What do you think of this Muley? Score and age class?

[steeliedrew]

Pretty positive that is a Wyoming deer, but I didn't read all 2 pages.

Home grown in WA.  When I first saw him I went... 

[cbond3318]

Pretty positive that is a Wyoming deer, but I didn't read all 2 pages.

Home grown in WA.  When I first saw him I went... 

  I know , just thought I'd bring a little levity to a derailment by adding a derailment.  It is an A typical Bad A buck!! My knees would be knocking if I had him in my spotter!

[addicted2hunting]

And I missed the sucker at 38 yds.... but yes the velvet makes him look much larger...my final thoughts are 170...my stepdads buck was similar in frame but not as tall in the back and his net score was 168 and some change...

[steeliedrew]

MtnMuley,

You have mail. 

[LDennis24]

I would say 26" inside on the main beams and 32" outside. Overall probably a 170" buck at best. Has good height but weaker front forks and deductions. That said I wouldn't even think twice about taking a buck like that. Wall hanger for sure!

[huntnphool]

And I missed the sucker at 38 yds.... but yes the velvet makes him look much larger...my final thoughts are 170...my stepdads buck was similar in frame but not as tall in the back and his net score was 168 and some change...

 What would be helpful is if all of you that guess a total score would include your breakdown.

[Miles]

Where's the guesswork in that? 

I really wish Billythekidrock would just post a picture of it with the official score sheet.

[Jonathan_S]

I would say your in the 190s To about 230 wide deer but fronts are week and same withe back forks good deer tthrough

I will always score very conservative and want to be pleasantly surprised that an animal exceeds my expectations. I don't want to be that guy that claims everything is 10-20" bigger

The answer probably lies somewhere in between 160" and 230" 

[Karl Blanchard]

All that I have gathered from this thread is that someone from the forum poached a 37" 3x4 at night in Wyoming, and a half dozen other members are in on it.   Until photographic evidence is presented to prove otherwise, this must be the truth

[Jonathan_S]

All that I have gathered from this thread is that someone from the forum poached a 37" 3x4 at night in Wyoming, and a half dozen other members are in on it.   Until photographic evidence is presented to prove otherwise, this must be the truth

Duh.

[Reidus]

Definitely a high fence buck being fed horn growing minerals. What's it cost to shoot something like this?








 

[cbond3318]

All that I have gathered from this thread is that someone from the forum poached a 37" 3x4 at night in Wyoming, and a half dozen other members are in on it.   Until photographic evidence is presented to prove otherwise, this must be the truth

 

[steeliedrew]

Definitely a high fence buck being fed horn growing minerals. What's it cost to shoot something like this?

.





 

You caught me. He's in my back yard right now. He's yours for $20k

[cbond3318]

Definitely a high fence buck being fed horn growing minerals. What's it cost to shoot something like this?

.





 

You caught me. He's in my back yard right now. He's yours for $20k

Shoot 20K? There is a shoulder mount of a similar buck down at Goodwill right now for 70 $. And I get to make up my own story.

[steeliedrew]

Definitely a high fence buck being fed horn growing minerals. What's it cost to shoot something like this?

.





 

You caught me. He's in my back yard right now. He's yours for $20k

Shoot 20K? There is a shoulder mount of a similar buck down at Goodwill right now for 70 $. And I get to make up my own story.

High fence ain't for everyone.