Finding the toughest broadhead out there....

[ThePascoKid]

I was watching a buddy shoot, he missed the target on one of his shots and hit a conex with a zwickey made it about 1/2" through I was pretty impressed.

[windygorge]

I will finish that last post now i was just 

   you had me goin real good

[Button Nubbs]

im in for an old style magnus stinger 4 blade 125 and a g5 100gr montec. they have both just been rollin around in my box.

[et1702]

I'll send you an old 125gr Muzzy, a 125gr G5 Striker, plus my current BH, which is a 150gr AK Archery Samurai. 

Looks like Colockum is already donating a 125gr Slick Trick, or you could have one of these too.  They do fly good, but I don't like them.  Very Poor penetration in my experience w/deer & elk, plus broken blades.  Only BH I've never had full penetration thru critters.  Just so you know, it's not the bow.  I shoot 72lbs, 31.5" draw, Hoyt Trykon XL w/IBO of 318fps.  My current arrow & BH setup is 525gr and still shooting 270 to 275 fps and almost 90ftlbs KE.

ET

[D-Rock425]

I also have a 100 grain grim reaper.

[whacker1]

While I think it is cool to have your own test, because different tests will have the potential for different results, I think it is most impeative to read the one on archery talk, so you can at least look at their scoring system and come up with your own scoring measure.  I don't think the scoring systems need to be the same, but I do think they need to be consistent.  While archery talk tested both fixed blade as well as Mechanicals, I think it would be very interesting to compare their results on fixed blade heads with your results.

I posted the Archery Talk thread on the slick trick conversation on page 4.  It is over 50 pages now and they have tested a done of different broadheads. 

Here is the link again in case you want to read up on it.

http://www.archerytalk.com/vb/showthread.php?t=1790525&highlight=Ulmer+Edge

[Harborhunter]

I would put my money on the shuttle T's.  Neat idea to get all the broadheads together and test them out. 

[D-Rock425]

Are we taking bets now?  Online gambling is illegal.

[Button Nubbs]

Are we taking bets now?  Online gambling is illegal.

only if you get caught.

[D-Rock425]

Right. 

[deerslyr]

Awesome idea, and finally BH45 will shut up about those dang wasp broad heads  . I would like to see how "toughest" is going to be scored, how about a penetration test too?

[D-Rock425]

To do this correctly all broadheads need to be shot on identical arrows from the same bow.

[GT]

These may be really hard to beat:
Broadhead Durability Test (Raw Footage)

Link to the company's website:
http://solid-broadheads.com/products/

I have no affiliation with this company.

[eltaco]

I want to see the new SOLID broadhead tested... somewhere! If you're looking for toughest head, I'd think it might compete well. Of course the hunor and Silverflames should make an appearance as well

[D-Rock425]

I think the guys running that test are from Idaho.  I think i talk to him at the sportsman's show in Portland.