****Update****
I've put some miles down on these suckers and I honestly have nothing bad to say about them. They fit my foot, which is not an easy thing to do, as I have flat, wide feet. They give me enough support when climbing and when descending. The first day they were a little rough on the heel when climbing real steep but I think that is to be expected when breaking in a new boot.
I did spend a day with heavy moisture/rain, and I'm pretty sure one of the boots leaked. It seemed more than just wicking down off my sock, but I was never uncomfortable in the field with them. My pants weighed about 30 pounds when I was done, and I'll bet with a set of gaitors I would have been fine.
I would recommend these boots to anyone looking for an uninsulated, lite boot, but.....It may or may not fit your foot which is most important IMO.