Hunting Washington Forum
Big Game Hunting => Elk Hunting => Topic started by: dreamingbig on April 07, 2017, 10:14:44 AM
-
Why do modern firearm bull permit holders get 14 days afield in most of the eastern draw permits for elk while archery bull permit holders only get 13 days?
My proposal give archery branch antlered permit holders an extra 5 days just like they do for modern firearm.
Thoughts?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
There is significantly more rifle hunters than archery hunters. The "cash cow" needs to be as happy as possible. Archery gets first crack, a plenty long season and rut timing. Doesn't seem so bad to me? :dunno:
-
1 day less than someone carrying a boom stick isn't my definition of plenty long. I can't argue with first crack.
I remain steadfast in my belief that archery is harder even with the month difference in time.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
I am predominantly a muzzleloader hunter. It was archers who complained during the last season setting process that ML hunters got days to hunt quality tags before the general season and archers did not. So instead of getting your extra days, you got the ML guys extra days before the season taken away. Thanks guys! >:( Beyond that, archery is the fastest growing user group with rapidly advancing technology every year. The "hard way" is getting easier every year. You chose the "hard way." Why do archers feel that they deserve more than other groups? I'll trade you ML season for your archery season any time you like. I own a bow, ML, and rifles. I happily hunt with them all. In fact, I'll be archery elk hunting this season because I am unhappy with the dates that ML gets for this year. A short 6 day season bumping up to opening weekend of modern firearm deer season. No thanks!
-
All user groups have seen technology increases. I am not saying increase the general archery season just for the quality permits. Look at the success rates for archery quality permits. It is still much harder by that stat.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
you might want to hunt archery and see how easy it is... NOT newer technology may increase accuracy but hasn't changed shooting distance.you still need to get as close as you did ten years ago.
-
Why do modern firearm bull permit holders get 14 days afield in most of the eastern draw permits for elk while archery bull permit holders only get 13 days?
My proposal give archery branch antlered permit holders an extra 5 days just like they do for modern firearm.
Thoughts?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
So where would these 5 days come from? What group will sacrifice part of their season.
-
There's a lot more people and competition in the woods during rifle season :dunno:
-
Why do modern firearm bull permit holders get 14 days afield in most of the eastern draw permits for elk while archery bull permit holders only get 13 days?
My proposal give archery branch antlered permit holders an extra 5 days just like they do for modern firearm.
Thoughts?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
So where would these 5 days come from? What group will sacrifice part of their season.
Open Archery season 5 days earlier?
-
Didn't the archery hunters just push for a later start last year? :dunno:
-
The modern bull permits may get 14 days but they only get 5 days to hunt before the general season starts and thousands of modern firearm hunters hit the woods.
-
Why do modern firearm bull permit holders get 14 days afield in most of the eastern draw permits for elk while archery bull permit holders only get 13 days?
My proposal give archery branch antlered permit holders an extra 5 days just like they do for modern firearm.
Thoughts?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
So where would these 5 days come from? What group will sacrifice part of their season.
Open Archery season 5 days earlier?
Yes. For the permit holders. The calendar has the room.
Someone how they managed to fit a 5 day rut hunt in at the end of September for modern firearm too.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
The modern bull permits may get 14 days but they only get 5 days to hunt before the general season starts and thousands of modern firearm hunters hit the woods.
And archery permit hunters get zero days before all the archery hunters and multiseason permit holders hit the woods.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Switch weapons and you'll be fine. You can draw a tag every 10-15 years versus every 5 years for that one extra day to hunt.
-
Point creep is alive and well for archery too. Took 9 years beginning in 2003 to draw 1st time around. This will be the 5th year hoping for another chance.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
You bow hunters slay me.
The talk about how you have chosen the "Sharp Stick" method of hunting due to the challenge, then the tears about how everyone else has an advantage due to the Mantle of Difficulty that is associated with Archery hunting. You can't have it both ways, that is how it works, so quit crying and practice shooting, ranging, calling and get in shape. Oh yeah, put your big boy pants on too.
I have often thought about taking up bow hunting but have not due to my work schedule being very hectic in September and October.
If and when I ever do take up archery you can bet that I won't be posting the tearful complaints that I see here.
Being in the field during the rut is a huge break, I realize that it is difficult to get within bow distance, but rifle seasons no picnic either.
Having hunted elk for 43 years, I am not always successful, but that's hunting.
I spent 20 (Very Successful) years catching steelhead on the fly during the summers in SW Washington.
I believe that it was more difficult than using conventional gear, that was my choice and I treasured the victories with no animosity towards the guys using eggs, corkies, spoons etc. During the winter, that was what I used, but summer was for the fly as far as my choice.
In closing, Life's Not Fair, get used to it.
Have a nice day,
Rob.
-
Compared to all other states Washington's Archery season is very short. You can't blame a guy for wanting to hunt more can you? :dunno:
-
I don't feel that he is whining about season dates or even season length but the fact that if you get drawn for a quality bull tag your season opens and closes the same time as General season, and yes archery numbers have increased tremendously which makes hunting a bull not just about you and the elk but now includes all of the retards jogging thru the woods with a bow ( I'm not saying all bow hunters are retarded but there are just a lot more of them out there now days). I don't see any reason that if you were lucky enough to ever draw a quality bull tag that you shouldn't have three days for just the quality tag holders. If it's good enough for the other weapons it should be good enough for all of the weapons
-
How about if early general archery elk season gets shortened from 13 to 10 days except for bull tag holders who get those 3 days for their quality tags. If you want something that bad make the sacrifice from your own season.
-
I don't feel that he is whining about season dates or even season length but the fact that if you get drawn for a quality bull tag your season opens and closes the same time as General season, and yes archery numbers have increased tremendously which makes hunting a bull not just about you and the elk but now includes all of the retards jogging thru the woods with a bow ( I'm not saying all bow hunters are retarded but there are just a lot more of them out there now days). I don't see any reason that if you were lucky enough to ever draw a quality bull tag that you shouldn't have three days for just the quality tag holders. If it's good enough for the other weapons it should be good enough for all of the weapons
Well I have had peddle mountain bikers with dogs, motorcycles with no orange on ride in between me and a bull I was about to pull the trigger on during modern season too! So it doesn't matter what season your hunting your going to run into the same situation. Public land is public use. Only difference is they have all year to do their sport while we have a window to do ours.
-
Wdfw does not care if you harvest or not.As long there is a season ,so you buy your permit,tag. If you don't like it go modern,mean this one day hurts you that bad .
-
Your guys replies are funny. I wasn't expecting you to be able to acknowledge the inequity and you delivered. 😎
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
This is the nature of separating user groups and the reason why most states allow you to hunt all seasons with the proper weapon. It's quite possible that WA went the way it did to purposely dilute the voice of the hunter and pander to the majority. We should be able to hunt big game all fall long during each season. It would spread out the hunters more and be a real change for increased opportunity.
-
And I have been up and watched Archery hunter they run the Elk with 4 wheelers to get close seen guys on the back of them running along a herd with bows drawen, and shooting so during ML I have seen ELK with arrows in them I understand it happens, But the way they hunt for them is wrong, I have hunted the same spot for 30 years and since they have open it up for cows we don't see the animals and hear that they have been pushed off the mountain, and that is by the Biologist
-
And I have been up and watched Archery hunter they run the Elk with 4 wheelers to get close seen guys on the back of them running along a herd with bows drawen, and shooting so during ML I have seen ELK with arrows in them I understand it happens, But the way they hunt for them is wrong, I have hunted the same spot for 30 years and since they have open it up for cows we don't see the animals and hear that they have been pushed off the mountain, and that is by the Biologist
Simply ridiculous assertions......because you saw one person / group doing something stupid or illegal, you now associate it with all bow hunters and the lack of elk on a mountain. Really??? Not like the elk just vanished because they opened up an area to cow elk, they just changed their habit. You should read the book "Who moved the Cheese" you will be a happier and more successful elk hunter. You need to adapt and change your strategy based on the situation. Maybe even take up bow hunting so you can chase a cow. :tup:
-
This is the nature of separating user groups and the reason why most states allow you to hunt all seasons with the proper weapon. It's quite possible that WA went the way it did to purposely dilute the voice of the hunter and pander to the majority. We should be able to hunt big game all fall long during each season. It would spread out the hunters more and be a real change for increased opportunity.
Very well put....I 1000% agree!! :yeah: :yeah: :yeah:
-
Your guys replies are funny. I wasn't expecting you to be able to acknowledge the inequity and you delivered. 😎
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
The inequity? Really? You guys got your later season dates with better rut timing. You got your lighted nocks and expandable broadheads. You have 2 lenghty seasons to hunt and you can harvest cows on a general tag. The squeaky wheel has been greased, shut up and hunt!
-
Your guys replies are funny. I wasn't expecting you to be able to acknowledge the inequity and you delivered. 😎
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
The inequity? Really? You guys got your later season dates with better rut timing. You got your lighted nocks and expandable broadheads. You have 2 lenghty seasons to hunt and you can harvest cows on a general tag. The squeaky wheel has been greased, shut up and hunt!
This is precisely what I was talking about. They've got us pointing fingers at each other so we don't point our fingers at them. Well played, WDFW, well played. :tup: :tup:
-
Your guys replies are funny. I wasn't expecting you to be able to acknowledge the inequity and you delivered. 😎
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
The inequity? Really? You guys got your later season dates with better rut timing. You got your lighted nocks and expandable broadheads. You have 2 lenghty seasons to hunt and you can harvest cows on a general tag. The squeaky wheel has been greased, shut up and hunt!
🤔 apples to apples it is still 14 to 13 with branch bull permit in hand. I will still be hunting; you don't have to worry about that. I will also be hunting out of state again after I am unsuccessful drawing a bull tag.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Anyone with a brain goes out of state. General season out of state is way better than any westside permit you can even apply for... I'll be cutting my hunting back dramatically here cause of the liberal agenda. I'll even take my business else where too with all this sanctuary city crap.
-
Being a hunter who archery hunts and rifle hunts. When I am helping friends or just out in the woods in sept. And hunting rifle elk with my friends, I see way more game in sept . Easier to locate etc. Now I am not saying they are easier to harvest but I feel finding game is easier in sept, at least with elk.
-
I am predominantly a muzzleloader hunter. It was archers who complained during the last season setting process that ML hunters got days to hunt quality tags before the general season and archers did not. So instead of getting your extra days, you got the ML guys extra days before the season taken away. Thanks guys! >:( Beyond that, archery is the fastest growing user group with rapidly advancing technology every year. The "hard way" is getting easier every year. You chose the "hard way." Why do archers feel that they deserve more than other groups? I'll trade you ML season for your archery season any time you like. I own a bow, ML, and rifles. I happily hunt with them all. In fact, I'll be archery elk hunting this season because I am unhappy with the dates that ML gets for this year. A short 6 day season bumping up to opening weekend of modern firearm deer season. No thanks!
The technology is not rapidly advancing. Bows are no faster, no more accurate, and no easier to shoot than 10 yeaars ago. Quality may have gotten better and bows may be a bit quieter, but the technology advancements have been very slow for a long time. Actually Some bows, like Elites, had more letoff and were easier to shoot in 2010. All the latest and greatest now is all marketing. A fiber optic pin now is no differend then a fiber optic pin 10 years ago. Movable sight have been around a long time. Rests, not much different. Pro target shooters still use the old lizard tongue rests and QAD ultrarests are basically the same they were 10 years ago. The only thing thats gotten better is expandable broadheads, and the new ones are still inferior to fixed broadheads IMO. :twocents:
-
Like 777 powder and fiber optic pins were traditionally used on a flintlock... don't go that route and pin us against each other. Muzzy guys got some new units too and I might just wait till October to start in Washington... We are all hunters. The seasons should be exactly like Idaho. Where the department gets its fair share in revenue and we get ours in hunting opportunitys. Less pressure spread out through the month means better time spent afield for all. We all know most of our hunts here are pressured due to lack of public land avalible. Pressured till there's no hunt for anyone. The game leaves the area. Even the permits are packed with Yahoos on the bugle tubes or road hunters one after another driving around and keeping the animals out of sight. Hunting in Washington has gone to the wolf lover and non hunter. Sad to see. If they don't listen up people will start to catch on and take all this permit $ tag increase $ and overall hunting expenses to other states that accommodate hunters.
-
This wasn't a technology argument. It was and is simply why should a modern firearm permit holder have 14 days while an archery permit holder only gets 13. I think the archery permit holders should get a few extra days. At minimum they should have the same amount of days. The permit doesn't carry over to late season.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Probably because the archery season is during the rut when elk are bugling and are much easier to locate. Not to mention that they haven't been hunted yet. If people think the archery season isn't as good as modern firearm, they're free to purchase a modern firearm tag instead of an archery tag. They can even hunt with their bow during modern firearm season if they wish. I don't see where archery hunters have any room to complain.
-
For those of you that don't bow hunt, keep in mind there is a very good reason every other states archery season is at least 2 times as long as WA (rut or not). We are all on the same team here.
-
For those of you that don't bow hunt, keep in mind there is a very good reason every other states archery season is at least 2 times as long as WA (rut or not). We are all on the same team here.
Yep, and the reason is those states have more elk and less people.
Oh, and I do archery hunt, just not every year.
-
For those of you that don't bow hunt, keep in mind there is a very good reason every other states archery season is at least 2 times as long as WA (rut or not). We are all on the same team here.
Yep, and the reason is those states have more elk and less people.
Oh, and I do archery hunt, just not every year.
You don't have to lie to hang out buddy!
-
For those of you that don't bow hunt, keep in mind there is a very good reason every other states archery season is at least 2 times as long as WA (rut or not). We are all on the same team here.
Yep, and the reason is those states have more elk and less people.
Oh, and I do archery hunt, just not every year.
You don't have to lie to hang out buddy!
:dunno:
-
Let me rephrase, I don't think anyone that draws a quality tag ( which is almost an oil tag in some areas) should not have at least 3 days in the woods with very limited pressure, I don't care what weapon or season they choose
-
Here are some articles about bows from 10 years ago and bows today. I call BS on technology not advancing. If it wasn't, bow companies couldn't charge what they do now and you wouldn't pay it!
https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=http://www.outdoorlife.com/photos/gallery/photos/2006/08/ol-bow-test-look-back-2006&ved=0ahUKEwjfw9ug55zTAhUN6GMKHRngDYsQFggaMAA&usg=AFQjCNG--U-RnfW8Zb35-dh2Sv9YuAjJSQ&sig2=hvpTdBeU8pvhkEtvCqv4vA
https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=http://www.outdoorlife.com/best-new-hunting-bows-2017-compounds&ved=0ahUKEwir1qm_55zTAhUD32MKHQG4BY8QFgh3MAY&usg=AFQjCNG-ZOhoiwPe669tDHcAXZkrfHlvHQ&sig2=sjovhlJPIzz2V3I1UlsSVA
Furthermore, I challenge anyone to quote where I said any other weapon types have not had technology advancements.
-
All hunting technology has advanced. I believe this started with m fowl saying that archers complained and got their way... :dunno: if any of the weapons seasons were liberal we'd have nothing to argue about. This state has the worst seasons of any for what they call quality tags. I can't think of a westside archery quality tag that I would waste my points on. Not one that is possible to draw.
-
It doesn't matter how tech has advanced for any method of hunting. It's either allowed or it isn't. The whole argument of "your season is better than my season" is ridiculous and allows the WDFW to sit back and watch us weaken our voice. We all should be able to hunt all seasons. Change this argument from being against your fellow hunters to one against the WDFW as "your regulations/opportunities suck as compared to other states' regulations/opportunities".
-
We all should be able to hunt all seasons.
We can. Just not in the same year.
-
That's helpful.
What was the Fred Bear quote about supporting other hunters in how they choose to hunt?
-
Everyone needs to read "5 dysfunctions of a team" and then reply to this post. We are all part of the same team and we are failing miserably which ultimately going to be the death of our sport. Very sad....
-
Seriously? We are failing? How? Because we support regulating ourselves in such a way as to preserve our elk populations in Washington state? Do we really want everyone to have a multiple season elk tag? Supporting such a thing is supporting the team? Really? If so then I guess I don't support the "team" and I never will.
-
We're not regulating ourselves. The WDFW is regulating us. And, we have less opportunity here than in most of the lower 48. How is it that other states let their hunters hunt during all of the seasons and maintain populations? How is it that hunter numbers have steadily declined since 1970 yet opportunities have not proportionately increased for the remaining hunters?
-
What I said before- the other states have more elk and less people, and even more importantly much more elk habitat AND public land that is open to hunting. I'll ask this- does California have more or less elk hunting opportunity than us?
-
Seriously? We are failing? How? Because we support regulating ourselves in such a way as to preserve our elk populations in Washington state? Do we really want everyone to have a multiple season elk tag? Supporting such a thing is supporting the team? Really? If so then I guess I don't support the "team" and I never will.
I guess you will have to read the book to understand my statement. If you think hunters as a team (group) are not failing then you have your head in the sand. We lose ground every year to the state and the tree huggers.....We fight internally and have no plan. We are failing.....period.
-
Seriously? We are failing? How? Because we support regulating ourselves in such a way as to preserve our elk populations in Washington state? Do we really want everyone to have a multiple season elk tag? Supporting such a thing is supporting the team? Really? If so then I guess I don't support the "team" and I never will.
I agree with this. Just because I am at odds with others on this issue does not mean that I do not or will not support other hunting groups. As I stated previously, I own a bow. I've hunted with it and will continue to in the future. What bothers me is that a user group in a state where things aren't great for everyone, IMO, has the best opportunities yet isn't happy with them. On top of that, wants to complain openly about it and blame the other side for their rebuttals. I am a hunter, just give me a reason, bow, rifle, ML, fun, food or lifestyle. Sign me up.
-
All the fighting would make sense if I was suggesting subtracting from other opportunities or user groups. I wasn't. I was suggesting adding 5 days for archery branch antlered permit holders without subtraction.
We should all be on the same team and support hunting. Which is why the MF and Muzzleloader guys SHOULD support this change! 😎
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
By the way, one of the main reasons the archery season was pushed back was because there was too many animals spoiling. Temps in early september can be into the 90's in some areas. This decision was made from feedback from multiple groups including numerous butcher shops processing wild game. Get your facts straight.
-
What I said before- the other states have more elk and less people, and even more importantly much more elk habitat AND public land that is open to hunting. I'll ask this- does California have more or less elk hunting opportunity than us?
Oh yeah they are hurting so bad out east for elk habitat and public land... not enough areas to ride the quad... :dunno: there's plenty of elk and plenty of public land WHERE wdfw didn't let the property owners double dip on tax breaks and charge us for land that had already had access guaranteed. Now, you can hunt a bull on the westside if you pay for access too. Or you can hunt a bull every eight or so years out east... but the spike and cow opportunitys... wdfw bent over for big timber and then put our hunting in the can. Our state need a system identical to idahos. We must not have enough elk... give me a break. More like they can't capitalize monetarily on the elk if they don't sell us wish hunts every year. Or there not smart enough to do math and charge what needs to be charged to generate the same amount of revenue from general tags.
-
So I have elected to eat my lunch slowly and therefore want a longer lunch hour. You guys go back to work and I will be along shortly.
I'm habitually late and want the same raise that the punctual guys got.
I gotta say, I have never heard such persistent whining in my life.
Dreaminbig, did you get beat up a lot in school?
Again, life is not fair.
-
What we're lacking in this state is winter range for elk. It's been converted to farms, orchards, and subdivisions. You can't tell me other western states don't have more and better quality elk habitat, and especially winter range.
-
NW Surveyor - read the thread. Mine has all been above the belt. No insults or name calling here. Other folks have chimed in and started throwing stones.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
So, advocating for a way to make one user group more successful. Then something has to be given up to maintain allocation. A slice of general season? Other permits? Spike becomes true spike? If not, then just trying to take allocation from other groups.
-
How about if early general archery elk season gets shortened from 13 to 10 days except for bull tag holders who get those 3 days for their quality tags. If you want something that bad make the sacrifice from your own season.
So, advocating for a way to make one user group more successful. Then something has to be given up to maintain allocation. A slice of general season? Other permits? Spike becomes true spike? If not, then just trying to take allocation from other groups.
:yeah:
-
Why is it that rifle hunters gripe about muzzleloader and archery seasons and muzzleloaders gripe about the others...archery hunters gripe about getting the short end of the stick. Use a different weapon if you don't like it. :twocents:
-
What we're lacking in this state is winter range for elk. It's been converted to farms, orchards, and subdivisions. You can't tell me other western states don't have more and better quality elk habitat, and especially winter range.
This was always the impression I was given as well by bios and people I considered in the know. The problem in Washington isn't out spring summer fall capacities but our ability to sustain a herd through the winter. I don't know all the science behind it but have heard it from multiple people I consider credible.
That being said I think all the seasons have benefits over the others in certain areas and that someone who puts in the time and effort has a reasonable shot at being successful
-
So, advocating for a way to make one user group more successful. Then something has to be given up to maintain allocation. A slice of general season? Other permits? Spike becomes true spike? If not, then just trying to take allocation from other groups.
Did you read the whole thread or the original post? This is about the branch antlered bull permits only. Pretty small group overall. Much less than the modern firearm numbers given the allocation formula. It is not additional tags only additional days for the few lucky ones who draw a tag.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
So, advocating for a way to make one user group more successful. Then something has to be given up to maintain allocation. A slice of general season? Other permits? Spike becomes true spike? If not, then just trying to take allocation from other groups.
Did you read the whole thread or the original post? This is about the branch antlered bull permits only. Pretty small group overall. Much less than the modern firearm numbers given the allocation formula. It is not additional tags only additional days for the few lucky ones who draw a tag.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Yep. And what do you want the WDFW/bios to do when the harvest success goes up by X% on bulls taken by those permits? Cut back on permit numbers or in the general?
-
By the way, one of the main reasons the archery season was pushed back was because there was too many animals spoiling. Temps in early september can be into the 90's in some areas. This decision was made from feedback from multiple groups including numerous butcher shops processing wild game. Get your facts straight.
It was actually the WSB who led the charge for season changes, lighted nocks and expandable broadheads. Below is an excerpt from a 2013 issue of WSB magazine. Which is also shortly before the WDFW had their open comment period for the last season setting process.
Our number one goal for next
season is to push the WDFW to hard
set our elk season from September
8-21. My personal goal is to stop
fighting hard to get back seasons
that we lose, and start fighting for
additional seasons and opportunity
for bowhunters. Since I’ve been
a member of the WSB, it seems
we are continually fighting the
WDFW to not take our seasons and
opportunity or trying to get back
lost opportunity. We now need to
focus on getting new opportunity so
our units aren’t as crowded causing
conflict among bow-hunters.
At the recent WDFW
Commission meetings WSB
expressed approval for the lighted
nock. It’s been a long road and
everything that is going to be said
on this issue has been said. At the end of the day,
the vast majority of our membership supported an
exception to the general rule of no electronics on a
bow. We balanced that interest with all of our users
and issued support for the measure. The Commission
voted to approve the use of lighted nocks for the
upcoming season. This has been the most divisive
issue I’ve faced in my time at the WSB. I’m hoping
we can put this issue to rest and continue to focus on
seasons and opportunity.
-
So, advocating for a way to make one user group more successful. Then something has to be given up to maintain allocation. A slice of general season? Other permits? Spike becomes true spike? If not, then just trying to take allocation from other groups.
Did you read the whole thread or the original post? This is about the branch antlered bull permits only. Pretty small group overall. Much less than the modern firearm numbers given the allocation formula. It is not additional tags only additional days for the few lucky ones who draw a tag.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Yep. And what do you want the WDFW/bios to do when the harvest success goes up by X% on bulls taken by those permits? Cut back on permit numbers or in the general?
Zero. Impact will be minimal. They didn't take away days or permits from modern when they added the 5 day rut hunts in September.
Heck if money is what they want then charge an extra $50 for the archery tag if drawn for the extra 5 days.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
So, advocating for a way to make one user group more successful. Then something has to be given up to maintain allocation. A slice of general season? Other permits? Spike becomes true spike? If not, then just trying to take allocation from other groups.
Did you read the whole thread or the original post? This is about the branch antlered bull permits only. Pretty small group overall. Much less than the modern firearm numbers given the allocation formula. It is not additional tags only additional days for the few lucky ones who draw a tag.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Yep. And what do you want the WDFW/bios to do when the harvest success goes up by X% on bulls taken by those permits? Cut back on permit numbers or in the general?
Zero. Impact will be minimal. They didn't take away days or permits from modern when they added the 5 day rut hunts in September.
Heck if money is what they want then charge an extra $50 for the archery tag if drawn for the extra 5 days.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Let's clarify, which rifle bull hunts are you upset about. September hunts are considered quality hunts and the odds on them are not far below OIL tags. November hunts, with the 14 day season you keep referring to are bull tag hunts. Archery has quality tags and bull tags as well. Some archery bull tags are or atleast were late season tags as in the case of the Teanaway tags. Your quality tags are during the rut just like rifles quality tags.
I would also like to point out that the draw odds for archery tags are far better than rifle tags. A guy is lucky to get more than 1 or 2 chances to hunt Eastside bulls in a lifetime with a rifle. An archery hunter could realistically pull 5x that many in a lifetime. The odds appear to me to be in your favor.
-
But how many of the archery tags are filled compared to rifle permits. They give out less rifle permits cause the odds the rifle permits gets filled is substantially greater. Most of the archery permits go un filled .
-
Such a simple solution- if you think the rifle permits are better than the archery permits, apply for the rifle permits. Everyone can make that choice every year. I do. I've hunted all three, archery, muzzleloader, and rifle. I usually pick the one that fits my schedule best each year. The last few years my priority has been Wyoming hunts. So for elk hunting in Washington I pick the season that conflicts the least with my hunt or hunts in Wyoming.
-
But how many of the archery tags are filled compared to rifle permits. They give out less rifle permits cause the odds the rifle permits gets filled is substantially greater. Most of the archery permits go un filled .
Are you a hunter? Do you need WDFW to tie a bull to a tree for you? If you just want to fill your tag go to one of those ranches in Texas that are pay to play. You chose the hard way, the caveat is, you might not fill your tag. For a rifle guy, the caveat is, you may not draw a tag. Your not the only user group with challenges to face. I had a ML quality bull tag once, I didn't even see a branch bull or hear a bugle during my entire season. I shot a spike with that tag in my pocket on day 5 and I had several days to hunt prior to the general season. All you get is a chance. You want a guarantee, go hunt a high fence ranch.
-
Cow modern you only have 5 days of hunting. In the past I have eaten 2 cow tags and that is the way it is. It is called hunting not shooting. I have eaten several general modern spike tags too! I don't complain about it as I enjoy being out in the outdoors. If I do fill a tag I consider it a bonus. That is hunting. :twocents:
-
I never complained about rifle anything... I simply stated we should have the same as Idaho has for elk. Calling names and trying to pin my style against yours make you look pathetic. You are desperate for an argument and I have none. Don't think we need longer permits. Never said we did. Just pointing out how rediculous you sound trying to pick a fight with the other user groups.
-
I never complained about rifle anything... I simply stated we should have the same as Idaho has for elk. Calling names and trying to pin my style against yours make you look pathetic. You are desperate for an argument and I have none. Don't think we need longer permits. Never said we did. Just pointing out how rediculous you sound trying to pick a fight with the other user groups.
My apologies! It was not you specifically I was calling pathetic but more the "handicap"some bowhunters (IMO) seem to feel they deserve for choosing a difficult style of hunting. I provided info to this thread to refute suggestions of inaccuracies and crooked facts and to let others draw their own conclusions. I am not a hunter hater nor do I wish to divide user groups. Please scour my posting history and you will find I am predominantly a positive member of this site not an internet troll looking for a fight.
This concludes my participation in this thread. I hope you draw the tag you are after this season subsequently followed by the hunt of a lifetime! Whichever weapon you choose to hunt with. Peace in the middle East! Make Love not War!
-
By the way, one of the main reasons the archery season was pushed back was because there was too many animals spoiling. Temps in early september can be into the 90's in some areas. This decision was made from feedback from multiple groups including numerous butcher shops processing wild game. Get your facts straight.
It was actually the WSB who led the charge for season changes, lighted nocks and expandable broadheads. Below is an excerpt from a 2013 issue of WSB magazine. Which is also shortly before the WDFW had their open comment period for the last season setting process.
Our number one goal for next
season is to push the WDFW to hard
set our elk season from September
8-21. My personal goal is to stop
fighting hard to get back seasons
that we lose, and start fighting for
additional seasons and opportunity
for bowhunters. Since I’ve been
a member of the WSB, it seems
we are continually fighting the
WDFW to not take our seasons and
opportunity or trying to get back
lost opportunity. We now need to
focus on getting new opportunity so
our units aren’t as crowded causing
conflict among bow-hunters.
At the recent WDFW
Commission meetings WSB
expressed approval for the lighted
nock. It’s been a long road and
everything that is going to be said
on this issue has been said. At the end of the day,
the vast majority of our membership supported an
exception to the general rule of no electronics on a
bow. We balanced that interest with all of our users
and issued support for the measure. The Commission
voted to approve the use of lighted nocks for the
upcoming season. This has been the most divisive
issue I’ve faced in my time at the WSB. I’m hoping
we can put this issue to rest and continue to focus on
seasons and opportunity.
[/quote
Thank you for this. :dunno: Still not why they changed the season. 2016 Sept 10th. 2017 9th. 2018 Sept 8, 2019 Sept 7, 2020 Sept 5th. Every year the Saturday gets 1 calendar day sooner. So in a few years they will have to push it back again for the same reason.
-
I just got to thinking about this thread and I offer up this thought.
There is a significantly more amount of daylight available in September than there is I'm November. Over the period of 12 days I would guess that the actual amount of time available to hunt would more than make up for the one day difference that our bowhunting friends are crying about. Of course this would need to be broken down to hours, but time in the field is relative to time in the field. Every day cannot be Opening Day.
I therefore suggest that we finance a detailed study to determine how many days should be taken from the BHers and reassigned to the modem firearm hunters.
In lieu of this I suggest you quit whining and go practice bugling, shooting and get in shape.
I'll bet whoever started this thread wishes they hadn't.
Oh yeah, I just greased my boots, good for me.
Later,
Rob.
-
I started it and have no regrets. I also didn't whine just offered a few facts. As to the rest you mentioned it is a year round thing for me. Always in shape, always scouting and always shooting.
Sorry to hit a sore spot with you. If was interesting to see how quick folks resorted to name calling and rude comments.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk