.

[hogsniper]

Now thats the best of both worlds!!!  I dunno id be tagged out on whatever one I saw first!   Im a sucker for width but that little bit of trash and deep forks is worthy also!!!    Id say the wide one first but dont tempt me!  Both great bucks and cool pics!

[mack2255]

As for the first set of photos I like buck 1 nice rack and size. they are all nice . The second photo has a doe in the background so I would hope thats not the shot. As for the 3rd photo I would take the shot,but I really like buck 1

[throttlejocky20]

What ever buck I saw first would make my year. But if they were standing side by side I would put my luck on the heavy one.

[MLhunter1]

Either one would make my sights shaky, but I like the spread.  Plus he looks like he has 50lbs on the other one.

[Lowedog]

LR7MM # 2!  Although #1 is a toad!

[MtnMuley]

#2 without a doubt for me.  You got him tied up yet....

[longrange7mm]

#2 without a doubt for me.  You got him tied up yet....

Yup just need to draw that 5% tag 

[throttlejocky20]

Ok I like looking at big mulies and whitetails But my passion is Blacktails so heres one for you.

Buck one 3x4 decent forks + eyguards
Buck two 4x4 + eyeguards
(As far as I know buck one is still around He wont beat me 2 years in a row)

[longrange7mm]

throttlejocky20 - #2 Maybe 1 with a better look both real nice bt

[throttlejocky20]

#1 was a long pic I will enlarge it more but quality will be bad

[Boss .300 winmag]

Here is a couple more, got them from a buddy there WY bucks

#1 is wide
#2 is heavy

#2 like heavy

[throttlejocky20]

her is the best I could do Its not easy to get close to these creaturs and my camera is not the best.

[wsucowboy]

I think I would take the top black tail. Both are good black tail bucks and are trophy's for sure

[throttlejocky20]

I would take buck number 1. Both bucks are close in size. I love eye guards and the right one is awsome. And I watched him three different times the week before the season and he disapeared like a fart. He must have scraped that fuzzy stuff.

[HuntingFanatic]

I cant decide throttlejockey. They are both good bucks! Ill go with #1