Your pick

[DOUBLELUNG]

General season Washington, I'd convert either one to rectangular white freezer paper packages.  Out of state, they'd walk.

[bamalefty]

Are you kiddin'??  They both look like breakfast sausage, deer steaks, and tenderloin to me!!!! 

BOOM!!!!!!!!

[Rick]

Are you kiddin'??  They both look like breakfast sausage, deer steaks, and tenderloin to me!!!! 

BOOM!!!!!!!!

I wouldn't be able to get a round in the chamber fast enough.

I'm not all about the antlers. If I come across a monster,thats great. if I come across either of those,thats great also.

[JBar]

The arrow couldn't leave the string fast enough on the first one, the second one would probably have a little more time before the arrow flew just in case there was a bigger one behind him.

JBar

[Red Dawg]

It would be hard but I think I would pass on the first one. Looks like he could grow a little bit more. The second I would not even have to think about it. Let em do some breedin.

[Houndhunter]

i'd shoot that first one, i'd like to get a blackie this year that size

[boneaddict]

OK.....another scenario for you guys.  If you were to have a late permit.  One of the Methow or Entiat units. Would you take him or not.  For those that haven't stated the other two, list all three.

[rougheye]

Im a sucker for nice tall racks    I would have to take a hard look at that one . Very nice pic   

[wastickslinger]

Buck #1- yes if it is a general unit and I have not been seing anything better while prescouting.

Buck #2- no

Buck #3- not the chilliwist/Methow tag, unless its the last day.

[MichaelJ]

Buck #1- yes if it is a general unit and I have not been seing anything better while prescouting.

Buck #2- no

Buck #3- not the chilliwist/Methow tag, unless its the last day.

Same for me.... last buck looks like he could be better next year too!

Michael

[50CalJim]

Well since I passed on 2 bucks the same size as the 1st two yesterday in the Alta unit I guess my answer is no I wouldn't shoot them but it helps that I 've got the Multi tag in my pocket. On the 3rd pic it depends on the time frame. Early in the hunt I wouldn't kill it it's two spindly for me I like more girth.The pic could be deceiving though. But at crunch time different story.  

[kirkl]

he has some decent forks but not much mass. Would also have to have a front view to see the width.

[demontang]

That last one is a close call, I dont know if I would pass or not. He might end up hanging on the wall

[jackelope]

 

[bucklucky]

I would shoot all three just because I probably wont have but a day or two to hunt deer this year.