Not for that, I don't. Most grunt tubes are designed for whitetails. Muledeer grunts are smother, "less rattle" I guess is the best to describe it. I use it all the time when I am photographing but only to get them to look at me. Many of my photos where they are keyed on me or looking at me, its becasue I have grunted. I purchased a "muledeer" grunt tube but its still not quite natural.