Post by: Rainier10 on April 12, 2024, 07:02:27 AM
I would be for a shed hunting license if it wasn’t just a money grab. If the revenue actually went to more enforcement in the woods that would be great. I get over run with trespassers during shed season. And the closed roads next to me get hammered by guys on motorized pit bikes driving in.
https://www.themeateater.com/conservation/wildlife-management/should-shed-hunting-require-a-license?utm_source=sfmc&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=4.10.24_MeatEater%20%28Shed%20Hunting%20License%29&utm_term=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.themeateater.com%2Fconservation%2Fwildlife-management%2Fshould-shed-hunting-require-a-license&utm_id=1207129&sfmc_id=500202409
Post by: 2MANY on April 12, 2024, 07:18:27 AM
Lock the gates!!!
Man is so damn dumb.
Post by: fishngamereaper on April 12, 2024, 07:40:31 AM
People are crazy...
This goes back to the do you Carry in the woods thread. And this is why I'm always packing a rifle. Besides training like you Hunt I prefer not to be outgunned
And no I don't like the license to shed hunt idea. It's recreation and we already pay enough to do that on public land.
Post by: trophyhunt on April 12, 2024, 07:52:54 AM
You fire warning shots at me you better be really good at concealment and cover cause you just picked a fight your most likely going to looseagree, they don’t need more money, they need to spend what they already get more wisely.
People are crazy...
This goes back to the do you Carry in the woods thread. And this is why I'm always packing a rifle. Besides training like you Hunt I prefer not to be outgunned
And no I don't like the license to shed hunt idea. It's recreation and we already pay enough to do that on public land.
Post by: Mtnwalker on April 12, 2024, 08:30:39 AM
Post by: wafisherman on April 12, 2024, 08:36:27 AM
Don't need to implement a license, just ban the sale of antlers. The guys going for a walk and collecting a few for their pile aren't the problem
Middle ground here - have a license requirement for the sales but the guy collecting a few for his own use is good to go.
Post by: elkrack on April 12, 2024, 09:05:30 AM
License or not the guy shooting in those guys direction is still going to do stupid crap :twocents:
Post by: bearhunter99 on April 12, 2024, 09:06:58 AM
:yeah:Don't need to implement a license, just ban the sale of antlers. The guys going for a walk and collecting a few for their pile aren't the problem
Middle ground here - have a license requirement for the sales but the guy collecting a few for his own use is good to go.
They are technically running a business and I personally think it should be treated as such. The amount of lawlessness (trespassing, wildlife harassment, assault and intimidation) that goes on with some areas that I used to shed hunt has gotten exponentially worse since it essentially became big business.
These guys that are out there intentionally "jumping" the deer herds and stressing out the animals just to get them to drop their sheds. I about got into a very serious situation once when a guy kept pushing this 170's 4 point. The buck had its tongue hanging out and laboring and the damn guy wouldn't leave it alone.
Post by: Mtnwalker on April 12, 2024, 09:16:16 AM
:yeah:Don't need to implement a license, just ban the sale of antlers. The guys going for a walk and collecting a few for their pile aren't the problem
Middle ground here - have a license requirement for the sales but the guy collecting a few for his own use is good to go.
They are technically running a business and I personally think it should be treated as such. The amount of lawlessness (trespassing, wildlife harassment, assault and intimidation) that goes on with some areas that I used to shed hunt has gotten exponentially worse since it essentially became big business.
These guys that are out there intentionally "jumping" the deer herds and stressing out the animals just to get them to drop their sheds. I about got into a very serious situation once when a guy kept pushing this 170's 4 point. The buck had its tongue hanging out and laboring and the damn guy wouldn't leave it alone.
Just wondering how a $100 license is going to lessen the pressure on the animals or insanity of the commercial guys...
Post by: elkrack on April 12, 2024, 09:19:08 AM
:yeah:Don't need to implement a license, just ban the sale of antlers. The guys going for a walk and collecting a few for their pile aren't the problem
Middle ground here - have a license requirement for the sales but the guy collecting a few for his own use is good to go.
They are technically running a business and I personally think it should be treated as such. The amount of lawlessness (trespassing, wildlife harassment, assault and intimidation) that goes on with some areas that I used to shed hunt has gotten exponentially worse since it essentially became big business.
These guys that are out there intentionally "jumping" the deer herds and stressing out the animals just to get them to drop their sheds. I about got into a very serious situation once when a guy kept pushing this 170's 4 point. The buck had its tongue hanging out and laboring and the damn guy wouldn't leave it alone.
Just wondering how a $100 license is going to lessen the pressure on the animals or insanity of the commercial guys...
It’s not going to. Money grab plain and simple
Post by: chukardogs on April 12, 2024, 09:45:23 AM
Post by: A. Cole on April 12, 2024, 09:52:24 AM
Post by: baker5150 on April 12, 2024, 10:52:55 AM
The minute someone fires in my direction on purpose, they're going to wish, they'd gone fishing that day.
This was my thought as well. I'm certainly not going to just continue shed hunting cause "Screw em". I'd prefer not to be killed.
This story seams a little fishy to me. :twocents:
Post by: fishngamereaper on April 12, 2024, 11:04:10 AM
Drug cartel's have long used NF for business. Doing erad back in the day we used to come across allot of crazy stuff in the NF and DFW land.
Not to mention a handful of off grid living crazies that set up shop in weird spots.
Post by: Sandberm on April 12, 2024, 11:24:26 AM
I'm not in Washington at the moment, and haven't been able to shed hunt this year, but I do have two cents on the shed hunting license. Why make more laws/licenses when your not enforcing the ones you already have? Shooting at people is already illegal. Pressuring/harassing wildlife is already illegal. Trespassing is already illegal. If those rules would be enforced, would licenses make any difference?For a young guy you're awful smart. :tup:
People so young who have common sense such as you will have a lifetime of frustration that others will over complicate straight forward things.
Post by: Rainier10 on April 12, 2024, 11:42:05 AM
Post by: OutHouse on April 12, 2024, 11:48:40 AM
Post by: bearhunter99 on April 12, 2024, 01:22:41 PM
:yeah:Don't need to implement a license, just ban the sale of antlers. The guys going for a walk and collecting a few for their pile aren't the problem
Middle ground here - have a license requirement for the sales but the guy collecting a few for his own use is good to go.
They are technically running a business and I personally think it should be treated as such. The amount of lawlessness (trespassing, wildlife harassment, assault and intimidation) that goes on with some areas that I used to shed hunt has gotten exponentially worse since it essentially became big business.
These guys that are out there intentionally "jumping" the deer herds and stressing out the animals just to get them to drop their sheds. I about got into a very serious situation once when a guy kept pushing this 170's 4 point. The buck had its tongue hanging out and laboring and the damn guy wouldn't leave it alone.
Just wondering how a $100 license is going to lessen the pressure on the animals or insanity of the commercial guys...
I don't know maybe it would expose them to the Dept of Revenue? They are technically a business operating without a business license? Make it $1,000 commercial license if they are selling them. Everything else is more expensive as a business. I can pull an L&I electrical permit as a homeowner for $X amount. If a licensed electrical contractor pulls the same permit for the same work it is 3-4 times $X (it has been a while since I have pulled one so no idea the cost these days)
Post by: highcountry_hunter on April 12, 2024, 08:01:03 PM
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Post by: elkslayer069 on April 12, 2024, 08:22:02 PM
Don't need to implement a license, just ban the sale of antlers. The guys going for a walk and collecting a few for their pile aren't the problem
100% agree. You can’t sell the meat so you shouldn’t be able to sell the capes or antlers shed or attached on the skull plate.
Post by: raydog on April 13, 2024, 06:37:59 AM
I’d be against a license 100%. But I would be 100% for a shed hunting opening date. Give the *censored* animals a break
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
:yeah:
Post by: Twispriver on April 13, 2024, 09:37:46 AM
Post by: dilleytech on April 13, 2024, 11:28:02 AM
If I’m walking around in February not shed hunting and come across a shed I’m expected to leave it because it’s not in season? Enforcing animal harassment makes more sense when feasible. Outlawing the selling of antlers makes sense. Sure would be a lot more sheds in the woods if guys were only taking the big ones.
I have bumped a lot of animals shed hunting but never felt One was being pressured . They simple move over the ridge and are safe, usually they sneak
Away and I never see them because it’s not like I’m being quiet. If pushing animals during winter should be illegal then I guess we should outlaw wolves coyotes and cougars.
Post by: pianoman9701 on April 13, 2024, 01:45:01 PM
Post by: buckfvr on April 14, 2024, 09:57:10 AM
Post by: dilleytech on April 16, 2024, 09:16:48 AM
Banning the sale of antlers and hides/capes does nothing to stop idiots from being idiots. When collected responsibly, both are a resource. If you ban hides and cape sales, then that will just be wasted and thrown away by most. Antlers are renewable. I agree with setting dates and strictly enforcing existing laws. I don't agree with additional fees or bans. :twocents:
Banning the sale of antlers would decrease people’s interest in getting as many sheds out of the field as possible. Most of us would still shed hunt but it would certainly decrease effort and competition. It would cut out a lot of those guys who take 2 months off every spring to just shed hunt for profit.
Post by: Feathernfurr on April 16, 2024, 09:44:52 AM
Granted these people are outlaws, that I think to some degree do it for the thrill. You see them go to great extents to not get caught. The ones that get caught are repeat offenders, sometimes accruing thousands in fines that don’t seem to deter them. So the ban of sales would, in my head, just drive the market underground so to speak. It would take a federal effort that would be incredibly difficult to coordinate and enforce.
I’ll tell you though, states are starting to put laws into place to protect their resources, often times at the downfall of their neighboring states. Wyoming has shut down their first week of season to non residents. Meanwhile Wyoming residents are raping Idaho closures, with too little law enforcement manpower across areas of multi agency land to enforce the laws. I can’t tell you the amount of times I’ve watched a timber sled, snow machine, or tracked side by side drive in on an opener, and leave 15 minutes later with 50 plus horns in a bundle.
Regardless of how any of us feel about it, and how the government attempts to manage it, I think we’re all in for a rude awakening in the next decade as to the state of shed hunting. I don’t see a future where our children will get to enjoy it the way we do, unless they’re willing to break the law, or can afford the luxury equipment to make it happen. The shoe lace express can’t keep up with the horses and machines that the money shed hunters will use to over consume.
Post by: CarbonHunter on April 16, 2024, 02:33:35 PM
Problem solved.
Post by: chukardogs on April 16, 2024, 06:41:20 PM
Post by: bigtex on April 16, 2024, 06:44:27 PM
https://www.outdoorlife.com/conservation/idaho-antler-poacher-sentenced/
Post by: bigtex on April 16, 2024, 06:46:45 PM
So you're saying a guy who goes and collects sheds and sells them to a buyer needs a business license? What about the migrants picking forest products, do they need a business license to sell to a buyer? My son used to go wrangle up baseballs near baseball fields and sell them to Play it Again Sports, should he need a business license?I don't know maybe it would expose them to the Dept of Revenue? They are technically a business operating without a business license? Make it $1,000 commercial license if they are selling them. Everything else is more expensive as a business. I can pull an L&I electrical permit as a homeowner for $X amount. If a licensed electrical contractor pulls the same permit for the same work it is 3-4 times $X (it has been a while since I have pulled one so no idea the cost these days)Just wondering how a $100 license is going to lessen the pressure on the animals or insanity of the commercial guys...:yeah:Don't need to implement a license, just ban the sale of antlers. The guys going for a walk and collecting a few for their pile aren't the problemMiddle ground here - have a license requirement for the sales but the guy collecting a few for his own use is good to go.
They are technically running a business and I personally think it should be treated as such. The amount of lawlessness (trespassing, wildlife harassment, assault and intimidation) that goes on with some areas that I used to shed hunt has gotten exponentially worse since it essentially became big business.
These guys that are out there intentionally "jumping" the deer herds and stressing out the animals just to get them to drop their sheds. I about got into a very serious situation once when a guy kept pushing this 170's 4 point. The buck had its tongue hanging out and laboring and the damn guy wouldn't leave it alone.
Post by: Tbar on April 16, 2024, 09:16:04 PM
Hell yes they should have a business license! The state and federal law enforcement should be empowered, this is theft of public resources. Resources held in trust, exploitation should be addressed. As for sheds, it's getting ridiculous. so maybe it's time for the state to step in. If your kids wrangling balls hurts resources then it may need regulation.So you're saying a guy who goes and collects sheds and sells them to a buyer needs a business license? What about the migrants picking forest products, do they need a business license to sell to a buyer? My son used to go wrangle up baseballs near baseball fields and sell them to Play it Again Sports, should he need a business license?I don't know maybe it would expose them to the Dept of Revenue? They are technically a business operating without a business license? Make it $1,000 commercial license if they are selling them. Everything else is more expensive as a business. I can pull an L&I electrical permit as a homeowner for $X amount. If a licensed electrical contractor pulls the same permit for the same work it is 3-4 times $X (it has been a while since I have pulled one so no idea the cost these days)Just wondering how a $100 license is going to lessen the pressure on the animals or insanity of the commercial guys...:yeah:Don't need to implement a license, just ban the sale of antlers. The guys going for a walk and collecting a few for their pile aren't the problemMiddle ground here - have a license requirement for the sales but the guy collecting a few for his own use is good to go.
They are technically running a business and I personally think it should be treated as such. The amount of lawlessness (trespassing, wildlife harassment, assault and intimidation) that goes on with some areas that I used to shed hunt has gotten exponentially worse since it essentially became big business.
These guys that are out there intentionally "jumping" the deer herds and stressing out the animals just to get them to drop their sheds. I about got into a very serious situation once when a guy kept pushing this 170's 4 point. The buck had its tongue hanging out and laboring and the damn guy wouldn't leave it alone.
Post by: Scruffy on April 17, 2024, 01:45:10 AM
Post by: Karl Blanchard on April 17, 2024, 01:29:37 PM
Post by: ducks4days on April 17, 2024, 02:12:47 PM
So you're saying a guy who goes and collects sheds and sells them to a buyer needs a business license? What about the migrants picking forest products, do they need a business license to sell to a buyer? My son used to go wrangle up baseballs near baseball fields and sell them to Play it Again Sports, should he need a business license?I don't know maybe it would expose them to the Dept of Revenue? They are technically a business operating without a business license? Make it $1,000 commercial license if they are selling them. Everything else is more expensive as a business. I can pull an L&I electrical permit as a homeowner for $X amount. If a licensed electrical contractor pulls the same permit for the same work it is 3-4 times $X (it has been a while since I have pulled one so no idea the cost these days)Just wondering how a $100 license is going to lessen the pressure on the animals or insanity of the commercial guys...:yeah:Don't need to implement a license, just ban the sale of antlers. The guys going for a walk and collecting a few for their pile aren't the problemMiddle ground here - have a license requirement for the sales but the guy collecting a few for his own use is good to go.
They are technically running a business and I personally think it should be treated as such. The amount of lawlessness (trespassing, wildlife harassment, assault and intimidation) that goes on with some areas that I used to shed hunt has gotten exponentially worse since it essentially became big business.
These guys that are out there intentionally "jumping" the deer herds and stressing out the animals just to get them to drop their sheds. I about got into a very serious situation once when a guy kept pushing this 170's 4 point. The buck had its tongue hanging out and laboring and the damn guy wouldn't leave it alone.
Yes, and we already do. Commercial foraging requires a license that you can buy on the website.
We should just align this to the existing licensing scheme for foraging other things, and set rules and regs around it, open up and close seasons, etc.. At a minimum, it gives green jeans another lever to pull for people who go overboard. Its not just a charge for harassing wildlife, but can also suspend commercial licensing for sheds for a season or number of years.
Post by: Sneaky Squirrel on April 18, 2024, 10:15:43 AM
:yeah:Don't need to implement a license, just ban the sale of antlers. The guys going for a walk and collecting a few for their pile aren't the problem
Middle ground here - have a license requirement for the sales but the guy collecting a few for his own use is good to go.
They are technically running a business and I personally think it should be treated as such. The amount of lawlessness (trespassing, wildlife harassment, assault and intimidation) that goes on with some areas that I used to shed hunt has gotten exponentially worse since it essentially became big business.
These guys that are out there intentionally "jumping" the deer herds and stressing out the animals just to get them to drop their sheds. I about got into a very serious situation once when a guy kept pushing this 170's 4 point. The buck had its tongue hanging out and laboring and the damn guy wouldn't leave it alone.
Just wondering how a $100 license is going to lessen the pressure on the animals or insanity of the commercial guys...
I don't know maybe it would expose them to the Dept of Revenue? They are technically a business operating without a business license? Make it $1,000 commercial license if they are selling them. Everything else is more expensive as a business. I can pull an L&I electrical permit as a homeowner for $X amount. If a licensed electrical contractor pulls the same permit for the same work it is 3-4 times $X (it has been a while since I have pulled one so no idea the cost these days)
The above is a flat out lie. Electrical Business and Homeowners fill out the same permit app as each other and the permit is the same cost for each.... It's been this way for the last 20+ years. Maybe you haven't pulled a permit in that time.... I won't argue with you that there is additional cost of running a business but this isn't one of them.
Post by: Sneaky Squirrel on April 18, 2024, 10:34:30 AM
I'm not in Washington at the moment, and haven't been able to shed hunt this year, but I do have two cents on the shed hunting license. Why make more laws/licenses when your not enforcing the ones you already have? Shooting at people is already illegal. Pressuring/harassing wildlife is already illegal. Trespassing is already illegal. If those rules would be enforced, would licenses make any difference?
:yeah:
Same page