I have a system for new arrows.
First, choose 1 arrow. Foot powder test until I determine exactly how to rotate the nock.
Then I rotate all the knocks as close to identical to the first one I can.
Third, shoot every arrow through paper a couple times and ensure they are all tearing consistently (at this point I'm not looking for a bullet hole, that comes later with tuning, if one nock is over/under rotated it will tear differently than the rest.) This assumes you have a bow that is close to in tune for those arrows of course.
Fourth, NUMBER THE ARROWS, and shoot at a NEW 5 spot target at 20 yards, assigning each arrow to one spot. If one is off, it will show itself after about 4 rounds because the holes in the paper will consistently be in a different place than the others in relation to the X ring.
This method keeps the lipstick and foot powder mess to a minimum, as it's only used on one arrow.