Same deer

[alwinearcher]

I know its tuff to tell because my pictures (the one on the right) is real low quality..
Could this be the same deer though?

[Miles]

It could be.

[Kola16]

  I just saw that deer dead on the side of the road this morning............

....JK Looks to me like the same deer or it is its twin

[bloodhound]

i wanna say no seeing as i dont see the split tine on the right side

[Big P]

I'm gonna say no. The deer on the left - his mainbeams curve up. While the ones on the right parallel the ground more and they curve in more

[alwinearcher]

i wanna say no seeing as i dont see the split tine on the right side

Maybe its just hidden bhind the tip of the main beam?

[huntnnw]

i say no..the frame looks bigger on the left and doesnt have the basket like the one on the right.. I see 6 on the buck on the right and 7 on the buck on the left on the same side.

[Kola16]

Looking at it closer I think big p is right

I'm gonna say no. The deer on the left - his mainbeams curve up. While the ones on the right parallel the ground more and they curve in more

[alwinearcher]

i say no..the frame looks bigger on the left and doesnt have the basket like the one on the right.. I see 6 on the buck on the right and 7 on the buck on the left on the same side.

You guys are no fun!

Alright DBzona, I have failed again.. I guess I gotta get back out there and continure to search for your spot

[Big P]

Are both pics from this year?

[DBZona]

You guys are no fun!

Alright DBzona, I have failed again.. I guess I gotta get back out there and continure to search for your spot

Your slacking!  I gave you a 50 mile radius!  You should have found him by now.           

[alwinearcher]

You guys are no fun!

Alright DBzona, I have failed again.. I guess I gotta get back out there and continure to search for your spot

Your slacking!  I gave you a 50 mile radius!  You should have found him by now.           

I know, BUT Ive had to maintain all my other spots so I could only devote a couple cameras to it!
I dont care about either of the deer in the pictures (or the deer in the pictures) I just want to find the one you had on camera last year

[DBZona]

You guys are no fun!

Alright DBzona, I have failed again.. I guess I gotta get back out there and continure to search for your spot

Your slacking!  I gave you a 50 mile radius!  You should have found him by now.           

I just want to find the one you had on camera last year

You and me both!    

[300UltraMagShooter]

Same deer.  The angle of his head tilt makes it look slightly different but is not.

The perceived upward/lower main beam curve is an optical illusion of sorts.  The pic that makes it look like the main beam is more parallel only looks that way because we are seeing the bottom of his main beam from that angle which is slightly blurred.

Anyway, my guess is same buck.   

[alwinearcher]

Same deer.  The angle of his head tilt makes it look slightly different but is not.

The perceived upward/lower main beam curve is an optical illusion of sorts.  The pic that makes it look like the main beam is more parallel only looks that way because we are seeing the bottom of his main beam from that angle which is slightly blurred.

Anyway, my guess is same buck.   

I like your answer!
I should have better pictures of him soon.. That should tell us more

[Elkslayer]

Looks like the same deer to me!

[180-GRAIN]

I think it could very well be the same deer just a week or so farther along in the antler development! If not They have the same genes and are the same age.

[6x6in6]

I'm going to say different.
Look at the right ears. 
The one on the left has a flat spot on the top about 2 inched in from the tip.  The right deer has an even radius to the ear tip and no flat spot.

[Gringo31]

I say same buck.

[DBHAWTHORNE]

Yes...same buck

[MtnMuley]

I'd put money it's the same buck.  Dandy!

[greenhead_killer]

i hope i can get to a point in my hunting career that i can say i dont care about either of these deer!!! especially coming out of washington. whether it is one deer or two, both pics are of toads. they look the same to me, notice the palmation on both. id have a hard time seeing two deer almost identical like that, unless they were twins with incredible genes. anyhow, nice pics, post one when its dead

[alwinearcher]

i hope i can get to a point in my hunting career that i can say i dont care about either of these deer!!! especially coming out of washington. whether it is one deer or two, both pics are of toads. they look the same to me, notice the palmation on both. id have a hard time seeing two deer almost identical like that, unless they were twins with incredible genes. anyhow, nice pics, post one when its dead

They are or is nice deer, but are or is Young...

[DBZona]

In my opinion, there is no definitive way to tell from that picture.  Once more are available with better quality and angles then we will know for sure. 

But...Based off the pic that is available, I am guessing not the same deer.  If it is, the Right antler hardly grew at all between pictures and the left main beam, and mainframe points grew a few inches each except the last point.  Which does not seem very natural to me. But that is based off a grainy picture with a not very good angle.   

[benhuntin]

Looks like the same deer, but it would be better if there were two. Ive heard twins are awesome

[pat riotic]

Looks like the same deer, but it would be better if there were two. Ive heard twins are awesome

[alwinearcher]

Dont worry DB, after a massive bear invasion I pulled my camera out of that area..
I hate those stinky things!
Ill be back in Nov

[DBZona]

Dont worry DB, after a massive bear invasion I pulled my camera out of that area..
I hate those stinky things!
Ill be back in Nov

No worries.  Stupid bears!     Off too Idaho this morning with a youth for bear and got me a wolf tag in my pocket.