.17 hmr or .22 wmr

[WildfireArcher]

I'm sure this question has been beat to death, but im torn between which would be a better all around caliber for shooting coyote,bobby coming in and stopping at 150 yrd with perfect condtions? .17 hmr or .22 wmr?? i've been doing a lot of research and find that they are both capable, but neither is "ideal"17 hmr or .22 wmr?? i am leaning towards .17 hmr cuz of flatter shooting at longer distance. and the accuracy of the .22wmr i'm not sure of at that distance? feel free to throw in personal experience...
thanks guys for the help, and sorry if this question is old and annoying

-Wildfire

[jackelope]

.17 is too light. The shot placement would have to be perfect...and I know they're only coyotes but I'm a firm believer in clean ethical kills and there's too much risk for me with a .17 or the .22 for that matter.

I'd rather shoot them with a .243 than a .17. personally I don't hunt for pelts....just want them dead.

[WildfireArcher]

i edited the poll. my question was a little off compared to the poll once i started thinkin about it. sorry bout that guys
-Wildfire

[madmack76]

have killed several with both quick clean kills just dont reachout to far

[jackelope]

http://hunting-washington.com/smf/index.php/topic,4246.0.html

http://hunting-washington.com/smf/index.php/topic,38584.0.html

http://hunting-washington.com/smf/index.php/topic,18084.0.html

[bowhunterforever]

I would get the 22 mag over the 17hmr. Just because the 22 mag has alitte more knock down.

[Bigshooter]

I love the .22 mag.

[Special T]

I said the 17 because i had a buddy whack a yote with one at 150yds. I might go for the 22mag if it was a semiauto ruger! double tap and done!

[WildfireArcher]

well as i suspected, i am just gonna save up a little more and get a .223. Thanks for the advice!

-Wildfire

[Rob]

good call...

and the 17 hmr's drop like rocks after about 150...

[carpsniperg2]

not for me got to go 223 or better for me.

[Special T]

WFA was there a reason you limited your choice to the 2 calibers? I know in the Kittatas valley your are "Supposed" to only use rim fires between the KRD ditches? And over here on the Wet side the firearm restricted areas have the same kind of restriction??? If those weren't the limiting factors for you what were? Cost to shoot? Cost of rifle? 

[WildfireArcher]

WFA was there a reason you limited your choice to the 2 calibers? I know in the Kittatas valley your are "Supposed" to only use rim fires between the KRD ditches? And over here on the Wet side the firearm restricted areas have the same kind of restriction??? If those weren't the limiting factors for you what were? Cost to shoot? Cost of rifle? 

it was basically the cost of the rifle. But i decided to wait and buy the right tool for the right job. Which is what i knew i should have done from the start

-Wildfire

[Intruder]

Sounds like you made up your mind.... the rimfires are marginal at best in terms of being effective coyote guns.

[MikeWalking]

I have a question about the .17HMR. Why?

Is this a round the market was really calling for?

[zach1234]

i have a .22 mag to target shot with it is fun.

[boonerboy]

if you have the patience to let them get that close, I have killed them with both. For me I would rather pop one at 300 yards with my .243 and not have to worry about it...but they will knock a dog down.