at all times. While walking through the woods do not have it deployed. Use it like you do an arrow. When you would nock an arrow is when you would deploy the decoy. If you bust an elk you can deploy it in a second. It is not in your pack or on your back, it is ready.
There is no noise while shooting and it does not affect your shot.
I give a hundred percent satisfaction guaranty. If you are not completely satisfied, send it back for a complete refund.
-
slim 9300 sent me a video of walking up on a bull across an open meadow. He got within 25 yds before the bull took off. He was not trying to kill the bull, just trying out the decoy. Maybe he will give his thoughts on the decoy.
-
If you are in a wind you can pop it out of your quiver and hold it in your hand or tie it on a bush. It does not have to be used only on your bow.
You can also dedicate an arrow and put a broadhead on one end and a field point on the other. Then you have another option. Pop it out of your quiver and stick it in the ground.
This decoy is mounted to an arrow. It comes out as easily as removing an arrow. You do not have to only use it on your bow.
The huge benefit is the fact that it is ready at all times. While walking through the woods do not have it deployed. Use it like you do an arrow. When you would nock an arrow is when you would deploy the decoy. If you bust an elk you can deploy it in a second. It is not in your pack or on your back, it is ready.
There is no noise while shooting and it does not affect your shot.
I give a hundred percent satisfaction guaranty. If you are not completely satisfied, send it back for a complete refund.
I am definitely intrigued. Wish I could see one in person. Would be handier for the shooter than my current system.
-
slim 9300 sent me a video of walking up on a bull across an open meadow. He got within 25 yds before the bull took off. He was not trying to kill the bull, just trying out the decoy. Maybe he will give his thoughts on the decoy.
Welcome to the site as a sponsor, Poisonarrow. I just ordered one of your decoys. :tup:
-
Thanks for all the great input everyone. And poisonarrow, I'm seriously considering buying one... I drew a quality bull tag this year and trying to do everything I can to make the most of it.
-
They work good but I'd be Leary about ussing them in crowded areas.
-
They work good but I'd be Leary about ussing them in crowded areas.
If "anybody" is shooting at a cow face, they need more than a stern reprimand :rolleyes:
-
Depends where you hunt..in NE WA I bought one and it has sat in my basement for 15 years.. its to thick for them to ever see it and when they do see it they are in bow range
-
I own and use two decoys. The first will "always" be on my bow, they work and work very well.
http://www.poisonarrowgear.com/
The second is also a great tool in my elk kit but is deployed a bit more as the hunt dictates (I sometimes use the cow behind decoy slip and sometimes the camo slip). Plus, it's a great walking stick!
http://elkmtngear.com/
I just talked to my local archery shop about the poison arrow decoy and he said he'd looked at it but was concerned about bow stability in anything but the slightest wind. Can you address that concern, please?
I used the Poison Arrow cow decoy all last season and I hunted with the decoy for 4 weeks in both WA and MT. I also played around with the decoy for months before the season. The decoy flat out works and is the only decoy I will ever use. (And I have owned most of the options out there) All other types of decoys have been a hassle that simply aren't worth it. They never end out coming out because there isn't enough time. This decoy is nothing like the others and deploys is literally 2 seconds. Plus, it's shields your draw and distracts your quarry!
In light wind it's not noticeable. I heavy wind you simply don't deploy the decoy. If you are hunting in the timber there is rarely enough wind to affect the decoy. I will never hunt without the decoy on my bow. I could have killed a bunch of raghorns and a handful of six points last year with the help of the decoy holding the elk's attention for significantly longer than normal. I attributed this increase in time as being directly related to the decoy. I ended up killing an 8x7 on the second to last day of the hunt.
(https://hunting-washington.com/smf/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fimages.tapatalk-cdn.com%2F15%2F06%2F30%2F9fdb03bd4ac00fadcf747b9af45c0e78.jpg&hash=64e1b6d2a2f6a0916930f85d2a8a25189d002000)(https://hunting-washington.com/smf/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fimages.tapatalk-cdn.com%2F15%2F06%2F30%2F348a0cd70d3df58ed602dc928c0191c7.jpg&hash=1268e25d09b64a6e5cae32b6535ee71593d974e0)
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
I received one of the Poison Arrow decoys and I'm not sold on it. Seems like a big sail hanging off my quiver when deployed. I've "heard" of hunters walking up to bulls within bow range in the open with it deployed, but does anybody here actually have feedback using one?
See my post at the end of the thread. Let me know if you have any questions.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
slim 9300 sent me a video of walking up on a bull across an open meadow. He got within 25 yds before the bull took off. He was not trying to kill the bull, just trying out the decoy. Maybe he will give his thoughts on the decoy.
Here is the video in its raw form. I wish I could edit it but you get the idea. Sorry about the focus issues and problems keeping the same orientation.
Not a valid vimeo URL
This is the bull during the video. I took pics as I was walking toward him. I had a tag in my pocket and I could have killed this bull easily. He was about 30 yards at the closest. He was not tame, just confused. We called him in and I decided he wasn't big enough. Thus, I deployed the decoy, got up and attempted to get as close as I could in the fog. The calling and the decoy clearly helped to confuse him and keep in mind that I kept the decoy between him and I. I ran him back the direction he came simply because there was a herd of elk to my left. They were originally what I was after and I didn't want him to blow them out.
(https://hunting-washington.com/smf/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fimages.tapatalk-cdn.com%2F15%2F06%2F30%2F57fa7ef70e08ebf0e4bc5d726869ad63.jpg&hash=fab022f29446500c2f3261648cc42ba9c6acffec)
(https://hunting-washington.com/smf/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fimages.tapatalk-cdn.com%2F15%2F06%2F30%2F2a4baaa65744456d2f060398fab7737c.jpg&hash=b541ac8eca70e0e51aff212bd80a9aca561ef402)
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
They work good but I'd be Leary about ussing them in crowded areas.
You only deploy the Poison Arrow decoy when you need it. There is no cow face on the rear. This would never be my concern bow hunting.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Depends where you hunt..in NE WA I bought one and it has sat in my basement for 15 years.. its to thick for them to ever see it and when they do see it they are in bow range
Imagine having an extra 5-10 seconds (many times more in my experience) to shoot an elk that sees you and is spooked. That's the primary reason I love having the decoy on my bow.
I hunt places on the Westside that I have no doubt are much thicker than what you see on the NE. When you don't need the decoy, you don't notice it being there. When you need it, it's ready in a heartbeat regardless of how thick. It's all about timing when you deploy it.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
That bull wasn't big enough? :yike:
-
That bull wasn't big enough? :yike:
That bull was a squeaker compared to the one he arrowed last year :chuckle:
-
Must have been one of those hoof rot bulls that couldn't walk :chuckle:
-
Cool video.
-
That bull wasn't big enough? :yike:
The bull I killed was much bigger. ;)
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Slim, does that bull have double crowns and a split g4? :dunno:
I do believe that the decoy works. For what it's worth I was the biggest skeptic, questioned everything about the poison arrow decoy, and then ate crow on multiple occasions.
-
What do you guys think about the size of the head on that decoy?it seems so large to me, if it were smaller would it play with his depth perception on how close you really are.?
Slim can I come with you and shoot your satellites? :dunno: :chuckle:
-
Slim, does that bull have double crowns and a split g4? :dunno:
I do believe that the decoy works. For what it's worth I was the biggest skeptic, questioned everything about the poison arrow decoy, and then ate crow on multiple occasions.
I believe it does have double crowns! Pretty neat bull! ;)
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
What do you guys think about the size of the head on that decoy?it seems so large to me, if it were smaller would it play with his depth perception on how close you really are.?
Slim can I come with you and shoot your satellites? :dunno: :chuckle:
Hahahaha!
The size of the head does not seem to affect the elk in any way other than holding/drawing their attention. If you think about it (just like you implied), it would just give the elk the illusion that the cow is simply closer than it seems. I think it could fool a person for a second or two, and elk are much dumber (at least that's my impression).
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Have any discounts for us poison? :hello:
-
Have and discounts for us poison? :hello:
Yes, retroactive???? :hello:
-
I'm convinced. I will buy one right now if somebody can dig up a coupon code for us. :hello:
-
I'm convinced. I will buy one right now if somebody can dig up a coupon code for us. :hello:
Ditto! And um, since I started the thread originally... I had no idea it would generate this much discussion. Thanks again guys.
-
Guys, I sent the owner of Poison Arrow Decoys (James) a note asking if he's interested in perhaps running a 4th of July sale for his products for the esteemed members of the Hunt WA forum, perhaps knocking XX percent off... we'll see. I probably need to get another decoy model or two myself ;).
-
:tup: awesome
-
:tup: I'm wanting one as well.
-
Aw, shucks why not, 10% off through the 5th of July. Put july4th in the coupon box.
By the way the head is life size.
-
Left hand cow headed my way!
-
Aw, shucks why not, 10% off through the 5th of July. Put july4th in the coupon box.
By the way the head is life size.
Nice of you to do, even though I missed out! :cryriver:
-
Just ordered mine :tup:
-
Aw, shucks why not, 10% off through the 5th of July. Put july4th in the coupon box.
By the way the head is life size.
Awesome James!
I have killed many cows with my bow, I guess it's just hard to get an idea of the proportions without the rest of the animal. This cow probably had the largest head, and of course body, of any that I have ever seen. I wonder how she compares? Lol :D
(https://hunting-washington.com/smf/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fimages.tapatalk-cdn.com%2F15%2F06%2F30%2F0e96368a46ece6f8977db077b912cc66.jpg&hash=40d5e02b4c46b9fe838e2a7fc9125d690eba5f83)
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Just ordered one myself. :tup: thanks for the discount poinonarrow. Ive always been interested in using a decoy just never picked one up. Im curious to know if anyone has ever mounted one on a muzzleloader. :dunno: I would also be curious to know if the cow elk decoy would work on mule deer that have never even seen an elk before. :dunno: does anybody have any experience with that?
-
BL, the decoy is mounted on the last arrow in your quiver so not sure about a ML mount? Maybe. Oh, you know PAG makes a sweet looking muley doe face, yes?
-
I was thinking that there might be a way to mount it to the ram rod :dunno: either way I will use it for elk even if I have to hold it in my hand. I might even let my buddies use it on their peaches tag. Gonna try it out for deer as well. I saw the mule deer doe, but I can only afford one right now. I was drawn for the archery skok quality buck tag. I know those bucks have seen elk so im thinking it would work on them. Figured I would try it out on some mule deer this year as well.
-
I'm convinced. I will buy one right now if somebody can dig up a coupon code for us. :hello:
Ditto! And um, since I started the thread originally... I had no idea it would generate this much discussion. Thanks again guys.
Top 5 thread starters get 25% off... come on, who's with me! :IBCOOL:
-
I was drawn for the archery skok quality buck tag. I know those bucks have seen elk so im thinking it would work on them. Figured I would try it out on some mule deer this year as well.
You may be on to something. I betcha that cow face will hold their attention just fine. I put a spot/stalk on a nice Blacktail buck during my WA elk hunt last year and never even thought about deploying the PAG cow face. I like your thinking sir.
-
Aw, shucks why not, 10% off through the 5th of July. Put july4th in the coupon box.
By the way the head is life size.
Awesome James!
I have killed many cows with my bow, I guess it's just hard to get an idea of the proportions without the rest of the animal. This cow probably had the largest head, and of course body, of any that I have ever seen. I wonder how she compares? Lol :D
(https://hunting-washington.com/smf/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fimages.tapatalk-cdn.com%2F15%2F06%2F30%2F0e96368a46ece6f8977db077b912cc66.jpg&hash=40d5e02b4c46b9fe838e2a7fc9125d690eba5f83)
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Good gawd man, that's not a cow...... that's a stegasaurus :o
-
:tup:
-
Just watched the video on his website about mounting it. Im thinking that even if I have to stalk an elk with my muzzy pointed up I could make it work. And at the last min point and aim. By that time the elk wont know what hit him. Now trying to reload with it attached to the ram rod could be an issue. Perhaps once I get it I can come up with something that will make it attach and detach pretty easily so I can still use the ramrod
-
They work on mule deer. I was on a ridge last year and heard something coming up the trail. I deployed my elk decoy and three mule deer buck walked into plain sight , there was nothing between us. They stomped and pranced around trying to figure me out. I drew my bow back twice and let it down, no tag. I ranged them and they were 43 yds.
I finally got up and started towards them to see how close I could get. They took off. I could have easily shot any of the three several times.
-
What the heck, I've been spending money like wildfire on hunting gear lately so I ordered one too. Looks to be a good concept. :tup:
-
Old floppy has worked her but off for ten yrs. I have the montana elk decoy that looks head on. I broke one ear so I didn't look like a alert cow looking ahead. And use it set up behind me and just the head all folded up. Put two nice bulls down and a hand full of cows due to old floppy.
-
Hmmm wonder if I can hide the charge?
-
I've never been much of a decoy guy because hate packing the things, that is until I came across the Poison Gear Decoy, it's lightweight & you don't even know its on your bow. Definitely consider one of them.
ElkNut1
-
I've never been much of a decoy guy because hate packing the things, that is until I came across the Poison Gear Decoy, it's lightweight & you don't even know its on your bow. Definitely consider one of them.
ElkNut1
Good to see you Paul! Thank you for introducing me to James and his decoy. :)
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
They work!!! just get one and trust it....
-
One more post. I am running a photo contest, the best photo this next hunting season wins $1000.00. Send your photos to pictures@poisonarrowgear.com
It is for any species and it runs until the 30th of Jan. It does have to include a Poison Arrow Gear decoy.
-
:tup: hope to enter that this year!
-
Incidentally, I had a slight issue with my order and the response from the owner was immediate. I'm very happy not only with the decoy I got, but with the customer service. I will be recommending Poison Arrow to my hunting friends. :tup:
-
Incidentally, I had a slight issue with my order and the response from the owner was immediate. I'm very happy not only with the decoy I got, but with the customer service. I will be recommending Poison Arrow to my hunting friends. :tup:
My order has shipped but I don't see carrier or tracking information I can follow. How long did yours take to arrive, Pman?
-
3 or 4 days.
-
Mine shipped out Wednesday so I'm hopping to see it today or Monday :tup:
-
Incidentally, I had a slight issue with my order and the response from the owner was immediate. I'm very happy not only with the decoy I got, but with the customer service. I will be recommending Poison Arrow to my hunting friends. :tup:
My order has shipped but I don't see carrier or tracking information I can follow. How long did yours take to arrive, Pman?
On the email with the subject line "Your order has shipped", there should be a USPS tracking number.
-
Mine just came today, 3 days after I placed the order. :)
-
They are defiantly helpful in every situation when used correctly. Wether your by yourself or five people.
-
Just got mine today! worried when I saw the box all beat up but luckily the decoy was unharmed. Can't wait to put it to use :tup: