I love this style of evaluations when it comes to gun care. If you have something you love and are confident in, then use it. If you are open minded just look at the data. I have seen several of these and the one that stands alone for me is the Hornady product. I have never had any loyalty to any lube, corrosion inhibitor, or general gun treatment product due to wives tails, old timers advise or 40+ years of experience. I never disregard experience, but I always look at data. Many products are very purpose driven so obviously one product usually doesn't fit all. Good luck in your search. For me, I use the One Shot stuff with lots of success and no corrosion on all metal parts that don't require excessive pressure (ar-15 bolt locking lugs ect...).
Justin