Trophy deer poll

[Bigshooter]

I grew up hunting blacktails and still do love hunting them.  But if you put a 150 blacktail next to a 200 inch Mule deer I will kill the mule deer 100 out of 100 times.

[huntnphool]

 Mule deer hands down for me.

[Jonathan_S]

Blacktails are hard, sure.  Anything mature is hard though.

There are some tall-tined whitetail ghosts that would give blacktails a run for their money.  Those bucks you get on camera about three times a year 

Since I spend most of my time hunting mountain whitetail, I'll say that.  In my experience, Whitetail are the most intimate species to hunt. 

[Jonathan_S]

I grew up hunting blacktails and still do love hunting them.  But if you put a 150 blacktail next to a 200 inch Mule deer I will kill the mule deer 100 out 100 times.

Go to Klickitat, you'll find both

 

[tgomez]

Easy-Mule deer. Bigger bodies=more meat!

[widgeonwacher]

blacktail are the real deer 

[huntnphool]

blacktail are the real deer 

Says a guy with a whitetail rack as a avatar.

[fishnfur]

So he obviously knows what he's talking about!   

[Chad Osterholtz]

That picture Birddogdad posted gave me Goosebumps! I've put a couple trophy class whites and mules on the wall, but I just can't seem to bag a black worthy of the wall...

[kellama2001]

Desert muley for me all the way.  Something about them just gets in your blood. They're addicting!

[bowhunterwa87]

Love me some whitetails!!!

[beaslayer6]

A smasher blacktail is hard to beat..

[kodiak 907]

Blacktails all the way!

[JakeLand]

Blacktail hands down no question

[Turner89]

Blacktail   I love the way they look......knarly racks, and big roman nose.