What do you think of this Muley? Score and age class?

[Jimmy33]

This year


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Jimmy33]

I think its the same buck...oh wait...its not


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[MtnMuley]

You guys are all a bunch of wierdos


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I certainly won't argue that

[crabcreekhunter]

If the hunter doesn't want to post a picture or story leave it at that, maybe they aren't out for "keyboard" stardom and don't want the story and photos available to every hunter in washington.  Nothing wrong with that, very nice frame on that guy but not much score wise.

[Jimmy33]

If the hunter doesn't want to post a picture or story leave it at that, maybe they aren't out for "keyboard" stardom and don't want the story and photos available to every hunter in washington.  Nothing wrong with that, very nice frame on that guy but not much score wise.

I agree but i still think the way the post is going is wierd


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[_TONY_]

If the bucks dead, or not dead, it's probably not going to keep you from heading high up above the valley looking for him, or other bucks, is it? So, does it really matter? Keep at it!! 

LOTS of big bucks never get posted, and I'm okay with that. It's a personal choice for the individual hunter to post or not to post their harvest (I'm not posting my buck). Posting another's harvest just to prove a point, is just wrong.

He sure is a nice buck, but spend enough time in those bowls and rocks and I'm sure you'll turn one up that's a lot bigger!!

[Jimmy33]

Is there anyway we can just kill this thread and make it die forever


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[DUGANDEER]

For what its worth... I know a 250" non typ that was taken by a local over around Winthrop... its an older fella...

. 

How about a pic. I don't believe it w out a pic...lol

[steeliedrew]

I actually shot this buck


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

That's a great deer! Congrats and thanks for sharing and showing folks how to post pictures.    Look everybody...He posted a picture on an interweb forum and SURVIVED! 

[X-Force]

For what its worth... I know a 250" non typ that was taken by a local over around Winthrop... its an older fella...

. 

How about a pic. I don't believe it w out a pic...lol

Any buck over 200" not making it online is almost more unbelievable then a 250" shot in the methow. But I've been wrong before.

[steeliedrew]

If the bucks dead, or not dead, it's probably not going to keep you from heading high up above the valley looking for him, or other bucks, is it? So, does it really matter? Keep at it!! 

LOTS of big bucks never get posted, and I'm okay with that. It's a personal choice for the individual hunter to post or not to post their harvest (I'm not posting my buck). Posting another's harvest just to prove a point, is just wrong.

He sure is a nice buck, but spend enough time in those bowls and rocks and I'm sure you'll turn one up that's a lot bigger!!

For sure Tony.  There's good genetics where he's from.

[Boss .300 winmag]

 sweet one jimmy. 

[boneaddict]

I think it's safe to say most of them are dead this year, but if he says it's dead, pretty sure it's dead.

[bobcat]

Well I think the picture Jimmy33 posted proves that the buck in question is dead.

[M_ray]

Well I think the picture Jimmy33 posted proves that the buck in question is dead.

Not the same deer ... Steeliedrew's buck is a 3 pt on its right and a 4 on the left ... Jimmy33's buck is the opposite.