Hunting Washington Forum

Big Game Hunting => Elk Hunting => Topic started by: Bearhunter on January 05, 2010, 10:55:10 AM


Advertise Here
Title: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Bearhunter on January 05, 2010, 10:55:10 AM
Well it was just a matter of time before the Anti's put some crappy video together so all there Earth Muffin Granola crunchers could join in on a tear for the Soulless animals that were sacrificed for mere pleasure and trophy bragging rights.  What a crock of *censored*, these people are so brain washed its like they all were born and raised in a compound were there mothers all screwed there God sent leader.  What is this world turning into, its were frightening...  Save the ELK'S

Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Bearhunter on January 05, 2010, 10:55:47 AM
This should probably be moved to the Elk hunting Category.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: WDFW-SUX on January 05, 2010, 11:08:22 AM
Thats awesome.. :chuckle:

So do any of the Pollyanna's still want to make friends with these people?
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Ray on January 05, 2010, 11:11:06 AM
Fact is - if the compound archers could have reserved judgement not to shoot the animals when there was a crowd brewing on the highway there might not be a silly video.

If that's called making friends then you must not use the English language.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: WDFW-SUX on January 05, 2010, 11:13:37 AM
It doesn't matter what happens they are always going to have plenty of stuff to make there little movies with. 
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Ray on January 05, 2010, 11:14:04 AM
That's a pretty weak argument for bad judgement.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: robb92 on January 05, 2010, 11:14:35 AM
It doesn't matter what happens they are always going to have plenty of stuff to make there little movies with. 


So true so true!!!!
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Ray on January 05, 2010, 11:15:29 AM
Might as well just start shooting them more often next to the highway where cars are buzzing by and people are gawking. Give them all you can. They got it on the news. Might as well make national headlines. It would be good for the sport I guess.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: WDFW-SUX on January 05, 2010, 11:15:58 AM
I think apologizing for a legal hunt is a really really bad idea. 

Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Ray on January 05, 2010, 11:16:29 AM
But that's a lie. Nobody apologized.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: rasbo on January 05, 2010, 11:18:22 AM
very poor judgement by the hunters,and that video will change many minds against the sport..Better off rounding them up and shooting them and giving the meat to charity.I would rather them be transplanted
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Ray on January 05, 2010, 11:20:46 AM
Even if it wasn't preventable it is at least something to try and avoid.

Legal only equates to justified. It doesn't mean sound judgement was used all around.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Bearhunter on January 05, 2010, 11:24:19 AM
Ray, this show that went down is nothing new up there.  Its been happening every year for I dont know how long now, and every year there a incodents but the state keep leaving it open and not making changes for the better.  The State can make changes to help incodents like this from happening but they will have a hell of a time in changing the way a lot of hunters think and act and use there judgement/ethics.  I honestly believe that the officers that we pay should have stepped in and stopped the hunt or moved the bystanders off the road.  There were bad decisions made by all partys.  I refuse to partake in this hunt because its not my style, but there are a lot of guys that see it as an easy meat hunt.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Ray on January 05, 2010, 11:27:48 AM
That sounds sensible to me. I agree that the game department played a role in this matter. That's a slippery slope to declare  a hunt legal and open and then just stop the hunt because of a field decision. I think that would be a bad precedent. Which is nearly what happened but not quite. These guys were legally allowed to finish their work for the day. I do understand the ill feelings I just do not agree with every single one which has been presented.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: WDFW-SUX on January 05, 2010, 11:30:21 AM
Here is my question..Does a hunt become more "ethical" because the public isnt watching?  what if the hunt is videoed and posted on youtube at a later date? what if photos are posted online?  What if a commercial video is made and sold? The public See's it all the same right?

Just because I choose not to hunt that way doesn't mean that its wrong.

traps
damage hunts
baiting
hounds

lots of people enjoy all of them and some dont.  to each his own.

Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Ray on January 05, 2010, 11:32:04 AM
It's not a matter of ethics. It's a matter of sense. The public doesn't see it all in the same light until it is forced on their television set by some tree hugger who distorts the truth. Fact is - yes these things will happen. Should we not avoid these events if we can see they are about to happen?
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Axle on January 05, 2010, 11:35:26 AM
I find it interesting the a reporter/photographer just happened to be driving by at the right time.

There are some really screwed up anti hunters out there. I would also bet that those who were against the harvest eat meat on a daily basis.

I have known people who, if this was Indians doing this, they would say - 'oh look at that, the Indians are hunting to feed their families'.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Broken Arrow on January 05, 2010, 11:36:30 AM
Lots of folks who don't like what others do, be it hunting, politics, religion, etc.  My grandfather used to say...."if everyone in the world all thought the same, wouldn't it be a boring place?" Hunting is a way of life for many of us, and we will never change the views who believe differently. Its easier for me to just focus on what i can control, try to live a good life, be ethical, follow the laws and educate when you can. The rest God can figure out in the end.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: rasbo on January 05, 2010, 11:37:13 AM
I feel the same about the hunting videos..much as I love to hunt and harvest an animal,I dont need to show off the kill shot or the death scene to enjoy it.thats just me Im not pushing an attitude.But the more publicity given to the antis the tuffer it will be down the road for all of us...
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: WDFW-SUX on January 05, 2010, 11:38:07 AM
Quote
Should we not avoid these events if we can see they are about to happen?

People can choose to watch or not to watch.  its up to them.  There is a legitimate reason for these type of hunts.  If you dont like them just drive on by.

Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: COUG on January 05, 2010, 11:39:13 AM
I am a bow hunter and that was just the wrong solution to the problem.  

Imagine the call the head of the game dept. got after that one.  

This is not what we needed.

COUG
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Ray on January 05, 2010, 11:40:29 AM
There are lines where something becomes REAL fuel for the anti hunting community. I'm not sure I can draw all of those lines in the sand but this incident definitely was one of them. They had several elements to fuel a good fire. Most photos or videos would not bother the general public.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Ray on January 05, 2010, 11:41:15 AM
Quote
Should we not avoid these events if we can see they are about to happen?

People can choose to watch or not to watch.  its up to them.  There is a legitimate reason for these type of hunts.  If you dont like them just drive on by.



They are really not choosing to watch when it is brought into their living room on the news channel unannounced.

Nobody has questioned legality. You keep referring to that.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Bearhunter on January 05, 2010, 11:42:11 AM
The game department could have stepped in and called it a safety hazard?  The fact of the matter is there was plenty of time to fiqure out what to do.  The Elk were there from Daylight 7:30ish until after 12:00 noon.  
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Hillbilly270 on January 05, 2010, 11:45:21 AM
are they just questioning bowhunting?  what if they shot'em with rifles?
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: WDFW-SUX on January 05, 2010, 11:47:09 AM
Its an interesting issue.  Highly public area and real damage complaints..what do you do?  The game dept decided that low KE weapons were the ticket to ensure public safety but didnt realize the social implications of killing with arrows.  

Is killing with arrows in public ethical?

There probably isn't an answer to this problem that wont piss someone off...
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: the1rod on January 05, 2010, 11:53:02 AM
The only thing i see questionable about this hunt, is why is it archery? if it is a damage control hunt, and they jsut want to get them out of there why not use rifles? i mean dont most bow hunters hunt with a bow for the increased challenge? it jsut seems to me that a rifle season would better fit the need. other than that, the anit's were way out of line. couldent some of the hunters thay they show sue for slander? man i would love to see that.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: COUG on January 05, 2010, 12:13:59 PM
If I ruled the world...

Expand the current hunting regulations for the unit until the numbers start to decline.  If this doesn't work round then up and euthanize.  Give the meat to the needy.

Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: hunt4 on January 05, 2010, 01:46:47 PM
The only thing i see questionable about this hunt, is why is it archery? if it is a damage control hunt, and they jsut want to get them out of there why not use rifles?

Because east to west you could almost shoot a rifle from one end of the unit to the other ;)...almost.  and i am sure you could shoot a rifle over the unit the other direction north to south
and there are plenty of houses
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Shootmoore on January 05, 2010, 02:00:46 PM
The only thing i see questionable about this hunt, is why is it archery? if it is a damage control hunt, and they jsut want to get them out of there why not use rifles?

Because east to west you could almost shoot a rifle from one end of the unit to the other ;)...almost.  and i am sure you could shoot a rifle over the unit the other direction north to south
and there are plenty of houses

Pretty much this.  Most of the properties are the 5 to 10 acre variety.  0 field of safe fire in any direction.  Even muzzys in the past were a little to long ranged in my opinion.

I'm hoping that they come up with something next year, weather its a limited draw or they start thinking outside the box.  something like the quality goose hunt writ large or something to this affect.  The herd needs to be thinned but I don't want hunters to loose the op to hunt it.  (maybe West side tag holders could toss there name in before the season for dated hunts or something)

Shootmoore
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: h2ofowlr on January 05, 2010, 02:20:39 PM
Unfortunately many unedited videos that make there way to youtube are going to end up in the hands of the anti-hunting community and they will come to haunt the hunting community.  Not because anything illegal happened, just do to the ignorance of the anti hunters and the claims of animal suffering.  There will be a day that they will try to charge a hunter for legally harvesting an animal with animal cruelty due the method used or poor shot placement and the animal doesn't expire right away.  Just a matter of time in the good old state of Washington. 
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: haus on January 05, 2010, 02:39:47 PM
Well it was just a matter of time before the Anti's put some crappy video together so all there Earth Muffin Granola crunchers could join in on a tear for the Soulless animals that were sacrificed for mere pleasure and trophy bragging rights.  What a crock of *censored*, these people are so brain washed its like they all were born and raised in a compound were there mothers all screwed there God sent leader.  What is this world turning into, its were frightening...  Save the ELK'S

Crappy video? It doesn't take much effort to make a propaganda video when someone else does it for you. I dunno why they even edited and chopped, it was adequate in raw form. Just pick a section, hit play and be treated to several minutes of damn near pets being shot, did any of those elk have names?  :dunno:   :chuckle: I'm sure the shooters had some alfalfa in their free hand, I'm impressed that they hid it from the camera!!!!

I wish I could ask those "hunters" na just tell them.  :violent1: Aside from the ethics and laws reasonings; What ya did takes a special kind of stupid, a special kind of ignorance. If you couldn't equate that your fish in a barrel demonstration in full view along a well used public highway would have consequences for the rest of us, then Darwinism has failed. :chuckle:

I mean I'll admit I've done some dumb **** in my day legal or not legal, the law is not founded on a principle such as respectful judgement, but at least those things were in a manner that would only hurt me and not others, directly or indirectly. Well maybe someone was wondering where their backyard pet buck went....... :chuckle:
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: bigbeamhunter on January 05, 2010, 03:51:36 PM
even it was legal,it show no sportsmanship .ive always said there are people that are hunters and people who just go hunting ...and in my opinion that wasnt either . iwent to grays river about ten years ago and seen the same thing.i like to hunt em eat em hate to see them suffer..they just made a bad choice
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Skillet on January 05, 2010, 03:58:16 PM
I'm both impressed with the tenacity of those who will still argue in support of this as a "hunt" and dissappointed by their lack of vision.

No matter how many times or different ways you say the same thing, it doesn't change the fact that our hunting privileges (NOT rights) are for us to protect, and we ignore the negative impressions made upon the voting public by public displays like this at our own peril.  We have historically enjoyed their support, but with the bad press circulating around this, we should not take it for granted.  The attitude of "It is legal, so if anybody doesn't like what I am doing, tough" being displayed here by the few is not productive and runs contrary to the impression we need to support that hunters in general are a thinking, aware and ethical group of people.  It may not be legal for long.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: bearpaw on January 05, 2010, 04:17:30 PM
I just watched the anti video, and I have seen the news footage before.

While I don't agree with the guys shooting those elk while a crowd watched, here is the first thing that popped into my mind when I started watching the elk being shot at again that were wounded:

If those bowhunters were wolves, the crowd would have been cheering them on, but since it was human bowhunters they are hated by the same people who would be cheering on the wolves.

It's not that those antis are so concerned about an animal suffering, they really could care less about deer and elk, that is just a smoke screen to accomplish there goal of keeping people from hunting. They hate society and people...... :dunno:

Like i said, throw a pack of wolves in the field and they woiuld be cheering while the elk were eaten alive.... :twocents:

That my friends is the sad truth.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: WDFW-SUX on January 05, 2010, 04:19:00 PM
good post.

I think that anytime they can misrepresent a situation they will.  Ignoring the damage control aspect of this hunt by the media and anti's is not surprising.  Its much easier to vilify than explain the legitimate reasons for the hunt.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: high country on January 05, 2010, 04:20:21 PM
Fact is - if the compound archers could have reserved judgement not to shoot the animals when there was a crowd brewing on the highway there might not be a silly video.

If that's called making friends then you must not use the English language.

or if WDFW had enforced the law.....there would not have been a crowd.
REVISED CODE OF WASHINGTON ANNOTATED
TITLE 77. GAME AND GAME FISH
CHAPTER 77.16. PROHIBITED ACTS AND PENALTIES
 
77.16.340. Obstructing the taking of fish or wildlife--Penalty--Defenses
(1) A person commits the crime of obstructing the taking of fish or wildlife if the person:

(a) Harasses, drives, or disturbs fish or wildlife with the intent of disrupting lawful pursuit or taking thereof; or
(b) Harasses, interferes with, or intimidates an individual engaged in the lawful taking of fish or wildlife or lawful predator control.


(2) Violation of this section is a gross misdemeanor under RCW 77.21.010.

(3) It is a defense to any prosecution under subsection (1) of this section, if the person charged:

(a) Interferes with any person engaged in hunting outside legally established hunting seasons;
(b) Is preventing or attempting to prevent the injury or killing of a protected wildlife species, as defined by this title;

(c) Is preventing or attempting to prevent unauthorized trespass on private property; or

(d) Is defending oneself or another person from bodily harm or property damage by a person attempting to prevent hunting in a legally established hunting season.


Enacted by Laws 1988, ch. 265, § 1, eff. July 1, 1988.
 
 
 
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: bearpaw on January 05, 2010, 04:20:42 PM
The members on this forum are more concerned about pain and suffering of deer and elk than the antis really are.... :twocents:
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: WDFW-SUX on January 05, 2010, 04:23:04 PM
Quote
Harasses, interferes with, or intimidates an individual engaged in the lawful taking of fish or wildlife or lawful predator control

Id say the individuals involved in this have been harassed wouldnt you?
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Axle on January 05, 2010, 04:48:53 PM
Bear in mind folks, if the onlookers were a hungry crowd, it would have a totally different twist.
Since they have never had a hungry day in their lives, it is emotional feelings to them.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: WDFW-SUX on January 05, 2010, 04:50:13 PM
There's some perspective!
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Skillet on January 05, 2010, 05:01:50 PM

It's not that those antis are so concerned about an animal suffering, they really could care less about deer and elk, that is just a smoke screen to accomplish there goal of keeping people from hunting.

Agree 100% with the above.  I've made the point before, and I'll do it again.  Wasting time and effort worrying about what the anti's think is just that - a waste.  Not going to change their minds, so don't try.  Spend the time and effort properly representing ourselves as a group to the people who VOTE.  That's who the anti's made this video for.  Not us.  They know we are as entrenched in our positions as they are in theirs.  They are just being as effective as possible with the video some on this board don't see anything wrong with.  By going about it in trying to appeal to the people who were indifferent to hunting before, but may be swayed by this type of propaganda, they will find support for their cause.  And those that won't see the forest for the trees because they are too proud, or too tired of feeling persecuted and judged by the anti's today, will be the first to complain that the public are idiots for taking away their "right to hunt".  And they will probably still need to be reminded that they didn't lose a right, but failed to properly protect a privilege...

Defending what happened there is not helping we as hunters, it's helping the anti's.  The average voter did not get a feeling of "I am indifferent to hunting, but I will support the tradition" when watching King 5 that night.  Lose the average voter's support, and it's over.  Having a hard time believing that some of you can't see that.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Ray on January 05, 2010, 05:03:17 PM
Fact is - if the compound archers could have reserved judgement not to shoot the animals when there was a crowd brewing on the highway there might not be a silly video.

If that's called making friends then you must not use the English language.

or if WDFW had enforced the law.....there would not have been a crowd.
REVISED CODE OF WASHINGTON ANNOTATED
TITLE 77. GAME AND GAME FISH
CHAPTER 77.16. PROHIBITED ACTS AND PENALTIES
 
77.16.340. Obstructing the taking of fish or wildlife--Penalty--Defenses
(1) A person commits the crime of obstructing the taking of fish or wildlife if the person:

(a) Harasses, drives, or disturbs fish or wildlife with the intent of disrupting lawful pursuit or taking thereof; or
(b) Harasses, interferes with, or intimidates an individual engaged in the lawful taking of fish or wildlife or lawful predator control.


(2) Violation of this section is a gross misdemeanor under RCW 77.21.010.

(3) It is a defense to any prosecution under subsection (1) of this section, if the person charged:

(a) Interferes with any person engaged in hunting outside legally established hunting seasons;
(b) Is preventing or attempting to prevent the injury or killing of a protected wildlife species, as defined by this title;

(c) Is preventing or attempting to prevent unauthorized trespass on private property; or

(d) Is defending oneself or another person from bodily harm or property damage by a person attempting to prevent hunting in a legally established hunting season.


Enacted by Laws 1988, ch. 265, § 1, eff. July 1, 1988.
 
 

I'd call that craphouse attorney work. It wouldn't fly in a courtroom. No offense.

Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Ray on January 05, 2010, 05:04:16 PM
Quote
Harasses, interferes with, or intimidates an individual engaged in the lawful taking of fish or wildlife or lawful predator control

Id say the individuals involved in this have been harassed wouldnt you?

How is that? They got their photo taken? Is that against the law?
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Ray on January 05, 2010, 05:05:07 PM
The members on this forum are more concerned about pain and suffering of deer and elk than the antis really are.... :twocents:

That's beyond ridiculous. It is not based on anything factual.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Skillet on January 05, 2010, 05:11:43 PM
Bear in mind folks, if the onlookers were a hungry crowd, it would have a totally different twist.
Since they have never had a hungry day in their lives, it is emotional feelings to them.

They were hungry - for the show.  Same reason people rubberneck at accident sites.  With today's technology of phones with cameras and video capability, now everybody gets to see it. And that video by the anti's shows that even the most unaware and simple-minded that walk the earth can provide the commentary.
You are right about it being emotional for them - they "get meat from the store - where it's made".  Trouble is, we can't cancel their vote because they are emotional about it.  Ever tried telling your wives what they were saying didn't count because they were "just being emotional?"  How'd that work out for ya? :chuckle:
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Jerome on January 05, 2010, 05:12:41 PM
Like James has said this has been going on for years and there has been nothing changed except for taking away the muzzle loader season.  What does fish and wildlife expect when they have a unit that is in some parts a mile wide and the two boundary markers are highways.  Shut it down for good and give out more nooksack tags.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Ray on January 05, 2010, 05:13:53 PM
Quote
Having a hard time believing that some of you can't see that.

Some people here have
1) made claims that objectors are apologists for the actions
2) suggested that the objectors are questioning legality of the actions
3) suggested that the objectors are more sympathetic to the animals than anti hunters are.
4) suggested without any basis that the hunters were harassed (a little more debatable but nothing backing it up).

Anything else people need to misrepresent? How about sticking to what was stated instead of making stuff up?
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Skillet on January 05, 2010, 05:15:43 PM
The members on this forum are more concerned about pain and suffering of deer and elk than the antis really are.... :twocents:

That's beyond ridiculous. It is not based on anything factual.

I think bearpaw is saying they don't care a bit about animal pain and suffering, but more about advancing their agenda.  We try to ensure shot placement, proper equipment, etc., to ensure the quickest kill possile.  Correct me if I'm wrong, bearpaw?

*edited for spelling
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Ray on January 05, 2010, 05:18:18 PM
Point taken. I was honestly confused by that response.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: whacker1 on January 05, 2010, 05:30:14 PM
Quote
I just watched the anti video, and I have seen the news footage before.

While I don't agree with the guys shooting those elk while a crowd watched, here is the first thing that popped into my mind when I started watching the elk being shot at again that were wounded:

If those bowhunters were wolves, the crowd would have been cheering them on, but since it was human bowhunters they are hated by the same people who would be cheering on the wolves.

It's not that those antis are so concerned about an animal suffering, they really could care less about deer and elk, that is just a smoke screen to accomplish there goal of keeping people from hunting. They hate society and people......

Like i said, throw a pack of wolves in the field and they woiuld be cheering while the elk were eaten alive....

That my friends is the sad truth

If you can get the footage of an animal going down at the jaws of a wolf, I would be happy to submit it to the same news station to see if they are willing to do a story or not?  My guess is that they would not show it, but the only way to see if they would air the footage.  I would be sure to send this youtube link with it to see if they would show the wild kingdom at work.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: NWHydroprint on January 05, 2010, 05:33:05 PM
Ethical or unethical we all can argue this till we turn blue in the face. I myself would have walk away my decision.
But lets not forget that everyone hunting was not breaking the law but everybody park on the side of the road did break the law in more than 1 way like parking on the side of a hiway all bystanders should either been told to move immediately or ticketed this would have lesson the impact to both hunters and the elk trying to escape the way they came in. The do gooders caused more problems by breaking the law.
NWH
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: AKBowman on January 05, 2010, 05:33:18 PM
The men hunting in these critters where not "hunters" IMO, they were fat ass lazy slobs that make all ethical hunters look bad.

TERRIBLE ethics displayed by these idiots. If anyone reads this and was a part of that you should hang your hunting boots up and move the hell out of WA
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: mkcj on January 05, 2010, 05:38:29 PM
One thing is for sure this gave all hunter's a black eye in the minds of people that may not hunt but support hunting. I think the state really needs to find a better way to control the herd and the hunters need to take into account the perception towards our non hunting supporters. we cannot afford to loose those people.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Aneoakleaf on January 05, 2010, 05:45:03 PM
Like James has said this has been going on for years and there has been nothing changed except for taking away the muzzle loader season.  What does fish and wildlife expect when they have a unit that is in some parts a mile wide and the two boundary markers are highways.  Shut it down for good and give out more nooksack tags.
This is the kind of vidio work that got bear baiting and hound hunting shut down . The skagit hunt wasn't grafic enough so they threw in some other grafic sceens , probibly their own doing.  :dunno:
The vidio even made me sick, because of the thought of how horiabe it looks and sounds with all the lies in it.  :(

Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Wea300mag on January 05, 2010, 06:21:16 PM
They really threw a lot of extra drama into that, I'm with most in saying the hunt and the video were both BS.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Oneshot1Kill on January 05, 2010, 06:44:32 PM
Well i could seriously do some damage to those people. There own video's of those animals dying are the sick ones! They taped the doe dying in her own blood, and look at the shot placement! THOSE people should be, i dunno, this kinda thing pisses me off.. >:( >:( >:( >:( >:( >:( >:( :bash: :bash: :bash: :bash: :bash: :bash: :bash: >:( >:(
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: funkster on January 05, 2010, 06:50:41 PM
I feel that we support the WDFW, they did not support the community that support them,hunters. They should have stood behind the "hunt" addressing that it was a damage hunt to begin with. That the elk are ruining farmers way of making a living, destroying their personal land, costing them a lot of money repairing broken fences caused by the elk and also causing multiple car wrecks endangering humans. I feel the WDFW should have touched on not having the proper funding to handle the situation properly while they had the TV exposure instead of degrading the "hunt" that they "approved".

As far as the video goes that is just ignorant anti's that don't know that bow hunting is one of the oldest ways of hunting game. They also don't understand without hunting the animal population would explode spreading diseases like wild fire wiping out entire species.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: bigbeamhunter on January 05, 2010, 07:35:06 PM
it wasnt a hunt
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: funkster on January 05, 2010, 11:00:10 PM
I personally agree 100% and that is why I put "hunt". But that wasn't the point I was trying to make,it was that the WDFW cowardly backed down and didn't explain to the public why the "hunt" was even started in the first place.That could have maybe taken a little heat of the hunting community.

I don't agree with what went on but how are you supposed to thin a problem herd in 10-50 acre tracks and not have someone see it? Again if the WDFW talked about needed funds to transplant the elk instead of cower,maybe a bad situation could have turned out positive in the long run.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Alan K on January 05, 2010, 11:44:34 PM
Dont have time to read the whole thread, but I did watch the whole video.  What a joke lol. . . If they think bowhunting is barbaric they should watch some videos of their beloved wolves ripping elk apart and eating them alive. . .
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: bearpaw on January 06, 2010, 12:36:39 AM
The members on this forum are more concerned about pain and suffering of deer and elk than the antis really are.... :twocents:

That's beyond ridiculous. It is not based on anything factual.

I think bearpaw is saying they don't care a bit about animal pain and suffering, but more about advancing their agenda.  We try to ensure shot placement, proper equipment, etc., to ensure the quickest kill possile.  Correct me if I'm wrong, bearpaw?

*edited for spelling


Skillet you read my thoughts exactly right.... :tup:

Sometimes I post comments that are hard to understand, my apologies. I think many hunters are more concerned about not making an animal suffer any more than absolutely necessary. The antis use that for theiir argument to stop hunting, but if they really cared about animal suuffering, they would want to at least manage predators appropriately. Predators inflict much more pain when hunting than human hunters.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: billythekidrock on January 06, 2010, 06:00:25 AM
The game department could have stepped in and called it a safety hazard?  The fact of the matter is there was plenty of time to fiqure out what to do.  The Elk were there from Daylight 7:30ish until after 12:00 noon. 

I agree. This would have been an appropriate action on behalf of the DFW. Another would have been to ask those that pulled over on the hiway to move on or get a citation.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: billythekidrock on January 06, 2010, 06:02:37 AM
I just watched the anti video, and I have seen the news footage before.

While I don't agree with the guys shooting those elk while a crowd watched, here is the first thing that popped into my mind when I started watching the elk being shot at again that were wounded:

If those bowhunters were wolves, the crowd would have been cheering them on, but since it was human bowhunters they are hated by the same people who would be cheering on the wolves.

It's not that those antis are so concerned about an animal suffering, they really could care less about deer and elk, that is just a smoke screen to accomplish there goal of keeping people from hunting. They hate society and people...... :dunno:

Like i said, throw a pack of wolves in the field and they woiuld be cheering while the elk were eaten alive.... :twocents:

That my friends is the sad truth.


Absolutely!
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Axle on January 06, 2010, 08:19:09 AM
One goal of the game department is to get the elk out of the private farmers fields and back into the mountains.
One way to do this is to cause a commotion and run them or scare them into the hills. Remember on the video, the guy said they tried to scare them off without hunting them (he used other words).
If this commotion got them out of there, then it would be considered a success. I have my doubts that they will want to stay up in the hills with all the other predators.
Archery is a good way to accomplish this. It has been used in orchards on the east side many times for deer. It keeps the kills down but runs off the animals (normally).
If you just 'drop' a few of them with a gun and haul them off, the others will just stand and watch.
(just a thought)
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: high country on January 06, 2010, 08:35:02 AM
One goal of the game department is to get the elk out of the private farmers fields and back into the mountains.
One way to do this is to cause a commotion and run them or scare them into the hills. Remember on the video, the guy said they tried to scare them off without hunting them (he used other words).
If this commotion got them out of there, then it would be considered a success. I have my doubts that they will want to stay up in the hills with all the other predators.
Archery is a good way to accomplish this. It has been used in orchards on the east side many times for deer. It keeps the kills down but runs off the animals (normally).
If you just 'drop' a few of them with a gun and haul them off, the others will just stand and watch.
(just a thought)

the dept uses master hunters for this pretty often. what they want is the hunters to slip in unnoticed, kill the animals or haze them off and slip out unnoticed. typically it goes off w/o a hitch. this was a bit different, these guys were guys like you and I that just burned their points on this chance and while the opportunity to take an elk was present the opportunity to do so unnoticed was not. master hunters would have likely faced the board on this one, but a guy burning his points is a different story.

the dept really dropped the ball. I just hate to see these guy grilled for taking elk in an open season on a legal tag. I agree that the fences make it look like fish in a barrel, but I have seen elk shove over fences, jump fences and trample fences MANY times. in my exp a fence does not mean squat to an elk, let alone a herd
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: WDFW-SUX on January 06, 2010, 08:36:56 AM
Its an OTC hunt.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: high country on January 06, 2010, 08:42:50 AM
oh boy, that is really gonna throw a twist on how I view this.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Shootmoore on January 06, 2010, 09:00:13 AM
Yep its an over the counter hunt not a draw.  From my understanding they tried to do a Master Hunter on this one but only 3 put in for it.  I have thought about going through the Master Hunter program but I just don't have the time to complete it.

Shootmoore
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Holg3107 on January 06, 2010, 09:08:09 AM
Shootmore, I'm in the same boat, I'm really going to try and find some extra time this year to make the master hunter program happen. This would be an easy way to make this hunt go better, and if it didn't the WDFW would at least have someone to blame since it would be in a more controlled situation. My guess is that with all of the negative press this year there wouldn't be a whole lot of trouble getting a few of the master hunter permit holders to step up and fill these tags. If not my guess is that the WDFW will take care of it themselves without any hunters knowing and donating the meat. After 2 years of bad press on this they have to be sceptical about keeping it an over the counter "hunt"
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Little Dave on January 06, 2010, 10:32:50 AM
The film doesn't seem to be particularly effective if it was ment to change anbody's prior opinion.  These films usually forget to compare and contrast the favored way of the animal dying.  Maybe I can help:

After the sad new age music part, change to bright and happy smurf music and show the wolves attacking, then show them hit by trucks carrying tofu products, starving animals, yearlings frozen to death, drowning, animals falling to their death, disfiguring diseases... then end with a pretty rainbow. 

Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Skillet on January 06, 2010, 10:44:47 AM
The film doesn't seem to be particularly effective if it was ment to change anbody's prior opinion.  These films usually forget to compare and contrast the favored way of the animal dying.  Maybe I can help:

After the sad new age music part, change to bright and happy smurf music and show the wolves attacking, then show them hit by trucks carrying tofu products, starving animals, yearlings frozen to death, drowning, animals falling to their death, disfiguring diseases... then end with a pretty rainbow. 


 :chuckle:  I'll be first in line to donate to the production costs of that one!
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: 7mm short mag on January 06, 2010, 11:35:32 AM
To bad bugs didn't scream bloody murder when they are dragging their ass across their winshield. Make a video on that :dunno:
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: haus on January 06, 2010, 02:03:28 PM
The film doesn't seem to be particularly effective if it was ment to change anbody's prior opinion.  These films usually forget to compare and contrast the favored way of the animal dying.  Maybe I can help:

After the sad new age music part, change to bright and happy smurf music and show the wolves attacking, then show them hit by trucks carrying tofu products, starving animals, yearlings frozen to death, drowning, animals falling to their death, disfiguring diseases... then end with a pretty rainbow. 
hey thats doable, minus getting footage of the tofu truck death mobile
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Jerome on January 06, 2010, 02:57:18 PM
Yep its an over the counter hunt not a draw.  From my understanding they tried to do a Master Hunter on this one but only 3 put in for it.  I have thought about going through the Master Hunter program but I just don't have the time to complete it.

Shootmoore
They had a muzzle loader draw for 15 permits this year.  Instead of master hunters getting the tags i would like to see the land owners get the tags. 
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: CP on January 06, 2010, 03:07:29 PM
A landowner can already get a tag.  All they have to do is wave their damage compensation.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Mike_D on January 06, 2010, 05:26:15 PM
I've really wanted to post to these comments to these threads around concrete, and there are a lot of great points including:

definition of hunts
legality vs. ethics
hunters vs. lazy slobs
etc., etc.,

As far as I'm concerned there is no single point to assign blame here...  Blame should go across the board. 

****WDFW for not preventing a gawking circus... (remember he's essentially a peace officer with the appropriate authority)

**** The land owner for not maintaining control

**** the hunters/harvesters for not having brains...

I don't mean to be too sarcastic above , but if WDFW/land owner/harvester had worked together, this wouldn't have looked half as bad....

For example,

landowner managing the number of hunters at one time.... say allowing maybe two hunters at a time out to harvest, then two more, etc. etc.

The WDFW to maintain order, check tags, keep the traffic moving etc....him standing around as far as I'm concerned is not what I'm paying him for...

The hunters to provide a little discretion and efficiency...

I think the problem is trying to assign blame in only one direction when if they had talked and worked together, it might have looked a little bit better, but for the antis- the results would have been only slightly better, and you'd still be seeing the videos.  However, WDFW/landowner would at least have been able to say that they worked closely together, to get the job done as quickly as possible and meet the states/landowners goals.

course, this is only my two cents worth....
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: danceswitharrows on January 06, 2010, 06:00:12 PM
 :yeah:
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: danceswitharrows on January 06, 2010, 06:10:12 PM
I would also strongly agree with Bearpaws comments that we care more about the animals than the antis.  I would even go so far as to say we care more about the trees than the tree huggers.  I would argue the point that a random ten members from this site has done more for this planet than a random ten from green peace.  We just have differnt managment perspectives and we would not be caught dead in a prius
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: singleshot12 on January 06, 2010, 06:21:09 PM
More realistic managment perpectives I would say..most anti's and tree huggers were born and raised in the city.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: danceswitharrows on January 06, 2010, 09:04:00 PM
100% agree, great word add to an otherwise perfect spiel
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: hirshey on January 06, 2010, 10:09:57 PM
Unfortunately that will never happen. One of the great things about this country is freedom of speech (most times). And that means hearing from a large spectrum of people on many incidents. These types of theatrics so close to a large group of individuals that may or may not understand what hunting means to many of us is simply (and unfortuantly) just ammunition against our hunting privileges.

It is a PRIVILEGE to hunt anymore... its a privilege to be allowed an over-the-counter hunting liscence... its a privilege to be drawn for special permits. It is in our hands as hunters to ensure those privileges continue in the future, and whether we like it or not these kinds of things can have an effect on our hunting seasons/areas.

As much as I hate to admit it, discreetness around those who do not understand or do not care to understand is part of the ethics game anymore. If they don't like it, it doesn't mean they'll turn the other cheek.

Quote
Should we not avoid these events if we can see they are about to happen?

People can choose to watch or not to watch.  its up to them.  There is a legitimate reason for these type of hunts.  If you dont like them just drive on by.


Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: hirshey on January 06, 2010, 10:13:52 PM
Couldn't agree more, Mike.  :archery_smiley: couldn't have hit it more dead center myself.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Hillbilly270 on January 07, 2010, 09:31:17 PM
They say the animals suffer being shot with bow and arrow and it was sad to watch.  Would they rather watch someone shoot thier heads off with an elephant gun so they dont suffer so much?  thier is no winning is there?
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: washelkhntr on January 07, 2010, 11:14:55 PM
Who the hell are you and whay are you on our site? Your time here will be short lived!
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: Ray on January 07, 2010, 11:23:46 PM
I took care of that turd.  :ban: :pee:
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: washelkhntr on January 07, 2010, 11:25:31 PM
Thank you Ray!
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: mountainman1 on January 07, 2010, 11:42:57 PM
This type of killing is just part of life when you live out in the country, the difference was the wrong people had to see it. These people don't hace a clue about the real life.Living in the mountains its just a way of life,  :yike:better than living in the big cities where some people hunt each other. I don't see them anti's running in downtown Seattle trying to stop people from hunting each other..
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: rawhide on January 10, 2010, 09:53:39 PM
Its a dam good thing no one watched (video) my pig die this year..
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: haus on January 11, 2010, 11:06:02 AM
This type of killing is just part of life when you live out in the country, the difference was the wrong people had to see it.

O'rly. The flinging arrows willy nilly at a bunch of elk your chasing around in a pasture? Can't say I've seen that. Saw it during muzzy season once just down the way from our place, was many years ago. Don't really get the point, it looked like killin' livestock for fun to me, it sure as hell didn't look like huntin'.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: 180-GRAIN on January 13, 2010, 07:15:17 PM
Seems like maybe they should put out a few more special permits in the units if they are having problems with elk populations.
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: DOESLICKER on January 14, 2010, 06:05:37 PM
YUM ELK MEAT :)
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: hornhunter on January 16, 2010, 12:36:39 AM
We need video camera holdin hippies to get the low down on the tribal hunting issues  :hello:
Title: Re: Anti's Youtube Video regarding Skagit Elk Hunt
Post by: fishwhackin on February 18, 2010, 02:08:14 AM
I have not seen the video but I can tell you from reading this post and all the replies that I don't feel that anything negative happened.  Sure they got video of a wound shot.  Was it followed up with a kill shot?  I am (guessing yes)  Either way, quit defending the sport and start celebrating it.  What is worse for the elk, a couple arrows and dying humanely with a crowd watching it so the anti's can have a little fuel to try and downplay hunting or getting hit by one of them tools driving their honda hybrid and taking out its back legs and hobbling off to suffer through winter to die a slow painful death.  There was a crowd gathered I understand, but wouldn't there be people traveling in opposite lanes that see the later situation?  what is the difference?  That is right, as hunters, they did it as humanely as possible given the circumstances.  I commend them, I damn sure ain't going to pass up sending a meat missile at a legal game animal because someone who might be offended is watching.  Just rather unfortunate that the first shot wasn't a good shot.
SimplePortal 2.3.7 © 2008-2025, SimplePortal