What do you think of this Muley? Score and age class?

[NOCK NOCK]

No, no, no........that buck is gone and some one is correct, he was shot next to a road and I have proof. I was sent the pic and I don't give a freak who knows how I got the pic I'm posting it. End this thread once and for all.

What are you waiting for?

I'll bite....................................................................Pics or it didnt happen.............

[2labs]

Wait, hey, it didnt go 12

you lucky SOB, good work.

Luck..... Ha

[PlateauNDN]

There now this thread can be put to bed

[2labs]

Those are Benchlegs.

[WARHORSE]

You should rename him "Maybe"   

How about mmmmm.   Dead!

[steeliedrew]

After seeing Bornforhorns' pic that he posted I've been thinking all day. At first I thought "not wide enough" but that crab claw looks just like how it looked in September when me and addicted2hunting got back on him. The dead buck has better tine depth too but the picture I posted of Krusty was from July so he was still growing at that point.

I know you all just wanted the thread to die but this is kinda interesting:



 

Also doesn't appear to have quite the same width but it's hard with the angle of the shot and the laid back ears on the dead buck to really tell.

[DUGANDEER]

After seeing Bornforhorns' pic that he posted I've been thinking all day. At first I thought "not wide enough" but that crab claw looks just like how it looked in September when me and addicted2hunting got back on him. The dead buck has better tine depth too but the picture I posted of Krusty was from July so he was still growing at that point.

I know you all just wanted the thread to die but this is kinda interesting:



 

Also doesn't appear to have quite the same width but it's hard with the angle of the shot and the laid back ears on the dead buck to really tell.

Not the same buck...IMO

[jackelope]

Not the same buck.

[Romulus1297]

Some people will just saw the antlers off and not mount it. This buck wasn't killed in Gold Ck was it?.

[MtnMuley]

Even better than a guy could have ever imagined.

[huntnphool]

Not the same buck.

+1

[steeliedrew]

Pretty dang close though. Just goes to show that there's more than one deer like Krusty out there. 

[fishngamereaper]

14 pages and nothing accomplished...

just adding to my post count

carry on, will check back in a few days.

[bornforhorns]

Well another way to eliminate the thought of it being the same deer is if you didn't see him in the Sinlahekin...it probably isn't. 

[2labs]

14 pages and nothing accomplished...

just adding to my post count

carry on, will check back in a few days.

BENCHLEG