Free: Contests & Raffles.
Surprised the Nazi Police hasn't said anything about using traps...........
sounds like a raccoon to me. They like to reach in from the sides of cage traps and pull out what they want with out triggering it. Maybe a big coon since it got the rat trap caught on it and was able to back out of the cage trap. Then came back to get the goodies out of the cage trap. Raccoons as smart and strong, had one break the slider on my f150 to get a some smoked salmon I left in the truck. Do you have a trail cam you could hang over the area?See mink or coon post down below yours
If your trap is covered you and quietly walk up, pick up the trap up and move it somewhere safe, either walking or in the bed of your truck. You can then drown it, release and shoot it, or just release it, however the latter is frowned upon by the state as your just giving your problem to someone else. Best bet is to drown them, no odor and you can skin them and make a very nice tanned fur.