I have one of each in mid weight. I have never really worn the hood. If I need head coverage I end up wearing a beanie. Depending on when you would be wearing it would help determine whether to get a hood or not, also if you're a hood person or not. I'm generally not so it's usually down. If the hood isn't up the collar tends to fold over so you will lose some neck coverage. Very happy with them though! I think you will be happy either way.