Free: Contests & Raffles.
I would like to know more about this as well. I talked my uncle into applying for a muzzleloader elk permit this year. He normally hunts with a rifle, but does own a muzzleloader. (He is disabled)I'm wondering if we can both carry muzzleloaders during his hunt. I'd like to carry mine just to back him up. I'm pretty sure it's legal. But what if we end up 1/4 mile apart and I shoot his elk for him? I also think that would be legal but would like some verification.
The way I understand it is that you can carry and shoot weapons specific to whatever tags they have. My question is that if I am the designated hunter for someone who is really immobile and cant really leave the car it seems a bit restrictive to only let me be 1/4 mile away from the truck. Seems to me that if they are letting the individual buy the tags and then letting me shoot the animal, who cares how far away from me they are???
I guess my point is in the case of extreme disability. Why limit the person w the tag and said designated hunter to 1/4 mile if the tag holder wants to eat wild game why not let them?? I don't see the difference really between letting a person sit in their car a 1/4 mile a way from me while I shoot them a deer or an elk or letting them sit on their couch. In my opinion they are pretty similar experiences!
I feel the difference is that in the former example the person doesn't have an option of really hunting because of their disabilities. In the later example the person doesn't want to hunt but wants you to hunt for them but has the physical ability to.
I guess my point is in the case of extreme disability. Why limit the person w the tag and said designated hunter to 1/4 mile if the tag holder wants to eat wild game why not let them?? I don't see the difference really between letting a person sit in their car a 1/4 mile a way from me while I shoot them a deer or an elk or letting them sit on their couch. In my opinion they are pretty similar experiences![/pquote]My father is disabled and I carried the companion card. In the spirit of fair chase as explained to me by a gw the disabled hunter is supposed to get first attempt at the animal if accommodations are able to be made. To address the communication issue we used FRS/GMRS handhelds gt them for 50 at Costco work in heavy cover up to a mile 5 miles max range. I never asked about the 1/4 mile I figured its plenty of distance. With disabled hunters the state is supposed to accommodate you with access to closed gates even in areas where no motor vehicles are allowed.
True!New to this concept and trying to figure out were I am on the issue.
The thought of someone "hunting" for another person at home on his couch is repulsive to me. Hunting is far more than meat harvest.The current program is a good one.
My dad and I go out each year with his license and.companion card. I have shot 5-6 deer for him. It is a great way to spend time hunting together like when I was young even though my dad can't get around well. I've always been pretty close to my dad when I shot but one reason or another I was the one to pull the trigger.
Quote from: matt345 on May 14, 2013, 05:10:26 PMI guess my point is in the case of extreme disability. Why limit the person w the tag and said designated hunter to 1/4 mile if the tag holder wants to eat wild game why not let them?? I don't see the difference really between letting a person sit in their car a 1/4 mile a way from me while I shoot them a deer or an elk or letting them sit on their couch. In my opinion they are pretty similar experiences!This is about hunting not eating. If they don't want or are unable to get outside, then the program isn't open to them. Someone they know can certainly donate some meat to them in this case. There are many accommodations made for disabled hunters. Maybe more could be done. However, allowing someone to shoot an animal for them while they remain at home is not and should not be one of those accommodations.
The whole idea for the companion is to ASSIST the disabled hunter......... Pretty tough to do from a half mile away. My wife holds my companion card, she doesn't carry a gun, she DOES retrieve, helps me up if I fall and just generally ASSISTS.