Back to the original question on rain gear after I hijacked the thread...

It is my opinion that one set of rain gear will not work as a do it all system, that in fact one should have a few systems ready to go.
1) Light Weight Breathable system for just in case type use
2) Heavier weight durable breathable system (3 layer +)
3) Just pure water protection (Helly Hansen, or other rubber style protection)
I have a variety of sets, tailored to my chosen activity set.
Brands I have had good experiences with include: OR, Patagonia, Sitka, KUIU, First Lite, LLBean, Carhartt, and Helly Hansen.
I think the most important part is to figure out when and how you will use it. Determine your specific balance of weight vs. durability, and then shop around and try some out till you find what works for you. Lots of good reviews out there on specific products as you narrow down your choices.