call the shot...Muzzelloader

[Skillet]

Went back and looked close - not going to take that offhand shot.
Tag soup for me...

[PolarBear]

Pass.  Don't like the shot, don't like the buck.

[TopOfTheFoodChain]

Pass, based on photo alone. Cannot tell how thick the grass/brush is below him. Could be a doe's head in the dark in front, never know. I would take it if I could see more hair clearly.

[Dan-o]

Dropping him right where he stands.... even if it's 5 minutes into legal shooting on opening morning.

I mean seriously people......

[6x6in6]

Pass.
Could be a doe standing broadside, head down and munching right in front him.

[Curly]

I'd kill him, but then the skull plate would be toast.

[The100Road]

Dropping him right where he stands.... even if it's 5 minutes into legal shooting on opening morning.

I mean seriously people......

 

[spikehunter]

after the smoke clears, i'll go retrieve my buck

[Nilehunter]

I would sneak in and jig em with my knife saving the lead for elk season...

Okay, Okay I would think about taking the shot.

[shorthair-on-point]

Pass, hope he steps out where I can get a better look/shot.

[Killercolin]

give him another 15 yrds to make if more fair for him. 

[grundy53]

I'd kill him, but then the skull plate would be toast.

[CAMPMEAT]

Shoot it. Muzzleloader bullet weights are heavier and wouldn't have any problem with "logging the grass" that's in front of the deer.

[Lowedog]

Not a good shot.  I would pass and hope for a better opportunity.