Scoring Non-typical deer

[AntlerHound]

I had my buck scored at the sportsmans show this year and entered into the book. It will go in the book as net. If they had used the gross score it would of given it 7 extra inches. Now since it was scored as a non-typical I don't understand the reasoning for the deductions.... Kinda stumps me

[BULLBLASTER]

The main frame is still scored for symmetry and then the nontyp inches are added. Deductions come from differemces in the main or typical frame.

[AntlerHound]

Right I understand "where" I guess I mean "why" if it's a non typical then why deduct differences

[huntnphool]

Right I understand "where" I guess I mean "why" if it's a non typical then why deduct differences

 Forget about B&C and P&Y, score it SCI.

 If the animal grew it then it should get credit.

[kentrek]

Right I understand "where" I guess I mean "why" if it's a non typical then why deduct differences

 Forget about B&C and P&Y, score it SCI.

 If the animal grew it then it should get credit.

 

[AntlerHound]

I very much so agree.. Do they have their own book and measurers like NW BIG GAME, INC.

[jackelope]

I very much so agree.. Do they have their own book and measurers like NW BIG GAME, INC.

SCI has their own scorers and book.

[BULLBLASTER]

Im in the same camp. To me the score is just a number. I only pay attention to gross anyways.

[walleye1]

B&C is for world-class animals S :bdid:CI is for all the rest

[jackelope]

B&C is for world-class animals S :bdid:CI is for all the rest

All the books are for people who feel like they need to compare themselves to everyone else.

 

[BULLBLASTER]

B&C is for world-class animals S :bdid:CI is for all the rest

All the books are for people who feel like they need to compare themselves to everyone else.

 

to me the number is so i cqn get an idea of size. A "dandy 5 point" whitetail could be 115 inch to some and 150 to others. Numbers give a scale. None of mine will ever be entered into amy book except my memory book

[huntnnw]

B&C and P&Y are a joke! rewarding for perfect antlers...everything in the wild is unique and should be given credit for it all!!!

[Maverick]

B&C and P&Y are a joke! rewarding for perfect antlers...everything in the wild is unique and should be given credit for it all!!!

Exactly!

[walleye1]

99.9 % of you will never see Boone and Crockett deer so why do you care how they score them.you all act like you're sitting on a bunch of book heads and are protesting Boone Crockett lol

[jackelope]

99.9 % of you will never see Boone and Crockett deer so why do you care how they score them.you all act like you're sitting on a bunch of book heads and are protesting Boone Crockett lol

Oh gawd.......

[huntnphool]

99.9 % of you will never see Boone and Crockett deer so why do you care how they score them.you all act like you're sitting on a bunch of book heads and are protesting Boone Crockett lol

Oh gawd.......

  +1

[Maverick]

99.9 % of you will never see Boone and Crockett deer so why do you care how they score them.you all act like you're sitting on a bunch of book heads and are protesting Boone Crockett lol

You must be only talking about yourself! I have in fact seen b&c bucks while hunting, hiking, and even driving. They're around. I don't care if a buck is even on both sides or not. Antlers should be scored for every inch they've grown. No deductions

[BULLBLASTER]

99.9 % of you will never see Boone and Crockett deer so why do you care how they score them.you all act like you're sitting on a bunch of book heads and are protesting Boone Crockett lol

Oh gawd.......

[BULLBLASTER]

B&C and P&Y are a joke! rewarding for perfect antlers...everything in the wild is unique and should be given credit for it all!!!

[huntnnw]

I have seen plenty

[kentrek]

I have seen plenty

I doubt it....18494 members × .001= less then 19 of us have ever laid eyes on a booner ! more mystical than Bigfoot 

[jackelope]

I have seen plenty

I doubt it....18494 members × .001= less then 19 of us have ever laid eyes on a booner ! more mystical than Bigfoot 

Reallistically its probably a tie.

[huntnnw]

I have seen plenty

I doubt it....18494 members × .001= less then 19 of us have ever laid eyes on a booner ! more mystical than Bigfoot 

I have shot one that I figured was over 185" whitetail typ 5x5 that I never recovered

I have killed whitetail bucks that grossed 194" and 177" deductions didnt net booner... I have watched 4 bucks in my life over 170" one was well over 200"

whats sad  with the scoring system is I could make the bucks make the "magical" book with a hammer and bust off extras thats should tell you how screwed up the system is

[Maverick]

I have seen plenty

I doubt it....18494 members × .001= less then 19 of us have ever laid eyes on a booner ! more mystical than Bigfoot 

I have shot one that I figured was over 185" whitetail typ 5x5 that I never recovered

I have killed whitetail bucks that grossed 194" and 177" deductions didnt net booner... I have watched 4 bucks in my life over 170" one was well over 200"

whats sad  with the scoring system is I could make the bucks make the "magical" book with a hammer and bust off extras thats should tell you how screwed up the system is