Grain size for a 38sp+P snub nose

[cwuwildcat]

Is a 158gr pill too big to push out of a snub nose at standard pressure?  I've got an LCR and a bunch of 158gr plated HP, and am wondering if I should take the time to work them up at standard pressures, or get something at a lower grain.  I could use them for .357 instead.

[FC]

My J frame shoots 158gr the best I think, accurate and easier on the hand than some of the lighter loads, more of a push than a snap.

[cwuwildcat]

Is that with a + load?

[FC]

No,it was standard pressure, I want to try Buffalo Bore in 158gr now though. The snappiest stuff I have shot through that little pistol has been PMC fmj in (I think) 115gr, that stuff flat stings! I've shot a bunch of +p Hydra-shok and Gold dot ammo through it and both seem to bite less than that PMC.

[JackOfAllTrades]

You're getting that snap from the higher velocity from the lighter loads, and will get a different slam from the 158's. The FBI did a lot of testing of pills in 38cal from snubbies.  I think you'll find managability and better performance from 147gn HP's at near +P loads.

-Steve

[DOUBLELUNG]

I like 125gr +p JHPs for mine - they are snappy for sure, but that factory grip is awesome for absorbing felt recoil.  Remington Golden Saber being the brand of choice.   

[JackOfAllTrades]

Golden Sabre's are what I have loaded in my wife's snubby.

-Steve

[madmack76]

125 is the way to go with .38 round

[boots]

Good info guys. Just got a S&W J frame yesterday so hope to go test it out in the next couple days. Will have to keep these loads recommendations in mind

[ribka]

I carry a 626 at work and shoot the Federal 158 gr +P. nyclad  and also Speer 135 gr GDHP. Both shoot accurately for me.

Most of my shooting is done under 15 yds.

After about 50 rounds hands gets a bit sore though.