Your welcome Nez Pierce.

[Bigtine96]

Completely irrelevant green broke, if he has a tag he has the right to call from wherever he pleases.

[Green broke]

If it's in an area where tribes are hunting also you would have to know this would be a risk.  I would give it strong consideration if it was my tag and certainly wouldn't let it happen twice.
 

[Simcoe hunter]

itll never change..just like selling um whole to migrant workers in wapato and toppenish for $50

They can sell fish, why not game animals?  I don't agree, just being devils advocate.  I think it is wrong that they can sell anything they take for subsistence.  I know the treaty probably says they can, but that doesn't make it right.  Even more so in todays world than in the one the treaty was written in.

[Bigtine96]

If you have to worry about an indian shooting a bull from the road if you call it into an opening dont you think there might be a problem green broke?

[Simcoe hunter]

If it's in an area where tribes are hunting also you would have to know this would be a risk.  I would give it strong consideration if it was my tag and certainly wouldn't let it happen twice.

He may or may not have known.  If he knew, shame on him.  Sounds like he may have been being the lazy one.  But are you aware that the Yakamas can hunt any unclaimed land by the Treaty of 1855.  That means anything not privately owned.  All federal, State, County, etc.  Why do you think one of them got off with such little fallout for shooting an animal at the feeding station in Naches a few years back?  You never know when they will turn up to pick up some meat to sell.

[Green broke]

If you have to worry about an indian shooting a bull from the road if you call it into an opening dont you think there might be a problem green broke?

I will not call from the road.  I am wary whenever I am in the woods. I would rather pack a little further than risk someone else harvesting my animal. 

[PlateauNDN]

itll never change..just like selling um whole to migrant workers in wapato and toppenish for $50

Do you work at valley gun and pawn?

[hrd2fnd]

I don't know if anyone can answer this question. What other states have Indian reservations that worked out deals for off Rez Rights? Obviously WA... Nez Pierce in ID? where else??? Does anyone know of a book that is written on the subject of How the treaties came to be and why they were so different? From ANY point of view...

I've read that Runamuk has some background from her studies hopefully she can help shed some light 

[PlateauNDN]

Don't know of a book but OR. Does and many others try internet search.

[furbearer365]

Treaties and Indian Hunting "rights"   I saw first hand what this is all about and what they did to the St Helens herd when I was a kid.  No words can be said that will take the images out of my head of truck loads of dead elk and many dead left behind.  Don't care if "not all Indians" hunt this way or not.  What I have seen tells me that this happens enough every year and needs to stop.  You Indians say, "here we go again" when we spout about Indians that shoot up everything that walks, but its funny because when your people shoot em, we are the ones saying "here we go again."  So who is right and who is wrong?  Are we wrong for being angry that our elk and deer herds are slaughtered or are you wrong for thinking it is ok because not all of you do it? We are not making these stories up year after year yet you still defend it because "you personally" don't hunt this way.

[Green broke]

Furbearer you can pee on whatever you want.  I can sit back and whine and say you are all like Cody Strearns. I however recognize the diversity, both good and bad in all user groups.  If what he claims is true he probably killed more animals single handedly than all the tribes took out if St.  Helens.

[Landowner]

Lightning rod topic.

Responsible harvests and focus on preserving enough healthy game populations for years to come is important for all involved. 

[turkeyfeather]

You guys that claim the op was calling from the road, how do you know that? How do you know the guy wasn't way off the road and the native wasnt a really good long range shot?

[The100Road]

You guys that claim the op was calling from the road, how do you know that? How do you know the guy wasn't way off the road and the native wasnt a really good long range shot?

Exactly. Im thinking he was on the far hillside and calling a bull up from the bottom. truck comes driving down the ridge and shoots the bull across the canyon from the road. anything like that could have happened. its just wrong that you even have to worry about that in archery season.

[Green broke]

Where is the op to provide clarification?