for a cheap, easy to do feeder- get the black corrugated drain pipe from home depot or wherever- ususally 3-4" diameter. an 8 foot piece is like 8$, and makes 2 feeders.. bend one end of it in a J shape- and use wire to get it to stay bent like this- put knife slits in the underside of the bend- helps rain water drain out. tie it to a tree or post- bent end down, obviously. fill it and cap the top (or put a piece of plastic bag over the top) to keep rain out. these little feeders work well with shell corn, havent tried them with something as big as apples. we used to use them down south where there were hogs (hogs are hard on feeders) or where we were concerned someone might mess with, or take, your feeder.. for the price you cant beat it..