The bottom one doesn't go outside the ears. The width is not that wide. Good symetry though.
The top buck is wider. Without the head and ears it is difficult to tell in these pictures. I definitely think the top buck is bigger. I think 180"? So hard to tell. We need some more pictures.
I think the scorer used the same method my brother does to score his deer... 8 beers + B&C score + 25" = internet score.
Crap, hope I don't have to eat pie with Bone...

They are still bigger than anything I've shot.