Bear Spray or Handgun

[hunter399]

Bear spray is on my chest holster at all times, don't need to draw to fire.  Just push the button. 

You know the old Alaskan saying: don't worry about caliber of pistol with a grizzly, just make sure you file off the sights so it hurts less when the grizzly shoves it up your rectum.

I will say the chest rig does look pretty handy,but its just not for me .I always have a pistol on my hip,or a rifle in my hand in the woods.

[buglebrush]

This subject simply comes down to what makes you feel safer and thus enjoy yourself more.  There is anecdotal evidence aplenty to support whichever you prefer, but no definitive empirical evidence either way.  I feel naked without my pistol, so that is what I carry.   

[JDHasty]

https://www.ammoland.com/2017/09/bear-spray-failure-bow-hunter-mauled/#axzz4sDDpRzqj

[Mudman]

Um, did you read whole article?  Seems like a lack of proper use of spray or no chance to use it?  Unless these guys are married standing hand in hand how is a spray failure connected to the bear running away from spray and to the other prey who was not spraying?

[Bob33]

This subject simply comes down to what makes you feel safer and thus enjoy yourself more.  There is anecdotal evidence aplenty to support whichever you prefer, but no definitive empirical evidence either way.  I feel naked without my pistol, so that is what I carry.   

There is empirical data, but people may choose to deny or ignore it which is as it should be.

[Alchase]

I can't even believe this is still a discussion. To me it is silly to have to choose.
Packing both has never been a detriment, and in many cases saved lives.
If spray works great, if it does not, I want a backup, or 12 of them.

For every spray deterrent, there have been as many heavy caliber pistol deterrents.

[Mudman]

  Agreed.  Many who are bear hunting will be armed so carry a spray if ya want.  If not bear hunting or archery then a decision can be argued for weight if its a long hike but both is always the best of course.  But many people don't carry when hiking or fishing and such so a spray may be good choice.   After seeing what a .45 did to a bear I prefer the spray over an injured angry black bear charging after 3 rounds are in it.  It is not easy to place a pistol round in a lethal zone from 30yards on amoving bear... Both is answer for most..