collapse

Advertisement


Author Topic: ONP Goat relocation outcome  (Read 11226 times)

Offline fishngamereaper

  • Trade Count: (+7)
  • Old Salt
  • ******
  • Join Date: Oct 2011
  • Posts: 8837
  • Location: CDA/CQ
Re: ONP Goat relocation outcome
« Reply #45 on: May 10, 2024, 07:12:44 AM »
The reality is they could of left the goats alone.

The justification for attempted relocation didn't merit giving those goats a death sentence in my book.

In a State that's having a difficult time managing any sort of wildlife you'd hope science and common sense says leave a thriving resource alone and add some protocols to manage it better. Instead of take a chance and hope they survive a mass relocation.
NPS was lead on NEPA. Did you comment? Did you attend the meetings and speak up? There was opportunities for all to be involved in the determination of their existence in the park. Many involved did not support eradicating them but really wanted to make the best of the situation.

Yes and yes
Unfortunately what's done is done
But I will stand firm that I disagree with the EIS and the associated CBI review that goats allegedly where not native to the area. 
And that removal was the only option....
A major factor of the management plan was human interaction. Maybe they should of taken a step in managing humans first....that park is overdue for a reduction in tourism..
I grew up in those mountains and the flood of people the last few years is mind blowing.

And just to be clear even if the relocation was a complete success I would still have the same opinion..those mountains deserve goats....


Offline Tbar

  • Non-Hunting Topics
  • Trade Count: (+26)
  • Frontiersman
  • *****
  • Join Date: Jun 2011
  • Posts: 3077
  • Location: Whatcom county
Re: ONP Goat relocation outcome
« Reply #46 on: May 10, 2024, 02:24:04 PM »
The reality is they could of left the goats alone.

The justification for attempted relocation didn't merit giving those goats a death sentence in my book.

In a State that's having a difficult time managing any sort of wildlife you'd hope science and common sense says leave a thriving resource alone and add some protocols to manage it better. Instead of take a chance and hope they survive a mass relocation.
NPS was lead on NEPA. Did you comment? Did you attend the meetings and speak up? There was opportunities for all to be involved in the determination of their existence in the park. Many involved did not support eradicating them but really wanted to make the best of the situation.

Yes and yes
Unfortunately what's done is done
But I will stand firm that I disagree with the EIS and the associated CBI review that goats allegedly where not native to the area. 
And that removal was the only option....
A major factor of the management plan was human interaction. Maybe they should of taken a step in managing humans first....that park is overdue for a reduction in tourism..
I grew up in those mountains and the flood of people the last few years is mind blowing.

And just to be clear even if the relocation was a complete success I would still have the same opinion..those mountains deserve goats....
No disagreement.  It is just tough to convey the effort by so many to try to salvage a NPS decision.  This was not on the WDFW or tribes. 

 


* Advertisement

* Recent Topics

New #3 World Record Columbian Blacktail by BlackRiverTaxidermy
[Yesterday at 09:24:33 PM]


Winthrop has a turkey problem by full choke
[Yesterday at 06:03:02 PM]


Idaho deer 2026. Let’s go!! by andrew_in_idaho
[Yesterday at 04:29:54 PM]


Big game season proposals by TriggerMike
[Yesterday at 03:26:57 PM]


Buffalo Creek Machine barrel vise/bushing and tikka action wrench by craigapphunt
[Yesterday at 03:15:22 PM]


Florida Bear Hunt by Pegasus
[Yesterday at 02:46:25 PM]


Idaho Selway A pack out camps by Rimrock hunter
[Yesterday at 01:47:51 PM]


Muzzy needs by wapiti22
[Yesterday at 12:49:31 PM]


Flooded Corn: Senator Calls USFW To Conduct Formal Study by johnsc6
[Yesterday at 12:15:58 PM]


Dorsal skinned beaver by BA Mongor
[Yesterday at 10:27:03 AM]


Most effective electronic calls for coyotes? by Goshawk
[Yesterday at 10:13:50 AM]


Canadian Invasion by HighCountryBC
[Yesterday at 08:30:04 AM]


bc style down rigger rod by Crunchy
[Yesterday at 08:11:09 AM]

SimplePortal 2.3.7 © 2008-2026, SimplePortal