Looking for a handgun...

[WDFW Hates ME!!!]

Havn't had one fora while and it is time. I have been doing my research. And i want a .40.But what i can't decide is wich to get the H & K USP40 or the SigPro 40.

Also like the looks of the 1911 in .45 ACP. I am a big guy with big hands.

Need some opinions... Lets not make this a pissin match.

[D-Rock425]

 

[addicted]

Price range homey........ i cant believe i just called you "homey"


Cant have a good pissing match without a price range.

[carpsniperg2]

Of the three you listed i would look at the 1911 that fits in your price range. If you have not looked at the xdm, they are a very good handgun. They make both the 40and45. Just somthing for you to look at, if you have not already.

[runamuk]

Price range homey........ i cant believe i just called you "homey"


Cant have a good pissing match without a price range.

That's funny....lol

[Tony 270]

Which one feels best in your hands?

[JackOfAllTrades]

If you're stuck on 40... I think you need to add one gun to your list.

I'm a complete 1911 fan, yet I would not advise one in 40. 45? Yes.. But if you're going 9 or 40, take advantage of the double stack capacity.

I think you should really look at the Springfield XD.  I don't own one. But everyone that I know that does, really likes theirs.

http://www.springfield-armory.com/xd.php?version=75

-Steve

[Heredoggydoggy]

Take a look at the FNH FNX-40 too.  I got the FNX-9 a while back.  Great gun.  I've got an XD-40 sub compact that I like too, butI like the FN better.  It's made in the USA, too, if that's a consideration.  There's a .45 version too, but a bit bulkier, but if you have big paws you might like it.

[WDFW Hates ME!!!]

Price... Under 1000.Less if possible. I was going for the 40 because during the ammo crisis the 40 was readilyavailable where 9 and 45 was harder to find. Recoil is not much of an issue.

I like the 1911 in .45. So in the 1911 wich is the better model, there are so many.
I am not a big fan of the 9mm.
Had to go from the 45 in the navy to the 9 and i prefered the 45.

[norsepeak]

I've got the FNH 45 and love it, but I"ve also got the XD40 and love it too...

[ribka]

$500-$600 price range Springfield XD or new Glocks. Have shot/owned  both and very good pistols for the money.

$700-$1000 range going to get a better pistol. You mentioned the HK USP and Sig Pro. Have shot both of those too and own them too. Am partial to Sig because have carried at work for almost 20 years and have shot over 20,000 rounds with no issues. Again HK and SIg are very good and proven pistols and a little better than the Springfield and Glock but will pay a little.

And there are the 1911's...

Go to a gun store/range and try shooting different pistols and see what you like

[JackOfAllTrades]

1911?  45acp?

I love my Kimber Stainless II!

Otherwise, you can't go wrong with a Series 70 Colt 1911 in 45acp!

-Steve

[FC]

Have a look at a Sig P226, P228, P229 and P239. All are available in .40 and they are all-metal Sigs, the best and most reliable guns there are How is that? 

Seriously they really are the best.

[timberghost72]

My vote is for the 1911 in .45 but I am a HUGE fan of the 1911. I tend to compare all of the pistols I buy to my 1911's and I always like those better even if I purchace another model. H&k and Sig both are excellent firearms with good reputations so I would rent or find someone who has those and try them out. My hands are on the smaller size and when I went looking to buy a CC sidearm I was dead set on a Sig because they have great reputations and are reliable and also they are awesome looking too. When I went and rented one and handled multiple models I was very disappointed because they didn't fit my hands how I like. I was really looking forward to getting a Sig but was glad I was able to try one out first. I like the 1911's because of the single stack mags and recoil seems much more manageable than other .45's I have used. Even the 3 inch recoil doesn't feel too bad.  You can find Kimbers for a reasonable price if you search around. I got my Kimber Custom II in stainless fixed sights for $640.00 new. I wanted a blued one but at that price I couldn't pass it up.  

[kenjo]

I own 3 Glocks in 40 S&W; the 22, 23 and 27. All have been very reliable and accurate out of the box, with no mods required other than replacing the silly stock sights. In 45, I have a full size Glock 21. Shooters tend to like or dislike the Glock based on how it fits their hand or looks. Its simple design makes for easy cleaning and maintenance.

Another good firearm in 40 is the H&K USP Compact or the P2000. The P2000 comes with different back straps so you can change the size of the grip to fit your hand. The LEM trigger in the USP Compact and P2000 is awesome, if you don't mind not having an external safety.

There are lots of excellent 1911s out there and the quality is usually closely related to price. Try to shoot a few different makes and models before you decide.

[addicted]

 

[Alchase]

How does that birdshot work for you? I almost bought a box in .40 at Cabelas the other day.

[jdb]

have you considered buying a revolver?

[Schwag173]

Which handgun(s) you buy depends entirely upon a) what you'll be using it for and b) how much you're willing to spend.  Truth is, all of the major manufacturers are turning out quality these days.  I've carried a Beretta 92 9mm, HK USP .40 and S&W M&P .40 almost every day of the past 20 years.  For the past 15 I've also carried a Glock 27 .40 as a backup and off-duty gun.  None was a 'bad' gun. 

A $3500 1911 is beautiful but I'd rather carry a $500 Glock and spend the other $3000 on other things.  Unless you are restricted to using FMJ ammo, any argument between .40 & .45 is just silly.

Since you mentioned .40 & .45 I assume you're talking semiauto 'carry' guns.  WHATEVER you buy, buy something small and light enough that you'll actually carry it EVERY day.  The big, beautiful 1911 that stays at home isn't as good as the smaller Glock 27 that lives in the small of your back.

We all have our preferences and prejudices.  Buy the one that feels good and that you shoot well.   

[GlennGTR]

For under a grand you can find a 1911 in 45acp, or...40 ...or 9mm. Check out Para Ordnance and Springfield arms. Looks and feels like a 1911 but in the cheaper 40 cal ammo.

[addicted]

How does that birdshot work for you? I almost bought a box in .40 at Cabelas the other day.

killed a couple mice with it. Tried for a rabbit once but it was just too far i guess, about 12 yards.

I think it will be more useful if i get stationed somewhere hot next, I HATE poisonous things.

[WDFW Hates ME!!!]

thanks you for the suggestions... I am not looking for a revolver.

I think i am going to go withthe sig pro in 40 cal. cheaper ammo than a 45. I like the 1911 but it is a little larger of a gun.

One of the reasons i am getting a pistol is to carry more in the woods,during Muzzy season and when hiking in the summer and spring.

[Jekemi]

My buddy, my grandson, and I were at Cabela's today (it was a zoo). We looked at .40 caliber because both of us are in the market for one. In fact, I bought all the handloading paraphernalia needed to reload .40 caliber today in anticipation. I really like the Smith & Wesson .40 semi-auto, M&P bi-tone. It feels nice in the hand and has a fit & finish that I didn't see with the others we looked at in the same price range ($569).

[Fishnclifff]

If you are going to be at ridgefield, I will let you check out my XDM40.

[huntandjeep]

Jekemi i have the S&W M&P in 45 its a great shooting gun.

[groundhog]

A 1911 feels great, fits good and they are accurate and enjoyable to shoot. Great for home protection and a great choice for a larger person with decent sized hands. If you are not planning on packing it for long distances a 1911 is hard to beat. 

 If you are planning on packing it on long hikes I would consider a Glock model 22 in .40. It is light, has a fifteen round mag and they are surprisingly accurate out of the box. Sometimes I forget I am wearing mine. I never have that problem with the 1911. I have always been hung up on buying handguns with adjustable sights but the Glock is just as accurate with fixed sights. You really can't go wrong though, just as long as you buy one!

[addicted]

there are smaller ones than the glock 22 as well.

my 23 in 40 is a little bit more packable for the long hikes.

[WDFW Hates ME!!!]

All right, an update.
Went to Cabelas yesterday. Filled out the papers for a Ruger P90T it is a special edition they had on sale for 429. No money out of pocket... I have safety awards and gift cards saved up.
I got a call today saying all is well. I dont have my CWP yet. Working on that.

1 day to get an OK. I was told 3-7 days.
Can i buy ammo at the same time? I have a 50$ off of 500 so i would like to  buy a few boxes.

[WDFW Hates ME!!!]

[FC]

Yeah you will be able to buy ammo at the same time.

[WDFW Hates ME!!!]

Thank you.

[Mossy]

Let us know how it turns out.  I like my ruger revolver.  I've been looking at what you got.

[WDFW Hates ME!!!]

Mossy from everything i have read this ruger is built like a tank. I have not read one bad review about this gun. I am going to pick it up on saturday.
Cabelas had the special edition 2 tone on sale for 429 and i couldn't pass it up. It has different grips than shown in that picture. They have the finger ridges in them.

[GoldTip]

Mossy from everything i have read this ruger is built like a tank. I have not read one bad review about this gun. I am going to pick it up on saturday.
Cabelas had the special edition 2 tone on sale for 429 and i couldn't pass it up. It has different grips than shown in that picture. They have the finger ridges in them.

WDFW, my Dad has that gun in a 45acp, and other than the grip feeling a bit boxy to me, it shoots great and runs well.  Fires everything from cheapo factory's to hot handloads with no problems.  I know a lot of guys don't seem to care much for the Ruger auto pistols, personally near as I can tell they are bullet proof.  My Dads rides under his seat and rarely see's a cleaning and has worked like a champ everytime I've layed hands on it.  Let us know what you think once you've been shooting it.

[JackOfAllTrades]

If you had a CPL you could have walked out with it the same day.

-Steve

[WDFW Hates ME!!!]

Working on my CPL.Turning my paperwork in tomorrow.
The grips on the P90T are different, i held the P90 and the P90T and the 90T has the finger indentions. where the 90 didn't and it felt boxy to me.

I was going to wait untill i got my CPL but i didn't want to wait untill the gun was not on sale anymore. I can buy a few boxes of ammo for the difference in cost.

[WDFW Hates ME!!!]

Put 20 rounds through it today.
What i like is the crisp trigger pull. Dead on accurate from 20 yards. Yeah i only put 20 through it factory PMC ammo. But i like it.
My wife shot it once (first time ever shooting a gun) and she handed it back to me, she wants something smaller.
My 11 year old shot it 4 times and said he loved it.
It didn't kick all that much.
Easy to take apart and clean.