Entiat whitetail?

[boonerboy]

Good day shed hunting. 5 total, 3 brown and 2 white. I read a post about whitetail in Mills canyon but didnt think anything about it till today. Sure look like whitetail to me! You be the judge!

[MtnMuley]

Nice finds.  100% Muley.

[Dipsnort]

Nice finds.  100% Muley.

  I'd say this is a very typical example of muley antlers being mistaken as whitetail.

[boonerboy]

I understand that people sometimes mistake mulie antlers as whitetail...I have hunted both whitetail and mulies for 15 years and have never seen mulie horns look this whitetail-ish. You can't tell in the pics but the smaller antler does have an eyeguard and I am almost positive belonged to the same deer last year. I compared the smaller one to a whitetail I shot years ago and they are very similar. Everyone I have showed them to (experienced hunters) also think they are whitetail. Also there have been sightings of whitetail in the general area. I am pretty convinced!

[MtnMuley]

I'm definately with you that it's the same deer from a previous year.  Especially by noticing the the unique shape of the peticle.  Also, by the same structure around the base.  As for being a whitetail, not a chance in my book.  I've picked up many whitey sheds, and have never seen a whitetail shed resemble that horn with it's base characteristics.  To go with that, being found in the Swakane area, rules it out imo.  Nice find though!

[fishnate]

Looks like poss. whitetail to me either way Nice job.

Nate D.

[boneaddict]

best way to tell is cut them in half and check out the core...... 

[alecvg]

Deffinatly looks like the same buck, but looks like a muley to me.   

[elkaholic]

Great Find..... I think you found the same shed, he is tsill alive!

[Pathfinder101]

Deffinatly looks like the same buck, but looks like a muley to me.   

 

[wastickslinger]

How about this one? Not a whitetail area. Its a muley. A mule deer can have a white tail configuration from time to time.

[Redmist]

OK, I'm old school.  CPU stupid.  In your photo posting I get only a picture frame with an "X" in a box displayed and no photo.  Clicking the attachment redirects to google.  What don't I have installed?  Paintshop Photo Album download needed?

[Dipsnort]

best way to tell is cut them in half and check out the core...... 

Are you pulling our leg?