Your pick

[PolarBear]

I'd have to pass on both, even with a short season.  Maybe archery on first but definitely not rifle or smoke pole for either.

[300rum]

Pass on the second. 

[WDFW-SUX]

Pass on 2nd unless I was looking for meat.

[Bigshooter]

I would kill the first one but not the second one.

[kirkl]

Id shoot both of them without hesitation.

[nw_bowhunter]

I also shoot the second one....

[Bean Counter]

I'd pop both--I'm a relatively younger hunter and therefore have lower standards... 

[demontang]

That second one looks a lot like the buck I took last year, I think I would pass on both . I believe I know where the pics are and would hold out for a little better buck. It would be hard to pass on them but if it was the first day then I hope I would find more deer.

[Ray]

I'd pop both--I'm a relatively younger hunter and therefore have lower standards... 

I would not have any problems shooting either one. I shoot does just as well. Nothing to be ashamed of.

[X-Force]

id have to pass on the second.

[MichaelJ]

This year I'd shoot both in a heartbeat... need the meat for school!  If I had a week to hunt, and wasn't worried about meat I'd pass on the second, and probably pass on the first as unless it was after the 4th or 5th day of the hunt...

Michael

[rougheye]

I would pass on both just because i shot my deer on the first day last year and i couldnt chase them in the late season but i would take the first one in the late archery season probably .

[Gobble]

I'd put both of them to sleep 

[washingtonmuley]

If I was archery hunting I would probably shoot either one. If I was rifle hunting then I would pass on both.

[Ryan]

If I was hunting in Washington I would shoot the first one but not the second one.  If I was in Idaho I would pass on both.