Boots are so subjective I find its difficult to get a truly honest representative of what will work for YOU. That said, I have had great luck with the Meindle Perfekt Hiker. I am on my second pair and thats after using a couple other big name brands, one of which worked great. The other a was quite a dissapointment. Both cost significantly more than the Meindle. Are they "Perfect".... no. The insoles can use upgrading, and not a big fan of the lacing system. But for me they are comfortable, have kept my feet dry, and lasted well for the money. So I consider them a very good, to excellent value.