This really comes down to how you hunt, and whats exceptable for comfort. I have hunted out of both and will never give up my wall tent. I sold my trailer a couple years ago and dont plan on buying another one. In fact I am planning on buying another tent, this time the 12x20. I like the tents because I feel that i get more freedom of where i can set up camp, and where I can hunt. If I want to tow my horse trailer and take the horses I just trow the tent in the bed of the truck and go. I love the wood stove, I had never been so warm and comfortable while hunting before I had a wood stove. Rain, wind, snow, doesn't matter if you buy a good quality tent, which are about 1/4 the cost of a nice used trailer.