Free: Contests & Raffles.
I haven't voted because I don't think it matters. I'm pretty sure if you make it draw only for mule deer the wolves and cats will eat what ever number you think your going to save.A bandaid on a pumping artery isn't going to change much.
First, I want to say that winters are in most cases probably the biggest factor in deer numbers. Next, with roughly 4000 cougar that average eating 25-50 deer per year, it seems that some 100,000 or more deer are destined to....
Yes, something needs to change. Shorten archery to a week, muzzleloader to four days, modern to 3 days. Drop permit hunts in migratory units in central WA. Able to use deer/elk/bear tag on cougars, bounty on coyotes. Anything to limit harvest from us hunters but allow opportunity and control the predators we can at this point.
Quote from: Special T on October 10, 2017, 04:14:35 PMI D & M T have much lower population densities that can support more animals. So I'd say that's not really a good comparisonI haven't voted because I don't think it matters. I'm pretty sure if you make it draw only for mule deer the wolves and cats will eat what ever number you think your going to save.A bandaid on a pumping artery isn't going to change much.I'd hazard a guess without doing any research that there are crap tons more wolves and cats in most other western states that have a lot more controlled mule deer hunting and it's better quality mule deer hunting in pretty much every other western state in the nation than it is here with wide open harvest.
I D & M T have much lower population densities that can support more animals. So I'd say that's not really a good comparisonI haven't voted because I don't think it matters. I'm pretty sure if you make it draw only for mule deer the wolves and cats will eat what ever number you think your going to save.A bandaid on a pumping artery isn't going to change much.
I personally think there's a lot that's got to change. The amount of hunters, predator management, all sorts of things. There is no 1 answer.
Quote from: Special T on October 10, 2017, 04:14:35 PMI haven't voted because I don't think it matters. I'm pretty sure if you make it draw only for mule deer the wolves and cats will eat what ever number you think your going to save.A bandaid on a pumping artery isn't going to change much.I'd hazard a guess without doing any research that there are crap tons more wolves and cats in most other western states that have a lot more controlled mule deer hunting and it's better quality mule deer hunting in pretty much every other western state in the nation than it is here with wide open harvest.
Quote from: jackelope on October 10, 2017, 05:24:56 PMQuote from: Special T on October 10, 2017, 04:14:35 PMI haven't voted because I don't think it matters. I'm pretty sure if you make it draw only for mule deer the wolves and cats will eat what ever number you think your going to save.A bandaid on a pumping artery isn't going to change much.I'd hazard a guess without doing any research that there are crap tons more wolves and cats in most other western states that have a lot more controlled mule deer hunting and it's better quality mule deer hunting in pretty much every other western state in the nation than it is here with wide open harvest.There is the phrase that brings out the need for clarification what this thread is about.I see "herd" mentioned and then guys start talking about point restrictions.I do not believe that does are not getting bred because of a lack of bucks. So, are you worried about the herd or are you worried you won't get your chance at a monster buck.There are a lot of people that are quite happy to get out hunting and success to them is some venison in the freezer even if it is a spike or in the current situation a three point. You are not going to get any support from these people to restrict you to every other year hunting. Sounds like ant-hunting rhetoric to me.If you are really talking about the herd, a lack of deer as opposed to big bucks then the problem is probably predators.I would dispute that we have less big cats then other western States. I think we have just as many or more plus we can't trap coyotes. Do something about that and you will have my full support. No doe tags Tell me I can't go hunting because we have too many predators and Joe Trophy Buck wants a better shot at B&C and you will not get my support.
Even though this my last year hunting in WA, I voted yes. Yes because of the state of the herds here. Cats, wolves, bad winters, and disease has continued to bring down the numbers here. I seen quite a few dead yearlings this spring and have found a dozen or so cat kills. I've been seeing less than a dozen deer per day this past week. I would like to see them implement a quota for tags and/or draw only for the Yakima herd. Try to reduce native harvest but that won't happen due to native rights. Increase cougar harvest to a dozen for each area.
Quote from: Naches Sportsman on October 10, 2017, 06:30:12 PMEven though this my last year hunting in WA, I voted yes. Yes because of the state of the herds here. Cats, wolves, bad winters, and disease has continued to bring down the numbers here. I seen quite a few dead yearlings this spring and have found a dozen or so cat kills. I've been seeing less than a dozen deer per day this past week. I would like to see them implement a quota for tags and/or draw only for the Yakima herd. Try to reduce native harvest but that won't happen due to native rights. Increase cougar harvest to a dozen for each area.Be happy with what you have. Here where I live on the W side I would think I was in heaven seeing that many deer. Been out two days this week. Saw three deer one of which was a cougar kill.So if there were no doe seasons how would shortening the season or limiting hunter participation increase the deer herd? That is what I don't get about these type threads.