Do you guys shoot every broadhead/arrow combination that you put in your quiver to see which arrow is the most accurate or do you assume if you've shot one combination of the same broadhead and arrow that they all shoot good?
I always shoot every arrow/broadhead combo no matter how much time I spend making and tuneing each arrow.

I shoot each and every one, and yes once in a while it does seem as if there is one arrow/broadhead combo that religiously seems to hit perfect every single time, not an inch high or an inch right, but perfect every single time. It groups in the center every time. I replace the blades on my broadhead, put that arrow in the first slot in my quiver and go huntin!