Hunting Washington Forum

Big Game Hunting => Elk Hunting => Topic started by: joebear on November 05, 2009, 06:30:03 PM


Advertise Here
Title: wasted elk!!!
Post by: joebear on November 05, 2009, 06:30:03 PM
So on the 31st a good friend of mine was hunting out of Ellensburg. He and his Friends son where looking down a draw and spotted a herd of elk. They saw a elk that looked like a spike so they went to get a closer look. as they got closer they noticed that it was not a true spike. so they sat down and started glassing again. They spotted a few hunters. These two hunters that they saw where making a move on the not true spike not to long after they watched them shoot and kill this elk! The two hunters walked up to the elk and noticed that it was not a true spike the shooter picked up the head and put it down then the two of them walked away!! My friend called his partner on the cell and let him know what was going on. His partner headed to the road to get a view of the truck and maybe a lic number. Then the cops where called and down to there camp they went. My friend told them that was the man that pulled the trigger and they told him to leave while they talked to them and that they would talk to him later.
The cops called him and they met for a wright up and he found out that the guy is a MASTER HUNTER AND A HUNTER SAFTEY INSTUCTOR. Also this man that did the shooting tried to tell the cops that my friend was the shooter but he did not call them because he did not want to make waves!! With this all said the cops went back up to the elk and cut off the head and left the rest of the elk what a joke.!!!!!   If this guy that did the shooting is a member of this sight and only you know who you are!! I think you are low worthless man. All you did is make all of us that love hunting look bad. I hope I never meet you.
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: markts on November 05, 2009, 06:32:36 PM
 :bash: :bash: :bash: :bash:Mark
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: WAPITIHUNTER on November 05, 2009, 06:35:45 PM
That makes me want to :puke:

That is freaking pathetic. How freaking hard is it to identify your quarry?
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: BLKBEARKLR on November 05, 2009, 06:37:22 PM
Joebear,  I totally agree with all the you said, and I know this was not you but just asking what would you do in this scenerio??


I am asking this because one time in Alaska I was on a moose, I watched  him for about 25 minutes and knew he was not legal when I seen a couple of other hunters on the ridge. I watched them for a few minutes and actually threw the bino's up on them and seen that they were about to get into a good rest to pull the trigger. I put 3 rounds into the dirt about 25 yards from me and that scared the moose off and it also startled the crap out of them. I caught up to them later in the day, and told them the moose was not even close to being legal and their comment was well at that distance it looked legal. So just asking if anyone would have done the same thing??

Like I said I know it was not you that observed but justy looking for opinions???

Joe
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: joebear on November 05, 2009, 06:43:41 PM
Joebear,  I totally agree with all the you said, and I know this was not you but just asking what would you do in this scenerio??


I am asking this because one time in Alaska I was on a moose, I watched  him for about 25 minutes and knew he was not legal when I seen a couple of other hunters on the ridge. I watched them for a few minutes and actually threw the bino's up on them and seen that they were about to get into a good rest to pull the trigger. I put 3 rounds into the dirt about 25 yards from me and that scared the moose off and it also startled the crap out of them. I caught up to them later in the day, and told them the moose was not even close to being legal and their comment was well at that distance it looked legal. So just asking if anyone would have done the same thing??

Like I said I know it was not you that observed but justy looking for opinions???

Joe
Well BB It really depends on how far I was away. Also hunting in AK you do not have as many hunters in the area.
This guy that did the shooting probley would not of even thought twice about someone else shooting. I think I would have well I better not say. I love my hunting rights and hate anybody that does STUPUD crap that help the Gov have a reason to think they can take them away from us enough said!!!!!
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: carpsniperg2 on November 05, 2009, 06:45:13 PM
bad deal i might of been tempted to go get some meat myself i don't know how long the whole deal took but if it wasn't to long i would of asked the cops if they cared had them right a note saying that i did not kill it but was using my tag and took the animal instead of leavin it there that is a bad deal for sure i don't think my plan would of worked but i would of give a shot a elk is such a great animal in my eyes to not respect it is a shame know what you are shooting at before you shoot to the *censored* that did it if he reads this post
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: BLKBEARKLR on November 05, 2009, 06:46:01 PM
good thoughts Joebear, like I said was just asking opinions, I did not look at it that way as they might not even have noticed the shots being fired.
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: joebear on November 05, 2009, 06:49:21 PM
good thoughts Joebear, like I said was just asking opinions, I did not look at it that way as they might not even have noticed the shots being fired.
No prob BB I think you di the right thing in ak!!
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: stumprat on November 05, 2009, 06:52:17 PM
Sounds like the shooter holds 3 titles.
Master Hunter
Hunter safety instructor
AND LIAR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: rasbo on November 05, 2009, 06:58:21 PM
 :bash: :bash:I worried about this true spike deal and that happening...guy should lose his right to hunt for a while..If your not positive dont shoot...Damn!
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: stumprat on November 05, 2009, 06:59:49 PM
At least man up to a mistake!
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: rasbo on November 05, 2009, 07:01:20 PM
At least man up to a mistake!
Im sure we wont hear that
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: stumprat on November 05, 2009, 07:03:32 PM
At least man up to a mistake!
Im sure we wont hear that



 >:(Of course not.
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: Huntbear on November 05, 2009, 07:03:50 PM
WTF!!!! What a waste of elk, and what a FRICCCCKKKKIN MORON!!!!!!!!!!!!!!  Stupid People PISS ME OFF!!!!  Liars are even worse!!!!!!!!!!
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: BENCHLEG on November 05, 2009, 07:09:36 PM
you had it all and you didn't get your points.
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: nw_bowhunter on November 05, 2009, 07:10:24 PM
What is the point of the game warden cutting the head off and letting it go to waste? Why not donate the animal to food shelter or offer it to the guy who turned the hunters in? If so would you have been willing to tag if you had the option?
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: sako223 on November 05, 2009, 07:32:52 PM
Another master hunter bites the dust. Wonder if he will continue to be an instructor.
Mistakes can truly happen to anyone. You still have to take responsibility and more so if you leave. Lazy on the part of the officer. Nearly every time I have been around the officer looks for a home for the meat and most often makes the offender pack it out.
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: Swiftkid on November 05, 2009, 07:38:13 PM
There can only be a handful of safety instructors in the area, someone needs to find this guy!
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: eastsidebugle on November 05, 2009, 07:52:42 PM
In such an instance the warden should have tried to recover the slug and pursue the case. that is their job.  They screw off 7 months out of the year.  I know for a fact that around my parts that wouldnt have gone down that way.  It is everyone of ours responsibility to see to it that they do their jobs and we do ours.  I have no problems with game management officials, they have a job and duty just like any of us do at our jobs.  As for donating the animal for use at a foodbank etc. that hasnt been utilized in Wa. state for years.. to much liability or some bureaucratic B.S.  If things were as stated the witnesss(s) should have been alotted the ten points in the case of conviction.  Some Gamies dont deserve the title or the job though and that is just how our society works!
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: NW-GSP on November 05, 2009, 08:31:41 PM
I would do the same thing as you,

Joebear,  I totally agree with all the you said, and I know this was not you but just asking what would you do in this scenerio??


I am asking this because one time in Alaska I was on a moose, I watched  him for about 25 minutes and knew he was not legal when I seen a couple of other hunters on the ridge. I watched them for a few minutes and actually threw the bino's up on them and seen that they were about to get into a good rest to pull the trigger. I put 3 rounds into the dirt about 25 yards from me and that scared the moose off and it also startled the crap out of them. I caught up to them later in the day, and told them the moose was not even close to being legal and their comment was well at that distance it looked legal. So just asking if anyone would have done the same thing??

Like I said I know it was not you that observed but justy looking for opinions???

Joe
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: jstone on November 06, 2009, 08:31:28 AM
P O S.... This is a person that teaches our kids.  :bash: :bash: :bash:
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: WSU on November 06, 2009, 08:44:00 AM
I'm not suprised that they didn't try to salvage the meat.  I reported something up the Clockum, and talked to a gamie prior to that.  He had a big bull in the back of his rig and was driving about 50 mph up the clockum road to respond to all the calls he had.  The officer I reported to had been working nonstop all weekend and was in Monday morning early trying to catch up on all the calls and messages he had.  It was probably a case of too much to do and not enough time to do.  According to the officer I talked to, there were only 2 to 3 officers working the whole clockum area.  They are spread awefully thin...
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: fishm@n on November 06, 2009, 08:50:12 AM
That's why they call the Master Hunter volunteer hours work sheet, the liar sheet. I know the WDFW has been trying to put more teeth into that program. This kind of thing should make them think about making the whole lot retest and hopefully weed out vermin like that guy!
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: MagKarl on November 06, 2009, 10:44:27 AM
This is not the first story involving criminal behavior committed by someone with "MH" status.  Though I support the idea of the MH program and those who participate lawfully, I refuse to participate myself as I will not in any way be associated with a group that includes in it's membership those that commit these sort of offenses.  What a disgrace. 
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: jackelope on November 06, 2009, 10:48:19 AM
was it a cop or a game warden? you said cop. i don't see that a cop would even touch the animal without first calling wdfw.

i have a hard time with the fact they cut the head off and left the rest lay. never heard of that happening before.

Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: Elkohol on November 06, 2009, 11:29:20 AM
There can only be a handful of safety instructors in the area, someone needs to find this guy!

If you got the guys name you should probably throw it out there, who wants their kids learning from that guy? i know i sure wouldn't. And if he didn't pay for what he did by losing his licence, he should at least have to pay through shame..
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: Galpster on November 06, 2009, 11:40:31 AM
Yes, If you know who it is let us know. I will not be bringing my son to that class!! What a jerk andwhat a waste!!
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: BLKBEARKLR on November 06, 2009, 03:03:51 PM
There can only be a handful of safety instructors in the area, someone needs to find this guy!

If you got the guys name you should probably throw it out there, who wants their kids learning from that guy? i know i sure wouldn't. And if he didn't pay for what he did by losing his licence, he should at least have to pay through shame..

Throwing a name out there is also called slandering until the guy is proven guilty. I myself no matter what I seen or was involved with would never put a name out there, I myself VALUE everything that I have. Not saying that I disagree with it, I am just saying it is a  :bdid: :bdid:   to do that.   
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: WDFW-SUX on November 06, 2009, 03:15:16 PM
Does his name start with the letter "N"?
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: woodswalker on November 06, 2009, 06:51:08 PM
Another master hunter bites the dust. Wonder if he will continue to be an instructor.
Mistakes can truly happen to anyone. You still have to take responsibility and more so if you leave. Lazy on the part of the officer. Nearly every time I have been around the officer looks for a home for the meat and most often makes the offender pack it out.

As a HE instructor and a MH...I can TELL you that he is DONE with both if convicted...and is suspended from HE and I think MH until its run its course. Even so he may get booted even if not convicted...under the color of making the program look bad.

And we as HE instructors WILL know about it.
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: THINK_N_ELK on November 07, 2009, 12:27:48 PM
In my opinion.   This person not only needs to lose hunting privileges.  But also removed from the Master Hunter program.  As well as having is Hunter Instructor credentials revoked to never be given back.  A person that hunts like that does not to teaching our younger generation his type of Hunting Ethics.  His hunting partner needs to lose his privilege for a couple years as well.  Just for being willing to cover it up by walking away.

As far as the animal goes.  It should have been given to a food bank.  The meat would go a long way, feeding the hungry.

 >:(

Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: C-Money on November 08, 2009, 09:10:12 AM
Wounder what area this guy is from. I have a couple youngsters that need to go threw hunters ed soon. Hope he was not from Moses Lake. Very sad that you had him pegged, and the guy was let go. Damn shame. So I guess AHE and hunters ed teachers words are more powerful than an average hunter. That is to bad! :bdid:
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: luvtohnt on November 08, 2009, 10:51:19 AM
First off the MH program was revamped this summer, they changed it from a master hunter card to a master hunter permit, because under state law they can revoke a permit without going through the courts. So I guarentee that he lost his MH status. I would also be willing to bet that he lost his HE credentials as well. He definatly deserves it. Now the game warden only cutting off the head, there are multiple factors against him here. The first being time, he would have to drive all the way to Cle Elum to get it to a proccesor, as well as the time it would take to drag it out. I personally would rather see him responding to ather calls then wasting time trying to save some meat. However if asked I would see no reason to not allow a hunter with a un-notched tag get use from the carcass. Cutting the head off was done to preserve evidence, he will now be able to show the jury what it was that he shot. I really wish there was a way to get the low-lifes out of the MH program, because I feel like it makes me less credable to carry that status!!

Brandon
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: C-Money on November 08, 2009, 05:38:42 PM
Hope that the Officer has a case to nail the guy. He should not have tried to peg someone els for the illeagle kill. Hope it ends well for honest hunters, and 10 points for turning in a poacher!
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: eastside boy on November 08, 2009, 06:52:21 PM
WTF!!!  I have run into way to many master hunters that have their heads up their asses.....I do know a couple of good ones, but others I have caught trespassing, cutting cross country in places where your not supposed to, and doing crap like what this thread is about.  Damn morons......has anyone else here run into MHs that are total dumb asses or have I just had bad luck?
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: AKBowman on November 08, 2009, 07:00:59 PM
What a piece of $hit...I hope I never meet you as well and I hope the guy who tried didnt get your plate number cuz if he did I would not want to be you!! You know who you are.

On a side not, Joe you shoot the shoot at Skookum yesterday...I ended up with three Wideon.
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: huntnphool on November 08, 2009, 07:10:25 PM
I'm sure the accused will have his name revealed in due time.
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: dbllunger on November 08, 2009, 07:45:09 PM
Illegal spike killing is no different then when we went to spike only.  Lots of branch antlered bulls killed.  Every one I saw had the head cut off by a gamie.  First off the bottom line is that it is the hunters responsibility to ensure the animal was legal regardless of distance or any other reason.  He should have taken care of the animal and take the lumps/citation he deserved.  Cops would not be involved in the interviewing and investigation of this case other then maybe the initial call.  A gamie had to have handled it.  The gamie can not make anyone pack out a animal, and he dang sure did not have time to do it.  I would rather have him out working then packing an elk out all day long.  As far as the MH and instructor issue goes I think he should and probably will lose both of those.   
I got stopped by a WSP Trooper this year (speeding) with a quartered out elk in the back of the truck.  He really ran me through the wringer on checking it out and how it was supposed to be tagged and other things.  Pretty much forgot about the speeding after seeing the elk foot sticking out.  He did not know the law specifically, but he knew enough to ask questions and call a gamie.  It took about 30 minutes and he then said "It looks like you are doing everything on the up and up, congratulations have a nice day sorry it took so long ".  I thanked him for checking and told him to continue to keep checking hunters and making sure they are legal.  We need more non gamie cops checking hunters.  Oh yeah he gave me a warning for speeding and another violation.  Had he given me a ticket you would not see me wanking about it as yes I was speeding and had the illegal equipment in use.
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: Alaska316 on November 08, 2009, 09:18:39 PM
Sad, what  a waste. There will be more animals left on hillsides with the true spike rule.
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: G.R.K on November 08, 2009, 10:19:08 PM
Nothing goes to waste in the woods.  :dunno:
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: Bob33 on November 09, 2009, 12:47:08 PM
If this individual is convicted he will be removed from the Master Hunter program for life.  That is a 100% certainty.  The Master Hunter program has a zero tolerance policy.

If convicted he will be cited and fined, and may lose hunting equipment used.

If convicted he will likely be disbarred from being an accredited Hunter Education instructor as well.

Enforcement is aware of this; let's allow them to do their job and hope they can convict him if he is indeed guilty.
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: jackelope on November 09, 2009, 01:53:20 PM
was it a cop or a game warden? you said cop. i don't see that a cop would even touch the animal without first calling wdfw.

i have a hard time with the fact they cut the head off and left the rest lay. never heard of that happening before.


:dunno:
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: Galpster on November 09, 2009, 04:00:12 PM
If he does go to court then it is public record and then you can post his name and charge he is being accused of. So f anyone sees charges to people let us know. Then it is not slander!!
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: DOUBLELUNG on November 09, 2009, 04:27:46 PM
The game warden cannot force someone to pack out an illegally killed elk.  However, he can give him the option of salvaging the carcass and turning it over to the officer, or be charged with wastage once the carcass sours. 

I too prefer to see them out checking hunters and responding to violation calls, to salvaging carcasses. 
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!fo
Post by: THINK_N_ELK on November 09, 2009, 07:47:31 PM
All the Enforcement Officer can do is make his case.  It is up to the Prosecuting Attorney to get the conviction.  Unfortunately game violation convictions are not a high priority with them. 

In my opinion, I think that is mainly due to them being uninformed.  I think when they become more informed there will be more conviction with stiffer fines and penalties.
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: steen on December 07, 2009, 12:09:33 PM
I don't know where you are from but in Whatcom County our Game Wardens work hard to prosecute unlawfull shooting of animals and work real close with the caller.  I teach hunter safety and am saddened by the fact that this person got away with it and is still teaching hunter safety classes.  My husband and his friends are on the phone alot trying to nail some repeat poachers.  Twice friends or family has received 10 bonus points for calling and getting a prosecution.  You're a Red Neck if you have your local game warden on speed dial.  I've elk hunted only once but see alot of wasted animals, unfortunetely the special permits reflect it.  It is up to you and I to help the game wardens with evidence, there are only two in our county.  Do the math, 40 hours a week and alot of country to cover. 
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: colockumelk on December 08, 2009, 03:43:52 PM
Sad, what  a waste. There will be more animals left on hillsides with the true spike rule.

The rule is not the problem.  The problem is irresponsible people who do not take the time to check what they're shooting at. 

There is no such thing as an accidental discharge or an accidental killing.  There is only NEGLIGANCE!!!!!
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: Elkster on December 08, 2009, 08:22:12 PM
This guy is not the only Master Hunter who does not obey hunting rules and regulations.  Every year, I watch some clowns  shoot off of the hoods of their trucks on a paved road in the Mossyrock Unit. They just drive the paved roads and cut off the elk as they run the fields.  I guess my image of a "Master Hunter" is a little different that what the state has in mind. 
This Master Hunter permit season occurs in late January when the elk are out grazing in pastures because they have been starving from running for the past 5 months of being hunted.  It is a also a 2-1 deal with the cows since they have been bred for the past couple of months.  Great game management by WDFW department. :P  This is a topic of discussion by itself.
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: stickthrower on December 09, 2009, 11:14:01 AM
 I have read thru most of this thread and have to ask does anyone know, for sure not rumor , this dumb ass was a M/H? I was over there on the rifle opener on stand by to help the wardens pack elk out to the mission. I didn't get a call or hear about this??? There was a email out to the master hunters to help by skining and packing the meat out to go to the mission in Yakama. The game guys dont want to wast an elk!! As far as i heard there were 3 elk packed out by M/H.. The master hunters were the guys that passed out the flyers on the NEW TRUE spike rule on the entry points to the clockem so incase there was that one guy that didnt read the rules.
 
 What i did hear (rumor) By 8:00 am there were over 40 calls into the games about hunting problems. From guys on quads to hunting on privet lands. Maybe the game guys were pissing away there time because someone couldn't read NO TRESPASSING??? 

 But If the guy IS or was a M/H he IS no longer. It only takes an accusation to get the permit pulled.  The gamys are there to enforce the laws that will ensure we all have the opportunity to hunt in the future. For those that don't think they work hard your way off base!! Try working 5:00am till 7:00-8:00pm ten sitting in a field till 10:00-11:00 hazing elk / doing paperwork. Like previous posters Help these guys out !!   

 So I hope  everyone had a good season. Thank for the vent seasion.

 jcl

   
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: SGM R on December 10, 2009, 01:29:24 PM
I considered the MH program, but now I thinking not! Good job on turning him in, you did absolutely the right thing..

Thanks
Title: Re: wasted elk!!!
Post by: coachcw on December 21, 2009, 06:56:55 AM
In no way do I think what was done was excusible . but I think that the game dept needs to concider going to a browtined bull rule rather than a true spike . It seems to me that alot of small fork bulls are getting killed just to be left to rot. I know that there's no excuse for not properlly iding your game but alot of the guys out hunting only get out once a year and some of wich I'm sure are hung over . Thats why I avoid the riffle season like the plauge .
SimplePortal 2.3.7 © 2008-2025, SimplePortal