436-4/8 points bull elk out of eastern washington

[ELKBURGER]

I think we would all do things differently if we had the dough. Great bull!

[idahohuntr]

I'm starting to think its a curse to shoot a 400+ bull or any kind of record book class animal for that matter...not saying some of these guys don't deserve some criticism...but I just don't hear a whole lot of pleasant stories once a bull gets up near that 400+ mark    Stick to the 350-380 range and you are safe   

[rossthebear]

"I woke up, put on my boots, walked 100 yards and dropped him.  What a hunt!"

[Taco280AI]

The whole jealousy argument is a joke. Is like playing the race card. It's the argument that is used when you have no valid argument.

With that said, that's one hell of a bull!

Where I think the negativity comes from is that he didn't do anything (other than earn money) to earn that bull. Guides did the work. They know the land, they know the bull, they have a good idea where to find him. That guy shows up, makes a 15 minute stalk, and is done. He didn't do anything other than pay a lot of money for that bull.

To me a bull that scored 200 points less that was DIY on public land would hold more value. Just like a guy who makes a longbow by hand vs buying one. Or putting together a classic car vs being the highest bidder at an auction. Nothing wrong with using the money you earned to get you things, but when you put in all the effort on your own and do it all yourself it just means more.

[jackelope]

"I woke up, put on my boots, walked 100 yards and dropped him.  What a hunt!"

Great 1st post.
Welcome to the site.

[westsidehntr]

Question for people bashing this guy. Would you pass up that shot at that bull?

[WapitiTalk1]

That is one horse of a bull taken in fair chase.   

[nwhunter]

Posts like this are why many many bulls dont get posted on here anymore!! Dan was nice enough to send an email with his pic and story of his San Carlos bull a few weeks back asking to have it posted on here for us to enjoy. When he sees stuff like this Im sure it makes him think twice about sharing his success. We dont all hunt the same or have the same opportunities as each other no doubt about it but it doesnt always make the other guys way of doing it wrong. People are all excited and supportive about guided hunts in Alaska and elsewhere but when they smell a gov tag and money the negativity skyrockets. Seems a little hypocritical to me. What an awesome bull and a lot of time and effort went into that thing. Let it go. nwhunter

[billythekidrock]

Posts like this are why many many bulls dont get posted on here anymore!! Dan was nice enough to send an email with his pic and story of his San Carlos bull a few weeks back asking to have it posted on here for us to enjoy. When he sees stuff like this Im sure it makes him think twice about sharing his success. We dont all hunt the same or have the same opportunities as each other no doubt about it but it doesnt always make the other guys way of doing it wrong. People are all excited and supportive about guided hunts in Alaska and elsewhere but when they smell a gov tag and money the negativity skyrockets. Seems a little hypocritical to me. What an awesome bull and a lot of time and effort went into that thing. Let it go. nwhunter

Why didn't he post it himself?

[trophyhunt]

The whole jealousy argument is a joke. Is like playing the race card. It's the argument that is used when you have no valid argument.

With that said, that's one hell of a bull!

Where I think the negativity comes from is that he didn't do anything (other than earn money) to earn that bull. Guides did the work. They know the land, they know the bull, they have a good idea where to find him. That guy shows up, makes a 15 minute stalk, and is done. He didn't do anything other than pay a lot of money for that bull.

To me a bull that scored 200 points less that was DIY on public land would hold more value. Just like a guy who makes a longbow by hand vs buying one. Or putting together a classic car vs being the highest bidder at an auction. Nothing wronghttp://hunting-washington.com/smf/Smileys/default/chuckle.gif with using the money you earned to get you things, but when you put in all the effort on your own and do it all yourself it just means more.

:yeah:Agree, the hunt we had this weekend after lots of scouting, hiking and prep work was what it's all about.  The bull wasn't the biggest on the mountain but the hunt and day was epic.  I have no negative thoughts about Dan's bull, but I highly doubt he felt the spirit of the elk like we did. Again, no negative remarks for him, I would love to hunt big bulls every year like he can.  Heck, he's put a ton of money back into the system, almost as much as my permit and license fee's the last few years!! 

[CAMPMEAT]

Who cares what others do with their money. I can't do it and could care less. Being a horn/record hunter ain't my thing.

[BOWHUNTER45]

I sure hope the money went where they said it would  but being in Washington ..I doubt it  other than that ...what a stud !

[724wd]

Where I think the negativity comes from is that he didn't do anything (other than earn money) to earn that bull. Guides did the work. They know the land, they know the bull, they have a good idea where to find him. That guy shows up, makes a 15 minute stalk, and is done. He didn't do anything other than pay a lot of money for that bull.

so guided hunts aren't REAL hunting now?   

[bearpaw]

Posts like this are why many many bulls dont get posted on here anymore!! Dan was nice enough to send an email with his pic and story of his San Carlos bull a few weeks back asking to have it posted on here for us to enjoy. When he sees stuff like this Im sure it makes him think twice about sharing his success. We dont all hunt the same or have the same opportunities as each other no doubt about it but it doesnt always make the other guys way of doing it wrong. People are all excited and supportive about guided hunts in Alaska and elsewhere but when they smell a gov tag and money the negativity skyrockets. Seems a little hypocritical to me. What an awesome bull and a lot of time and effort went into that thing. Let it go. nwhunter

I agree whole heartedly and appreciate him sharing his success with those of us who appreciate it. Thanks for sharing your adventures Dan! 

Negative posts will be removed!

[MountainWalk]

I usta be a hater. I'd boo and hiss and wish his hot tub was cold.


But now, hell, I dont care. Im not likely to ever draw a bada@@ tag or buy a gov tag. Its cool. Like Campmeat said, records aiint my style. But good for the guy. It was just a stroke of luck the entourage spotted him there. Im sure the hunter fully expected a hike and a hunt. Instead, he got lucky.  When Lady Luck looks your way and smiles, dont kick sand in her face!

I think it was TR(pretty sure im wrong) who said  " no fair chance shall be refused".